In his youth, Faustus was dedicated to studying public speaking and Christian philosophy. Around the year 420, Faustus joined the monastery of Lerins and was elected abbot in place of Saint Maximus in 433 or 434. There, he lived a strict life focused on prayer and study, imitating, as Sidonius tells us, the lives of the Fathers of the Egyptian deserts, on the barren island off the coast of the Province. Gennadius informs us that around this time, he wrote a letter to a deacon named Gratus, who was influenced by Nestorian errors. Saint Honoratus, the Bishop of Arles, who had been the Abbot of Lerins while Faustus was a monk there, held him in high regard, as mentioned in the life of Saint Hilary by a contemporary writer. The brother of Saint Sidonius was under Faustus's care at Lerins; and, as Saint Augustine tells us, Faustus sheltered Julian the Pelagian on his island when he was expelled from Italy for his heresy. This fact may have caused Baronius to hesitate in including the saint in the Roman Martyrology. There is no doubt that Faustus, like Saint Hilary and other Gallic saints, was alarmed by the rigid doctrine of predestination that Saint Augustine was trying to impose on the Church. Faustus recognized that this troubling doctrine, if followed, undermines the foundations of Christian morality and good works, and therefore he opposed it strongly. Julian sought refuge in Gaul, and Faustus offered him shelter in Lerins until a council could be convened at Arles to address the issues of Grace and Free Will.
Faustus was elected as the bishop of Riez around A.D. 452. In a homily about his predecessor, Saint Maximus, he spoke of himself with great humility. He said that Lerins had provided the Church with two successive bishops. It is proud of the first; it is embarrassed by the second. Both Saint Sidonius and Ruric of Limoges highly praised the eloquence and fervor of Saint Faustus when he preached the Word of God to the people.
Benedictus Paulinus consulted Saint Faustus about questions of repentance. The answer from the Bishop of Riez still exists. He said, “I am asked, in the second place, whether the knowledge of the Trinity in Unity is enough for salvation. In divine matters, I answer that the reason for belief is not the only thing required; the reason for pleasing God is also necessary. Naked faith without merits is empty and vain.”
In 473, the doctrines of predestination were presented in their most blatant and offensive form by a certain Lucidus, a priest. He believed that some people were predestined by God to sin, and therefore they sinned inevitably. Others were predestined to do good, and they lived holy lives out of inevitable necessity; there was no merit involved. Grace moved people wherever it wanted; some were led to damnation, while others were led to justification. Saint Faustus encountered Lucidus and tried to reason him out of his heresy, but it was in vain. Then he wrote him a letter, along with the Bishops of Arles and Lyons, which is a glorious summary of Catholic doctrine on grace and free will. This letter was written during an assembly of thirty bishops at Arles in 475. The archbishop and metropolitan Leontius wanted to condemn the error of the predestinarians in this synod. However, before the council could take any decisive action, Faustus wrote to Lucidus, informing him that the bishops were about to suspend him from his office unless he renounced his errors. As a summary of the points he was to accept, Faustus laid down the following propositions:
“1. Those who deny, like Pelagius, original sin and the necessity for grace are anathema.
“2. Anathema to those who maintain that a baptized Christian who falls into mortal sin does so through the inherence of original sin (that is, fatally, and not through the action of his free will).
“3. Anathema to those who hold that man is fatally doomed to spiritual death by virtue of the predetermined counsel of God.
“4. And to those who teach that those who are lost did not receive from God the means of salvation.
“5. And to those who declare that a vessel of dishonor may not rise to become a vessel of honor.
“6. Anathema to those who affirm that Christ sought the salvation of some, not of all men.”
If Lucidus would come and meet Faustus, the letter continues to state, the Bishop of Riez and other assembled bishops would provide him with the reasons for their conclusions. Faustus added, “As for us, we believe that he who loses his salvation through his own fault could have been saved with the help of grace if he had cooperated with it. Conversely, he who, by cooperating with grace, achieves salvation might have been lost due to negligence or his own fault. We reject all self-esteem, for we consider what we have received from the hand of the Lord to be a gift, not a debt.” Lucidus, realizing that his position was at risk, signed the letter.
