It is difficult to determine what is true about Edgar due to the conflicting accounts of historians. The land was at peace during his reign, and his rule appears to have been just and firm. To protect his kingdom from the Danes and Norsemen, Edgar, like Alfred, maintained a large fleet that patrolled the coasts, watching for the private ships of the invaders.
King Edgar frequently visited and sailed with his fleet. He also traveled throughout his kingdom to ensure that justice was served and to punish wrongdoers. He encouraged Germans and Flemings to settle in the country and sought to establish trade and commerce with the Continent.
Almost his only war was with the Welsh because Idwal, son of Ruderic the Great, a prince of North Wales, refused to pay tribute. In 963, Edgar invaded his lands, and if we can believe William of Malmesbury, he forced Idwal to pay a tribute of 300 wolves’ heads each year. This tribute was paid for only three years, by which time the wolves had been exterminated from the Principality of Wales.
It was not until Edgar had reigned for thirteen years that he was crowned king at Bath. After his coronation in 973, he sailed with his fleet around Wales to Chester. There, six, or as some say, eight of his vassal kings arrived with their fleets and paid homage. These eight are said to have included Kenneth, king of the Scots, Malcolm of Cumberland, Maccus of the Isles, and five Welsh princes. These eight kings rowed the Lord of all Britain in a boat, while Edgar himself steered, from the royal palace at Chester to the minster of Saint John, where they prayed before returning the same way. It was perhaps during this time that the incident related by William of Malmesbury occurred. Edgar was a small man, but he was strong and skilled with his sword. One night, Kenneth of Scotland remarked at a banquet, "How strange it seems that we kings should have to serve such a little fellow." This was reported to Edgar, who called Kenneth aside into the forest and said, "Draw your sword and strike boldly, and we will see who is most fit to reign. Men should not be quick with their words and slow with their swords." Then Kenneth fell at his feet and begged for his pardon for what he had said.
On the death of Archbishop Odo of Canterbury in 959, S. Dunstan took his place. He had significant influence over the king and was heavily involved in the governance of the realm. S. Dunstan then expelled the secular canons from many of the main churches in England and replaced them with monks. King Edgar showed him great respect.
One Sunday, while the king was out hunting, Dunstan fell asleep and dreamed he was attending Mass. The king returned just as S. Dunstan heard the words "Ite missa est" in his dream. "Now let us have Mass sung," said the king. "It is too late," answered the bishop, "I have just finished assisting at it." The king understood the message and never went hunting on Sunday again.
King Edgar does not appear to have been particularly strict in his morals, according to various stories told about him. He once took a nun from her convent, for which he was reprimanded by S. Dunstan and made to do penance, which included not wearing his crown for seven years. He married twice. His first wife was Ethelfleda, known as the White and the Duck, who was the daughter of Ordmar, the earl. After her death, he married Elfrida in 964, who was the daughter of Ordgar, earl of Devon, and the widow of Ethelwald, earl of the East Angles. She bore him two sons, Edmund, who died young in 971, and Ethelred. Edgar was also the father of S. Edith of Polesworth, by a woman named Wulfrida, who was a nun.
A very romantic story is told about the love between Edgar and Elfrida, which can be found in the works of William of Malmesbury and Geoffrey Gaimar. However, since their accounts are based on popular tradition and ballads, they should not be taken too seriously. Still, there is likely some truth to it. The story goes as follows: Edgar, hearing of Elfrida's beauty, sent his friend Ethelwald to see her and find out if she was as lovely as people said. Ethelwald fell in love with her and asked Ordgar for her hand in marriage. After receiving consent, he hurried back to the king and told him that the reports were exaggerated and that the maiden was only plain. However, since she was wealthy and the heiress of Ordgar, he asked Edgar to allow him to marry her. The king agreed, and Ethelwald married Elfrida, becoming the father of a boy whom he persuaded the king to be the godfather to, naming him Edgar. Ethelwald was pleased because he knew that, according to Church law, they had formed a spiritual relationship that would prevent the king from ever marrying Elfrida.
Now the report reached the king that Elfrida was the most beautiful woman in England, and that Ethelwald had deceived him. While he was hunting in the West, possibly on the royal grounds of Dartmoor, he sent word to Ethelwald that he would visit him at his castle of Harewood.
