M

Mennas became Patriarch of Constantinople in 536.

Read the essentials →
Traditional feast August 25 · Patriarch

St. Mennas of Constantinople

Feast

Traditional feast: August 25 (Roman Martyrology 1916 (archive.org OCR, sources/rm1916.txt))
Traditional date · cited source, no current calendar entry found

Traditional feast

August 25
1914 / pre-1969 calendar, per Baring-Gould (1897)

Represents

Patriarch

Feast days

Feast: August 25

This Saint’s Story

Adapted in modern English from Baring-Gould (1897–98) · original text below

Pope Agapetus had come to the imperial capital and found that the Empress Theodora wanted to move to the see a bishop suspected of Monophysite views (the belief that Christ has only one, divine nature, rejected by the Council of Chalcedon (the 451 worldwide council that taught Christ is one person in two natures, divine and human) in 451). The pope threatened to break communion, so the emperor Justinian named Mennas instead, and Agapetus himself consecrated him on April 22. The pope died soon after.

Mennas's time in office was overshadowed by the 'Three Chapters (writings of three 5th-century theologians condemned by Emperor Justinian)' controversy. Justinian, who loved theology, was persuaded to condemn the writings of three long-dead bishops (Theodore of Mopsuestia, Theodoret (5th-century bishop and church historian) of Cyrus and Ibas of Edessa), even though Chalcedon had accepted Theodoret and Ibas as orthodox. Mennas was required to sign the emperor's edict. Baring-Gould says he did so reluctantly and only provisionally, on condition that he could withdraw if the pope objected. He also argues that the charge that Mennas forced other bishops to sign cannot be proved.

Pope Vigilius arrived in 547 and at first excommunicated Mennas and the other signers. Then he swung round and condemned the Three Chapters himself, and later he wavered again. When Mennas and Theodore Askidas deposed the Patriarch of Alexandria for refusing to condemn them, Vigilius took sanctuary and excommunicated them both. In early 552 Mennas and the others sent the pope a profession of faith that satisfied him. In it they declared their full loyalty to Chalcedon and left the Three Chapters to a future council. Mennas died that August.

His short ancient biography adds a story of a Jewish glassmaker's son who received leftover Communion and was thrown into the furnace by his father, yet survived. Baring-Gould calls this 'a malicious lie', spread to stir up hatred of the Jews. In the story Justinian crucified the father and Mennas baptized the mother and child. The Jews of the empire were then stripped of their rights.

Struggles & surrender

His struggles

  • Pressure from the throne ·
    Pressed by the emperor to sign a contested edict, he did so only reluctantly and provisionally, and he was excommunicated by the pope before peace was made (Baring-Gould).

What he represents

How he teaches us to live

Drawn from themes in the original account

Stay faithful when it costs you. Holding firm under pressure is part of this story.

Celebrate this saint’s feast day. Remember him on August 25 with a short prayer, and ask for his help.

The full story

Baring-Gould’s account retold in modern English

Read the full story · 2,451 words · about 11 min

Agapetus arrived in Byzantium in February 336. He found the see of Constantinople empty, and the Empress Theodora was preparing to appoint the Bishop of Trebizonde, who was suspected of holding Eutychian views.

The Pope threatened that if such an appointment were made, he would cut off communion with the new Patriarch. Justinian listened to his objections and appointed Mennas to the vacant see. The new Patriarch was consecrated on April 22, 336, by the elderly Pope. Agapetus died shortly afterward.

This opportunity was taken by Vigilius. The scandalous story has been told elsewhere of Vigilius promising the Empress that he would support Eutychianism if she would help him become Pope, of how he rushed to Rome with treasures provided by Theodora to bribe the corrupt Roman people, of how he found Sylverius already in the position of Saint Peter, how he deposed him with the help of Belisarius, how he exiled him and caused his death, and thus cleared the way for his own rise to the apostolic throne. The Controversy of the Three Chapters now troubled the East. Justinian the Emperor was a theologian, or believed himself to be; while his borders were threatened by hungry barbarians, he chose to fight against heretics whom he could eliminate without risking his own safety. He sought victories over theological opponents while avoiding the uncertain outcomes of battle against the enemies of his empire and of Christianity.