Leontius of Arles and the synod gathered at Arles authorized Faustus of Riez to write a work on grace and predestination. To fulfill this task, he composed his two significant books titled “On the Grace of God and the Free Will of the Human Mind,” which he dedicated to Leontius. Unfortunately, Faustus specifically attacked Saint Augustine and identified him as the source of this harmful heresy. There is little doubt that Augustine did introduce these dangerous doctrines; however, the Church has forgiven him for this wrongdoing and has overlooked his culpability in this matter because of his invaluable contributions and efforts in support of true doctrine on other issues. His belief in predestination was the residue of his former Manichaean beliefs emerging from his soul. The fact that Faustus openly criticized Augustine has led to suspicion surrounding his legacy, and he has lost his place in the modern Roman Martyrology, even though his teachings align with those of Luis de Molina, which can be considered the accepted doctrine on grace and predestination in the Western Church.
Footnotes
- Gennadius informs us that around this time, he wrote a letter to a deacon named Gratus, who was influenced by Nestorian errors.
- Saint Honoratus, the Bishop of Arles, who had been the Abbot of Lerins while Faustus was a monk there, held him in high regard, as mentioned in the life of Saint Hilary by a contemporary writer.
- This fact may have caused Baronius to hesitate in including the saint in the Roman Martyrology.
- Faustus recognized that this troubling doctrine, if followed, undermines the foundations of Christian morality and good works, and therefore he opposed it strongly.
- Both Saint Sidonius and Ruric of Limoges highly praised the eloquence and fervor of Saint Faustus when he preached the Word of God to the people.
- Some copies are signed by Faustus alone, others by Faustus and ten other bishops.
- Faustus of Riez wrote “On the Grace of God and the Free Will of the Human Mind.”
- Luis de Molina was a Jesuit theologian known for his views on grace and free will.
Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.
Read the original 1870s text
Baring-Gould’s sources: At Riez on this day. In some Martyrologies on Jan. 16. Maurolycus, Ferrarius, Greven, &c. on Jan. 16. So also Saussaye. In some copies of the Martyro\pgy of Jerome on May 20. Baronins did not. however, insert S. Faustus in the Roman Martyrology. Authorities: — Mention by S. Avitus of Vienne, S. Sidonius Apollinaris, S. Eucherius of Lyons, &c. S. Faustus was a native of Britain or of Armorica. S. Avitus says he was “a Briton by birth," but it is not improbable that he may have meant that he was a native of Brittany. Facundus of Hermiane speaks of him as “ by nation a Gaul, bishop of Riez;J/ but Facundus was bishop of a diocese in Africa, and had no opportunities of learning with accuracy the birthplace of a Gallican bishop. Sidonius Apollinaris, in his 16th Carmen, written when Faustus was old, says that at that time his mother, then at an extremely advanced age, was resident with her son at Riez. Faustus had a brother, a priest, named Memorius, mentioned also by Sidonius.
In his youth Faustus was devoted to the study of elocution, and of Christian philosophy. In 420, or thereabouts, Faustus entered the monastery of Lerins, and was elected abbot in the room of S. Maximus, in 433 or 434. There he lived an austere life, devoted to prayer and study, imitating, as Sidonius tells us, the lives of the Fathers of the Egyptian deserts, in the barren isle off the shores of the Province. Gennadius tells us that about this time he wrote a letter to a deacon named Gratus, who was infected with Nestorian [Nestorius (d. c. 451), whose teaching split Christ into two persons; condemned at Ephesus in 431] errors. S. Honoratus, Bishop of Arles, who had been Abbot of Lerins whilst Faustus was monk in it, respected him greatly, as is mentioned in the life of S. Hilary by a contemporary writer. The brother of S. Sidonius was under his charge at Lerins; and, as S. Augustine tells us, Faustus harboured Julian the Pelagian [followers of Pelagius, who taught people could be good without God’s grace] on his isle when expelled from Italy for his heresy. It is this fact which, perhaps, made Baronius [Cardinal Baronius (d. 1607), church historian who edited the Roman Martyrology] hesitate to insert the saint in the Roman Martyrology. There can be no question that Faustus, in common with S. Hilary and other Gallic saints, viewed with alarm the iron dogma of predestinarianism to which S. Augustine was attempting to commit the Church. Faustus saw that this revolting doctrine, if acted upon, cuts at the roots of Christian morality and good works, and therefore opposed it vehemently. Julian sought v?. Faustus.
a refuge in Gaul [roughly modern France and Belgium], and Faustus offered him one in Lerins till a council could be held at Arles to decide on the questions of Grace and Free-will.
