St. Prosper of Aquitaine

Prosper of Aquitain, whose birth is usually placed in 403, was well taught in sacred and secular learning and called by his contemporaries a holy man.

Read the essentials →
Feast June 25 · —

St. Prosper of Aquitaine

Current feast

June 25 (also listed: July 7)
Secondary source · Wikipedia infobox

Traditional feast

June 25
1914 / pre-1969 calendar, per Baring-Gould (1897)

Represents

Feast

Feast days

Feast: June 25

This Saint’s Story

Adapted in modern English from Alban Butler's Lives of the Saints · Baring-Gould original below · little is known

Settled in Provence, probably at Marseilles, he took up the defence of St. Augustine's teaching on grace against those Butler calls Semipelagians, with a layman named Hilary. Butler doubts he was ever more than a layman. The text on this page gives 455 for his death.

What he represents

How he teaches us to live

Drawn from themes in the original account

Celebrate this saint’s feast day. Remember him on June 25 with a short prayer, and ask for his help.

The full story

Baring-Gould’s account retold in modern English

Read the full story · 1,538 words · about 7 min

Augustine's strict views on predestination seemed to overlook the freedom of human will, which he appeared to diminish or disregard in light of the compelling force of grace.

Prosper, a layman from Riez in Aquitaine, or rather Provence, began to write against Cassian and the advocates of free will. He corresponded with Saint Augustine, as did another Hilary, who was not the bishop of Arles. Their letters prompted Augustine to write his letters on the Predestination of the Saints, which contained the early ideas of the controversial teachings later developed by Luther in his "On the Bondage of the Will" and by Calvin in his "Institutes." In his first letter, Augustine explained that humanity is placed in a state of salvation through a pure and unearned gift of grace. In a second letter titled "On Perseverance," he argued that a person's condition, after receiving this grace, is not determined by the individual but is entirely the work of God.

The Semi-Pelagians reasonably argued that teaching this doctrine could harm Christian morality. Augustine acknowledged that caution should be exercised in proclaiming it; however, he insisted on its truth, not realizing that this acknowledgment undermined his doctrine. Augustine illustrates his teaching on predestination with the example of a mother who has twins. Each twin is a "lump of perdition." She favors one and it perishes unbaptized, entering an eternity of misery, while the other is baptized and saved. This teaching is similar to that of Muhammad, which Mr. Palgrave summarizes as follows: "It is God’s singular satisfaction to let created beings continually feel that they are nothing else than His slaves, His tools, and contemptible tools also, so that they may better acknowledge His superiority and His power over their power, His cunning over their cunning, His will over their will, His pride over their pride; or rather, that there is no power, cunning, will, or pride, except His own." God took clay at creation and broke it in half; one half He made into men and cast into heaven, saying, "And what care I?" The other half He made into men and cast into hell, saying, "And what care I?" This doctrine also aligns with Calvin's views on predestination.

What is truly Gospel truth should be suitable for everyone to hear and practice.

Prosper and Hilary, not satisfied with having obtained these writings from Saint Augustine, went to Rome in 431. They complained about those in Southern Gaul who refused to accept his teachings on grace. The Semi-Pelagians had exposed themselves to criticism on one weak point; they denied that grace was necessary to first activate the human will. In this, they were clearly mistaken. Pope Saint Celestine, influenced by Prosper and Hilary, wrote a letter to Venerius, the bishop of Marseilles, Leontius, the bishop of Frejus, and to the other bishops of Gaul. He required them to prohibit the teaching of erroneous ideas in their churches.

“As for Augustine,” he said, “a man of holy memory,” — he had died the previous year, in 430 — “he was always in our communion, and has never been suspected of false teaching; his knowledge was such that my predecessors regarded him as a chief teacher. He was loved and honored by all the world, therefore I urge you to resist those who dare to attack his memory and to silence them.”

To this letter, Saint Celestine added nine articles on grace, which were as follows: 1. Due to the Fall, man has lost the natural ability to rise, and his free will cannot elevate him to the state he was in before the Fall without the help of grace. 2. No one is perfectly good; goodness must be given by Him who is all-good. 3. Even those who are baptized cannot overcome daily temptation without the help of grace. 4. No one can use free will correctly except with the assistance of grace through Jesus Christ. 5. All the desires, works, and merits of the saints should be seen as contributing to the glory of God, for no one can please Him except through His grace. 6. God works in the hearts of people, inspiring free will, holy desire, and good intentions. 7. Grace not only forgives sin but also strengthens us to resist sin. 8. Prayers for the unbaptized that they may receive faith, and for those in schism that they may receive faith, are not empty rituals; they indicate that we need God to act on the unbaptized and the schismatic to lead them to the truth. 9. The practice of exorcism before baptism shows that the Church believes the unbaptized are under the control of Satan. Therefore, it should be believed that the grace of God “prevents,” meaning it goes before the merits of man. It does not take away the freedom of free will, but rather frees it, enlightens it, and guides it. It is God who desires that we use His gifts properly; however, we must cooperate with His gifts.

