Traditional feast: October 28
October 28
Virgin
Martyr
Share your faith, in words and by example. Preaching and conversion are part of this story.
Stay faithful when it costs you. Holding firm under pressure is part of this story.
Feed your mind with Scripture and good books. Learning and the Scriptures matter in this life.
This ridiculous nonsense hardly deserves consideration. It goes without saying that it is completely unhistorical. The Acts of Saint Laurence are a poor and foolish story without even the merit of being interesting. It is likely that Cyrilla and Tryphonia are fictional characters. Certainly, Decius had no wife and daughter with those names. Their bodies were unearthed by Pope Paul I in the 8th century. They are now in the church of Saint Martin in Montibus.
Saint Firmilian, Bishop of Caesarea. (Greek Menologies and Martyrologies, African Martyrology, Martyrology of Jerome, Bede, Floras, Ado, Hrabanus; but omitted from the Modern Roman Martyrology by Baronius because of his letter to Pope Stephen.) Saint Firmilian was a native of Cappadocia, of noble birth, and a student of philosophy under Origen at Caesarea. Firmilian became bishop of Caesarea around 232. He encouraged Gregory, who later became Bishop of Neocaesarea and was commonly called Thaumaturgus, or the Wonderworker, to become a disciple of that remarkable teacher. Around 232, not long after Firmilian was made bishop, a synod was held at Tanium, where he was present, on the contentious issue of re-baptizing heretics.
The first synod of which we have any knowledge, held in the 3rd century, was one called by Agrippinus, bishop of Carthage, with the bishops of Africa and Numidia, in that city. Saint Cyprian mentions this synod in his 71st and 73rd letters, stating that the bishops present unanimously declared that baptism conferred by heretics was invalid. The date of this synod can be determined through the Philosophumena of Saint Hippolytus, which indicates it took place between 218 and 222. This work states that the practice of re-baptizing those who had received heretical baptism was introduced by Pope Saint Callixtus in several churches associated with him. The reference is likely to Agrippinus and his synod of Carthage; for Saint Augustine and Saint Vincent of Lerins explicitly state that Agrippinus was the first to introduce the practice of re-baptizing. Therefore, the synod of Carthage occurred during the reign of Callixtus I, between 218 and 222. This date aligns well with the fact that Tertullian was the first Christian writer to declare the baptism of heretics invalid; one may presume that his book “De Baptismo” influenced the conclusions of the Council of Carthage.
The great Origen led to the formation of two synods in Alexandria. Around 228, he was called to Achaia and traveled through Palestine, where he was ordained as a priest at Caesarea by his friend Alexander, who was the Bishop of Jerusalem, and Theoctistus, the Bishop of Caesarea. However, there were two objections against him receiving sacred orders from them: he belonged to another diocese, and he was a self-made eunuch. Demetrius, the bishop of Alexandria and Origen's diocesan bishop, was very unhappy about this decision. Upon Origen's return to Alexandria, Demetrius expressed his displeasure and reminded him of his mutilation. But Demetrius's main opposition to Origen was due to the doctrines found in his books, “De Principiis” and the “Stromata.”
Finding it impossible to stay in Alexandria under the bishop's disapproval, Origen left. In 231, Demetrius gathered a synod of Egyptian bishops and priests in Alexandria, which declared Origen unworthy to teach and expelled him from the church of Alexandria. Demetrius presided over a second synod in Alexandria, where Origen was stripped of his priestly status. An encyclical published by Demetrius announced these decisions to all the provinces. Around this time, likely in 232, a synod was held at Iconium, which, similar to the one in Carthage under Agrippinus, declared that every baptism performed by heretics was invalid.
