He had been the bishop of Bersea and was a native of Sidon in Pamphylia. Saint Paulinus, the bishop of Antioch, had died that same year, and Eustathius was chosen to take his place. When the emperor Constantine entered the great hall where the Council of bishops was meeting, Eustathius of Antioch, who, according to Theodoret, sat on the right side of the throne, addressed the emperor. He thanked God for him and for the blessing He had given to the Church of peace and the opportunity to gather in council. For a few years, Eustathius held his patriarchal position in peace. However, the Arian party, after its defeat at Nicaea, regained its strength, surrounded the emperor, and trouble fell upon the Catholics.
The Eusebian party—whose leaders included Nicomedian Eusebius, his namesake from Caesarea, Acacius, a pupil of the latter, George, who had been deposed from the priesthood by Alexander of Alexandria, Leontius, a smooth and cautious man, Eudoxius, later infamous for his profanity, and Valens, the bishop of Mursa in Pannonia, who became equally known for his blatant dishonesty—had one clear goal: to undo the work of Nicaea. Their strategy was to maintain their influence over the emperor, to eliminate the leading Catholic bishops, and to spread Arianism in ways that were less overtly offensive to general Christian sentiment than those condemned by the Council.
Their first victim was Eustathius. The patriarchal see of Antioch had suffered greatly in the third century due to the scandal of having an heretical bishop. It was now to endure further suffering from which it never fully recovered. Eustathius had maintained a firm stance against the Arians; he would never allow them to share in communion. He had expressed his distrust of the orthodoxy of Eusebius of Caesarea and two other bishops. Eusebius retaliated by accusing him of Sabellianism, a charge that Arians often leveled against Catholics. Determined to ruin him, Eusebius, the cunning bishop of Nicomedia, pretended to have a strong desire to visit Jerusalem and the magnificent church built there by the emperor. He set off with Constantine providing him with transportation and covering all his travel expenses. Theognis of Nicsea, his confidant, traveled with him. Upon reaching Antioch, they feigned friendship towards Eustathius and were welcomed with kindness and hospitality.
When they arrived in Jerusalem, they met Eusebius of Caesarea, Patrophilus of Scythopolis, Aetius of Lydda, Theodotus of Laodicea, and other Arians. They revealed their plan to these men, and the entire group of bishops traveled to Antioch, pretending to accompany Eusebius of Nicomedia as a courtesy. Upon reaching Antioch, a council was called, which was attended by Saint Eustathius and some other Catholic bishops who were unaware of the scheme.
Once everyone was gathered, the public was excluded at the request of the Arians. They then brought in a disreputable woman with an infant at her breast, whom they had bribed to accuse Eustathius of being the child's father. Saint Eustathius angrily demanded evidence to support this terrible accusation. The only evidence was from the wretched woman, who was put under oath. Then, with one voice, the Arian bishops condemned him to lose his position as bishop.
The other bishops, who were not part of the conspiracy, firmly refused to accept this outrageous decision and urged Saint Eustathius not to comply with the sentence. They appealed to Moses and to Saint Paul, who forbade a condemnation based on a single testimony. But the Arians held the power. They did not disclose the reason for the deposition of the patriarch but suggested that he had been found guilty of Sabellianism (a belief that God is one person who has revealed Himself in different forms). Eusebius of Nicomedia and Theognis quickly returned to the emperor and convinced him of Eustathius's guilt, adding that Eustathius had not shown proper respect to Helena, the emperor's mother.
Constantine exiled him, labeling him as “a pollution,” to Illyria in 331. Paulinus of Tyre was appointed to Antioch, and after his death shortly afterward, Eulalius became bishop. Eulalius soon followed Paulinus in death. The vacant see was then offered to Eusebius of Caesarea, who declined it on canonical grounds, and Constantine greatly praised his refusal.