“What is there to fear,” asked a bold conspirator of his associates, “from this bigoted tyrant? Sleepless and unarmed, he spends whole nights in his chamber, debating with respected elders and poring over ecclesiastical texts.” It had now been three hundred years since the death of Origen. The orthodoxy of this significant ecclesiastical writer became a topic of debate, controversy, and condemnation. Justinian, with a keen eye, identified more than ten errors in his works, and his memory was condemned. However, the writings of Origen were cherished by the monks of Palestine and by many of the more educated and learned Oriental bishops. It was necessary to redirect the Imperial controversialist's attention to another topic. Theodore Askidas, Archbishop of Ctesarea in Cappadocia, both respected the memory of Origen and appreciated the works of that great doctor. He may have been inclined to adopt Monophysite views of the nature of Christ, but this is not confirmed. The immoral Theodora, whom Justinian had elevated to the Imperial throne as his wife, was deeply influenced by these views and sought an opportunity to undermine or weaken the authority of the Council of Chalcedon. Theodore and Theodora combined their influence over the weak-minded Justinian to stir up a controversy that would serve their respective purposes.

Theodore of Mopsuestia, Theodoret of Cyrus, and Ibas of Edessa had not been condemned; on the contrary, they had been recognized as orthodox by the Council of Chalcedon. All three were already dead, but what did that matter? Let their memories become the battlefield for a new controversy! If these three writers were declared heretical, the authority of Chalcedon would be undermined—this was what Theodora sought. The heat and excitement of the controversy would also distract the Emperor’s attention from Origen—this was the aim of Theodore Askidas.

Pope Vigilius had a written promise to the Empress to secure the condemnation of the Council of Chalcedon. It was necessary to bring him to Constantinople. He was therefore ordered to go to the imperial capital, and he set out, burdened with the curses of the Roman people and pelted with stones, as he was accused of being the murderer of Sylverius and of his nephew, whom he had scourged to death. “May famine and pestilence pursue you; you have done evil to us, may evil overtake you wherever you are!”

Meanwhile, Justinian had finished reading the writings of Theodore of Mopsuestia, Theodoret of Cyrus, and Ibas of Edessa. He looked for heresy, and his passion was satisfied. He found minor points, words, and expressions that could be twisted to suggest unsound views. He formulated these into the Three Chapters and prepared to issue an edict condemning them. This was presented to Mennas, and he was asked to sign it. He hesitated and only agreed reluctantly, on the condition that his signature was provisional and that he could withdraw it if Pope Vigilius objected to the condemnation.

Ephraem, Patriarch of Antioch, initially refused to sign the edict but gave in when threatened with deposition. Peter, Patriarch of Jerusalem, showed the same cowardice and inconsistency. When a crowd of zealous and protesting monks surrounded him, he swore that the edict attacked the Council of Chalcedon and that he would never support it; yet, when threatened by the Emperor, he shamefully submitted to it. Zoilus of Alexandria followed their disgraceful example. Mennas was accused of forcing his suffragans to sign, but this is not a charge that can be proven. It was merely an excuse made by some of the signers to Stephen, the papal secretary, to justify their own submission to the imperial will.

Facundus, Bishop of Hermiane, and other African bishops were then in Constantinople. Facundus drafted a defense of the Three Chapters, and he and his African allies broke off communion with Mennas and all those prelates who had signed the condemnation.

At this point, Vigilius arrived in Constantinople on January 25, A.D. 547, and was received by the Emperor with the highest honor. When Vigilius left Rome, he had been earnestly and solemnly instructed by the clergy and the people not to listen to any proposals made by the Empress to obtain a condemnation of the Council of Chalcedon. It had become known that Vigilius owed his position as Pope to her, and that in exchange for his advancement, he had made some promise to support the Monophysite heresy. His unscrupulous and irreligious character was well known, and the Church of Rome viewed Vigilius's journey to Constantinople with open alarm.

