St. Hilary of Arles

Hilary, Archbishop of Arles, was born about 401 into a notable family of northern Gaul, probably the same family as St. Honoratus, his predecessor at Arles.

Read the essentials →
Feast May 5 · Bishop

St. Hilary of Arles

Current feast

May 5
Secondary source · Wikipedia infobox

Traditional feast

May 5
1914 / pre-1969 calendar, per Baring-Gould (1897)

Represents

Bishop

Feast days

Feast: May 5

This Saint’s Story

Learned and rich, he gave up honours and wealth at Honoratus's urging and followed him to the monastery of Lérins (a famous island monastery off Cannes), giving himself to austerity and the study of Scripture. Baring-Gould adds that he sold his estates to his brother and gave the money to the poor.

When Honoratus, by then Archbishop of Arles, was dying, Hilary went to his side. As he set out to return to Lérins, the people of Arles held him back by force and proclaimed him archbishop, at about twenty-nine. A story in Baring-Gould says the messengers did not know him until a dove settled on his head; it is told as tradition. He took up the heavy charge with resolution and attended the councils of Riez, Orange, Vaison and Arles.

Then came his famous quarrel with Pope St. Leo the Great. In 444 a gathering of bishops over which Hilary presided, with St. Eucherius of Lyons and St. Germanus of Auxerre present, deposed a bishop named Celidonius. Celidonius appealed to Rome and was restored. Hilary went to Rome to defend himself, crossing the Alps on foot according to Baring-Gould, but was poorly received and returned in haste to Gaul. Fresh complaints followed, among them the hurried consecration of a successor to the sick bishop Projectus. Leo excommunicated him, took away his metropolitan rights over the province of Vienne, and obtained an edict from Valentinian III to that effect. Baring-Gould notes that we have these charges only from his opponents.

The Catholic Encyclopedia judges that peace was probably soon restored between Hilary and Leo, and that the dispute arose because the rights of Rome and of metropolitans, including the right of appeal, were not yet clearly defined. His contemporary biographer describes his last years of toil and austerity and his death on 5 May 449, mourned by the whole city, even by the Jews. Some writings are attributed to him, but the Encyclopedia warns that many are not authentic.

Struggles & surrender

His struggles

  • Excommunicated by the pope ·
    After a dispute over a deposed bishop, Pope Leo received him coldly, and on his enemies' charges excommunicated him and stripped his see of privileges; peace was probably restored later.

What he represents

How he teaches us to live

Drawn from themes in the original account

Be a peacemaker. Making peace is part of this story.

Celebrate this saint’s feast day. Remember him on May 5 with a short prayer, and ask for his help.

The full story

Baring-Gould’s account retold in modern English

Read the full story · 836 words · about 4 min

Aspiring to perfection, he sold all his estates to his brother and distributed the money among the poor. In 426, Honoratus was chosen as the archbishop of Arles, and Hilary followed him to the city. However, he soon felt a strong desire to return to the islet of Lerins, so he left Arles and rejoined the monastic community there. But God, who had other plans for him, did not allow him to enjoy his beloved retirement for long. Honoratus recalled Hilary to Arles, and he stayed with the archbishop until his death, which occurred in 428 or 429. After that, he set out to return to the peaceful isle of Lerins. However, the citizens of Arles, aware of his departure, sent messengers after him. They caught up with him, brought him back, and he was immediately elected, confirmed, and consecrated as archbishop, even though he was only twenty-nine years old.

He presided over the council of Riez in 439, the first council of Orange in 441, the council of Vaison in 442, and the second council of Arles in 443. His impulsive character led him to take actions that were more than questionable in terms of church law, which caused him to fall out of favor with Leo the Great, the pope of Rome (April 11). He was known to make visitations accompanied by his friend, Germain of Auxerre, likely going beyond the uncertain or undefined boundaries of his metropolitan authority. During one of these visitations, accusations of unfitness for the episcopal office were made against Celidonius, who was, according to some accounts, the bishop of Besançon. Hilary quickly summoned a council of bishops and declared a sentence of deposition against him. When he learned that Celidonius had gone to Rome to appeal against this decree, Hilary reportedly set out on foot, crossed the Alps, and traveled without a horse or pack mule to the Great City. He presented himself before Leo and earnestly requested him not to violate the ancient customs of the Gallic Churches. Leo then proceeded to annul Hilary's sentence.

