E

The church of Carthage had been without a bishop for twenty-four years; but at last, at the prayer of the emperor Zeno and the Princess Placida, whose sister Huneric had married, h

Read the essentials →
Feast July 13 · Bishop

St. Eugenius of Carthage

Current feast

July 13
Secondary source · Wikipedia infobox

Traditional feast

July 13
1914 / pre-1969 calendar, per Baring-Gould (1897)

Represents

Bishop

Feast days

Feast: July 13

This Saint’s Story

Eugenius was unanimously elected Bishop of Carthage to succeed Deogratias after a long vacancy forced by the Arian (followers of Arius's teaching that the Son is a created being, not fully God) Vandal kings (Germanic rulers of North Africa), who taught that the Son is a created being, not fully God. The Catholic Encyclopedia dates the election to 480; Baring-Gould, the text on this page, places Huneric's permitting edict in June 481, granted at the urging of the emperor Zeno and the princess Placidia, into whose family the Vandals (a Germanic people who conquered Roman North Africa) had married. His wise government, charity to the poor, austere life and courage under persecution won even the Arians' admiration. Both sides claimed the name "Catholic"; the Arians called their opponents Homoousians.

When he received Vandals into the Catholic Church against royal orders and worsted Arian theologians in debate, Huneric struck hard. A conference held between 481 and February 484 ended when the chief Arian bishop withdrew, claiming he could not speak Latin. The king then exiled forty-six bishops to Corsica and three hundred and two to the African deserts. Eugenius was sent to the desert of Tripoli under a brutal guard named Antonius. As he left he wrote a letter of consolation to the faithful of Carthage that still survives among the works of Gregory of Tours. He also wrote an exposition of the Catholic faith on the consubstantiality of the Word and the divinity of the Holy Spirit, and other defenses of the faith.

Gunthamund, Huneric's successor, allowed Eugenius to return and reopen the churches. After eight years of peace Thrasamund renewed the persecution, condemned him to death, then changed the sentence to exile at Vienne near Albi in Languedoc. There Eugenius built a monastery over the tomb of the martyr St Amaranthus and lived in penance until his death on 13 July 505. Tradition holds that he miraculously cured a blind man.

What he represents

How he teaches us to live

Drawn from themes in the original account

Stay faithful when it costs you. Holding firm under pressure is part of this story.

Feed your mind with Scripture and good books. Learning and the Scriptures matter in this life.

The full story

Baring-Gould’s account retold in modern English

Read the full story · 1,597 words · about 7 min

The church of Carthage had been without a bishop for twenty-four years. However, at last, due to the prayer of Emperor Zeno and Princess Placida, whose sister had married Huneric, he allowed the Catholics to choose a bishop. He made the reasonable condition that if he tolerated Catholic bishops and priests in Africa, Zeno should grant similar tolerance to Arian teachers in the Eastern Empire. On June 18, 481, his edict was read by his notaries before Zeno's ambassador and the gathered African bishops in the church at Carthage. The bishops hesitated to accept these terms, but the official in charge refused to acknowledge their protest, and the election continued.

Eugenius was ordained as the bishop of Carthage to the great joy of the people, some of whom were young enough to have never seen a bishop in the prominent church. Eugenius quickly earned the respect and affection of all the people of Carthage through his virtues. His reputation as a preacher stirred jealousy among the Arian bishops, who pressured Huneric to prevent the bishop from allowing anyone wearing Vandal clothing to enter the Catholic churches. Eugenius refused to comply, and Huneric, likely angry that the Eastern emperor had ignored his request for toleration for the Arians, stationed officers at the church doors to arrest and forcibly remove the hair of any Vandal who entered to hear the bishop preach about the equal divinity of the Son. Those who were determined to abandon Arianism often lost their eyesight or died due to the brutal treatment they received. A common form of torture involved twisting small knotted sticks into the hair and then tearing them out, often removing large patches of scalp. Women who suffered this treatment were paraded around the city by a public crier, who warned others that they would face similar punishment if they embraced the Catholic faith.

