One Person exists in two natures, which are neither mixed together nor separated. He wills and acts at the same time in both the Divine and the human ways. Others say that in one Person, the two natures are united without division, and the distinction between these natures is not erased. Following the characteristics of these natures, one and the same Christ operates in both the Divine and the human ways.
We believe, with God's help, that it is our duty to put an end to the flame of conflict and to protect souls from being endangered by it. Therefore, we forbid our subjects from this moment onward to argue and fight over whether there is one will and one energy, or two wills and two energies. Our decree is not meant to undermine any teachings of the holy fathers regarding the Divine Word. We simply wish to end all disputes over this issue, and we want our subjects to adhere to the sacred scriptures and the traditions of the five ecumenical councils, as well as to the teachings and propositions of the fathers, without shortening, adding to, or distorting them in any way. Every effort should be made to maintain the doctrine that was held before this controversy arose, and neither side should blame the other.
To help resolve this issue peacefully, the emperor ordered the removal of the Ecthesis of Heraclius, which outlined the doctrine of the One Will, from the narthex (entrance area) of the great church in Constantinople. He also threatened the factions with various punishments.
Immediately after the publication of the Type, and likely before he was aware of it, Theodore died. Martin had been the apocrisiarius (representative) of the Holy See in Constantinople before he became the Pope, so he was very passionate about the controversy that had surrounded him. The Acts of S. Ouen state that the emperor immediately asked Martin, in a friendly manner, to support the Type, but the Pope refused in the most decisive way. Martin then asked the king of the Franks to send learned bishops to Rome to discuss how best to counter and dismantle the emperor's peaceful attempts and reignite the controversial issues that were affecting the East. The king decided to send Ouen of Rouen and Eligius of Noyon to Rome, but circumstances prevented them from making the journey.
In October 649, a council of one hundred and five bishops gathered in the Lateran at Rome. The bishops were mostly from Italy and the nearby islands. After five sessions, during which Monothelitism was proven to be heretical and against Christ according to the authority of the Church fathers, twenty canons were established condemning the heresy and its proponents. However, Pope Martin was not satisfied with merely condemning the erroneous doctrine of the Single Will, humiliating the rival prelate of Constantinople through excommunication in a full council, and declaring the edict of the deceased emperor Heraclius, known as the Ecthesis, to be utterly impious. He also denounced the Type of the reigning emperor, which encouraged peace, as equally impious. He scorned its call to set aside differences in Christian charity, viewing it as a temptation to accept heresy. He believed that refraining from passionate debate on such doctrines was a wicked suppression of Divine truth.
Martin was also active in defending his strong stance. He published the decrees of the Lateran Council throughout the West. He appointed a legate in the East to replace the Monothelite patriarchs of Antioch and Jerusalem. Paul of Thessalonica had agreed to condemn the doctrine but hesitated to excommunicate those who had accepted the doctrine of the One Will out of misunderstanding. Martin expressed his anger towards him for this hesitation.
Because he refrained from action, Martin condemned him as a concentration of all heretical wickedness. He wrote to the faithful in the patriarchates of Antioch and Jerusalem to encourage them to oppose Macedonius and Peter, the bishops of Antioch and Alexandria, who had accepted the Ecthesis and the Type. While the Lateran Council was in session, the emperor sent his chamberlain, Olympius, to Italy to secure acceptance of the Type by any means necessary. Upon arriving in Rome, later writers, such as Anastasius the Librarian, claim that Olympius attempted to arrange the assassination of the Pope while Martin was administering communion. However, it is said that a sudden blindness fell upon the servant assigned to carry out the murder, preventing him from seeing either the Pope, the communion, or the kiss of peace. The reason the would-be murderer saw none of this was that there was no intended murderer to see them.
