In the church of Blachernae, a part of Constantinople, the walls were decorated with painted or mosaic images depicting the entire Gospel story from the Nativity to the descent of the Holy Spirit. The emperor ordered these images to be destroyed. This infuriated a devoted Christian layman named Paul, who boldly confronted the emperor and argued for the importance of sacred images in churches as “ways leading to Christ.”
Constantine replied, “How can one represent the incomprehensible, invisible, inaudible God, who exists not in comprehension, but solely in infinity? How can one represent the unimaginable with a picture and the unknown with lines and colors?” Paul responded, “Only because God became Incarnate.” Constantine's words reveal the core principle of the Iconoclastic persecution; it was a conflict between Deism, which was a modified form of Arianism, and the reality of the Incarnation.
The monks, priests, and laypeople who endured terrible deaths and tortures in defense of their images may not have fully realized that they were actually fighting for a fundamental principle of Christianity. Through the images, the reality of the Incarnation was being challenged. If the images were removed and the pictures erased, the significant events of the Gospel story would fade into myths of the past, and Christianity would dissolve into a form of theism, with Jesus as its great prophet.
Constantine ordered that Paul’s nose be cut off, and the martyr was taken away to prison while chanting, “In the way of Thy testimonies is my delight; as in all manner of riches. I will speak of thy testimonies even before kings, and will not be ashamed.”
After three days, he was brought back before the emperor and ordered to trample on images of the Savior and Saint Mary. Paul, looking at the ground, raised his hands to heaven and cried, “Far be it from me, Lord Jesus Christ, Son of the living God, to profane Your image, or that of Your Mother and Your Saints. For by these we are led, as by a road, to the adoration of You!”
Then Constantine ordered that burning pitch and sulfur be poured over his head. He was taken away while singing psalms, later blinded, and dragged over the stones of the marketplace until he died. His body was secretly buried by the faithful in a monastery and was later exhumed and honorably enshrined when the Iconoclastic persecution ended, one hundred and twenty-two years later.
In 1326, the body was taken by the Venetians from Constantinople and placed in the church of Saint George the Greater in Venice, where it remains to this day.
Footnotes
- The church of Blachernae was a significant religious site in Constantinople.
- The Iconoclastic persecution involved the destruction of religious images and was a major conflict in early Christianity.
- Arianism was a belief that denied the full divinity of Jesus Christ.
- Saint George the Greater is a prominent church in Venice, dedicated to Saint George.
Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.
Read the original 1870s text
Baring-Gould’s sources: Venerated on this day at Venice. He is not to be confounded with S. Paul. M. at Constantinople, for the same cause, and about the same time, commemorated in the Roman Martyrology on March 17th. Authority: — A Latin Hfe by an anonymous writer of the date 1326. But this is only a translation from a Greek life written apparently in 888, or shortly after. That it is a translation there can be little doubt, for the Latin writer introduced Greek words — as “Manus antartica” / for antarsia, tyrannical, in another place leaves a blank for the Greek word which he could not translate, and in another gives an incorrect translation, making nonsense, but which one can at once rectify with a little knowledge of Greek.] The emperor Constantine Copronymus having resolved to proceed against images in churches, went into the vol. vii. 13 [July*.
…church of Blachernae, a part of Constantinople, where the walls were adorned with painted, or mosaic representations of the whole Gospel story from the Nativity to the descent of the Holy Ghost, and ordered them to be defaced. This so exasperated a zealous Christian layman, named Paul, that he boldly withstood the emperor, and argued the advantage of sacred representations in churches as “ ways leading to Christ.” Constantine answered, il How can one represent the incomprehensible, invisible, inaudible God, who exists not in comprehension, but solely in infinity? How represent the unimaginable by a picture I and the unknown by lines and colours ?” “ Only,” answered Paul, “ because God became Incarnate.” The words of Constantine exhibit at once the main principle of the Iconoclastic persecution; it was a struggle of Deism, exalted altered Arianism [followers of Arius, who taught that the Son is a created being, not fully God], against the reality of the Incarnation. The monks, and priests, and laymen who suffered horrible deaths and tortures in defence of their images, may little have understood that in reality they were fighting for a fundamental principle of Christianity. For, in fact, through the pictures, the reality of the Incarnation was assailed. Remove the images, efface the pictures, and the great facts of the Gospel story would fade out of remembrance into myths of the past, and Christianity dissolve into a theism, with Jesus as its great prophet. Constantine ordered the nose of Paul to be cut off, and the martyr was led away to prison chanting u In the way of Thy testimonies is my delight; as in all manner of riches. I will speak of thy testimonies even before kings, and will not be ashamed.”
After three days he was agaio brought before the emperor, and ordered to trample on representations of the Saviour and S. Mary. Then Paul, looking on the Inly 8.] Sunni/a.
ground, spread his hands to heaven and cried, “Far be it from me, Lord Jesus Christ, son of the living God, to profane thine image, or that of thy Mother and thy Saints. For by these we are led, as by a road, to the adoration of Thee l”
Then Constantine ordered lighted pitch and sulphur to be poured over his head. He was led away singing psalms, was afterwards deprived of his eyes, and dragged over the stones of the market-place till he was dead. His body was secretly buried by the faithful in a monastery, and was exhumed and honourably enshrined on the cessation of the Iconoclastic persecution, a hundred and twenty-two years later.
In 1326, the body was taken by the Venetians from Constantinople, and placed in the church of S. George the Greater at Venice, where it still remains.