The most detailed account we have of this council comes from a letter written by S. Firmilian to S. Cyprian of Carthage, which is preserved among Cyprian's letters. It states: “Some of the faithful raised doubts about the validity of baptisms given by heretics. We decided some time ago, in a council held at Iconium in Phrygia with the bishops of Galatia, Cilicia, and the neighboring provinces, that the ancient practice of considering baptisms administered by heretics as invalid should be upheld. At the end of the letter, we read: ‘Among us, as we have only recognized one Church, we have also acknowledged the one baptism of this Church. Some had doubts about the validity of the baptism given by those who accept new prophets (the Montanists), but who seem to worship the same Father and the same Son as we do. We gathered in large numbers at Iconium, examined the issue very carefully, and decided that every baptism outside the Church should be rejected.’” From a passage in the third chapter of S. Augustine’s third book against Cresconius, it appears that the Council of Iconium included fifty Eastern bishops.
When Origen left Alexandria, he moved to Caesarea in Cappadocia at the invitation of S. Firmilian. He was held in the highest regard by S. Firmilian, as well as by Alexander of Jerusalem and Theoctistus of Caesarea in Palestine, who viewed him as a teacher and eagerly listened to his interpretations of Scripture. In 235, the persecution under Maximinus began and continued until 238. A letter from S. Firmilian to S. Cyprian describes the suffering of the Church in Cappadocia and Pontus during this difficult time. There had been repeated earthquakes in Asia Minor, which were so severe that entire cities were destroyed and swallowed up. This led the people to turn against the Christians, blaming these disasters on the gods' anger because their worship had been abandoned for that of Christ. The Governor of Cappadocia, Serenianus, shared the common people's prejudices and persecuted the Church with relentless hostility.
Additionally, the believers were led astray by a woman who pretended to be a prophetess. She went into ecstatic trances and claimed to be inspired by the Divine Spirit. She misled one priest and a deacon, and many laypeople followed her. She even went so far as to baptize her followers and perform the Eucharist. Eventually, an exorcist confronted her, and his rituals and accusations of her being possessed by an unclean spirit frightened her so much that she eventually confessed to being influenced by diabolical inspiration.
We hear nothing more of S. Firmilian until the time of S. Cornelius, who became Bishop of Rome in 251 and was martyred the following year. Eusebius states that Dionysius of Alexandria wrote to Cornelius of Rome in response to a letter from him regarding Novatus (Novatian). In this response, Dionysius mentions that he had been invited by Helenus, Bishop of Tarsus in Cilicia, along with others including Firmilian, bishop in Cappadocia, and Theoctistus of Palestine, to meet at the Council of Antioch. There, certain individuals were attempting to promote the schism of Novatus (Novatian).
The issue of the baptism of heretics was brought up again in 255 when some African bishops believed that those joining the Church from heretical sects should not be rebaptized. Eighteen bishops from Numidia, who disagreed, asked the synod of Carthage to make a ruling on the matter. This synod was led by S. Cyprian and included thirty-one bishops. The 70th letter of S. Cyprian is essentially the response of the synod to the Numidian bishops' question. It informs them that their view on the baptism of heretics is entirely correct, stating that no one can be baptized outside the Church, as there is only one baptism, which is into the Church.
Soon after, however, in 256, a much larger council was held at Carthage on the same subject, attended by seventy-one bishops. The assembly wrote a letter addressed to Pope Stephen, stating that “he who abandoned a sect must be rebaptized.” They added that “it did not suffice to lay hands on such converts for the reception of the Holy Ghost if they did not also receive the baptism of the Church.” At the end of the letter, the synod expressed its hope that Stephen would agree with their decision. The letter added that too often, people do not want to renounce an opinion they have defended. More than one bishop, without breaking with his colleagues, will likely be tempted to continue in the custom he has embraced. The synod had no intention of forcing anyone or of prescribing a universal law, as every bishop can make his own decisions in the Church for which he must answer to God.