Olympius was quickly called from Rome to defend Sicily against an invasion by the Saracens, and he died from exhaustion on that island. Another exarch took his place, Theodoras Calliopas (June, 653), a man who was both determined and cunning. He marched to Rome at the head of a group of soldiers and ordered the Pope to submit to the imperial authority. There was some delay; Martin wrote to one of his friends that he was ready to rejoice rather than mourn in the midst of his troubles.
On June 15, the day Theodore entered Rome, he withdrew with all his clergy into the church of the Saviour, the Lateran basilica. The Pope sent a delegation to the exarch to congratulate him on his arrival and to excuse the delay.
(“So that by this you not only refuse to anathematize those whom we also anathematize, namely the very persons of the heretics, but also that you confirm every error of the Pagans, Jews, and heretics in you, and also condemn all the doctrines of all these as contrary and hostile to the truth; you, therefore, do not anathematize with us all those things which we anathematize, it follows that you have confirmed all these errors, which are anathematized by us or by the Catholic Church.”)
Martin was unable to meet the exarch due to feeling unwell. The exarch received the delegation kindly, and when he noticed that the Pope had not come to greet him and learned the reason, or rather the excuse, he hid his displeasure at the perceived rudeness and said he would visit the Pope the next day. Martin felt well enough that Sunday to celebrate Mass before a large crowd. The exarch, tired from his journey, postponed his visit until Monday. On that day, he sent his secretary to the Pope to ask why he had filled his residence with stones, weapons, and supplies as if preparing for a siege. Martin denied having done so and instructed the secretary to check every room to confirm that he had not done anything of the kind.
Martin then complained about the false accusations against him, including the claim that he had offered armed support to the "infamous" Olympius. The Pope had ordered his bed to be laid out before the high altar in the Lateran. The exarch and his troops entered the church, and the flickering candlelight reflected off the soldiers' armor. Theodore Calliopas immediately informed the priests and deacons that he carried a decree stating that Martin, having taken the episcopate unlawfully and irregularly, must be taken to Constantinople, and a successor should be appointed in his place. This charge was likely accurate. He had seemingly tried to bypass the emperor's approval during his election and was the first among the Popes to attempt to free himself from the imperial authority that claimed the right to accept or reject the Pope-Elect.
Various other accusations were fabricated against him, such as that he had sent money to the Saracens and had not taught the correct faith regarding the Blessed Virgin Mary. The people shouted, "Anathema to anyone who says that Martin has opposed the faith; anathema to anyone who is not faithful to the faith." The exarch calmed the crowd by clarifying that the issue was not a matter of differing beliefs but rather one of usurping authority. On Tuesday, the clergy of Rome visited the Pope. During the night, he was taken to Ostia and set sail for Constantinople with six or seven attendants. After a three-month voyage, they arrived at the island of Naxos, where Martin was imprisoned. The only privilege granted to him was the ability to bathe and stay in a hostel; however, the guards kept for themselves the gifts that were brought and offered to him by his friends and supporters.
On September 17, 654, Pope Martin arrived in Constantinople and was immediately taken to the prison called Prandearia, where he spent ninety-three days. During this time, he wrote his second letter to Theodore, in which he complained that he had been kept for forty-eight days without a bath. He stated that his bowels were out of order and that his food was disgusting and insufficient. When he was taken from prison to be tried, he was very weak and could not stand without support.
The president asked, “Unhappy one, tell me, what wrong has the emperor done to you?” Martin did not answer. Witnesses were brought forward, testifying that he had conspired with Olympius against the emperor. It was undoubtedly true that Olympius and Martin had been on friendly terms in Rome; however, it cannot be said how far Olympius had shared with Martin any plans for revolt against Constans II. It is not likely that the accusations were entirely unfounded. Instead of denying them, Martin attempted to shift the focus to the doctrinal issue. “When the Type was published and sent to Rome,” he began, but was interrupted by the prefect, Troilus, who said, “We are not discussing doctrine, but rebellion. You knew that Olympius was plotting against the emperor, and instead of arresting him, you maintained a relationship with him.”
