In his time, the question of how to treat those who had lapsed from the faith was revived. This issue had been debated passionately during the time of Saint Cyprian. The entire Christian world, except for the Novatians, had now agreed to follow the same general principles, but no specific rules had been established for individual cases. Before Easter of 306, Peter took it upon himself to create these rules for his own diocese. The fourteen canons he wrote still exist today. It is encouraging to see the respected bishop, who had himself stood firm for Christ, showing mercy and understanding towards those who had not demonstrated the same courage.
About this time, the persecution led by Maximinus began in Egypt, and Peter had to flee for safety. The extreme cruelty inflicted on Christians of both genders in the diocese of Alexandria would be hard to believe if it had not been reported by one of the bishops who was also a victim, as well as by Eusebius, who was present at the time. The number of victims ranged from ten to a hundred each day, and the leaders of the churches were specifically targeted. Faustus, a priest of Alexandria, who was old enough to have been a companion of Dionysius during the Decian persecutions, was beheaded. Phileas, the bishop of Thmuis, was imprisoned and wrote an account of the persecution from his cell to his congregation. Alongside him was Philoromus, who had been a magistrate in Alexandria. They were both beheaded. Three other bishops, Hesychius, Pachynius, and Theodore, were also imprisoned.
Meletius, the bishop of Lycopolis, took advantage of Peter's absence and the absence of the other bishops to establish regulations for the management of their dioceses. While provisions had been made for the spiritual needs of the Christians, Meletius was determined to interfere. News of his actions reached Phileas, Hesychius, Pachynius, and Theodore in prison, and they wrote a joint letter to Meletius, expressing their concerns about the irregularity of his actions. This letter still exists, and it shows that these bishops regarded Peter as their metropolitan. Meletius ignored their protest, and after the authors of the letter were martyred, he went to Alexandria and continued his irregular actions. Two individuals supported him in his ambitious plans: one was Isidorus, and the other was Arius, who later became well-known as a heretic. With their help, Meletius was able to attract some of the priests who had been left in charge of the Alexandrian Church.
Now leading a faction, he visited the confessors who were imprisoned or working in the mines, and two of them were ordained by him. When Peter learned of this blatant violation of his rights, he wrote from his hiding place to his congregation in Alexandria, instructing them not to associate with Meletius, but to wait until he could return and address the situation. The timing of his return to Alexandria is uncertain, but it was likely not before 311, when Galerius died and the persecution eased. Upon his return, Peter called a synod of bishops to try Meletius for encroaching on the authority of the bishop of Alexandria and for having sacrificed to save his life during the recent persecutions. A decision to depose him was made; however, instead of complying, Meletius created a schism and treated Peter with disrespect.
Arius did not join the breakaway group. He withdrew his support from Meletius, and Peter not only forgave him but also ordained him as a deacon. However, this reconciliation did not last long. The bishop found it necessary to issue a sentence of excommunication against all the followers of Meletius, and he took the firm step of refusing to recognize their baptisms. Arius then distanced himself from Peter and became involved in the excommunication directed at Meletius. But the persecution, which had lessened, flared up again.
Peter was seized by the direct order of Maximinus and was beheaded. As soon as Arius heard Maximinus's sentence, he is said to have rushed to the church and begged the clergy and people to intercede with Peter for him, hoping to be elected as his successor. Peter responded with a sigh that Arius had been cast away from the presence of God. Then, taking two priests from the crowd, he said to them, “Although I am a sinner, I know that I am called by heaven to die as a martyr. You are chosen to succeed me on the Alexandrian throne, first Achilles and then Alexander.
During the night, while I was finishing my prayer, I suddenly saw Christ my Lord appear in a white robe, torn from top to bottom. He held the pieces together with His hand over His chest. When I saw this, I asked, ‘My Lord, why do You appear this way?’ He answered me, ‘Arius has done this.’ Therefore, I warn and urge you not to accept Arius back into communion, for he is destined to tear apart the unity of the Church with a very serious schism.” This story was likely written after Arius had become a well-known heretic.
Footnotes
- Philip. Sideta, ap. Dodwell, Diss. ad Iren. p. 880.
- The persecution led by Maximinus began in Egypt around 303 AD.
- The Decian persecutions occurred during the reign of Emperor Decius from 249 to 251 AD.
- The year 311 marks the death of Galerius, which led to a temporary easing of persecutions.
- Arius was a Christian priest whose teachings led to significant theological disputes.
- Heresiarch refers to a leader of a heretical movement.
Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.