Upon his arrival in Byzantium, the Pope adopted a tone of high and rigid orthodoxy. He issued an interdict against Mennas of Constantinople, Ephraem of Antioch, Peter of Jerusalem, and all the bishops who had signed the edict of Justinian condemning the Three Chapters.

However, Vigilius was manipulated by Theodora and Justinian. Through flattery, persuasion, and every tactic that would appeal to a man like Vigilius, he was led to change his mind. He then echoed the imperial demands with his own anathemas against those who adhered to the orthodoxy of the Three Chapters. “In conformity with your invincible wishes,” wrote the Pope to Justinian and Theodora, “I anathematize the letter of Ibas, and the doctrine of Theodoret, and of Theodore, formerly Bishop of Mopsuestia, who was always alien from the Church and opposed to the holy Fathers. We anathematize everyone who does not acknowledge that the Word of God, Christ, has but one substance, one person, and one operation!” When Vigilius had thus changed sides, he returned to communion with Mennas and the other bishops whom he had previously excommunicated.

On April 11, 548, Pope Vigilius sent his “Judicatum” to Mennas, which, as the title indicates, contains the Pope's judgment on the questions posed to him. This document is unfortunately lost, but fragments remain that allow us to assess its content. He anathematized the Three Chapters but included a saving clause stating that no disrespect to the authority of the Council of Chalcedon was intended. In other words, he condemned as heretical those whose orthodoxy had been affirmed by the Fathers of Chalcedon, yet without prejudice to that. Three years later, when Vigilius had reverted again to the opposite side, he justified his “Judicatum” as a shifting document meant to appease a pointless controversy.

Shortly after the publication of the “Judicatum,” Empress Theodora died on June 28, 548 AD. However, her death did not settle the dispute, as Justinian was now filled with theological zeal and determined to force the entire Church to condemn Theodore of Mopsuesta, who had died a hundred years earlier while still in full communion with the Church, along with Theodore of Cyrus and Ibas of Edessa, whose orthodoxy had been upheld by the Fourth Ecumenical Council. The Pope's “Judicatum” had caused significant alarm and outrage. His nephew, the deacon Rusticus, and the Roman deacon Sebastian wrote to Italy stating that the Holy Father “had struck a blow at the authority of the Council of Chalcedon!” The Roman clerks, John, Gerontius, Severinus, John, and Deusdedit, opposed the “Judicatum” for the same reasons. Vigilius, feeling angry and alarmed, removed them from their positions. Valentinian, Bishop of Tomi, and Aurelian, Archbishop of Arles, wrote to the Pope expressing their concern. Rumors spread throughout Gaul that Vigilius had overturned the four great councils. In Illyria, Dalmatia, Africa, and Scythia, opposition to the “Judicatum” became strong. A synod of the Illyrian bishops convened, defended the orthodoxy of the Three Chapters, and deposed the Metropolitan Benenatus for condemning them in line with the Pope's “Judicatum.” Instead of calming the controversy, Vigilius's judgment had stirred it up.

The Pope decided it was wise to withdraw the “Judicatum” after consulting with Mennas, Dacius of Milan, and several other Greek and Latin bishops. However, at the same time he publicly withdrew his “Judicatum,” he privately promised Justinian on August 15, 550 AD, that he would work with the Emperor to obtain a sentence of anathema against the Three Chapters. It was also agreed that this arrangement would remain secret. Shortly after this, the Emperor called a large synod in Constantinople for the bishops of Illyria and Africa. The bishops from Illyria refused to attend, but those from Africa were present, either in person or by representation. The Emperor and the Greek bishops tried to persuade them to sign a condemnation of the Three Chapters. When they refused, Reparatus of Carthage was deposed on a trivial pretext, and his compliant secretary was promoted in his place. Firmus of Numidia was won over by gifts from the Emperor. Primasius of the province of Byzacene only agreed after his metropolitan died, allowing him to secure the metropolitan chair for himself by supporting the anathema. The fourth African deputy, Verecundus, remained stubborn.