Martin exclaimed, “And you did not prevent George and Valentine from revolting against the emperor. How could I restrain a man supported by all the military force of Italy? However, resolve my case as quickly as you can, and as you wish.”
The president criticized the interpreter for translating this defiant speech literally, and then went to the emperor to report what had happened. The Pope was taken from the tribunal and placed in the great court so that the people could see him, and so that the emperor might see him, he was lifted onto a platform. A fiscal officer came out from the emperor's apartments and confronted him with the words, “You have struggled against the emperor; what hope remains for you now? You abandoned God, and God has abandoned you.” The Pope's ceremonial garments were torn off, and he was handed over to the prefect of the city, with the mocking order from Demosthenes, “Let him be cut to pieces.” A chain was fastened around his neck, and he was taken to the praetorium and locked up in the prison of Diomede. It was winter and cold, and his clothes were in tatters. Two kind women, the wife and daughter of the jailer, provided him with warm clothing. Gregory, the prefect, sent him food; the weary man accepted it with a sigh. "Let us hope that you will not die,” said the prefect, and ordered his chains to be removed. The next day, the emperor visited the patriarch Paul, who was dying, to inform him of what had been done. The patriarch was shocked and angry, and he protested to the emperor, pleading with him not to use further violence.
Martin, who hoped for a quick martyrdom, felt regret upon hearing that his life was likely to be spared. After Paul’s death, Pyrrhus, who had returned from Italy, took the throne of Constantinople. A lengthy examination of Martin took place regarding Pyrrhus's actions in Rome. For eighty-five days, Martin suffered in prison; he was finally shipped out on March 26, 655, to Cherson in the Tauric Chersonese. There, he was deprived of food and died on September 16 of the same year. His body was buried in Cherson, in the church of S. Mary of Blachema. Two letters written by him from Cherson still exist, in which he complains of being neglected by his friends and the Roman clergy, who had abandoned him and sent him neither wine nor food.
There can be little doubt that the real reason for his imprisonment and the harsh treatment that hastened his death was his opposition to the Type of Constans, and that most of the charges against him were false or exaggerated.
Footnotes
- Ecthesis of Heraclius: a document defining the doctrine of the One Will.
- apocrisiarius: a representative of the Pope in a foreign city.
- Martin expressed his anger towards him for this hesitation.
- Because he refrained from action, Martin condemned him as a concentration of all heretical wickedness.
- However, it is said that a sudden blindness fell upon the servant assigned to carry out the murder.
- “So that by this you not only refuse to anathematize those whom we also anathematize, namely the very persons of the heretics, but also that you confirm every error of the Pagans, Jews, and heretics in you, and also condemn all the doctrines of all these as contrary and hostile to the truth; you, therefore, do not anathematize with us all those things which we anathematize, it follows that you have confirmed all these errors, which are anathematized by us or by the Catholic Church.”
- Martin, Epistle II to Theodore.
- Martin was kept for forty-eight days without a bath.
- Witnesses testified that he had conspired with Olympius against the emperor.
- It cannot be said how far Olympius had shared plans for revolt with Martin.
- Martin attempted to shift the focus to the doctrinal issue.
- Troilus interrupted Martin, stating they were discussing rebellion, not doctrine.
- Martin pointed out that George and Valentine were not prevented from revolting.
- Demosthenes: a famous ancient Greek statesman and orator.
Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.