When the representatives of the Carthaginian synod arrived in Rome, Pope Stephen showed great anger at the decision. He refused even to see or listen to them, would not allow them to share in communion, forbade the faithful from welcoming them into their homes or offering them the usual hospitality, and did not hesitate to call S. Cyprian a false Christian, a false apostle, and a deceitful worker. Pope Stephen strongly stated his belief that the baptism of heretics was valid and opposed the practice of repeating the sacrament for those who had already received heretical baptism.
Upon receiving Stephen's letter, which contained this angry expression of opinion, S. Cyprian called a third council at Carthage. This council included eighty-seven bishops from proconsular Africa, Numidia, and Mauritania, along with many priests, deacons, and a large crowd of laypeople. The records of this synod still exist. It began on September 1, but the year is not specified; it was probably 256. The Bishop of Carthage required each bishop present to freely express his opinion on the baptism of heretics. He declared that no one should be judged or excommunicated for differing opinions. He added, with a barely concealed reference to Stephen of Rome, that no one in this assembly claims to be the bishop of bishops or dreams of forcing his colleagues to submit to him through tyrannical fear.
Then the bishops voted in hierarchical order, with Cyprian voting last, and all unanimously decided that baptism conferred by heretics was invalid. They agreed that for admission into the Church, those who had received heretical baptism must be rebaptized. Around this time, Cyprian sent his deacon Rogatian with a letter to Firmilian to inform him of the decision made in Africa on this issue. He also apparently shared with him the records and documents related to this matter.
Firmilian quickly expressed his complete agreement with Cyprian in a letter that still exists. This letter also contains an expression of his deep anger at the actions of Pope Stephen, who had threatened to excommunicate the Churches of Asia Minor if they followed the same practice.
Firmilian clearly states that Stephen separated himself from the other churches, rather than these churches separating from him. He calls the Pope a schismatic because he had withdrawn from the unity of the Church; and by allowing the baptism of heretics, he had shown himself to be worse than all heretics. He mentions that his righteous anger was stirred by the obvious foolishness of Stephen, who boasted about his episcopal rank and his succession from Saint Peter. Regarding this latter claim, he suggests that in Rome, actions are taken that have no tradition to support them, yet are presented as having apostolic authority.
The Church in Alexandria also seems to have sided with Cyprian rather than with the Bishop of Rome. Dionysius of Alexandria wrote to Stephen; although his letter is lost, he appears to have urged him to be moderate and informed him that the few decisions on record declared heretical baptisms to be invalid. His letter may have made some impact in Rome, as two of Stephen’s clergy wrote to consult him about the matter and received letters in response. This suggests that even in Rome, the Pope's actions were not seen as entirely satisfactory. The outbreak of the persecution under Valerian and the martyrdom of Stephen ended the dispute. Once the turmoil had passed, Dionysius of Alexandria wrote: “All the Churches throughout the East, and beyond, that were previously divided have been united again. All the bishops are now in harmony everywhere, rejoicing greatly at the peace that has been established beyond expectation. These include Demetrianus of Antioch, Theoctistus of Caesarea, Mazabanes of Elia, Marinus of Tyre, Heliodorus of Laodicea, and Helenus of...”
Those who are in Rome do not observe all the traditions that have been handed down from the beginning, and they pretend in vain to uphold the authority of the apostles.
The restoration of peace after persecution quickly brought a renewal of troubles within the Church. Paul, a native of Samosata, was at that time the Bishop of Antioch, having succeeded Demetrianus in 260. If we can believe the account given by the bishops who were his contemporaries, he was greedy and dishonest in accumulating wealth, and his moral conduct was believed to be questionable. However, what was more serious and dangerous was the fact that Paul taught doctrines about the nature of our Blessed Lord that strongly resembled heresy.