Justinian, at the urging of Theodore Askidas, created a second edict that condemned the Three Chapters. The announcement of this edict caused great distress for the Pope. He realized that it would be impossible for him to continue addressing the issue of the Three Chapters without provoking the entire Western Church against him. The cautious and compromising “Judicatum” had been presented as a test, and it revealed that the West was firmly committed to the decisions of the Chalcedonian Council and would not tolerate any indirect criticism of it. It was certain that Justinian would force him to accept the edict if he stayed in Constantinople. If he accepted it, Rome would rebel, and he would never be able to return there. When there was a suggestion that he might give in, the determined Romans had thrown stones at him. How would they react if he cowardly accepted the edict? He sought refuge in the basilica of St. Peter, along with Dacius of Milan and other Latin bishops who were with him. Meanwhile, Theodore Askidas, in collaboration with Mennas, removed Zoilus, the Patriarch of Alexandria, because he refused to condemn the Three Chapters, and appointed a man named Apollinaris in his place. From the church of St. Peter, Pope Vigilius wrote a sentence of excommunication and deposition against Askidas, Mennas, and all their supporters, and entrusted it to a woman, who was to announce it if certain conditions arose.

When Justinian learned of the Pope's flight, he sent soldiers to bring him out of the church. However, Vigilius refused to leave the sanctuary. When they threatened to use force, he ran to the altar and clung to one of its pillars. The soldiers grabbed his legs and pulled; the Pope, a strong and sturdy man, held onto the pillar. The column began to give way, and the altar slab would have fallen and crushed his head if some of the clergy had not supported it with their shoulders. The Pope's determination thwarted the soldiers' intentions, and they retreated. The Emperor then swore that he would not harm the Pope or restrict his freedom if he would return to his palace, and Vigilius left his place of refuge.

As time went on, Vigilius realized that he was being kept in Constantinople solely to wear him down until he surrendered to the Emperor's demands. He had now been in Constantinople for nearly four years; the challenges he faced were not easing and were becoming increasingly complicated. He secretly fled again from his palace, crossed the Bosphorus, and sought refuge in the church of St. Euphemia at Chalcedon. From there, in January 552, he issued the edict of excommunication that he had prepared six months earlier against Askidas, Mennas, and others.

A month later, he received a profession of faith in his sanctuary from Askidas, Mennas, and the others, which satisfied him. They assured him that they respected the Council of Chalcedon and adhered to its decisions without adding to or subtracting anything from them. As for the matter of the Three Chapters, that should be decided by a future council.

Not long after, in August, A.D. 552, Mennas died and was succeeded in the patriarchal see by Eutychius. The brief biography of Mennas does not add much to what is known about him from other sources. He participated, but in a harmless way, in one of those persecutions of the Jews based on false charges that have stained Christian history. It was customary for any Holy Eucharist that was not consumed at Mass by the communicants to be given to innocent children. There was a Jewish boy, the son of a glass maker, who was at school, and on one occasion, he was given what remained of the Host, as the priest did not know that he was unbaptized. The story goes that when his father heard what he had received, filled with rage, he threw his child into the glass furnace. The mother searched for him in vain; on the third day, going near the furnace, she called for her son, and the boy answered from the middle of the fire and came out unharmed.

Thus ran the malicious lie, which was diligently spread among the people to incite them to fury against the Hebrews. Justinian immediately seized the glass-blower and crucified him; Mennas took the wife and child and baptized them. The Jews were stripped of all their privileges and were burdened with a troublesome law that forced them to observe Passover on the same day that Christians celebrated Easter.

Footnotes

  1. The story of Vigilius promising the Empress to uphold Eutychianism is detailed elsewhere.
  2. Procopius, De Bell. Goth. iii. 32.
  3. See on the purpose of Theodore in stirring up this controversy, Hefele’s Concilien Geschichte, iii. 1. 4, c. 1.
  4. The words “one operation” are probably an interpolation.
  5. Besides the fragment published by Baluze, Bishop Hefele has discovered five more in the Constitution of Vigilius.
  6. Theodora died on June 28, 548 AD.
  7. The Fourth Ecumenical Council upheld the orthodoxy of Ibas of Edessa.
  8. The synod of Illyrian bishops defended the Three Chapters.
  9. Reparatus of Carthage was deposed on a trivial pretext.
  10. Primasius of Byzacene secured the metropolitan chair for himself.
  11. A.D. 552: Anno Domini 552, meaning "in the year of our Lord 552."

Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.

Read the original 1870s text

Baring-Gould’s sources: Greek Menology and Modern Roman Martyrology. Authorities: — A Greek anonymous life, and authorities for the life of Popes Agapetus and Vigilius.] When Justinian, Emperor of the East, was preparing to invade Italy and rescue it from the domination of the Goths, the Gothic King Theodotus sent Pope Agapetus to Constantinople (a.d. 535), to ward off the impending danger, by exercising his influence upon the Emperor, and should all his efforts to obtain peace prove unavailing, he was to produce a letter from the Gothic King containing a declaration of war. Should Justinian land his troops in Italy, Theodotus declared his intention of instantly putting the Roman Senate to the sword, and razing the city of the Caesars to the ground.

Agapetus reached Byzantium in February, 336. He found the see of Constantinople [a bishop’s “see” is his diocese, named from his seat (Latin sedes)] vacant, and the Empress Theodora prepared to translate to it the Bishop of Trebizonde, suspected of Eutychian [followers of Eutyches, who said Christ had only a divine nature; condemned at Chalcedon in 451] views.

The Pope threatened in the event of such an appointment to cut off communion with the new Patriarch. Justinian [Byzantine emperor 527–565] listened to his remonstrances, and nominated Mennas to the vacant see. The new Patriarch was consecrated, April 22nd, 336, by the aged Pope. Agapetus died shortly after.

The opportunity was seized by Vigilius. The scandalous story has been told elsewhere1 of Vigilius promising the Empress to uphold Eutychianism if she would obtain for him the Papacy, of how he hastened to Rome with treasures supplied by Theodora to bribe the venal Roman people, how he found Sylverius already in the chair of S. Peter, 1 See life of S. Sylverius, June 20.

how he deposed him with the help of Belisarius, how he banished him and caused his death, and so cleared the way for his own accession to the apostolic throne. The Controversy of the Three Chapters now disturbed the East. Justinian the Emperor was a theologian, or thought himself so; whilst his frontiers were threatened by hungry barbarians, he took the field against heretics whom he could exterminate without danger to his person. He would reap victories over theological opponents when he shrank from exposing himself to the precarious fortune of battle against the enemies of his empire and of Christianity.

“What is there to fear,” asked a bold conspirator of his associates, “ from this bigoted tyrant? Sleepless and unarmed he sits whole nights in his closet, debating with reverend greybeards, and turning over the pages of ecclesiastical volumes.” 1 It was now three hundred years since the death of Origen. The orthodoxy of this great ecclesiastical writer was made the subject of debate, of controversy, of anathema. Jus tinian, with penetrating eye, descried more than ten errors in his works, and his memory was condemned to reprobation. But the writings of Origen were dear to the monks of Palestine, and to many of the more intelligent and learned of the Oriental bishops. It was necessary to divert the mind of the Imperial controversialist to another subject. Theodore Askidas, Archbishop of Ctesarea in Cappadocia [a region of central Turkey], both respected the memory of Origen and loved the works of that great doctor. He was perhaps disposed to take Monophysite views of the nature of Christ; but this is not established. The harlot Theodora, whom Justinian had raised to the Imperial throne as his consort, was deeply tainted with these views, and sought an opportunity to 1 Procopius, De Bell. Goth. iii. 32.

August 25.3 S. Mennas. overthrow or weaken the authority of the Council of Chalcedon. Theodore and Theodora combined their influence over the feeble mind of Justinian to excite a controversy which would further their several ends.