Read the original 1870s text
Baring-Gould’s sources: Roman Martyrology. Usuardus, & c. By the Greeks as a confessor on April 11, and as a martyr on November 12. Authorities: —His Letters, and the “ Commemoratio eorum quae.... acta sunt in S. Martinum,” in Mansi, t x. p. 855.] Martin, a native of Todi, son of Fabricius, was elected Pope on the death of Theodore, in 649. It was a time of controversy. Paul, a Monothelite, was patriarch of Constantinople, occupying the throne of the exiled Pyrrhus. Pyrrhus was also a Monothelite. He came to Rome when Theodore was Pope, to claim his interference, and to secure it, he proclaimed his adhesion to the doctrine of the Two Wills. But his conscience reproached him for this abandonment of his convictions for the sake of his interests, and he returned to Ravenna, and there recanted his acknowledgment of the two wills. Theodore excommunicated him with a pen dipped in the consecrated chalice. Theodore at the same time excommunicated Paul. Paul revenged himself by suppressing the religious worship of the papal envoys at court, maltreating, and even causing to be scourged, some of their attendants. Constans II., the emperor, sought to put an end to the controversy by publishing a decree, which has received the name of the Type. It began with the statement of the cause of its issue: “ We have remarked that our orthodox people have been thrown into great perplexity, because on the subject of the oeconomy of God, that is, the Incarnation, some profess that there was but one will, saying that Christ, one and the same, operated the Divine and the human, while others teach and profess two wills and two energies. The former support their opinion by saying that our Lord Jesus Christ is but [Nov. is.
One Person in two natures, which are neither confounded nor separated, and that He wills and operates at one and the selfsame time that which is Divine and that which is human. The others say, as in one person two natures are united without division, the difference of these natures is not effaced, and following the attributes of these natures, one and the selfsame Christ operates the Divine and the human.... We have thought, with the help of God, that it is our duty to extinguish the flame of contention, and not to suffer souls to be thereby imperilled. We therefore forbid our subjects from this moment to dispute and quarrel whether there be the one will and one energy, or the two wills and two energies. Our ordinance is not issued to destroy any teaching of the holy fathers on the subject of the Divine Word, we wish simply to bring to an end all wrangling over this question, and that our subjects should conform themselves to the sacred scriptures and the traditions of the five oecumenical councils, and to the teaching and propositions of the fathers, without curtailing or adding thereto, or twisting them to a perverse meaning. Let every effort be made to preserve the doctrine held before the present controversy broke out, and let neither party blame the other.”
To facilitate this peaceful issue, the emperor ordered the removal of the Ecthesis of Heraclius, formulating the doctrine of the One Will, from the narthex of the great church at Constantinople, and threatened the factions with divers punishments.
Immediately after the publication of the Type, and probably before it came to his knowledge, Theodore died. Martin had been apocrisiarius of the Holy See at Constantinople, before his elevation to the vacant chair of S. Peter, and was therefore hot and vehement on the controversy which had raged around him. The Acts of S. Ouen assert that the emperor at once asked Martin, in a friendly manner, to give
his adhesion to the Type, but that the Pope refused it in the most peremptory manner; and Martin then asked the king of the Franks [the Germanic people who ruled Gaul and gave France its name] to send learned bishops to Rome to deliberate with him how best to combat and overthrow the pacific attempts of the emperor, and rake up the controversial fire which was consuming the East. The king resolved to send to Rome Ouen of Rouen, and Eligius of Noyon, but they were prevented by circumstances from undertaking the journey.
In October, 649, a council of a hundred and five bishops assembled in the Lateran [St. John Lateran, the pope’s cathedral in Rome] at Rome.. The bishops were nearly all from Italy and the adjacent islands. After five sessions, in which Monothelitism was convicted on the authority of the fathers of being heretical and antichristian, twenty canons were framed condemning the heresy and its authors. But Pope Martin was not content with anathematizing the erroneous doctrine of the Single Will, with humbling the rival prelate of Constantinople by excommunication in full council, with declaring the edict of the deceased emperor Heraclius, the Ecthesis, absolutely impious; he denounced as of equal impiety the Type of the reigning emperor, counselling peace. Its exhortation to sink differences in Christian charity he scorned as a persuasive to unholy acquiescence in heresy; abstention from controversial vehemence on such doctrines was a wicked suppression of Divine truth.