Sabellius had tried to support the idea of the unity of the Godhead in the doctrine of the Trinity by downplaying the differences between the Persons and instead presenting three modes of operation and manifestations of the activity of the One God. Paul of Samosata took an opposite approach. He separated the Persons, particularly the Father from the Son, by a significant divide. He, like Sabellius, confused the Persons, as he viewed the Logos as an emanation from God rather than as a distinct Personality. He acknowledged that Jesus was miraculously born of a Virgin, but he did not believe that He was God incarnate; he taught that Jesus was an exceptionally distinguished man, filled with the Logos, the Spirit of God, which sanctified Him and made Him worthy to bear the divine Name. He also claimed that, since the Logos is not a person, the Holy Spirit is merely an impersonal divine quality belonging to the Father, distinguishable from Him only in an intellectual sense. His impiety became increasingly extreme as his views faced opposition and condemnation, leading him to forbid the singing of hymns in honor of Jesus Christ.
That a bishop of such an important see as Antioch should be accused of heresy was a new occurrence in the history of the Church. The matter required a serious investigation. A council was convened to meet at Antioch and hear Paul’s explanations. In 264 or 265, a large number of bishops from Asia gathered, notably S. Firmilian of Caesarea in Cappadocia, S. Gregory the Wonder-worker and his brother Athenodorus of Pontus, Archbishop Helenus of Tarsus, Nicomas of Iconium, Hymenaeus of Jerusalem, Theotecnus of Caesarea in Palestine, and many other bishops, priests, and deacons. Dionysius the Great of Alexandria had been invited, but his age and illness prevented him from attending, and he died shortly afterward. However, he sent a letter to Paul of Samosata condemning his errors, just as he had previously condemned those of Sabellius.
The council treated the Bishop of Antioch with great care and showed a sincere desire not to take harsh actions, but to exercise love and patience. Paul skillfully wrapped his teachings in complex Platonic language, which confused the bishops and led them to think that his beliefs had been misrepresented or exaggerated in the reports they received. He completely denied the beliefs that had been attributed to him. The council concluded, thanking God that harmony was restored and a scandal was avoided. However, they soon had to gather again in Antioch. Firmilian seems to have led the first council, and he certainly presided over the second one. The exact date of this second synod is not known. It explicitly condemned Paul's teachings, who promised to abandon his errors; deceived by his promises, Firmilian and the other bishops left, allowing him to remain in his position.
But Paul did not keep his promise and did not retract his errors; soon rumors spread that he was teaching them with renewed vigor. The bishops, however, did not want to immediately cut him off from the Church's communion; they patiently tried again to bring him back to the right path and sent him a letter for this purpose. It was only when this attempt failed that a third council was called to meet in Antioch at the end of the year 269.
Firmilian set out from Caesarea to attend it, but he died in Tarsus on his way due to extreme old age. Baronius, disapproving of the tone and content of his letter to Stephen of Rome, removed his name from the Sacred Calendar of the West.
This ridiculous nonsense hardly deserves consideration. It is needless to say that it is utterly unhistorical. The Acts of S. Laurence are a poor and foolish romance without the 1 Roma, sotterranea, t. i. p. 144.
merit even of being interesting. Probably Cyrilla and Tryphonia are the creations of imagination. Certainly Decius [Roman emperor 249–251, who ordered everyone to sacrifice to the gods] had no wife and daughter of those names. Their bodies were dug up by Pope Paul I., in the 8th century. They are now in the church of S. Martin [St. Martin of Tours (d. 397), soldier turned bishop] in Montibus.
S. FIRMILIAN, B. OF CiESAREA. [Greek Menseas and Menologies, African Martyrology, Martyrology of Jerome, Bede [English monk and historian (d. 735)], Floras, Ado, Hrabanus; but omitted from the Modern Roman Martyrology by Baronius [Cardinal Baronius (d. 1607), church historian who edited the Roman Martyrology] because of his letter to Pope Stephen.] S. Firmilian was a native of Cappadocia [a region of central Turkey], of noble birth, and a student of philosophy under Origen at Caesarea.1 Firmilian became bishop of Caesarea about 232. He induced Gregory, afterwards Bishop of Neocaesarea, commonly called Thaumaturgus, or the Wonderworker, to become a disciple of that remarkable teacher. About 232, not long after Firmilian was made bishop, a synod was held at Tanium, at which he was present, on the vexed question of the re-baptizing of heretics.