On Ascension Day in 483, in the presence of Reginus, the ambassador of Emperor Zeno, Huneric sent an edict to Eugenius to be read in the church of Carthage, along with copies to all the African churches. The edict called for a conference to be held on February 1 of the following year, between the Arian and Catholic bishops, in his presence, to discuss their disagreements. The Catholic bishops responded that to hold a proper synod, the bishops from the rest of the Church must be gathered. “Write to the kings, your allies,” Eugenius said, “and I will write to the bishops, my brethren; and we will show you, when they come, what our common faith is.”

Between this summons and the assembly of the meeting, a miracle occurred that astonished the Arians. A blind man dreamed that on the feast of the Epiphany, he was told to anoint his eyes with the chrism used for the baptismal fonts, and he would be able to see. He went to the church while the ceremony was taking place, shared his vision with Eugenius, who then applied the holy oil to his eyes, and the man regained his sight.

The conference that followed did not lead to any satisfactory outcome. It convened on February 1st under very troubling circumstances. Huneric arrested several of the most capable defenders of the orthodox faith on trivial charges and sentenced them to death. One of the wisest and most learned Catholic bishops, Laetus, was burned alive to intimidate the others. Therefore, when the assembly met, the Catholic bishops did not expect fair treatment; nonetheless, they resolved to uphold their beliefs and defend their teachings fearlessly. Cyril, the Arian patriarch, sat on a high throne, while the Catholic bishops were forced to stand below him as if they were on trial. They protested, saying, “In a conference, there should be equality and impartiality.”

A notary of Huneric began, “The patriarch Cyril has said…” “Wait,” interrupted the Catholics, “by what authority does Cyril claim the title of patriarch?” The Arians erupted in loud and angry protests. “Who will act as the judge?” asked the Catholics. “Let the king appoint notaries or allow the people to participate.” The arrogant Arian bishops ordered the Catholic bishops to receive a hundred blows each for daring to make such a suggestion. Then S. Eugenius exclaimed, “May God witness the violence done to us and the persecutions we suffer.” The Catholic bishops said to Cyril, “Present the matter in dispute; make your proposal.” “I do not know Latin,” Cyril replied. The Catholics responded, “You have always spoken it until now; why are you avoiding the controversy you initiated with such a pretext?”

However, the Arians refused to discuss the matter openly. Then a Catholic profession of faith was read, declaring the unity of substance in the Godhead and the Trinity of persons; that the Son was of one substance with the Father, and the Holy Spirit of one substance with the Father and the Son. This document was dated April 20th, 484, indicating that the conference must have lasted nearly three months. Upon hearing this confession, the Arians objected to the orthodox claiming the exclusive right to the title of Catholic.

No conclusion was reached by this assembly, nor could one have been reached. Huneric ended the meeting by issuing an edict to close all the churches in Africa and to transfer the property of the Catholic clergy and bishops to the Arian clergy. In this edict, he stated that the bishops who had been summoned to Carthage to defend their use of the term Homoousios (meaning "of one substance") as applied to Christ had failed to do so. They had evaded the issue, postponed their responses, and had called upon the people in a disorderly manner to support their cause against their opponents. The edict was dated February 25th, which means it must have been prepared before the assembly concluded.

When the edict was announced, Huneric ordered the bishops to be expelled from Carthage, their horses to be taken away, and they were to be stripped of their slaves and clothing. Anyone who sheltered them would be burned along with their houses. The unfortunate bishops, cast out beyond the gates of Carthage, did not know where to go. They remained there, exposed to the elements, starving and destitute. One day, Huneric rode out with his entourage of Vandals. The bishops approached him pleadingly, asking, “What evil have we done? We gathered at your command, and now we are dying from cold and hunger.” Huneric responded, “Ride them down!” turning to his followers. The barbarians charged at the defenseless old men, injuring and trampling some of the most aged and frail.

They were all summoned to meet in the Temple of Memory. A sealed document was presented to them, and they were told, “The king, though angered by your disobedience, is willing to treat you better. Swear to do what is written in this document, and he will allow you to return to your churches.” All replied, “We hold the one true apostolic faith; we are Catholic bishops.”