Nor was Martin wanting in activity to maintain his bold position. He published the decrees of the Lateran Council throughout the West. He appointed a legate [an official representative sent by the pope] in the East to supersede the Monothelite patriarchs of Antioch and Jerusalem. Paul of Thessalonica had agreed to condemn the doctrine, but hesitated about excommunicating those who through misunderstanding had accepted the doctrine of the One Will. Martin poured out on him the vials of his wrath. fNov. is.
Because he thus abstained, Martin condemned him as a concentration of all heretical pravity.1 He wrote to the faithful of the patriarchates of Antioch and Jerusalem, to stir them up against Macedonius and Peter, the bishops of Antioch and Alexandria, who had accepted the Ecthesis and the Type. Whilst the Lateran Council was holding its session, the emperor sent his chamberlain, Olympius, to Italy to obtain the acceptance of the Type by eveiy means in his power. On reaching Rome, it is pretended by later writers — like Anastasius the Librarian — that Olympius endeavoured to obtain the assassination of the Pope at the moment that Martin was communicating the chamberlain, but that a sudden blindness fell on the servant detailed for the murder, so that he could not see either the Pope, or the communion, or the kiss of peace. The reason why the would-be murderer saw none of this was that there was no intending murderer to see them.
Olympius was hastily summoned from Rome to repel an invasion of Sicily by the Saracens [medieval Christian name for Arab and Muslim peoples], and died of fatigue in that island. Another exarch came in his place, Theodoras Calliopas (June, 653), a man firm and crafty. He marched to Rome at the head of a body of soldiers, and summoned the Pope to surrender to the imperial authority. Some delay took place; Martin wrote to one of his friends that he was ready to exult rather than weep in the midst of his difficulties. On June 15, the day when Theodore entered Rome, he retired with all his clergy into the church of the Saviour, the Lateran basilica. The Pope sent a deputation to the exarch to offer him compliments on his arrival, and to excuse 1 “ Ut per hoc non solum eos etiam quos anathematizamus, nempe ipsas haereticorum personas, anathemadzare recuses.... sed ut etiam omnem omnium errorem Paganorum, Judaeorum, haereticorum in te confirmed sed etiam omnia omnium horum dogmata condemnamus, ut contraria et inimica veritati, tu veto omnia tina nobiscum voce non anathematizas quae anathematizamus, consequent est, te horum omnium errorem confirmasse, qui a nobis sive ab ecclesia catholic! ana thematizatur."
Nov. xu.] Martin. his presence on the plea of indisposition. The exarch received the deputation with favour, and when he remarked that the Pope had not come to meet him, and heard the reason, or rather the excuse, he dissembled his annoyance at the discourtesy, and said he would pay the Pope a visit next day. Martin was well enough on that day, Sunday, to say mass before a crowd. The exarch, tired with his journey, deferred his visit till Monday. On that day he sent his secretary to the Pope to ask why he had filled his house with stones, arms, and provisions as if for a siege. Martin denied that he had done so, and bade the secretary visit every room and convince himself that he had done nothing of the sort Martin then made complaints of the false accusations which had been made against him, as of having offered to give armed support to the “ infamous ” Olympius. The Pope had ordered his bed to be strewed before the high altar in the Lateran. The exarch and his troops entered the church, the light of the candles flickered on the armour of the soldiery. Theodore Calliopas at once announced to the priests and deacons that he was the bearer of a decree to the effect that Martin, having seized on the episcopate irregularly and unlawfully,1 must be conducted to Constantinople, and a successor appointed in his room. The charge was probably correct. He had, apparently, attempted to dispense with the sanction of the emperor on his election, and first among the Popes had made an effort to shake himself free of the imperial authority which claimed a right to accept or reject the Pope-Elect. Various other charges were trumped up against him, as that he had sent money to the Saracens, and had not taught the right faith on the Blessed Virgin Mary. The people shouted, “ Anathema to him who says that Martin has opposed the faith; anathema to him who is not faithful to the faith.” The exarch quieted the people by explaining 1 “ Irregulari ter et tine lege.” Mart. Epist. ii. ad Theod. [Nor. xs.