The first synod of whicli we know anything, held in the 3rd century, was one convoked by Agrippinus, bishop of Carthage, of the bishops of Africa and Numidia, at that city. S. Cyprian speaks of this synod in his 71st and 73rd letters, saying therein that the bishops present had unanimously declared void baptism conferred by heretics. The date when this synod took place can be fixed by means of the Philosophumena of S. Hippolytus as taking place between 218 and 222. This work relates that the practice of re-baptizing those who had received heretical baptism was 1 S. Gregor. Nyss. op., Migne Patr. Grsec. t. xlvi. coL 906. •S'. Firmilian.
introduced by Pope S. Callixtus in several churches in relation with him. The reference is doubtless to Agrippinus and his synod of Carthage; for S. Augustine and S. Vincent of Lerins expressly state that Agrippinus was the first to introduce the practice of re-baptizing. The synod of Carthage therefore took place in the reign of Callixtus I., between 218 and 222. This date agrees well with the fact that Tertullian was the first Christian writer to declare invalid the baptism of heretics; and one may presume that his book “ De Baptismo ” exercised some influence on the conclusions of the Council of Carthage.
The great Origen gave rise to two synods at Alexandria. Having been called about 228 into Achaia, Origen passed through Palestine, and was ordained priest at Caesarea by his friend Alexander, Bishop of Jerusalem, and Theoctistus, Bishop of Caesarea, although two objections stood against his receiving sacred orders from them— he belonged to another diocese, and he was a self-made eunuch. Demetrius of Alexandria, the diocesan bishop of Origen, was highly dissatisfied at this step, and on the return of Origen to Alexandria expressed his displeasure, and recalled to him the fact of his mutilation.1 But his chief opposition to Origen was on account of the doctrines contained in his books, “De Principiis” and the “Stromata.” Origen finding it impossible to remain at Alexandria subject to the displeasure of the bishop, departed. Demetrius gathered a synod of Egyptian bishops and priests of Alexandria in 231, which declared Origen unworthy to teach, and excluded him from the church of Alexandria. Demetrius presided at a second synod at Alexandria in which Origen was declared deprived of his sacerdotal dignity; and an encyclical published by Demetrius announced these resolutions to all the provinces. About this time, probably in 232, a synod was held at Iconium, which, like that of Carthage under Agrippinus, declared invalid every baptism administered by heretics. The fullest account we have of this council is given in a letter addressed by S. Firmilian to S. Cyprian of Carthage, and which is preserved among the letters of the latter. It says: “Some of the faithful having raised doubts relative to the validity of baptism conferred by heretics, we decided, some time ago, in a council held at Iconium in Phrygia with the bishops of Galatia, Cilicia, and the neighbouring provinces, that the ancient practice (of holding invalid baptism administered by heretics) should be maintained and supported.0 At the end of the letter we read * “ Amongst us, as we have only recognized one Church, so have we only acknowledged the one baptism of this Church. Some having had doubts on the validity of the baptism conferred by those who admit new prophets (the Montanists), but who seem to adore the same Father and the same Son as we, we met in great numbers at Iconium; we examined the question very carefully, and we decided that every baptism outside the Church ought to be rejected.” From a passage in the third chapter of S. Augustine’s third book against Cresconius, it would seem that the Council of Iconium consisted of fifty Eastern prelates.