Theodore of Mopsuestia, Theodoret of Cyrus, and Ibas of Edessa, had not been condemned — on the contrary, they had been admitted as orthodox, by the Council of Chalcedou.. They were all three dead — but what did that matter? Let their memories be the battlefield for a new controversy ! If these three writers should be pronounced heretical, the authority of Chalcedon would be shaken — this was what Theodora sought; and the heat and excitement of the controversy would distract the Emperor’s thoughts from Origen — this was the purpose of Theodore Askidas.1 Pope Vigilius was under written promise to the Empress to obtain the condemnation of the Council of Chalcedon. It was necessary to bring him to Constantinople. He was accordingly ordered to resort to the imperial capital; and he set forth, loaded with the imprecations of the Roman people, and assailed with volleys of stones, as the murderer of Sylverius, and of his nephew, whom he had scourged to death. “ May famine and pestilence pursue thee; evil hast thou done to us, may evil overtake thee wherever thou art !” In the meantime Justinian had concluded his perusal of the writings of Theodore of Mopsuestia, Theodoret of Cyrus, and Ibas of Edessa. He looked for heresy, and his passion was gratified. He detected minute points, words, expressions, capable of being forced to express unsound views. These he formulated in Three Chapters, and prepared to issue an edict condemning them. It was presented to 1 See on the purpose of Theodore in stirring up this controversy, Hefele’s Con cilien Geschichte, iii. 1. 4, c. 1.

VOL. IX. Mennas, and he was required to sign it. He hesitated, and only yielded reluctantly, on the understanding that his signature was provisional, and that he might withdraw it, should Pope Vigilius object to the condemnation. Ephraem, Patriarch of Antioch, at first refused to sign the edict, but yielded when threatened with deposition. Peter, Patriarch of Jerusalem, showed the same cowardice and inconsequence. When a crowd of zealous and protesting monks besieged him, he swore that the edict attacked the Council of Chalcedon, and that he would never sanction it; yet, when threatened by the Emperor, he basely gave in to it his adhesion. Zoilus of Alexandria followed their ignoble lead. Mennas is charged with having forced his suffragans to subscribe, but this is not a charge that can be substantiated. It was an excuse made by some of the subscribers to Stephen, the papal secretary, to cover their own subservience to the imperial will.

Facundus, Bishop of Hermiane, and other African bishops were then in Constantinople; Facundus drew up a defence of the Three Chapters, and he and his African allies broke off communion with Mennas and all those prelates who had signed the condemnation.

At this juncture Vigilius arrived in Constantinople, January 25, a.d. 547, and was received by the Emperor with the highest honour. Vigilius on leaving Rome had been earnestly, solemnly charged by the clergy and the people not to listen to any overtures made by die Empress to obtain a condemnation of the Council of Chalcedon. It had leaked out that to her Vigilius owed his position on the throne of S. Peter, that in return for his advancement he had made some promise to support the Monophysite heresy; his unscrupulous, irreligious character was too well known, and the Church of Rome viewed the journey of Vigilius to Constantinople with undisguised alarm. The Pope assumed a tone S. Mennas.

of high and rigid orthodoxy on his arrival at Byzantium. He launched an interdict against Mennas of Constantinople, Ephraem of Antioch, Peter of Jerusalem, and all the bishops who had signed the edict of Justinian condemning the Three Chapters.

But Yigilius was subjected to the manipulation of Theodora and Justinian; by flattery, persuasion, and every art which would weigh with an unscrupulous man like Yigilius, he was brought into an opposite frame of mind, and he fulminated his anathemas in echo to the imperial thunders against those who adhered to the orthodoxy of the Three Chapters. “ In conformity with your invincible wishes,” wrote the Pope to Justinian and to Theodora, “I anathematize the letter of Ibas, and the doctrine of Theodoret, and of Theodore, formerly Bishop of Mopsuestia, who was ever alien from the Church, and opposed to the holy Fathers. We anathematize every one who does not acknowledge that the Word of God, Christ, has but one substance, one person, and one operation l”1 When Vigilius had thus changed sides, he returned to communion with Mennas and the other bishops whom he had previously excommunicated.