Faustus was elected to the bishopric of Riez in or about a.d. 452. In a homily by him on his predecessor, S. Maximus, he speaks of himself with the utmost humility. Lerins, said he, has furnished the Church with two successive bishops. It is proud of the first; it blushes for the second. Both S. Sidonius and Ruric of Limoges praise highly the eloquence and unction of S. Faustus when preaching R* the people the Word of God.
Benedictus Paulinus consulted S. Faustus on questions 0 repentance. The answer of the Bishop of Riez is extant “ I am asked, in the second place, says he, whether th< knowledge of the Trinity in Unity suffices for salvation In divine things, I answer, the reason of belief is not alone demanded, but also the reason of pleasing God. Naked faith without merits is empty and vain.7' In 473 the doctrines of predestination were propounded in their most flagrant and offensive baldness by a certain Lucidus, a priest. He held that some men were predestined by God to sin, and so they sinned inevitably; others were predestined to do good, and they lived holy lives by inevitable necessity; there was no merit; grace blew men where it listed; this into damnation, that into justification. S. Faustus met Lucidus, and endeavoured to reason him out of his heresy, but in vain. Then he wrote him a letter, in concert with the Bishops of Arles and Lyons, which is a glorious summary of Catholic doctrine on grace and freewill.1 This letter was written on the occasion of an assembly of thirty bishops at Arles in 475. The archbishop and metropolitan [the archbishop who heads a group of dioceses] Leontius wished to condemn the l Some copies are signed by Faustus alone, others by Faustus and ten other bishops error of the predestinarians in this synod. But before the council took any decisive action, Faustus wrote to Lucidus, telling him that the bishops were about to suspend him from his office unless he renounced his errors. And as an abridgment of the points which he was to admit, Faustus laid down the following propositions: — “ 1. Those who deny, like Pelagius, original sin, and the necessity for grace, are anathema.
“ 2. Anathema to those who maintain that the baptized Christian falling into mortal sin does so through the inherence of original sin (/.<?., fatally, and not through the action of his free will).
“ 3. Anathema to those who hold that man is fatally doomed to spiritual death by virtue of the predeterminate counsel of God.
“ 4. And to those who teach that such as are lost did not receive from God means of salvation. “ 5. And to those who declare that a vessel of dishonour may not rise to become a vessel of honour. “ 6. Anathema to those who affirm that Christ sought the salvation of some, not of all men.”
If Lucidus would come and meet Faustus, the letter goes on to state, the Bishop of Riez and others of the assembled prelates would give him the reasons for their conclusions. And Faustus added: — “ As for us, we think that he who loses his salvation by his fault, might have been saved by the assistance of grace, if he had co-operated with it; and, on the other hand, that he who, by co-operating with grace, attains to salvation, might, by negligence or his own fault, have been lost. We exclude all self-esteem, for we regard as a gift, not as a debt, what we have received from the hand of the Lord/’ Lucidus, seeing that his position was endangered, sub' scribed the letter.
Lioba. Leontius of Arles and the synod assembled at Arles empowered Faustus of Riez to draw up a work on grace and predestination. In fulfilment of this mission, he composed his two grand books “ De gratia Dei et humanse mentis libero arbitrio,” which he dedicated to Leontius. But unfortunately Faustus attacked S. Augustine by name, and pointed to him as the source of this mischievous heresy. There can be little question that Augustine did start these fatal doctrines; but the Church has pardoned him this evil, and overlooked his blameworthiness in the matter, for the sake of his inestimable merits and labours in behalf of true doctrine on other points. His predestinarianism was the rust of his old Manichaeism working its way out of his soul. The fact that Faustus had thus openly attacked Augustine has occasioned suspicion to cling to his memory, and has lost him a place in the modern Roman Martyrology, though his doctrine is the same as that of Molinus, which may be said to represent the accepted teaching on grace and predestination in the Western Church.