When Origen left Alexandria, at the invitation of S. Firmilian he took up his abode at Caesarea in Cappadocia. He held him in the greatest honour, as did also Alexander of Jerusalem and Theoctistus of Caesarea in Palestine, who regarded him as a master, and listened to his interpretation of Scripture with enthusiasm. In 235 the persecution ol Maximinus broke out, and lasted till 238. A letter of S. Firmilian to S. Cyprian gives an account of the distress of the Church in Cappadocia and Pontus [a region on the Black Sea coast of Turkey] during this trying season. There had been repeated earthquakes in Asia Oct. a&] Firmilian. 689 Minor, he says, so serious that whole cities had been ruined and engulfed. This excited the people against the Christians, who attributed these disasters to the anger of the gods because their worship was deserted for that of Christ. The Governor of Cappadocia, Serenianus, shared the prejudices of the common people, and persecuted the Church with relentless animosity. Nor was this all. The believers were seduced by a woman who feigned herself to be a prophetess, went into raptures, and professed herself inspired by the Divine Spirit. She drew away one priest and a deacon, and great numbers of the laity; and carried her infatuation to the extent of baptizing her disciples and consecrating the Eucharist. At last an exorcist opposed her, and his ceremonial rites and denunciations of the unclean spirit, which he was determined to believe possessed her, so scared the woman, that in a revulsion of feeling she confessed she was the agent of diabolical inspiration.
We hear nothing more of S. Firmilian till the time oi S. Cornelius, created Bishop of Rome in 251, who suffered martyrdom in the following year. Eusebius [Eusebius of Caesarea (d. c. 339), the first historian of the Church] says that Dionysius of Alexandria “ wrote to Cornelius of Rome in answer to an epistle from him against Novatus (Novatian); in which answer he shows that he had been invited by Helenus, Bishop of Tarsus in Cilicia, and the rest that were collected with him, viz., Firmilian, bishop in Cappadocia, and Theoctistus of Palestine, that he should meet them at the Council of Antioch, where certain persons were trying to establish the schism of Novatus (Novatian).” 1 The question of the baptism of heretics was again revived in 255, when, some African bishops being of opinion that those who joined the Church from heretical sects should not be rebaptized, eighteen Numidian bishops who were of a different opinion asked the synod of Carthage to give a decision on iji if t the question. This synod was presided over by S. Cyprian, and was composed of thirty-one bishops. The 70th letter of S. Cyprian is, in fact, the reply of the synod to the question of the Numidian bishops. It informs them that “ their opinion on the baptism of heretics is perfectly just; that no one can be baptized outside the Church, as there is but one baptism, and that is into the Church.”
Soon after, however, in 256, a far larger council was held at Carthage on the same subject, attended by seventy-one bishops. A synodal letter was written by the assembly, addressed to Pope Stephen, in which it was laid down that “ he who abandoned a sect must be rebaptized, ” and adding that “ it did not suffice to lay hands on such converts for the reception of the Holy Ghost, if they did not also receive the baptism of the Church.” At the close of the letter the synod expresses its hope that Stephen will assent to their decision; too often, the letter adds, one does not like to renounce an opinion one has defended, and more than one bishop, without breaking with his colleagues, will be tempted, no doubt, to persevere in the custom he has embraced; the synod has no intention of doing violence to anyone, or of prescribing a universal law, as every bishop can make his own will prevail in the Church for which he must render an account to God.
When the legates of the Carthaginian synod came to Rome, Pope Stephen showed great indignation at the decision; he refused even to see and listen to them, would not admit them to communion, forbade the faithful from receiving them into their houses and showing them the ordinary rites of hospitality, and did not hesitate to call S. Cyprian a false Christian, a false apostle, a deceitful worker. Pope Stephen emphatically pronounced his opinion that the baptism of heretics was valid, and against the practice of reiterating the sacrament on those who had already received heretical S. Firmilian.
baptism. On receiving the letter of Stephen containing this violent expression of anger and opinion, S. Cyprian summoned a third council at Carthage. It was composed of eighty-seven bishops of proconsular Africa, Numidia, and Mauritania, of many priests and deacons, and a crowd of laity. The acts of this synod exist. It opened on September 1, but the year is not indicated; it was probably 256. The Bishop of Carthage required each bishop present to express freely his opinion on the baptism of heretics; he declared that no person should be judged or excommunicated for differences of opinion; for, added he, with scarce veiled reference to Stephen of Rome, no one in this assembly gives himself out to be episcopus episcoporum, or dreams of constraining his colleagues to yield to him by inspiring them with tyrannical fear.