The careful and measured language of the Pope was equally opposed to the extremes of Augustinian predestinarianism and the Semi-Pelagian denial of the precedence of grace.

Saint Vincent of Lerins had outlined sixteen propositions based on the writings of Saint Augustine, which he claimed were logical conclusions of Augustine's teaching. These conclusions suggested that God did not will the salvation of all people, that He intentionally created the majority of people to be damned eternally, that salvation is impossible for those predestined for damnation, and therefore that God is responsible for their sins. These conclusions were indeed later reached by Calvin in subsequent centuries.

Saint Prosper took on the task of refuting these accusations, along with fifteen articles created by the bishops and scholars of Gaul against Augustinian predestinarianism. These articles were similar in substance to those of Saint Vincent, asserting that predestination imposes on people a fatal necessity to sin. They claimed that free will does not exist and that people are governed by fatal necessity. If God does not will the salvation of all people, then if He truly desires it and has absolute control, why does He not save everyone? His will, rather than human cooperation, determines a person's fate. Therefore, if a person is lost, it is not their fault but rather the deliberate will of God. If people are fatally predestined to either life or death, what was the purpose of Jesus Christ dying for us?

Saint Prosper wrote a work to counter these rigid and logical conclusions. However, his main work was a defense of Saint Augustine against the writings of Saint John Cassian, which had already been mentioned. He wrote this defense in the year 432. Cassian had argued that (1) a person can sometimes reach a state of grace without God's cooperation; (2) Adam did not lose all ability to do good or all knowledge of what is good through his sin; (3) the merits of the saints are not solely due to God's preventing grace, and if they were, we would attribute nothing good to human nature, which is a Manichean view; (4) every human soul naturally contains the seeds of virtues, which grace helps to grow and flourish; (5) some people are saved by God, while others are merely assisted by Him.

One of these propositions, the first, is highly questionable in terms of orthodoxy. The second has been effectively approved by the Church in the catechism and decrees of the Council of Trent. The fourth is also true, provided Cassian acknowledged, as there is little doubt he did, that the life in these seeds is a divine gift. The fifth proposition is true if we understand its meaning correctly: that God offers His grace to everyone, and those who refuse to use it or benefit from it are lost due to their deliberate neglect to cooperate with grace, while others who utilize grace are saved as a result.

S. Prosper claimed that by these statements, Cassian supported the Pelagians and contradicted himself. He ended his work with a plea to S. Sixtus, the pope, to expel all hidden Pelagians, just as his predecessors had removed those who were openly Pelagian. The pope wisely chose not to follow this narrow-minded advice, and S. John Cassian remained in the Church until the end without being censured. He has been recognized as a saint by both the Eastern and Western Churches (July 23rd) for being a champion of human free will.

S. Prosper wrote a poem titled "De Ingratis," expressing his bitterness towards those who refuse to see divine grace as something that undermines human freedom. He also authored a Chronicle that details the history of the world from Creation to the year 455, which is likely the year of his death. He had served as secretary to S. Leo the Great, and some authors believe he wrote the letters attributed to S. Leo that were against the errors of Eutyches. He also wrote a book titled "On Grace and Free Will," as well as a collection of sayings taken from S. Augustine. Some think he authored a work called "On the Vocation of the Gentiles," which is usually included among the writings of Pope S. Leo.

Footnotes

  1. Augustine's "On the Bondage of the Will" discusses human will and divine grace.
  2. Mr. Palgrave's summary reflects a view of divine sovereignty in Islam.
  3. The term "Semi-Pelagians" refers to a theological group that held a view of grace and free will that was seen as a middle ground between Pelagianism and Augustinianism.
  4. One passage in these articles has passed into a proverb, “ut legem credendi, lex statuat supplicandi!”
  5. "De Ingratis" is a poem by S. Prosper.
  6. Eutyches was a theologian whose views were condemned as heretical.
  7. "On Grace and Free Will" is a book by S. Prosper.
  8. "On the Vocation of the Gentiles" is often attributed to S. Leo.

Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.

Read the original 1870s text

Baring-Gould’s sources: Roman Martyrology. Authorities The letters of S. Augustine, and his own writings.] S. John Cassian, in order to instruct and discipline the army of monks he had assembled in his monastery of S. Victor, at Marseilles, wrote his “ Institutions ” and “Conferences,” the latter on account of the practical teaching of the chief Egyptian abbots. One of these, named Chaeremon, appears to have taught a doctrine much like Semi-Pelagianism, that man’s resolve to do good must precede grace; and the perusal of S. Augustine’s work “ On Correction and Grace,” led Cassian, S. Hilary of Arles, and other leading churchmen at Marseilles, and throughout the South of Gaul, to take serious exception to 354 Lives oj the Saints. tjuncas.