Ethelwald was in distress, and he told his wife how he had been sent to seek her hand for the king, but how he had kept her for himself. Fearing the king’s anger, he begged her to disguise her beauty. However, when Elfrida heard this, she became furious. She dressed in her most expensive clothes, adorned herself with all her jewels, and went out to meet the king in all her radiant beauty. Edgar became madly and passionately infatuated with her. This led to a secret affair and a plan to eliminate Ethelwald.
One day, while they were hunting together in the woods around Harewood and were alone, the king struck Ethelwald with a javelin. This Harewood is on the Tamar River, not the Harewood near Leeds as some Yorkshire historians claim. This is clear from Gaimar, who states that to get rid of Ethelwald, the king sent him to Yorkshire, where he was killed. Afterward, Elfrida came up from Devon to meet the king, accompanied by all the nobles of the West. The entire story is charming in Gaimar; it is told so vividly and with such picturesque details. After Ethelwald died, Edgar took Elfrida to be his wife. To atone for their wrongdoing, he built a convent in the Harewood forest.
King Edgar died in 975 and was buried at Glastonbury. He was only thirty-two years old when he died. It is hard to understand why he should be honored as a Saint, except that he allowed Saint Dunstan and the monks to have their way in church matters, rather than opposing them and supporting the secular clergy against their encroachments like his brother Edwy.
So says William of Malmesbury, but according to Gaimar, the king killed him by the sword of the rebels in Yorkshire, where he had sent him to be out of the way. The killing of Ethelwald in the woods may be a reminder of a mythological story among the Anglo-Saxons similar to the Nibelungenlied. Ethelwald is Sigurd, Elfrida is Kriemhild, Edgar is Etsel, and Hagen is in one.
Footnotes
- William of Malmesbury described him as "libidinous towards maidens."
- This Harewood is on the Tamar River, not the Harewood near Leeds as some Yorkshire historians claim.
- This is clear from Gaimar, who states that to get rid of Ethelwald, the king sent him to Yorkshire, where he was killed.
- The killing of Ethelwald in the woods may be a reminder of a mythological story among the Anglo-Saxons similar to the Nibelungenlied.
Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.
Read the original 1870s text
Baring-Gould’s sources: In Anglican Martyrologies on May 24th and June 8th. Authorities Bede, William of Malmesbury, the Saxon Chronicle, Osbern’s Life of S. Dupstan, and other later writers.] Edgar, king of the Mercians, was chosen king of the whole people of the English, on the death of his brother Edwy; 1 in 959; when he was only sixteen years old. He was not anointed king, as he had received the unction on his election to be king of the Mercians when they revolted against Edwy.
It is difficult to distinguish, in the conflicting accounts of historians, what is true about Edgar. The land was in peace during his reign, and his rule seems to have been just and firm. To preserve his kingdom against the Danes [Viking raiders from Scandinavia] and Norsemen, Edgar, like Alfred, kept up a great fleet, which sailed along the coasts watching for the private ships of the invaders.
King Edgar often visited and cruised about in his fleet, and he also went through his kingdom to see that justice was done, and to punish wrong-doers. He encouraged Germans and Flemings to settle in the country, and endeavoured to establish intercourse and commerce with the Continent.
1 See Life of S. Odo (July 4th), and Life of S- Dunstan (May 19th). J»iy80 Almost his only war was with the Welsh, because Idwal, son of Ruderic the Great, a prince of North Wales, refused to pay tribute. In 963, Edgar invaded his lands, and, if we may believe William of Malmesbury, forced him to pay a tribute of 300 wolves’ heads yearly; this tribute was paid for only three years, by which time the wolves were exterminated out of the Principality of Wales.
It was not till Edgar had reigned thirteen years that he was crowned king, at Bath, and after his coronation (in 973) he sailed with his fleet round Wales to Chester, and there six, or as some say, eight, of his vassal kings came with their fleets and did homage. These eight are said to have been Kenneth, king of the Scots, Malcolm of Cumberland, Maccus of the Isles, and five Welsh princes. These eight kings rowed the Lord of all Britain in a boat, while Edgar himself steered, from the royal palace at Chester to the minster of S. John, where they prayed, and went back the same way. It was perhaps at this time that the incident occurred related by William of Malmesbury. Edgar was a little man, but strong and skilful with his sword. One night Kenneth of Scotland said at a banquet, il How strange it seems that we kings should have to serve such a little fellow.” Now this was related to Edgar, and he called Kenneth apart into the forest, and said, li Draw thy sword, and lay on manfully, and we will prove which is fittest to reign. Men should not be swift with their tongues and sluggish with their swords.” Then Kenneth fell at his feet, and besought his pardon for what he had said.