Thereupon the bishops gave their votes in hierarchical order, Cyprian last, and all with one consent decided that baptism conferred by heretics was invalid, and that for admission into the Church those who had received heretical baptism must submit to be rebaptized. About this time Cyprian sent his deacon Rogatian with a letter to Firmilian, to inform him of the decision come to in Africa on this question. He communicated to him at the same time, apparently, the acts and documents relating to this affair.
Firmilian hastened to express his full agreement with Cyprian in a letter which still exists. This letter, moreover, contains an expression of his unbounded indignation at the conduct of Pope Stephen, who had threatened to excommunicate the Churches of Asia Minor if they adopted the same practice.
Firmilian says plainly that Stephen separated himself from the other churches, and not these churches from him. He calls the Pope a schismatic, inasmuch as he had withdrawn from the unity of the Church;l and by allowing the baptism of heretics, he had shown himself to be worse than all heretics.3 He speaks of his just indignation being excited by the plain and palpable folly of Stephen, who boasted of his episcopal rank and succession from S. Peter:3 as for this latter pretension, he intimates that at Rome things are done which have no tradition to support them, and are yet given out as reposing on apostolic authority.4 The Alexandrian Church appears also to have agreed with Cyprian rather than with the Bishop of Rome. Dionysius of Alexandria wrote to Stephen; and though his letter is lost, he seems to have exhorted him to moderation, and to have told him that the few decisions which were on record pronounced heretical baptisms to be invalid. His letter, perhaps, produced some impression at Rome, for two of Stephen’s clergy wrote to consult him upon the subject, and received letters in reply; from which we may infer that even at Rome the conduct of the Pope was not considered quite satisfactory. The breaking out of the persecution of Valerian [Roman emperor 253–260, who persecuted bishops and clergy] and the martyrdom of Stephen put an end to the contest. When the storm was passed, Dionysius of Alexandria wrote: “ All the Churches throughout the East, and farther, that were formerly divided, have been united again. All the bishops, also, are everywhere in harmony, rejoicing exceedingly at the peace which has been established beyond expectation. These are Demetrianus of Antioch, Theoctistus of Caesarea, Mazabanes of^Elia, Marinus of Tyre, Heliodorus of Laodicea, Helenus of 1 “ Peccatum quam magnum tibi exaggerasti, quando te a tot gregibus scidisti ? Excidisti enim te ipsum, noli te fallere. Si quidem ille est vere schismaticus, qui se a communione ecclesiasticac unitatis apostatam fecerit. Dum enim putas omnes a te abstineri posse, solum te ab omnibus abstinuisti.” 3 “ Quin immo tu hacreticis omnibus pejor es." 3 “ Atque ego in hac parte juste indignor ad hanc tam apertam et manifestam Stephani stultitiam, quod qui sic de episcopatus sui loco gloriatur, et de successione Petri tenere contendit.”
4 “ Eos autem qui Rom* sunt non ea in omnibus observare qu* sint ab origine tradita. et frustra apostolorum auctoritatem p rw tend ere. M ifc — I Tarsus, and all the Churches of Cilicia, Firrailian, and all Cappadocia; for I have mentioned only the more distinguished of the bishops by name.”1 [ The restoration of peace after persecution brought speedily j a renewal of troubles within. * Paul, a native of Samosata, was at this time Bishop of \ Antioch, having succeeded Demetrianus in 260. If we may [ believe the account which was given of him by the bishops j his contemporaries, he was rapacious and fraudulent in j amassing wealth, and his moral conduct was believed to be not free from suspicion. But what was as serious and more dangerous, was the fact that Paul taught doctrines concerning the nature of our Blessed Lord which savoured strongly of heresy.
