“My son,” said Isaac, “the Lord has shown me that He has destined you to be with me for the rest of my life.” Then Dalmatius went home, said goodbye to his wife and daughter, and took his son Faustus with him. They were both shorn together in Isaac's house. He quickly became a model monk, fasting for long periods and entering into ecstasies. After Isaac's death, he was elected hegumen (the head of a monastery) in his place.
In 427, after the death of the patriarch Sisinnius, the Syrian Nestorius was appointed as the bishop of Constantinople. He was a man of great ability; he was fluent, eloquent, and had a clear, ringing voice, like a silver bell. He had been a priest in Antioch, where his sermons attracted large crowds. Constantinople believed that with Nestorius, she had gained a second Chrysostom (a famous early church father). However, he was quite different from the great John. Immediately after his appointment, he showed a fierce and intemperate zeal against heretics. In one of his first sermons, he exclaimed, turning to Emperor Theodosius, “Give me, O Emperor! the land purged of heretics, and I will give you heaven in return. Help me in destroying heretics, and I will help you to fight the Persians.” Not long after—he had not been bishop for a week—he tried to take away an oratory in Constantinople that the Arians used for private worship. In the chaos that followed, the oratory was set on fire, and the flames spread to nearby houses, reducing several to ashes. He then attacked the Novatians, the Quartodecimans, and the Macedonians, persuading the Emperor to enact harsh laws against these heretics.
This intolerance upset Dalmatius and other level-headed individuals, and they instinctively felt that the heart of the persecutor was not right with God. It was not long before Nestorius himself began to be suspected of heresy. He denied the Blessed Virgin the title of Mother of God. He claimed she was the mother of the human aspect of Christ, but could not be regarded as the mother of the divine nature. He went further; he asserted that “God the Word was not
born of Mary, but that He took up His dwelling in the man born of Mary. The orthodox were alarmed. The patriarch appealed to the Emperor to suppress them. A council was summoned at Ephesus. The Nestorians surrounded the place, stopping all communications with Constantinople. Eventually, a beggar conveyed a letter from the bishops gathered at Ephesus to the monks of Constantinople, describing their distress. The letter prompted a response from all the monks. Led by Dalmatius, who had not left his monastery for forty-eight years, they marched in a long line to the palace. The Emperor allowed the archimandrites to enter, and they read to him the letter they had received from Ephesus.
“Well,” said the Emperor, “if matters are thus, why do not some of the bishops in the council come here to complain?”
“Sire!” replied Dalmatius, “they are prevented from leaving.”
“No one prevents them,” the Emperor said.
“Yes, sire, they are prevented. Those who agree with Nestorius have full freedom to come and go, but no one is allowed to approach Your Piety on behalf of the holy Synod or inform you of what is happening.” He added, “Will you hear six hundred bishops, or listen to one impious man?”
The Emperor agreed that messengers from the council should come to Constantinople. Then the archimandrites left, leading their group of monks and the crowds that followed them into the church of St. Mocius. Dalmatius ascended the pulpit and recounted what had occurred. When he finished, everyone shouted, “Anathema to Nestorius!”
The bishops at Ephesus sent a letter to Dalmatius thanking him for his intervention on their behalf. The history of the council has been fully detailed elsewhere, so it does not need to be repeated here. After this notable act of intervention for the orthodox bishops, Dalmatius returned to his monastery and did not leave it again until his death.
Footnotes
- Socrat. Hist. Eccl., vii. 29
- The history of the council has been given fully elsewhere, and need not be repeated here.
Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.
Read the original 1870s text
Baring-Gould’s sources: By the Greeks on this day; also in the Syriac and Armenian kalendars. The Menology of the Emperor Basil commemorates the hegumen Isaac along with Dalmatius and Faustus. All three on this day in the Russian kalendar. Authorities: — An ancient Greek life, the letters of S. Cyril, and writers on the Council of Ephesus.] Dalmatius had borne arms under Theodosius the Great, and had served in the second company of the guards. But S. Isaac, hegumen or abbot of a monastery in Constantinople, bade him enter the religious life. Dalmatius, amazed answered him, “ My father, I have a household and children.”