When they were urged again to take the oath, two bishops, Hortulanus and Florentianus, spoke on behalf of the others, saying, “What! Are we animals, to swear to something we do not understand?”

The king's emissaries insisted, “Swear that, upon the king's death, you will support his son Hilderic, and that none of you will send letters beyond the sea.”

Some of the bishops took the required oath. The rest, including S. Eugenius, refused it. Their refusal is difficult to understand. Huneric anticipated what eventually happened, that his nephews, Gundamund and Thrasimund, would contest the throne with the child. As it turned out, Gundamund and Thrasimund were persecutors, while the mild Hilderic favored the Catholics.

Those bishops who refused to take the oath did so with an unworthy excuse, saying, "The Scriptures say, Swear not at all." Huneric punished both those who had sworn and those who had not by placing them under a common ban. Those who took the oath were forced into exile to work in the fields, where they had to plow, sow, and harvest grain, and they were forbidden to perform their sacred duties or even to handle a book. Those who refused the oath were exiled to Corsica and condemned to chop wood and build ships.

Saint Eugenius of Carthage, seeing himself taken into exile without time to encourage his flock, wrote them a letter. In it, he urged them, by the majesty of God, to remain steadfast in the true faith and the one baptism.

Along with him was Vindemialis, the bishop of Capsei, in the province of Byzacene, and Longinus of Pamara, in Mauritania Caesariana. We have a list of all the bishops who attended the conference and were exiled. In total, there were four hundred and sixty-six bishops, of whom eighty-eight died. Forty-six were sent to Corsica, three hundred and two to other locations, twenty-six fled for safety, and eighty-eight conformed to Arianism.

The hardships of ten years of exile must have diminished their numbers, and the Catholic succession would have ended had they conformed to the law of Thrasimund, which prohibited episcopal ordinations. They disobeyed, and their disobedience led to a second exile of two hundred and twenty bishops to Sardinia, where they suffered for fifteen years until the kind Hilderic came to power. Eugenius had been recalled at the end of Gundamund's reign in 488, but he was caught up in the second banishment decree. He was sent to Gaul, possibly to Alaric, who was an Arian like Thrasimund. He died at Albi in Provence, and his relics are still honored there.

Footnotes

  1. Reginus was the ambassador of Emperor Zeno.
  2. The feast of the Epiphany celebrates the revelation of Christ to the Gentiles.
  3. The chrism is a consecrated oil used in various sacraments.
  4. The title of patriarch refers to a senior bishop in certain Christian traditions.
  5. Homoousios: a term used in Christian theology to describe the nature of Christ.
  6. Eugenius of Carthage was a bishop who faced exile for his faith.
  7. Vindemialis was the bishop of Capsei, located in Byzacene.
  8. Longinus was the bishop of Pamara, in Mauritania Caesariana.
  9. Thrasimund was a king known for his opposition to Catholic bishops.
  10. Hilderic was a king who succeeded Gundamund and was more favorable to Catholics.
  11. Alaric was a king associated with Arianism, similar to Thrasimund.

Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.

Read the original 1870s text

Baring-Gould’s sources: Ancient and Modem Roman Martyrologies. Florus, Ado, Usuardns, Notker. At Albi on Sept. 6th, on account of a translation of relics. Authorities: —An account in Gregory of Tours, from a book of the sufferings of the African Martyrs under the Vandals, which he had under his eyes when he wrote (a.d. 591), mention by S. Isidore of Seville, in his Little History of the Vandal Persecution, and last, but not least, Victor of Utica, in his contemporary History of the Vandal Persecution (cca. Genseric, king of the Vandals in Africa, died at the beginning of the year 477, and was succeeded by his eldest son, Huneric. At first he exhibited moderation towards the Catholics, so that they began to assemble in the places whence Genseric had driven them. Huneric commenced his series of persecutions by attack. ing the Manichees; he burnt many of them, and killed others.

