This Saint’s Story
He is not a later namesake pope. The Catholic Encyclopedia says it is generally believed he had been a Benedictine (monks following the Rule of St. Benedict) monk at St Hermes in Palermo; Baring-Gould adds that he spent several years as treasurer of the Roman Church. There is good authority that he was more than a hundred years old when he became pope as successor to Donus—the Encyclopedia places the accession in 678; Baring-Gould, following Anastasius, in 679. Contemporaries and later writers mark his charity, gentleness, and affability.
Soon after his election St Wilfrid, archbishop of York, unjustly and uncanonically deposed by Theodore of Canterbury, came to Rome to appeal. Agatho held a Lateran synod that investigated the case and restored Wilfrid to his see. The chief event of the reign was the Sixth Ecumenical Council, the third of Constantinople, in 680, against the Monothelite (the claim that Christ had only a divine will, not also a human one) teaching. Papal legates presided. Baring-Gould stresses Agatho’s learned letter to the emperor Constantine Pogonatus, which appealed to Rome’s constant tradition as mother and mistress of the churches from Peter, to whom Christ committed His flock with the promise that his faith should never fail. On 25 February the council condemned Macarius, author of that teaching, removed the stoles of Macarius and of Basil of Crete, and cast their thrones from the hall; before the decrees reached Rome for papal approval, Agatho had died.
He was buried in St Peter’s on 10 January 681; this page keeps that feast. Tradition holds that he wrought many miracles and was styled Thaumaturgus, or Wonderworker. Both the Latin and the Greek churches honour him; the Greeks keep his memory on 21 February. No patronage is clearly assigned to him in the Catholic Encyclopedia.