This Saint’s Story
Eugenio Pacelli was born in Rome on March 2, 1876, into a family that had long served the Holy See (the pope and the Vatican's central offices). He was ordained in 1899, served as nuncio in Bavaria and then in Germany, and in 1930 became Cardinal Secretary of State. In that office, in 1933, he signed the Reichskonkordat, a treaty with Nazi Germany on the legal place of the church. He was elected pope on March 2, 1939, his sixty-third birthday, and took the name Pius XII. His pontificate lasted until his death on October 9, 1958, and it ran through the Second World War and the murder of the Jews of Europe.
During the war the Holy See said it was officially neutral. Pius issued encyclicals, including Summi Pontificatus at the outbreak of the war, and he gave radio addresses at Christmas. Critics say his public words about the killing of the Jews were too few and too general, and that a clearer protest might have saved lives. Defenders say he worked through diplomats and through religious houses to hide people, and that a louder public denunciation would have made the killing worse, in Rome and beyond. Both sides argue from documents. The Vatican archives for this pontificate were opened to researchers in 2020, and the work of reading them is still going on.
He died at Castel Gandolfo on October 9, 1958. Benedict XVI declared him Venerable on December 19, 2009. That title means the church has judged that he lived a life of heroic virtue, and that a cause for sainthood may go forward. It is not a verdict on every public decision of the war, and it is not beatification, and it is not canonization. Some lists keep October 9 as a commemorative date. It is not a general-calendar feast of a saint, because he is not a saint.
For today: When a history is still argued, you can learn the dates and the documents before you pick a slogan. You can read one serious critic and one serious defender, and you can say which claim comes from which side. You can also refuse to treat a church title as if it settled a historical quarrel it was not meant to settle.