The church of Carthage had been without a bishop for twenty-four years; but at last, at the prayer of the emperor Zeno and the Princess Placida, whose sister Huneric had married, he permitted the Catholics to choose a bishop; but made the not unreasonable stipulation that, if he tolerated Catholic bishops and priests in Africa, Zeno should accord to Arian [followers of Arius, who taught that the Son is a created being, not fully God] teachers a like toleration in the Eastern empire. On the 18th June, 481, his edict was read by his notaries before the ambassador of Zeno and the assembled African prelates, in the church at Carthage. The bishops hesitated to accept these terms; but the commissary refused to accept their protest, and the election was proceeded with.

Eugenius was ordained bishop of Carthage to the great joy of the people, some of the younger of whom had never seen a bishop occupy the throne in the great church.

Eugenius soon attracted the respect or love of all the Carthaginians by his virtues. His reputation as a preacher excited the jealousy of the Arian prelates, who besieged Huneric to forbid the bishop from admitting any wearing Vandal costume within the gates of the Catholic churches. Eugenius refused, and Huneric, angry, no doubt, that the Eastern emperor had paid no attention to his demand for toleration to the Arians, placed officers at the church doors, who should arrest and pluck out the hair of any Vandal entering to hear the bishop preach the co-equal godhead of the Son. Those who proved earnest in their resolution to abandon the errors of Arianism, lost their eyes, or died in consequence of the cruel usage to which they were subjected. A favourite torment was to twist little knotted sticks in the hair, and then tear them from the head, bringing away often large pieces of the scalp. Women, with their heads thus torn, were conducted round the city by a public crier, who denounced similar treatment to all such as should embrace the Catholic faith.

On Ascension Day, 483, in the presence of Reginus, ambassador of the emperor Zeno, Huneric sent an edict to Eugenius, to be read in the church of Carthage, and copies to all the African Churches. In the edict a conference was summoned to be held on the 1st February following, between the Arian and Catholic bishops, in his presence, on the subject of controversy between them. The Catholic prelates answered that to hold a proper synod the bishops of the rest of the Church must be assembled, “ Write to the kings, your allies,” said Eugenius, “and I will write to the bishops, my brethren; and we will show you, when they come, what is our common faith.”

[July is. Between this summons and the assembly of the meeting, a miracle was wrought, which confounded the Arians. A blind man dreamt, that on the feast of the Epiphany he was bidden anoint his eyes with the chrism wherewith the baptismal fonts were anointed, and he would see. He went to the church as the ceremony was being performed, narrated his vision to Eugenius, who struck his eyes with the holy oil, and the man saw.

The conference led to nothing satisfactory. It assembled on the ist February under the most ominous circumstances. Huneric arrested several of the ablest champions of the orthodox cause, on the most frivolous charges, and condemned them to death. One of the wisest and most learned of the Catholic prelates, Laetus, he consigned to the flames, to intimidate the rest. When the assembly met, therefore, the Catholic bishops did not expect to be fairly treated; nevertheless they determined to maintain their cause, and defend their teaching undauntedly. Cyril, the Arian patriarch [the title of the bishops of the great ancient sees: Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, Jerusalem], occupied an exalted throne, the Catholic bishops were made to stand beneath as culprits on their trial. They complained; “In a conference there should be equality and impartiality.”

A notary of Huneric began, “The patriarch Cyril has said ” 44 Stay,” interrupted the Catholics; 44 by what authority does Cyril claim his title of patriarch ?” The Arians burst into loud and angry exclamations. 44 Who is to stand as umpire ?” asked the Catholics. 44 Let the king delegate notaries, or admit the people.” The insolent Arian prelates ordered the Catholic bishops to receive a hundred blows each for having dared to make such a proposition. Then S. Eugenius exclaimed, J«iy is.) S. Eugenius.

11 May God behold the violence dealt us, and the persecutions we endure.” The Catholic bishops said to Cyril, “ Bring forward the matter in dispute, make your proposition.” “I do not know Latin,” answered Cyril. The Catholics replied, “You have always spoken it hitherto, why evade the controversy you have yourself proposed, by such a quibble ?”

