This Saint’s Story
The early record says that a Christian named Valentine was buried on the Via Flaminia, north of Rome, and that by the eighth century the West was keeping his feast on that day. Accounts differ on whether he was a priest in Rome or a bishop of Terni, some sixty miles up the same road, or whether two men have been folded into one name. The honest answer is that we do not know. Terni and Rome have both claimed him. Relics from the cemetery of San Valentino in Rome were later moved to the church of Santa Prassede.
Later "acts" give him a trial before a judge, a healing, and a conversion. Those acts are late, and they should be read as legend around a real feast and a real grave. A still later story, popular in modern times, says he secretly married Christian couples when a Roman emperor had forbidden soldiers to marry. That story is not in the early notices. It should not be told as if it were.
From the later Middle Ages, February 14 gathered poems about love. Chaucer is often cited at the beginning of that custom. The modern valentine card is a nineteenth-century growth from the same date. It is a custom of the day. It is not a story the early church told about the martyr on the Via Flaminia. You can keep both facts at once: a man was killed for the faith, and, many centuries later, people began to send letters of love on his feast. The Eastern churches commemorate a Valentine on July 6.
For today: You can send a note of love on February 14 and still tell the truth about the saint. The early fact is a martyr buried on the Via Flaminia. The cards came later. If you write to someone, you can write plainly, and you can remember that the day first belonged to a man who paid with his life.

