St. Optatus

Optatus was bishop of Milevis in Numidia in the fourth century.

Read the essentials →
Feast June 4 · Bishop, Confessor

St. Optatus

Current feast

June 4
Secondary source · Wikipedia infobox

Traditional feast

June 4
1914 / pre-1969 calendar, per Baring-Gould (1897)

Represents

Bishop
Confessor

Feast days

Feast: June 4

This Saint’s Story

St Augustine names him among those who brought learning out of paganism into the Church, and he had probably been a rhetorician. Baring-Gould, following the older notices, calls him an African converted from idolatry. He is known by his books against the Donatists (a North African breakaway church that rejected clergy who had lapsed under persecution), written as a reply to Parmenian, Donatist bishop of Carthage. St Jerome says the work was in six books under Valens and Valentinian; we now have seven, with papal and Donatist lists carried into the 380s, so the first edition belongs about 366–370 and a second about 385–390.

Catholics and Donatists agreed that the Church must be one. Optatus argued that it cannot be shut in a corner of Africa: it must be the catholic Church spread through the world. He accepted five of the six marks Parmenian listed, and claimed the first—the episcopal chair—for the Catholics by pointing not to Carthage but to Rome, where Peter first sat and where, in Optatus’s day, Siricius sat in communion with the whole world. He was notably mild toward the schismatics. They had rejected unity, he said, yet they kept true doctrine and true sacraments, so Parmenian should not threaten them with damnation. Against their Cyprianic claim that baptism outside the Church is void, he insisted that the sacraments are holy in themselves, not through the minister, and that in baptism the Trinity and the believer matter more than the one who pours the water. He rebuked their sacrilege against altars as seats of the Body and Blood of Christ. In a seventh book he adds that Peter sinned gravely and denied his Master, yet retained the keys, and the Apostles did not break fellowship with him; so Catholics may receive Donatists back without harshness, for the cockle grows with the wheat.

His style is vigorous and charitable; he calls the Donatist bishops his brethren. He has left no clear ancient cultus; his name was later inserted in the Roman Martyrology (the Church's official list of saints for each day) on 4 June, which this page keeps. No patronage is clearly assigned to him in the Catholic Encyclopedia.

Short entry · the summary here is 50 words; Baring-Gould’s fuller original text and its sources are below. We have not filled any gap with invented detail.

What he represents

How he teaches us to live

Drawn from themes in the original account

Share your faith, in words and by example. Preaching and conversion are part of this story.

Feed your mind with Scripture and good books. Learning and the Scriptures matter in this life.

From the Catholic Encyclopedia

1913 · 1328 words

Bishop of Milevis, in Numidia, in the fourth century. He was a convert, as we gather from St. Augustine: "Do we not see with how great a booty of gold and silver and garments Cyprian, doctor suavissimus, came forth out of Egypt, and likewise Lactantius, Victorinus, Optatus, Hilary?" (De Doctrina Christ., xl). Optatus probably had been a pagan rhetorician. His work against the Donatists is an answer to Parmenian, the successor of Donatus in the See of Carthage. St. Jerome (De viris ill., cx) tells us it was in six books and was written under Valens and Valentinian (364-75). We now possess seven books, and the list of popes is carried as far as Siricius (384-98). Similarly the Donatist succession of antipopes is given (II, iv), as Victor, Bonifatius, Encolpius, Macrobius, Lucianus, Claudianus (the date of the last is about 380), though a few sentences earlier Macrobius is mentioned as the actual bishop. The plan of the work is laid down in Book I, and is completed in six books. It seems, then, that the seventh book, which St. Jerome did not know in 392, was an appendix to a new edition in which St. Optatus made additions to the two episcopal lists. The date of the original work is fixed by the statement in I, xiii, that sixty years and more had passed since the persecution of Diocletian [Roman emperor 284–305, who began the ‘Great Persecution’ of Christians in 303] (303-5). Photinus (d. 376) is apparently regarded as still alive; Julian is dead (363). Thus the first books were published about 366-70, and the second edition about 385-90.

St. Optatus deals with the entire controversy between Catholics and Donatists (see DONATISTS). He distinguishes between schismatics and heretics. The former have rejected unity, but the have true doctrine and true sacraments, hence Parmenian should not have threatened then (and consequently his own party) with eternal damnation. This mild doctrine is a great contrast to the severity of many of the Fathers against schism. It seems to be motived by the notion that all who have faith will be saved, though after long torments,—a view which St. Augustine has frequently to combat. Donatists and Catholics were agreed as to the necessary unity of the Church. The question was, where is this One Church? Optatus argues that it cannot be only in a corner of Africa; it must be the catholica (the word is used as a substantive) which is throughout the world. Parmenian had enumerated six dotes, or properties, of the Church, of which Optatus accepts five, and argues that the first, the episcopal chair, cathedra, belongs to the Catholics, and therefore they have all the others. The whole schism has arisen through the quarrel as to the episcopal succession at Carthage, and it might have been expected that Optatus would claim this property of cathedra by pointing out the legitimacy of the Catholic succession at Carthage. But he does not. He replies: "We must examine who sat first in the chair, and where. . . .You cannot deny that you know that in the city of Rome upon Peter first the chair of the bishop was conferred, in which sat the head of all the Apostles, Peter, whence also he was called Cephas, in which one chair unity should be preserved by all, lest the other Apostles should each stand up for his own chair, so that now he should be a schismatic and a sinner who should against this one chair set up another. Therefore in the one chair, which is the first of the dotes Peter first sat, to whom succeeded Linus." An incorrect list of popes follows, ending with, "and to Damasus Siricius, who is to-day our colleague, with whom the whole world with us agrees by the communication of commendatory letters in the fellowship of one communion. Tell us the origin of your chair, you who wish to claim the holy Church for yourselves". Optatus then mocks at the recent succession of Donatist antipopes at Rome.