and to restore Celidonius to his position as bishop. He summoned Hilary to challenge the evidence presented by Celidonius, to prove that his condemnation was unjust. Hilary's language was so arrogant that, according to the writer of his life, “no layman would dare to utter, and no ecclesiastic would endure to hear such words.” He firmly resisted the authority of the pope, boldly asserting his own extensive metropolitan power. Hilary believed his life was in danger, or he feared he would be captured and forced to communicate with the deposed Celidonius. He secretly left Rome, and although it was the middle of winter, he made his way back to Arles. The accounts of S. Hilary, which had previously been consistent, now diverge into strange contradictions. The author of his life claims that he attempted to reconcile with Leo, that he exhausted himself with labors, austerities, and devotions, and that he died before reaching his forty-first year. He died, visited by visions of glory, in a state of ecstatic peace; his grand funeral was honored by the tears of the entire city; even the Jews mourned loudly for the kind prelate.

The counter-statement fills the time before Hilary's death with other important events. Leo wrote a letter to the bishops of the province of Vienne, condemning Hilary's impious resistance to the authority of Saint Peter and releasing them from any allegiance to the see of Arles. Hardly had the matter of Celidonius been resolved by the see of Rome when a new accusation of violating canonical discipline was made against Hilary. The bishop Projectus complained that, while he was suffering from illness, Hilary, who was not part of his province, had consecrated another bishop in his place. He did this so hastily that he ignored all the canonical procedures for election; he did not wait for the vote of the citizens, the endorsements of the more distinguished individuals, or the election of the clergy. In this instance, and in other cases of irregular ordinations, Hilary had called upon military power and interfered tumultuously in the affairs of many churches. It is notably suggested that on every occasion, Hilary had been reckless with the last and most severe power held by the Church, which is excommunication. However, we only have the accounts from his enemies, and we do not know how exaggerated the charges were, or how some of his actions may have been misrepresented. Hilary was ordered by Saint Leo to limit himself to his own diocese, was stripped of the authority he claimed over the province of Vienne, and was forbidden to attend any future ordinations. At Leo's explicit request, Emperor Valentinian issued an imperial edict, denouncing Hilary's defiance of the primacy of the apostolic throne. He and all the bishops were warned to adhere to this permanent edict, which formally stated that nothing should be done in Gaul contrary to ancient customs without the authority of the bishop of the Eternal City.

Footnotes

  1. Hilary was designated as bishop by his predecessor.
  2. The messengers, accompanied by soldiers, sent to bring him back did not know him.
  3. A dove settled on his head, and they recognized him by that sign.
  4. no layman would dare to utter, no ecclesiastic would endure to hear such words.
  5. that he exhausted himself with labors, austerities, and devotions, and that he died before reaching his forty-first year.
  6. Emperor Valentinian: Roman Emperor from 364 to 375 AD.

Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.

Read the original 1870s text

Baring-Gould’s sources: Roman Martyrology. The ancient one attributed to S. Jerome, Hrabanus and Usuardus, Ado and Notker. Authority: — A life written by a contemporary, either S. Honoratus, Bishop of Marseilles, or by Ravennus, his successor in the see, and mention in the letters of S. Leo the Great and his own writings.] S. Hilary was born of noble parents in the year 401, and was a relative of S. Honoratus of Arles, who was then in the island of Lerins, abbot of the commnnity he had there founded. Honoratus left his retirement to seek his kinsman Hilary, and draw him to embrace the same life, but all his persuasion was at first in vain. “ What floods of tears/7 says S. Hilary, “ did this true friend shed to soften my hard heart ? How often did he embrace me with the most tender and compassionate affection, to obtain of me a resolve that I would consider the salvation of my soul. Yet, by an unhappy victory, I resisted his persuasion.” “Well, then,” said Honoratus, “I will obtain of God what you will not now grant to me.” And he left him, that in his island sanctuary he might pray for his relation. Three days after, S. Hilary had changed his mind, and went to Lerins to place himself under the discipline of Honoratus. “On one side,” he says, “ I thought I saw God calling me, on the other the world seducing me with its charms and pleasures. How often did I embrace and reject, will and not will the same thing. But in the end Jesus Christ triumphed in me.”