But the Arians could not be brought to discuss the matter openly. Then a Catholic profession of faith was read, declaring the unity of substance in the Godhead, and the Trinity of persons; that the Son was of one substance with the Father, the Holy Ghost of one substance with the Father and the Son. This memoir was dated April 20th, 484, so that the conference must have been protracted nearly three months. The Arians, on hearing this confession, took objection to the orthodox assuming to themselves the sole right to the title of Catholic.

No conclusion was come to by this assembly, none could have been come to; and Huneric broke it off by issuing an edict to close all the churches in Africa, and give the substance of the Catholic clergy and bishops to the Arian clergy. In this edict he said that the bishops who had been summoned to Carthage to defend their use of the word, Homoousios (of one substance) as applied to Christ, had not done so; they had equivocated, and postponed their answers, and had called in the people tumultuously to maintain their cause against their opponents. The edict was dated Feb. 25th, and therefore must have been drawn up before the conclusion of the conference.

When it was promulgated, Huneric ordered the bishops to be driven out of Carthage, their horses to be taken from them; they were to be deprived of their slaves and their clothes. Any who should harbour them would be burned along with their houses. The unfortunate bishops, cast outside the gates of Carthage, knew not where to go; they remained there, exposed to the air, starving, destitute. One day Huneric rode forth with his train of Vandals. The bishops came to him suppliantly, 44 What evil have we done ? We assembled at thy command, and now we perish from cold and hunger.” “Ride them down!” said Huneric, turning to his followers. The barbarians galloped among the defenceless old men, and wounded and trampled under foot some of the most aged and feeble.

They were all summoned to meet in the Temple of Memory. A closed paper was presented to them; and they were told, 11 The king, though irritated at your disobedience, is disposed to treat you better. Swear then to do that which is written in this paper, and he will send you back to your churches.” All replied, “ We hold the one true apostolic faith; we are Catholic bishops.”

When the oath was again urged on them, two, Hortulanus and Florentianus, said in the name of the rest, 44 What ! are we beasts, to swear to that we do not know ?”

The emissaries of the king said, 44 Swear that, on the death of the king, you will support his son Hilderic; and that none of you will write letters beyond the sea.”

Some of the bishops took the required oath. The rest, S. Eugenius included, refused it. It is difficult to understand their refusal. Huneric foresaw what even6 *. Eugenius.

tually took place, that his nephews, Gundamund and Thrasimund, would dispute the throne with the child. As it fell out, Gundamund and Thrasimund were persecutors, the mild Hilderic favoured the Catholics.

Those of the bishops who refused the oath did so by an unworthy quibble, li The Scriptures say, Swear not at all.” Huneric involved those who had sworn, and those who had not, in common proscription; those who took the oath were banished to the fields to plough, and sow, and garner corn, and were forbidden to exercise their sacred offices, and so much as to handle a book. Those who refused the oath were exiled to Corsica, and condemned to hew wood and build ships. S. Eugenius of Carthage* seeing himself carried oft into banishment, without time allowed him to exhort his flock, wrote them a letter, in which he conjured them, by the majesty of God, to remain firm to the true faith and the one baptism.

With him was sent Vindemialis, bishop of Capsei, in the province of Byzacene, and Longinus of Pamara, in Mauritania Caesariana. We have a list of all the bishops who attended the conference, and were exiled. In all there were four hundred and sixty-six, of whom eighty-eight died. Forty-six were sent to Corsica, three hundred and two to other places, twenty-six sought refuge in flight; and eighty-eight conformed to Arianism.

The hardships of ten years exile must have reduced their numbers, and the Catholic succession would have expired had they conformed to the law of Thrasimund, which prohibited episcopal ordinations. They disobeyed; and their disobedience was punished by a second exile of two hundred and twenty bishops into Lives 0/ the Saints.

CJ«iy *3 Sardinia; where they languished fifteen years, till the accession of the gracious Hilderic. Eugenius had been recalled at the close of the reign of Gundamund, in 488, but was involved in the second edict of banishment. He was sent to Gaul [roughly modern France and Belgium], perhaps to Alaric, an Arian like Thrasimund. He died at Albi in Provence, and his relics [the bodily remains of a saint, or objects they used, kept with honor] are still venerated there.