Read the original 1870s text
Baring-Gould’s sources: Roman Martyrology, Usuardus, Ado, Notker, &c., instead of Nov. 25, the proper day of martyrdom; displaced so as not to interfere with S. Catharine. Surius on Nov. 25. The Greeks on Nov. 25. Authorities Eusebius, H. E. lib. vii. c. 34, viii. 13, ix. 6; S. Gregory Nazianzen, Orat. 23, 24. Anastasius the Librarian, in his preface to the Passion of the Ten Thousand, says he had translated the Acts of this great doctor and martyr of the Alexandrian Church. These are probably the Acts given by Surius, t. vi. p. 184.] N the death of Thomas, Bishop of Alexandria, in 300, Peter, who had previously been master in the catechetical school,1 succeeded to the see of Alexandria. He had been a sufferer with Dionysius fifty years before in the Decian persecution, so that he must have been very aged when elevated to the episcopal throne.
In his time the question of the treatment of the lapsed,
which had been agitated so warmly in the time of S. Cyprian, was revived once more. The whole Christian world, with the exception of the Novatians, had agreed now to act on the same general principles, but no definite rules had been laid down for particular cases. Before the Easter of 306 Peter undertook to do this for his own diocese. The fourteen canons which he drew up are still extant; and it is pleasing to see the venerable prelate, who had himself played the man for Christ, exhibiting lenity and indulgence towards those who had shown less courage.
About this time the persecution of Maximinus broke out in Egypt, and Peter was obliged to seek for safety by flight. The refinement of cruelty which was practised upon the Christians of both sexes in the diocese of Alexandria would exceed our belief, if it had not been related by one of the bishops who was himself a sufferer, as well as by Eusebius, who happened to be on the spot. The number of victims varied from ten to a hundred a day; and the heads of the churches were singled out for attack. Faustus, a priest of Alexandria, who was old enough to have been a companion of Dionysius in the Decian persecutions, was beheaded. Phileas, bishop of Thmuis, was imprisoned, and wrote an account of the persecution from his dungeon to his flock. With him was Philoromus, who had been a magistrate in Alexandria. They were beheaded. Three other bishops, Hesychius, Pachynius, and Theodore, were in prison. Meletius, bishop of Lycopolis, took advantage of the absence of Peter and of the other bishops to make regulations for the conduct of their dioceses. Provision had been made for the spiritual wants of the Christians, but Meletius was determined to interfere. An account of his proceedings reached Phileas, Hesychius, Pachynius, and Theodore in their prison, and they wrote a joint epistle to Meletius, expostulating with him upon the irregularity of his conduct. The letter is still extant, and it shows that these bishops looked up to Peter as their metropolitan [the archbishop who heads a group of dioceses]. Meletius paid no regard to this remonstrance, and when the authors of it had closed their career by martyrdom, he went to Alexandria, and continued there the same irregular proceedings. Two persons supported him in his ambitious views: one was Isidorus, and the other Arius, who afterwards became so celebrated as a heresiarch. With their assistance Meletius was able to draw after him some of the priests who had been left in charge of the Alexandrian Church. Being now at the head of a party, he visited the confessors, who were in prison or at the mines, and two of them received ordination at his hands. When Peter heard of this open infringement of his rights, he wrote from his place of concealment to his flock at Alexandria, telling them not to hold communion with Meletius, but to wait till he could return and investigate the affair. The time of his revisiting Alexandria is uncertain, but it was probably not before 31 1, when Galerius [Diocletian’s co-emperor in the East and driving force of the Great Persecution] died and the persecution was relaxed. Immediately on his return, Peter summoned a synod of bishops to try Meletius on the charge of having encroached on the prerogatives of the bishop of Alexandria, and of having sacrificed to save his life during the late persecutions. A sentence of deposition was passed against him; but so far from submitting, Meletius organized a schism, and treated Peter with insolence. Arius did not join the seceders. He ceased to give his support to Meletius, and Peter not only forgave him, but ordained him deacon. The reconciliation, however, did not last long. The bishop found himself obliged to issue a sentence of excommunication against all the Meletians, and he took the decided measure of not recognizing their baptisms. Arius now detached himself from Peter, and was involved in the excommunication launched against Meletius. But the persecution, which had abated, broke out again.
Peter was seized by the express order of Maximinus, and was beheaded. As soon as Arius heard the sentence of Maximinus, he is said to have hasted to the church and entreated the clergy and people to intercede with Peter for him, to raise the ban from off him, hoping to be elected his successor. Peter answered with a sigh that Arius was cast forth from the face of God. Then, taking two priests to him from the throng, he said to them, “ Although I am a sinner, yet I know that I am called by heaven to die as a martyr. You are elected to succeed me in order on the Alexandrian throne, first Achilles and then Alexander. In the night, when I was completing my sacrifice of prayer, I saw suddenly Christ my Lord appear in a white mantle, rent from top to bottom. And He held the portions together with His hand over His breast. And when I saw this I said, ‘ My Lord, why dost Thou so appear ? ? And he answered me, ‘ Arius hath done this.’ Therefore I warn and exhort you not to receive Arius again into communion, for he is destined to rend the unity of the Church with a most grievous schism.” This story was probably composed after Arius had become a noted heresiarch.