Aspiring to perfection, he sold all his estates to his brother, and distributed the money among the poor. In 426 S. Honoratus was chosen to the archbishopric of Arles, and S. Hilary followed him to the city; but soon the longing came upon him to return to the islet of Lerins, and he left Arles and rejoined the monastic community there. But God, who had other designs for him, did not suffer him to enjoy long his beloved retirement S. Honoratus recalled Hilary to Arles, and he remained with the archbishop till his death, which took place in 428 or 429. Then he set out on his return to the peaceful isle of Lerins. But the citizens of Arles, apprized of his departure, sent messengers after him, who overtook him, brought him back, and he was forthwith elected, confirmed, and consecrated archbishop, though only twenty-nine years of age.1 He presided in the council of Riez in 439, in the first council of Orange in 441, in the council of Vaison in 442, and in the second council of Arles in 443. His impetuous character precipitated him into actions of more than questionable canonicity, on account of which he fell into disfavour with S. Leo the Great, pope of Rome (April 11th). He was accustomed to make visitations, accompanied by his friend, S. Germain of Auxerre, not improbably beyond the doubtful or undefined limits of his metropolitan [the archbishop who heads a group of dioceses] power. During one of these visitations, charges of disqualification for the episcopal office were exhibited against Celidonius, bishop, according to some accounts, of Besançon. Hilary hastily summoned a council of bishops, and pronounced sentence of deposition against him. On the intelligence that Celidonius had gone to Rome to appeal against this decree, Hilary set forth, it is said, on foot, crossed the Alps, and travelled without horse or sumpter-mule to the Great City. He presented himself before Leo, and with respectful earnestness entreated him not to infringe the ancient usages of the Gallic Churches. Leo proceeded to annul the sentence of Hilary 3 He was designated as bishop by his predecessor. The messengers, accompanied by soldiers, sent to bring him back did not know him. A dove settled on his head, and they recognized him by that sign.

and to restore Celidonius to his bishopric. He summoned Hilary to rebut the evidence adduced by Celidonius, to disprove the justice of his condemnation. So haughty was the language of Hilary, “ that,” says the writer of his life, “no layman would dare to utter, no ecclesiastic would endure to hear such words.” He inflexibly resisted the authority of the pope, confronting him with the bold assertion of his own unbounded metropolitan power. Hilary thought his life in danger, or he feared he should be seized and compelled to communicate with the deposed Celidonius. He stole out of Rome, and though it was the depth of winter, found his way back to Arles. The accounts of S. Hilary, hitherto reconcilable, now diverge into strange contradiction. The author of his life represents him as having made overtures of reconciliation to Leo, as wasting himself out with toils, austerities, and devotions, and dying before he had completed his forty-first year. He died, visited by visions of glory, in ecstatic peace; his splendid funeral was honoured by the tears of the whole city; the very Jews were clamorous in their sorrow for the beneficent prelate.

The counter-statement fills up the interval before the death of Hilary with other important events. Leo addresses a letter to the bishops of the province of Vienne, denouncing the impious resistance of Hilary to the authority of S. Peter, and releasing them from all allegiance to the see of Arles [a bishop’s “see” is his diocese, named from his seat (Latin sedes)]. For hardly had the affair of Celidonius been decided by the see of Rome than a new charge of breach of canonical discipline was brought against Hilary. The bishop Projectus complained that, while he was afflicted with illness, Hilary, to whose province he did not belong, had consecrated another bishop in his place, and this in such haste that he had respected none of the canonical forms of election; he had awaited neither the suffrage of the citizens, the testimonials of the more distinguished, nor the election of the clergy. In this, and in other instances of irregular ordinations, Hilary had called in the military power, and tumultuously interfered in the affairs of many churches. It is significantly suggested that on every occasion Hilary had been prodigal of the last and most awful power possessed by the Church, that of excommunication. But we have only the statement of his enemies, and we do not know how highly-coloured the charges were, and how some of his acts may have been falsified. Hilary was commanded by S. Leo to confine himself to his own diocese, was deprived of the authority he claimed over the province of Vienne, and forbidden to be present at any future ordination. At the avowed instance of Leo, also, the Emperor Valentinian promulgated an imperial edict, denouncing the contumacy of Hilary against the primacy of the apostolic throne. He and all the bishops were warned to observe this perpetual edict, which solemnly enacted that nothing should be done in Gaul [roughly modern France and Belgium], contrary to ancient usage, without the authority of the bishop of the Eternal City.