Augustine’s predestinarian rigour, and to make a stand for the freedom of the human will, which Augustine seemed inclined to ignore, or reduce to nothing, before the constraining force of grace.

Prosper a layman of Riez, in Aquitain, or rather Provence, took up his pen against Cassian, and the supporters of free will. He entered into correspondence with S. Augustine, as did another Hilary, not the bishop of Arles, and their letters drew forth from S. Augustine his letters on the Predestination of the Saints, which contain the germs of that dangerous teaching afterwards embodied by Luther in his H De servo arbitrio,” and by Calvin in his “Institutes.”1 S. Augustine in his first letter showed that man was placed in a state of salvation by a pure unmerited gift of grace, and in a second letter “On Perseverance,” he contended that man’s condition, after having been so placed, is not of man’s making or marring, but is simply and solely the work of God. The Semi-Pelagians [followers of Pelagius, who taught people could be good without God’s grace] had with reason objected that to teach this doctrine would be disastrous to Christian morality. Augustine admits that caution must be used in declaring it, nevertheless he insists on it as true, not seeing that this admission condemned his doctrine as 1 S. Augustine illustrates his teaching of predestination by the case Of a mother who has twins. Each of these Is a “ lump of perdition/’ She overlies one and it perishes unbaptlsed, to enter an eternity of misery; the other is baptized and is saved. This teaching Is identical with that of Mahomet, which is thus summed up by Mr. Palgrave i — “It is God’s singular satisfaction to iet created beings continually feel that they are nothing else than his slaves, his tools, and contemptible tools also, that thus they may the better acknowledge his superiority and now his power to he above their power, his cunning above their cunning, his will above their will, his pride above their pride; or rather, that there is no power, cunning, will, or pride, save his own/* Arabia i., p. 366. God took clay, at the creation, and broke it in half, one half he made into men and cast into heaven, saying, “ And what care I ?*' The other he made into men and cast into bell, and said, “And what care I?'* This doctrine is also identical with the predestinarian ism of Calvin.

not divine; for what is Gospel- truth is fit for all to hear and all to put in practice.

Prosper and Hilary, not content with having elicited these treatises from S. Augustine, went to Rome, in 431, and complained of those in Southern Gaul [roughly modern France and Belgium] who refused to receive his doctrine on grace. The Semi-Pelagians had laid themselves open to attack on one vulnerable point, they had denied that grace was necessary first to stir the human will into activity; in this they were decidedly wrong. Pope S. Celestine, influenced by Prosper and Hilary, wrote a letter addressed to Venerius, bishop of Marseilles, Leontius, bishop of Frejus, and to the other bishops of Gaul, requiring them to forbid the teaching of what was erroneous in their churches. “ As for Augustine,” he said, “ a man of holy memory,” — he had died the previous year, 430, — " he was always in our communion, and has never been charged with the slightest suspicion of false teaching; his science was such, that my predecessors regarded him as a chief teacher. He was loved and honoured by all the world, therefore I exhort you to resist those who venture to attack his memory, and to impose silence upon them.” To this letter S. Celestine added nine articles on grace, to the following effect: — 1. By the Fall man has lost the natural power to rise, and his free-will is powerless to raise him to the condition man was in previous to the Fall without the assistance of grace. 2. No man is perfect Goodness must be communicated by Him who is All-good. 3. Not even the baptized can overcome daily temptation without the assistance of grace. 4. None can use free-will aright, except by the help of grace through Jesus Christ. 5. All the desires, works, and merits of the saints are to be regarded as appertaining to the glory of God, for none are able to please Him save by the assistance of His grace. 6. God works in the hearts of men, stimulating the free will, the holy desire, and the good intent 7. Grace not only remits sin, but strengthens to resist sin. 8. Prayers for the heathen that they may be given faith, for schismatics, that they may be given faith, are not vain forms, but signify that we require God to work on the heathen and the schismatic to bring them to the knowledge of the truth. 9. The ceremony of exorcism before baptism proves that the Church believes in the unbaptized being under bondage to Satan. Therefore it is to be believed that the grace of God “ prevents,” that is, goes before the merits of man. It does not destroy the liberty of free will, but emancipates it, illumines and directs it. It is God who wills that we should use his gifts aright; but his gifts must be co-operated with by us.1 The temperate and cautious language of the Pope was equally opposed to the extravagance of Augustinarian predestinarianism, and Semi-Pelagian denial of prevenience of grace.