Sabellius had sought to fortify the idea of the unity of the Godhead in the doctrine of the Trinity by suppressing the difference of Persons, and admitting in place of Persons three modes of operation and manifestations of the activity of the One God. Paul of Samosata took an opposite line. He separated the Persons, especially the Father from the Son, by a chasm. He, like Sabellius, confounded the Persons, for he regarded the Logos as an emanation from God, not as a Personality. He admitted that Jesus was miraculously born of a Virgin, but not that He was incarnate God; he taught that He was a supereminently distinguished man, penetrated by the Logos, the Spirit of God, which sanctified Him, and made Him even worthy to bear the divine Name. He added that, as the Logos is not a person, so the Holy Spirit is only an impersonal divine virtue belonging to the Father, and only intellectually distinguishable from Him. His impiety became most extravagant as his views met with opposition and condemnation, for he forbade the singing of hymns in honour of Jesus Christ.
VOL. XII. 22 That the bishop of so great a see as Antioch should be accused of heresy was a new event ip the annals of the Church, The matter demanded investigation of the most solemn description. A council was summoned to meet at Antioch, and hear the explanations of Paul. In 264 or 265 a large number of the bishops of Asia, notably S. Firmilian of Caesarea in Cappadocia, S. Gregory the Wonder-worker and his brother Athenodorus of Pontus, Archbishop Helenus of Tarsus, Nicomas of Iconium, Hymenaeus of Jerusalem, Theotecnus of Caesarea in Palestine,1 and many other bishops, priests, and deacons assembled at Antioch. Dionysius the Great of Alexandria had been invited, but his age and infirmity prevented him from attending, and he died shortly after. He, however, addressed a letter to Paul of Samosata condemnatory of his errors, as he had formerly condemned those of Sabellius.
The council dealt most tenderly with the Bishop of Antioch, and showed an earnest desire not to proceed to extremities, but to forbear in love. Paul skilfully enveloped his doctrine in a cloud of Platonic expressions, which bewildered the bishops, and led them to believe that his doctrine had been misstated or exaggerated in the form in which it had been reported to them. He entirely disclaimed those tenets which had been imputed to him. The council separated, thanking God that concord was re-established and a scandal averted. But before long they were again obliged to assemble at Antioch. Firmilian appears to have presided at the former council, he certainly did so at the second. The date of this second synod is not known. It condemned explicitly the doctrine of Paul, who promised to renounce his errors; and deceived by his promises, Firmilian and the other bishops withdrew, leaving him still in possession of the see.
teenus ui 26a S. Malchion. 695 But Paul did not fulfil his engagement and retract his errors; for soon the rumour spread that he was teaching them with renewed energy. The bishops, however, did not wish immediately to cut him off from the communion of the Church; they sought again with patience and forbearance to draw him back to the right way, and for this purpose addressed him a letter. It was only when this tentative failed that a third council was convoked to assemble at Antioch at the close of the year 269.
S. Firmilian started from Caesarea to attend it, but died at Tarsus, on his way, of extreme old age. Baronius, disliking the tenour and temper of his letter to Stephen of Rome, cut his name out of the Sacred Kalendar of the West.
Feast: October 28
One short email a day for nine days. The day's prayer, a line from St. Cyrilla's story, and a nudge to keep going.
Retold in plain modern English from Baring-Gould’s public-domain text, sentence by sentence, keeping the same facts and order. Short explanations in parentheses are ours.
From Sabine Baring-Gould, The Lives of the Saints, new edition in 16 vols. (London: John C. Nimmo, 1897–98); text from the Internet Archive scan (OCR, lightly cleaned; errors possible). Public domain in the United States. Reproduced unedited, except for short bracketed notes in grey that we added to explain names and terms (“S.” is the old abbreviation for Saint). Some history and judgments reflect 19th-century scholarship.