Meanwhile, the woman who had testified against Eustathius fell ill. Her conscience troubled her, and she called for the priests of Antioch to confess that she had been bribed to give false testimony. She revealed that a man named Eustathius was indeed the father of her child, but he was a coppersmith with the same name. What must have been the reckless wickedness of the Eusebian party to use such despicable means to undermine a champion of the true faith! Yet, even though the falsehood of the accusation was revealed and the guilt of the Arian bishops in promoting it was clear to everyone, the innocent Eustathius remained in exile.
We can understand why Eusebius of Caesarea avoided facing the orthodox people of Antioch after the exposure of the plot he had been involved in. Eustathius died in Thrace and was buried in Trajanopolis. His relics were moved to Antioch in 482.
Footnotes
- Eusebius of Caesarea: a prominent early Christian historian and bishop.
- Nicaea: a city in present-day Turkey, site of the First Council of Nicaea in 325 AD.
- Eusebius of Caesarea: a Christian historian and bishop.
- Patrophilus of Scythopolis: a bishop from Scythopolis, a city in ancient Palestine.
- Aetius of Lydda: a bishop from Lydda, a city in ancient Palestine.
- Theodotus of Laodicea: a bishop from Laodicea, a city in ancient Asia Minor.
- Sabellianism: a belief that God is one person in different forms.
- Eusebius of Nicomedia: a bishop known for his role in the Arian controversy.
- Helena: the mother of Emperor Constantine.
- Illyria: a region in the western part of the Balkan Peninsula.
- Paulinus of Tyre: a bishop of Tyre, a city in ancient Phoenicia.
- Eulalius: a bishop who succeeded Paulinus.
- Trajanopolis: an ancient city in Thrace.
Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.
Read the original 1870s text
Baring-Gould’s sources: By the Greeks on February 21st and June 5th. Also by the Copts on Feb. 21st. And by the Latins on July 16th. Roman Martyrology, Ado, Usuardus, &c. Authorities: — Eusebius, Theodoret, Socrates, Philostorgius, Sozomen, and the Encomium of S. John Chrysostom on the Saint.] famous Council of Nicaea met in the year 5, to hear and to condemn the teaching of ius. Among the Syrian bishops present, 3 first in dignity was the orthodox Eustathius, who either was, or was on the point of being made, patriarch of Antioch, the capital of Syria, the metropolis of the Eastern Church, then called 1 the city of God.* He had suffered in heathen persecutions, and was destined to suffer in Christian persecutions also. 1 But he was chiefly known for his learning and eloquence, which was distinguished by an antique simplicity of style. One work alone has come down to us, i Soz. ii. ip.
VOL. VIII. [July 16. on the ‘ Witch of Endor.’ 1 He had been bishop of Beroea, and was a native of Sidon in Pamphylia. S. Paulinus, bishop of Antioch, had died that same year, and Eustathius was designated to fill his place. When the emperor Constantine entered the great hall where the Council of the bishops sat, Eustathius of Antioch, who, according to Theodoret, sat on the right hand of the throne, addressed the emperor, thanked God for him, and the blessing he had given to the Church of peace and an opportunity of assembling in council. For a few years Eustathius occupied his patriarchal throne in tranquillity. But the Arian [followers of Arius, who taught that the Son is a created being, not fully God] party, after its defeat at Nicasa, gathered its strength, surrounded the emperor, and trouble fell on the Catholics.
The Eusebian party — the chiefs of whom were the Nicomedian Eusebius, — his namesake of Caesarea, — Acacius, the pupil of the latter, — George, whom Alexander of Alexandria had deposed from the priesthood, — Leontius, a smooth, cautious man, — Eudoxius, afterwards notorious for his profanity, — and Valens, bishop of Mursa in Pannonia [a Roman province roughly covering western Hungary and parts of Austria and Croatia], who became equally conspicuous by shameless want of truth, — had but one definite object before them, to undo the work of Nicasa. These tactics were, to maintain the hold they had obtained over the emperor; to get rid of the leading Catholic bishops; and to propagate Arianism in forms less flagrantly offensive to the general Christian feeling than those which the Council had condemned.