“My son,” said Isaac, “the Lord has shown me that he has destined thee to be with me through the rest of my life.” Then Dalmatius went home, arid bade farewell to his wife and daughter, and taking his son Faustus with him, they were shorn together in the house of Isaac. He speedily became a model of a monk, fasting long, and falling into ecstasies. On the death of Isaac, he was elected hegumen in his room.
In 427, on the death of the patriarch [the title of the bishops of the great ancient sees: Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, Jerusalem] Sisinnius, the Syrian Nestorius [Nestorius (d. c. 451), whose teaching split Christ into two persons; condemned at Ephesus in 431] was elevated to the bishopric of Constantinople. He was a man oi great ability; fluent, eloquent, with a clear, pealing voice, like a silver bell. He had been a priest at Antioch, where his sermons attracted great numbers. Constantinople thought that in Nestorius she had acquired a second Chrysostom. But he was a man of another sort from the great John. Immediately on his appointment, he manifested a hot intemperate zeal against heretics. In one of his first sermons he exclaimed, turning to the Emperor Theodosius [name of Roman emperors; Theodosius I (379–395) made Christianity the state religion], “Give me, O Emperor! the land purged of heretics, and I will give thee heaven in return. Assist me in destroying heretics, and I will assist thee to combat the Persians.”1 Not long after — he had not been bishop a week — he endeavoured to deprive the Arians [followers of Arius, who taught that the Son is a created being, not fully God] of an oratory in Constantinople which they possessed, and in which they worshipped privately. In the tumult that ensued, the oratory was set on fire, and the flames communicating with the neighbouring houses, reduced several to ashes. He next assailed the Novatians, the Quartodecimans, and the Macedonians, and persuaded the Emperor to pass severe laws against these heretics.
This intolerance displeased Dalmatius and other sound minded men, and they felt instinctively that the heart of the persecutor was not right with God. It was not long before Nestorius himself began to fall under suspicion of heresy. He denied to the Blessed Virgin the title of Mother of God. She was the mother of the manhood, but in no way could she be regarded as mother of the Godhead. He went further; he asserted that “ God the Word was not 1 Socrat. Hist. Eccl., vii. 29, S'. Dalmatius.
born of Mary, but that he took up his dwelling in the man born of Mary.’' The orthodox took the alarm. The patriarch appealed to the Emperor to suppress them. A council was summoned at Ephesus. The Nestorians surrounded the place, stopping all communications with Constantinople. At length a beggar conveyed a letter from the bishops assembled at Ephesus to the monks of Constantinople, narrating their distress. The letter caused a rising of all the monks. With Dalmatius at their head, who for forty-eight years had not set foot outside his monastery, they poured in a long train to the palace. The Emperor admitted the archimandrites; and they read to him the letter they had received from Ephesus. “ Well,” said the Emperor, “ if matters are thus, why do not some of the bishops in the council come here to complain ?”
“Sire!” replied Dalmatius, “they are prevented from leaving.” “No one prevents them*” “Yes, sire, they are prevented. Those who think with Nestorius have full liberty given them to come or go, but no one is suffered to approach your Piety on behalf of the holy Synod, or inform you of what is being done.” And he added, “Will you hear six hundred bishops, or listen to one impious man ?”
The Emperor granted that messengers from the council should come to Constantinople. Then the archimandrites left, and conducting their train of monks, and the crowds that followed, into the church of S. Mocius, Dalmatius ascended the pulpit and related what had passed. When he ceased, all, with a great shout, exclaimed, “ Anathema to N estorius !”
The bishops at Ephesus sent a letter to Dalmatius thanking him for his interference on their behalf. The history of the council has been given fully elsewhere, and need not be repeated here. Immediately after this one conspicuous act of intervention in behalf of the orthodox bishops, Dalmatius returned to his monastery, and did not leave it again till his death.