From the Catholic Encyclopedia

1913 · 556 words

Archbishop, b. about 401; d. 5 May, 449. The exact place of his birth is not known. All that may be said is that he belonged to a notable family of Northern Gaul [roughly modern France and Belgium], of which in all probability also came St. Honoratus, his predecessor in the See of Arles. Learned and rich, Hilary had everything calculated to ensure success in the world, but he abandoned honours and riches at the urgent solicitations of Honoratus, accompanied him to the hermitage of Lérins, which the latter had founded, and gave himself up under the saint's direction to the practice of austerities and the study of Holy Scripture. When Honoratus, who had meanwhile become Archbishop of Arles, was at the point of death, Hilary went to his side and assisted at his latest moments. But as he was about to set out on his return to Lérins he was retained by force and proclaimed archbishop in the place of Honoratus. Obliged to yield to this constraint, he resolutely undertook the duties of his heavy charge, and assisted at the various councils held at Riez, Orange, Vaison, and Arles.

Subsequently began between him and Pope St. Leo the famous quarrel which constitutes one of the most curious phases of the history of the Gallican Church. A reunion of bishops, over which he presided in 444 and at which were present St. Eucherius of Lyons and St. Germain of Auxerre, deposed for incapacity provided against by the canons a certain Cheldonius. The latter hastened to Rome, was successful in pleading his cause before the pope, and consequently was reinstated in his see. Hilary then sought St. Leo in order to justify his course of action in the matter, but he was not well received by the sovereign pontiff and was obliged to return precipitately to Gaul. Several priests afterwards sent by him to Rome to explain his conduct met with no better success. Moreover, several persons who were hostile towards him profited by this juncture to bring various accusations against him at the Court of Rome, whereupon the pope excommunicated Hilary, transferred the prerogatives of his see to that of Fréjus, and caused the proclamation by the Emperor Valentinian III of that famous decree which freed the Church of Vienne from all dependence on that of Arles. Nevertheless there is every reason to believe that, the storm once passed, peace was rapidly restored between Hilary and Leo. We are too far removed from the epoch in which this memorable quarrel occurred, and the documents which might throw any light on it are too few to allow us to form a definitive judgment on its causes and consequences. It evidently arose from the fact that the respective rights of the Court of Rome and of the metropolitan [the archbishop who heads a group of dioceses] were not sufficiently clearly established at that time, and that the right of appeal to the pope, among others, was not explicitly enough recognized. There exist a number of writings which are ascribed to St. Hilary, but they are far from being all authentic. Père Quesnel collected them all in an appendix to the work in which he has published the writings of St. Leo.

Albanez and Chevalier, Gallia Christ. noviss. (Arles, 1900), 29-36; Sevestre, Dict. patr. (Paris, 1854), II, 192-201; Ceillier, hist. des auteurs eccl. (Paris, 1747), XIII, 523-538; Baronius [Cardinal Baronius (d. 1607), church historian who edited the Roman Martyrology], Ann. (1595), 445, 9-18.

Help us add to this saint's story

Everything is read by a person before anything appears. Facts are checked against trusted sources first.

Facts are welcome; a source link helps (optional).With your permission we may share it on this page.

Nine days · Free

Pray the novena
with us.

One short email a day for nine days. The day's prayer, a line from St. Hilary of Arles's story, and a nudge to keep going.

Also on May 5
M

St. Maximus of Jerusalem

May 5 · Bishop
St. Maurontius

St. Maurontius

May 5 · Abbot
St. Pius, Pope

St. Pius

May 5 · Virgin
← All 1970 saints in the library
Sources & notes

Feast-day sources

Story sources

Sources

Credits

Image: Hilari14.jpg · Wikimedia Commons · Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Image: Wikimedia Commons, Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)

From “Catholic Encyclopedia (1913)/St. Hilary of Arles,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (New York: Robert Appleton Company, 1907–1914), via Wikisource. Public domain. Matched by name and feast date; text unedited except for our bracketed notes in grey.

Retold in plain modern English from Baring-Gould’s public-domain text, sentence by sentence, keeping the same facts and order. Short explanations in parentheses are ours.

From Sabine Baring-Gould, The Lives of the Saints, new edition in 16 vols. (London: John C. Nimmo, 1897–98); text from the Internet Archive scan (OCR, lightly cleaned; errors possible). Public domain in the United States. Reproduced unedited, except for short bracketed notes in grey that we added to explain names and terms (“S.” is the old abbreviation for Saint). Some history and judgments reflect 19th-century scholarship.

Notes

Story retold in our own words from the cited sources.