that the question was not one of difference in faith, but one of usurpation of office. On Tuesday the clergy of Rome visited the Pope. During the night he was removed to Ostia, and embarked for Constantinople with six or seven servants. After a three months’ voyage they reached the island of Naxos, where Martin was left a prisoner. The only favour accorded him was that he might bathe, and lodge in a hostel; but the guards kept for themselves the presents which were brought and offered him by his friends and admirers.
On September 17, 654, Pope Martin reached Constantinople, and was transferred at once to the prison called Prandearia, where he spent ninety-three days. During this time he wrote his second letter to Theodore, in which he complains that he had been kept forty-eight days without a bath. His bowels, he said, were out of order, his food was nasty and insufficient. When he was taken from prison to be tried he was very weak, and could not stand without support The president asked, “ Unhappy one, tell me, what wrong has the emperor done you?” Martin answered nothing. Witnesses were produced, testifying that he had intrigued with Olympius against the emperor. It was no doubt true that Olympius and Martin had been on terms of intimacy at Rome; how far, in their mutual recriminations against Constans II., Olympius had confided to Martin projects of revolt, cannot be said. It is not probable that the accusations were wholly unfounded. Martin, instead of rebutting them, tried to force the doctrinal question into the forefront. “ When the Type was published and sent to Rome ” he began, but was cut short by the prefect, Troilus, who said, “We are not speaking of doctrine, but of rebellion. You knew that Olympius was plotting against the emperor, and instead of arresting him, you kept on terms with him.” •S'. Martin.
Martin exclaimed, “ And you did not hinder George and Valentine from revolting against the emperor. How could I constrain a man backed by all the military force of Italy? However, settle my case as quickly as you can, and as you like.”
The president rebuked the interpreter for translating this defiant speech literally, and then went to the emperor to report what had taken place. The Pope was taken from the tribunal, and placed in the great court to be seen by the people, and that the emperor might see him, he was lifted upon a platform. A fiscal officer issued from the apartments of the emperor, and assailed him with the words, “ You have struggled against the emperor, what hope remains for you now ? You abandoned God, and God has abandoned you.” The pontifical ornaments of the Pope were plucked off, and he was given into the hands of the prefect of the city, with the sneering order from Demosthenes, “ Let him be cut to pieces.” A chain was attached to his neck, and he was taken to the praetorium, and shut up in the prison of Diomede. It was winter, and cold, and his clothes were in rags. Two good women, the wife and daughter of the jailer, supplied him with warm clothing. Gregory, the prefect, sent him meats; the weary man received them with a sigh. " Let us hope that you will not die,” said the prefect, and ordered his chains to be removed. Next day the emperor visited the patriarch [the title of the bishops of the great ancient sees: Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, Jerusalem] Paul, who was dying, to tell him what had been done. The patriarch was shocked and indignant, and remonstrated with the emperor, and entreated him not to use further violence.
Martin, who hoped for speedy martyrdom, heard with regret that his life was likely to be spared. On the death of Paul, Pyrrhus, who had returned from Italy, resumed the throne of Constantinople. A long examination of Martin took place on the conduct of Pyrrhus at Rome. For eightyfive days Martin languished in prison: he was at length shipped, March 26, 655, for Cherson in the Tauric Chersonese. There he was kept short of food, and died on September 16 in the same year. His body was buried at Cherson, in the church of S. Mary of Blachema. Two letters written by him from Cherson still exist, in which he complains of being neglected by his friends and the Roman clergy, who had abandoned him, and sent him neither wine nor com.
There can be little doubt that the real reason of his imprisonment, and the harsh treatment which accelerated his death, was his opposition to the Type of Constans, and that most of the charges against him were false or exaggerated.