S. Vincent of Lerins had drawn up sixteen propositions from the writings of S. Augustine, logical results of his teaching, as he asserted, which amounted to this — that God willed not the salvation of all men, that He has deliberately made the majority of men that He might damn them eternally, that to those who are predestined to damnation, salvation is impossible, and therefore that God is the author of their sins. These logical results of the teaching of Augustine were indeed arrived at by Calvin in after ages. S. Prosper undertook to refute these charges, together with fifteen articles drawn up by the Gaulish bishops and doctors against Augustinian [religious following the Rule of St. Augustine] predestinarianism. They were much the same in substance as those of S. Vincent, viz., predestination imposes on men a 1 One passage in these articles has passed into a proverb, “nt legem credendl cm status! supplicant! i.‘* fatal necessity to sin. Free-will does not exist, men are governed by fatal necessity. God wills not the salvation of all men, for if He wills it, and rules absolutely, why does He not save all. His will, not man's co-operation, rules man’s fate, and therefore if man is lost, it is not through his fault, but by the deliberate will of God. If men are fatally predestined to life or death, what was the use of Jesus Christ dying for us ?

S. Prosper wrote a work to answer, or deaden, the force of these rigid and logical conclusions. But the principal work of S. Prosper was a defence of S. Augustine against the work of S. John Cassian, already mentioned. He wrote it in the year 432. Cassian had advanced that (1) man can sometimes attain to a state of grace without the co-operation of God; that (2) Adam by his sin had not lost all faculty of good, all knowledge of what is good; (3) that all the merits of the saints are not solely due to God’s preventing grace, or if so, we are to attribute to nature nothing but what is evil, and this is Manicheism; (4) that every human soul has naturally in it the seeds of virtues, which it is the province of grace to make to grew and blossom; (5) that some are saved by God, others are only aided by him.

One of these propositions, the first, is of more than questionable orthodoxy; the second has been approved in effect by the Church in the catechism and decrees of the council of Trent1 The fourth is also true, if Cassian admitted, as there can be no doubt he did, that the germ of life in these seeds was of Divine gift The fifth proposition is true if we understand its drift aright, that God gives his grace to all, and that some refusing to use it or profit by it, are lost by deliberately neglecting to cooperate with grace, whereas others utilising grace, are thereby saved.

S. Prosper pretended that by these statements Cassian favoured the Pelagians, and contradicted himself He closed his work with an appeal to S. Sixtus, the pope, to drive out all concealed Pelagians, as his predecessors had expelled those who were manifest. The pope wisely refrained from acting on this bigoted advice, and S. John Cassian remained to the last in the Church, uncensured, and has been numbered with the saints both by the Eastern and Western Churches (July 23rd), as the champion of the freedom of man’s will. S. Prosper composed a poem entitled, 44 De Ingratis,” in the bitterness of his hostility to those who refuse to see in divine grace a power destructive to human liberty. He also wrote a Chronicle of the history of the world from the Creation to the year 455, which is probably that of his death. He had been secretary to S. Leo the Great, and some authors suppose that he wrote the letters attributed to S. Leo, against the errors of Eutyches. He was also the writer of a book 44 On Grace and Free Will,” and of a collection of maxims taken from S. Augustine. Some suppose that he wrote a work 44 On the Vocation of the Gentiles,” usually found among the writings of Pope S. Leo.

Help us add to this saint's story

Everything is read by a person before anything appears. Facts are checked against trusted sources first.

Facts are welcome; a source link helps (optional).With your permission we may share it on this page.

Nine days · Free

Pray the novena
with us.

One short email a day for nine days. The day's prayer, a line from St. Prosper of Aquitaine's story, and a nudge to keep going.

Also on June 25
S

Sts. Sosipater and Jason

June 25 · Feast
L

Sts. Lucy and Auceia

June 25 · Virgin, Martyr, King
St. Febronia

St. Febronia

June 25 · Virgin, Martyr
← All 1970 saints in the library
Sources & notes

Feast-day sources

Story sources

Sources

Credits

Image: Aquitániai Szent Prosper.jpg · unknown autor · Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Image: unknown autor, Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

Retold in plain modern English from Baring-Gould’s public-domain text, sentence by sentence, keeping the same facts and order. Short explanations in parentheses are ours.

From Sabine Baring-Gould, The Lives of the Saints, new edition in 16 vols. (London: John C. Nimmo, 1897–98); text from the Internet Archive scan (OCR, lightly cleaned; errors possible). Public domain in the United States. Reproduced unedited, except for short bracketed notes in grey that we added to explain names and terms (“S.” is the old abbreviation for Saint). Some history and judgments reflect 19th-century scholarship.