On April nth, 548, Pope Vigilius sent to Mennas his “Judicatum,” which, as the title expresses, contains the judgment of the Pope on the questions propounded to him. This document is unfortunately lost, but fragments remain which allow us to judge of its character.2 He anathematized the Three Chapters, but introduced a saving clause that no derogation to the authority of the Council of Chalcedon was meant thereby. That is — he condemned as heretical those whose orthodoxy had been proclaimed by the Fathers of Chalcedon, yet without prejudice to that 1 The words “ one operation ” are probably an interpolation. 2 Besides the fragment published by Baluze, Bishop Hefele has discovered five more in the u Constitution” of Vigilius. Council ! Three years after, when Vigilius had reverted again to the opposite side, he excused his “ Judicatum,” as a shifty production whose tendency was to appease a profitless controversy.

Shortly after the publication of the “Judicatum,” the Empress Theodora died, June 28th, a.d. 548. But her death did not appease the contest, for Justinian was now fired with theologic zeal, and bent on forcing the whole Church to condemn Theodore of Mopsuesta, dead a hundred years ago in full communion with the Church, Theodoretof Cyrus, and Ibas of Edessa, whose orthodoxy had been vindicated by the Fourth CEcumenical Council. The “ Judicatum " of the Pope had excited lively alarm and indignation. His nephew, the deacon Rusticus, the Roman deacon Sebastian, wrote to Italy that the Holy Father “ had struck a blow at the authority of the Council of Chalcedon !” The Roman clerks, John, Gerontius, Severinus, John, and Deusdedit, opposed the “Judicatum ” on the same grounds. Vigilius, angry and alarmed, deprived them of their offices. Valentinian, Bishop of Tomi, and Aurelian [Roman emperor 270–275], Archbishop of Arles, wrote in alarm to the Pope. The rumour spread through Gaul [roughly modern France and Belgium] that Vigilius had overthrown the four great councils. In Illyria, in Dalmatia, in Africa, and in Scythia, opposition to the “Judicatum” became determined. A synod of the Illyrian bishops met, vindicated the orthodoxy of the Three Chapters, and deposed the Metropolitan Benenatus for condemning them in conformity with the “Judicatum” of the Pope. So far from appeasing controversy, the judgment of Vigilius had excited it.

The Pope thought prudent to withdraw it, after a consultation with Mennas, Dacius of Milan, and several other Greek and Latin bishops. But at the same time that he openly withdrew his “Judicatum,” he privately by oath promised Justinian (Aug. 15, a.d. 550) “that he would endeavour, along with the Emperor, to obtain a sentence of anathema against the Three Chapters,” it was further stipulated that this compact should be kept secret. Soon after this, the Emperor convoked a great synod at Constantinople of the bishops of Illyria and Africa. The bishops of Illyria refused to attend, but those of Africa were present, either personally or by representation. The Emperor and the Greek bishops endeavoured to cajole them into signing a condemnation of the Three Chapters. On their refusal, Reparatus of Carthage was deposed on a frivolous excuse, and his compliant secretary elevated in his room. Firmus of Numidia was won by the presents of the Emperor. Primasius of the province of Byzacene only yielded when his metropolitan [the archbishop who heads a group of dioceses] died, and he was able, by giving in his adhesion to the anathema, to secure the metropolitan chair for himself. The fourth African deputy, Verecundus, proved stubborn.

Justinian, at the instigation of Theodore Askidas, now drew up a second edict charged with anathemas against the Three Chapters. The publication of this edict caused a commotion in the breast of the Pope. It was, he saw clearly, impossible for him to proceed further in the matter of the Three Chapters without rousing against him the whole of the West. The timorous, compromising “ Judicatum ” had been thrown out as a feeler, and it had shown him that the West was resolute in its chivalrous attachment to the Chalcedonian Council, and would not endure an oblique imputation cast at it. That Justinian would force him to subscribe the edict if he tarried in Constantinople was certain. If he subscribed it, Rome would be in revolt, and he could never again set his foot in it. At the suggested possibility of his yielding, the vigorous Romans had pelted him with stones. How would they treat him if he basely subscribed? He took refuge in the basilica of S. Peter, with Dacius of Milan, and other Latin bishops who were with him. I11 the meantime Theodore Askidas, in concert with Mennas, deposed Zoilus, Patriarch of Alexandria, because he would not condemn the Three Chapters, and appointed in his room a certain Apollinaris. From the church of S. Peter, Pope Vigilius drew up a sentence of excommunication and deposition against Askidas, Mennas, and all their partisans, and confided it to the care of a woman, who was to publish it in the event of certain contingencies.