Their first victim was Eustathius. The patriarchal see of Antioch [a bishop’s “see” is his diocese, named from his seat (Latin sedes)] had suffered much in the third century by the scandal of an heretical occupant. It was now to pass through sufferings from the effect of which it never quite recovered. Eustathius had maintained a ' in this he attempts to show against Origen, that the witch did not recall the ghost of Samuel, but that by the power of Satan the imagination of Saul and the woman were impressed with a phantom vision. July tfij *S. Eustathius.
firm demeanour towards the Arians, he would never admit them to communion. 1 He had expressed his distrust of the orthodoxy of Eusebius of Caesarea, and two other bishops. 2 Eusebius retorted by the charge of Sabellianism, which Arians always brought against the Catholics. Bent on his ruin, Eusebius, the wily bishop of Nicomedia, pretended that he had a great desire to visit Jerusalem, and the magnificent church built there by the emperor. He departed accordingly * Constantine furnishing him with carriage and all the cost of his journey. Theognis of Nicsea, his confidant, departed with him. On reaching Antioch they pretended friendship for Eustathius, and were received with kindness and hospitality.
On reaching Jerusalem they met Eusebius of Caesarea, Patrophilus of Scythopolis, Aetius of Lydda, Theodotus of Laodicsea, and other Arians. To them they discovered their design, and the whole party of bishops went to Antioch, under pretext of accompanying Eusebius of Nicomedia, as an act of courtesy. On reaching Antioch, a council was summoned, which was attended by S. Eustathius and some other Catholic prelates, who were ignorant of the plot. When all were assembled, the public were excluded at the request of the Arians, and they then introduced a profligate woman with an infant at her breast, whom they had suborned to accuse Eustathius of being its father. S. Eustathius indignantly demanded some evidence to substantiate this odious charge. There was none but that of the miserable woman, who was put upon her oath; and then, with one voice, the Arian prelates condemned him to lose his bishopric. The other bishops, who were not of the plot, peremptorily refused to acquiesce in this outrageous judgment, and entreated S. Eustathius not to submit to the sentence. They appealed to Moses, 1 to S. Paul, 2 who forbade a condemnation on a single testimony. But the Arians were in power. They did not publish the cause of the deposition of the patriarch [the title of the bishops of the great ancient sees: Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, Jerusalem], but hinted that he had been found guilty of Sabellianism. Eusebius of Nicomedia and Theognis then hastily returned to the emperor, and persuaded him of the guilt of Eustathius, adding, to ensure that the anger of Constantine should fall on the patriarch, that Eustathius had not treated Helena, the mother of the emperor, with respect. 3 Constantine banished him, as “ a pollution,” 4 to Illyria, in 331. Paulinus of Tyre was transferred to Antioch, and on his death, shortly afterwards, Eulalius was made bishop. He soon followed Paulinus. The vacant see was then offered to Eusebius of Caesarea. He declined it on canonical grounds, and Constantine highly applauded his refusal. But in the meantime the woman who had borne evidence against Eustathius had been stricken with illness. Then her conscience reproached her, and sending for the priests of Antioch, she confessed that she had been suborned to give false evidence. An Eustathius was indeed the father of her child, but was a coppersmith of that name. What must have been the reckless wickedness of the Eusebian party to have used such vile means to overthrow a champion of the true faith ! Yet, though the falsehood of the charge was exposed, and the guilt of the Arian bishops in bringing it forward was naked to the view of all, the innocent Eustathius remained in banishment. We may well understand why Eusebius 4 Euscb. Vit. Const, iii, 60.
S. Helier. of Caesarea shrank from facing the orthodox people of Antioch after the exposure of the intrigue in which he had been engaged. Eustathius died in Thrace, and was buried at Trajanopolis. His relics [the bodily remains of a saint, or objects they used, kept with honor] were translated to Antioch in 482.