From the Catholic Encyclopedia

1913 · 403 words

Eugenius of Carthage, Saint, unanimously elected Bishop of Carthage in 480 to succeed Deogratias (d. 456); d. July 13, 505. The election was deferred owing to the opposition of the Arian [followers of Arius, who taught that the Son is a created being, not fully God] Vandal kings and was only permitted by Huneric at the instance of Zeno and Placidia, into whose family the Vandals had married. The bishop's wise government, charity to the poor, austerity of life, and courage under persecution, won the admiration of the Arians. In his uncompromising defense of the Divinity of the Word he was imitated by the members of his flock, many of whom were exiled with him, after he had admitted Vandals into the Catholic Church, contrary to royal edict, and had worsted in argument Arian theologians, whom the king pitted against the Catholics. Both sides claimed the name "Catholic", the Arians calling their opponents "Homoousians". The conference was held some time between 481 and February, 484, and ended by the withdrawal of the chief Arian bishop on the plea that he could not speak Latin. The Arians being enraged, Huneric persecuted the Catholics, exiling forty-six bishops to Corsica, and three hundred and two to the African deserts. Among the latter was Eugenius, who under the custody of a ruffian named Antonius dwelt in the desert of Tripoli. On setting out he wrote a letter of consolation and exhortation to the faithful of Carthage which is still extant in the works of Gregory of Tours [bishop and historian of the Franks (d. 594)] (P.L., LVII, 769-71). Gunthamund, who succeeded Huneric allowed Eugenius to return to Carthage and permitted him to reopen the churches. After eight years of peace Thrasamund succeeded to the throne, revived the persecution, arrested Eugenius, and condemned him to death, but commuted the sentence into exile at Vienne, near Albi (Languedoc), where the Arian Alaric was king. Eugenius built here a monastery over the tomb of St. Amaranthus, the martyr, and led a penitential life till his death. He is said to have miraculously cured a man who was blind.

He wrote: "Expositio Fidei Catholicae", demanded of him by Huneric, probably the one submitted by the Catholic bishops at the conference. It proves the consubstantiality of the Word and Divinity of the Holy Ghost. He wrote also an "Apologeticus pro Fide"; "Altercatio cum Arianis", fragments of which are quoted by Victor de Vita; also pleas for the Catholics, addressed to Huneric or his successors. His letter to the faithful of Carthage has been mentioned above.

Help us add to this saint's story

Everything is read by a person before anything appears. Facts are checked against trusted sources first.

Facts are welcome; a source link helps (optional).With your permission we may share it on this page.

Nine days · Free

Pray the novena
with us.

One short email a day for nine days. The day's prayer, a line from St. Eugenius of Carthage's story, and a nudge to keep going.

Also on July 13

St. Silas

July 13 · Apostle

St. Sara

July 13 · Virgin, Abbess
M

Sts. Maura and Bridget

July 13 · Virgins, Martyrs
← All 1970 saints in the library
Sources & notes

Feast-day sources

Story sources

Sources

Credits

From “Catholic Encyclopedia (1913)/St. Eugenius of Carthage,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (New York: Robert Appleton Company, 1907–1914), via Wikisource. Public domain. Matched by name and feast date; text unedited except for our bracketed notes in grey.

Retold in plain modern English from Baring-Gould’s public-domain text, sentence by sentence, keeping the same facts and order. Short explanations in parentheses are ours.

From Sabine Baring-Gould, The Lives of the Saints, new edition in 16 vols. (London: John C. Nimmo, 1897–98); text from the Internet Archive scan (OCR, lightly cleaned; errors possible). Public domain in the United States. Reproduced unedited, except for short bracketed notes in grey that we added to explain names and terms (“S.” is the old abbreviation for Saint). Some history and judgments reflect 19th-century scholarship.

Notes

Story retold in our own words from the cited sources.