Justinian, hearing of the flight of the Pope, sent soldiers to take him from the church. But Vigilius would not leave the sanctuary. When they threatened force, he flew to the altar, and embraced one of its pillars. The soldiers seized him by the legs and pulled; the Pope, a stalwart and sturdy man, held the pillar; the column yielded, and the altar slab would have fallen on him and crushed his head, had not some of the clergy placed their shoulders under it and sustained it. The resolution of the Pope overcame the purpose of the soldiers, and they withdrew. The Emperor then swore that he would not injure the Pope, nor interfere with his liberty, if he would return to his palace, and Vigilius left his asylum.

Time passed, and Vigilius saw that he was being detained in Constantinople for no other purpose than that he should yield through exhaustion of patience to the resolution of the Emperor. He had now been nearly four years in Constantinople; the difficulties of his position were not lightened, they daily became more perplexing. He secretly fled again from his palace, crossed the Bosphorus, and took refuge in the church of S. Euphemia at Chalcedon. Thence, in January, 552, he launched the edict of excommunication drawn up six months before against Askidas, Mennas, &c. August 25.3 51. Mennas.

A month later he received in his sanctuary a profession of faith from Askidas, Mennas, and the rest, which satisfied him. They assured him that they respected the Council of Chalcedon, and adhered to its decisions without adding to or subtracting anything from them. As for the matter of the Three Chapters, let that remain to be decided by a future council.

Not long after, in August, a.d. 552, Mennas died, and was succeeded in the patriarchal see by Eutychius. The brief biography of Mennas does not add much to what is known of him from other sources. He took part, but it was a harmless one, in one of those persecutions of the Jews on a false charge which have disgraced Christian history. It was the custom for such of the Holy Eucharist as was not consumed at mass by the communicants to be given to innocent children. Now, there was a Jewish lad, son of a glass maker, at school, and on one occasion he was given what remained of the Host, the priest not knowing that he was unbaptized. The story goes that when his father heard what he had received, filled with rage, he cast his child into the glass-furnace. The mother sought him in vain; the third day, going near the furnace, she called her son, and the boy answered from the midst of the fire, and came forth unhurt.

Thus ran the malicious lie, diligently circulated among the people to excite them to fury against the Hebrews. Justinian at once seized the glass-blower and crucified him; Mennas took the wife and child, and baptized them. The Jews were stripped of all their immunities, and were oppressed with a vexatious law which compelled them to observe the Passover on the same day on which the Christians celebrated Easter.

Help us add to this saint's story

Everything is read by a person before anything appears. Facts are checked against trusted sources first.

Facts are welcome; a source link helps (optional).With your permission we may share it on this page.

Nine days · Free

Pray the novena
with us.

One short email a day for nine days. The day's prayer, a line from St. Mennas of…'s story, and a nudge to keep going.

Also on August 25
G

St. Genes

August 25 · Martyr
E

St. Ebba

August 25 · Virgin, Abbess

St. Louis

August 25 · King, Confessor
← All 1970 saints in the library
Sources & notes

Feast-day sources

Story sources

Sources

Credits

Retold in plain modern English from Baring-Gould’s public-domain text, sentence by sentence, keeping the same facts and order. Short explanations in parentheses are ours.

From Sabine Baring-Gould, The Lives of the Saints, new edition in 16 vols. (London: John C. Nimmo, 1897–98); text from the Internet Archive scan (OCR, lightly cleaned; errors possible). Public domain in the United States. Reproduced unedited, except for short bracketed notes in grey that we added to explain names and terms (“S.” is the old abbreviation for Saint). Some history and judgments reflect 19th-century scholarship.