On the death of archbishop Odo of Canterbury, in 9 59, his room was filled by S. Dunstan, who exercised great sway over the king, and had much to do with the government of the realm. Then S. Dunstan turned the secular canons out of many of the chief churches of England, and filled their places with monks. Edgar showed him the utmost respect. One Sunday the king was out hunting. Whilst he was out Dunstan fell asleep, and dreamt he had been present at mass. The king returned as S. Dunstan heard the u Ite missa est ” in his dream. il Now let us have mass sung,” said the king. “ It is too late,” answered the bishop, “ I have just done assisting at it.” The king took the hint, and never went out hunting on Sunday again. King Edgar does not seem to have been remarkably strict in his morals, if we may credit the various stories told of him. 1 He once carried off a nun from her convent, and was reprimanded by S. Dunstan and put to penance, that he should not wear his crown for seven years. He married twice. His first wife was Ethelfleda, called the White and the Duck, daughter of Ordmar, the earl. After her death he married, in 964, Elfrida, daughter of Ordgar, earl of Devon, the widow of Ethelwald, earl of the East Angles. She bore him two sons, Edmund, who died young, in 971, and Ethelred. Edgar was also the father of S. Edith of Polesworth, by a woman named Wulfrida, a nun. A very romantic story is told of the loves of Edgar and Elfrida, which is found in William of Malmesbury and in Geoffrey Gaimar, but as their authority was only popular tradition and ballads, not too much reliance can be placed on it. Nevertheless there is probably some foundation for it. 1 The story told briefly is as follows: — Edgar, hearing of the beauty of Elfrida, daughter of Ordgar, earl of Devon, sent his friend Ethelwald to see her, and ascertain if she was as fair as fame related. Ethelwald fell in love with » He was, says William of Malmesbury, *• libidinosus iu rirgines." her, and asked her hand of Ordgar for himself. Having received his consent, he hurried back to the king and told him that the report was exaggerated, the maiden was only plain, but as she was rich, and the heiress of Ordgar, he asked Edgar to suffer him to take her to be his own wife. The king gave his consent, and Ethelwald married Elfrida, and became by her the father of a boy whom he persuaded the king to stand godfather to, and to whom he gave the name of Edgar. Then Ethelwald was glad, for he knew that according to the laws of the Church, they had become connected by a spiritual relationship, which would prevent the king from ever marrying Elfrida.
Now the report reached the king that Elfrida was the loveliest woman in England, and that Ethel wald had deceived him; and when he was hunting in the West, perhaps on the royal chase of Dartmoor, he sent word to Ethelwald that he would visit him at his castle of Harewood. 1 Ethelwald was in dismay, and he told his wife how he had been sent to seek her hand for the king, and how he had kept her for himself, and dreading the king’s displeasure, he implored her to disguise her beauty. But when Elfrida heard the story she waxed wrath, and dressed herself in her most costly dresses, decked herself in all her jewels, and came out to meet the king in all her radiant beauty. Edgar became madly, passionately enamoured. The result was an intrigue and a resolution to destroy Ethelwald. As they were together hunting one day in the woods round Harewood, and when they were alone, the king smote Ethelwald with a javelin 1 Harewood on the Tamar; not, as Yorkshire antiquaries pretend, Harewood near Leeds. This isdear from Gaimar, for the king, to get rid of Ethelwald, sent him into Yorkshire, where be was killed, and then Elfrida came up from Devon to meet the king, attended by all the nobles of the West. The whole story is delightful in Gaimar, it is told so graphically and with such picturesque details. that he died j 1 and he took Elfrida to be his wife; and to expiate their offence, erected a convent in the Harewood forest.
King Edgar died in 975, and was buried at Glastonbury. He was only thirty-two years old when he died. Why he should have received veneration as a Saint one is at a loss to see; except that he let S. Dunstan and the monks have their own way in ecclesiastical matters, instead of opposing them and supporting the secular clergy against their encroachments like his brother Edwy.
1 So William ef Malmesbury, but according to Galmar, the king slew him, by the sword of the rebels in Yorkshire, whither he bad sent him to be out of the way. The slaying of Ethel wald In the wood is perhaps a reminiscence of a mythological story among the Anglo-Saxons akin to the Nibelungen Lied. Ethel wald is Sigurd, Elfreda is Kriemhild, Edgar Is Etsel and Hagen In one. Mr*] •S'.S’. Anatholia and Audax.