Optatus argues, especially in book V, against the doctrine which the Donatists had inherited from St. Cyprian that baptism by those outside the Church cannot be valid, and he anticipates St. Augustine's argument that the faith of the baptizer does not matter, since it is God who confers the grace. His statement of the objective efficacy of the sacraments ex opere operato is well known: "Sacramenta per se esse sancta, non per homines" (V, iv). Thus in baptism there must be the Holy Trinity, the believer and the minister, and there importance is in this order, the third being the least important. In rebuking the sacrileges of the Donatists, he says: "What is so profane as to break, scrape, remove the altars of God, on which you yourselves had once offered, on which both the prayers of the people and the members of Christ have been borne, where God Almighty has been invoked, where the Holy Ghost has been asked for and has come down, from which by many has been received the pledge of eternal salvation and the safeguard of faith and the hope of resurrection? . . . For what is an altar but the seat of the Body and Blood of Christ?" In book VII a notable argument for unity is added: St. Peter sinned most grievously and denied his Master, yet he retained the keys, and for the sake of unity and charity the Apostles did not separate from his fellowship. Thus Optatus defends the willingness of the Catholics to receive back the Donatists to unity without difficulty, for there must be always sinners in the Church, and the cockle is mixed with the wheat; but charity covers a multitude of sins.

Read the rest of the article

The style of St. Optatus is vigorous and animated. He aims as terseness and effect, rather than at flowing periods, and this in spite of the gentleness and charity which is so admirable in his polemics against his "brethren", as he insists on calling the Donatist bishops. He uses Cyprian a great deal, though he refutes that saint's mistaken opinion about baptism, and does not copy his easy style. His descriptions of events are admirable and vivid. It is strange that Dupin should have called him minus nitidus ac politus, for both in the words he employs and in their order he almost incurs the blame of preciosity. His is as strict as Cyprian as to the metrical cadences at the close of every sentence. He was evidently a man of good taste as well as of high culture, and he has left us in his one work a monument of convincing dialectic, of elegant literary form, and of Christian charity. But the general marshalling of his arguments is not so good as is the development of each by itself. His allegorical interpretations are far-fetched, but those of Parmenian were evidently yet more extravagant. An appendix contained an important dossier of documents which had apparently been collected by some Catholic controversialist between 330 and 347 (see DONATISTS). This collection was already mutilated when it was copied by the scribe of the only manuscript which has preserved it, and that manuscript is incomplete, so that we can have to deplore the loss of a great part this first-rate material for the early history of Donatism. We can tell what has been lost by the citations made by Optatus himself and by Augustine.

St. Optatus has apparently never received any ecclesiastical cultus; but his name was inserted in the Roman Martyrology on the fourth of June, though it is quite unknown to all the ancient Martyrologies and calendars. The editio princeps was by Cochlæus (Mainz, 1549). More manuscripts were used by Balduinus (Paris, 1563 and 1569), whose text was frequently reprinted in the seventeenth century. Dupin's edition includes a history of the Donatists and a geography of Africa (Paris 1700—); it is reprinted in Gallandi and in Migne (P.L., XI). The best edition is that of Ziwza (C.S.E.L., XXVI, Vienna, 1893), with description of the manuscripts.

Read more

The full original · 50 words

Read Baring-Gould’s full account

Baring-Gould’s sources: Roman Martyrologies. Authorities: — His own writings, and mention by S. Fulgentius and S. Augustine.

S. Optatus was an African, and was educated as an idolater, but was converted to Christianity, and became bishop of Milevis in Numidia. He is chiefly known by his books against the Donatists, which is a principal source of information concerning these schismatics in the early portion of their history.

Help us add to this saint's story

Everything is read by a person before anything appears. Facts are checked against trusted sources first.

Facts are welcome; a source link helps (optional).With your permission we may share it on this page.

Nine days · Free

Pray the novena
with us.

One short email a day for nine days. The day's prayer, a line from St. Optatus's story, and a nudge to keep going.

Also on June 4
Q

St. Quirinus (June 4)

June 4 · Bishop, Martyr
B

St. Breacha

June 4 · Virgin
St. Francis Caracciolo

St. Francis Caracciolo

June 4 · Priest
← All 1970 saints in the library
Sources & notes

Feast-day sources

Story sources

Sources

Credits

Image: Optat de Mileve.jpg · Jacques Callot · Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Image: Jacques Callot, Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

From “Catholic Encyclopedia (1913)/St. Optatus,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (New York: Robert Appleton Company, 1907–1914), via Wikisource. Public domain. Matched by name and feast date; text unedited except for our bracketed notes in grey.

From Sabine Baring-Gould, The Lives of the Saints, new edition in 16 vols. (London: John C. Nimmo, 1897–98); text from the Internet Archive scan (OCR, lightly cleaned; errors possible). Public domain in the United States. Reproduced unedited, except for short bracketed notes in grey that we added to explain names and terms (“S.” is the old abbreviation for Saint). Some history and judgments reflect 19th-century scholarship.

Notes

Story retold in our own words from the cited sources.