Z

Zephyrinus, birth date unknown, was elected bishop of Rome after Pope Victor in 198 and died on 20 December 217.

Read the essentials →
Feast August 26 · —

St. Zephyrinus, Pope

Current feast

August 26 (also listed: December 20)
Secondary source · Wikipedia infobox

Traditional feast

August 26
1914 / pre-1969 calendar, per Baring-Gould (1897)

Represents

Feast

Feast days

Feast: August 26

This Saint’s Story

Hippolytus called him a simple man without education; the Catholic Encyclopedia takes this to mean he had skipped the higher studies and gave himself to practical administration rather than theological learning. He soon recalled the confessor Callistus from Antium—where Victor had paid him a monthly pension—and set him over the community cemetery on the Via Appia, later called the cemetery of Callistus. Callistus became a deacon and the pope’s confidential counsellor, and afterward his successor.

About 202 or 203 an imperial edict forbade conversion under the severest penalties; nothing certain is known of its execution in Rome. Inside the Church, Trinity disputes marked the reign. Followers of Theodotus the Tanner, already cut off by Victor, formed a separate community and induced the confessor Natalis to serve as their bishop for pay until visions, the church historian of Caesarea records, drove him to beg reconciliation at Zephyrinus’s feet. Montanist teachers were also active. Hippolytus taught that the Divine Logos became man in Christ and differs in everything from God; Cleomenes and Sabellius opposed that school, stressing the absolute unity of God and treating the Incarnation as another mode of the Father—hence Modalists or Patripassians.

Zephyrinus did not take a sharp side. He said he acknowledged only one God, the Lord Jesus Christ, yet it was the Son, not the Father, Who had died—the Church’s tradition. Hippolytus pressed for a dogma condemning the Monarchians; when the pope refused, he turned his anger on Zephyrinus and especially on Callistus. After Callistus’s election Hippolytus withdrew, caused a schism, and made himself a rival bishop. Baring-Gould, following the same hostile portrait, stresses vacillation and even charges of avarice that the Encyclopedia treats as probably unjust, and notes there is no evidence Zephyrinus was a martyr. Two decrees on ordination and the liturgy later ascribed to him rest on no historical basis. He was buried over the cemetery of Callistus. This page keeps his feast on 26 August; older lists mark 20 December. No patronage is clearly assigned to him in the Catholic Encyclopedia.

What he represents

How he teaches us to live

Drawn from themes in the original account

Be a peacemaker. Making peace is part of this story.

Celebrate this saint’s feast day. Remember him on August 26 with a short prayer, and ask for his help.

The full story

Baring-Gould’s account retold in modern English

Read the full story · 616 words · about 3 min

The strict asceticism and stern puritanism of the Montanists attracted the admiration of Pope Victor. He recognized the inspiration of their prophets and issued letters of peace in their favor. However, at the urging of Praxeas, a fierce opponent of Montanism who had recently come from Asia Minor, Victor was told that his actions were contrary to those of his predecessors, Anicetus and Soter. Praxeas also provided an unfavorable report about the Montanist community in Asia Minor. As a result, Victor revoked his letters, denied their spiritual gifts, and expelled the prophets from Rome in disgrace. Praxeas gradually gained significant influence over the Pope's thoughts and, if we can believe Tertullian, introduced his unique Patripassian views into Victor's mind. However, an accusation made by Tertullian, stemming from his disappointment over the failure to gain papal approval for his favored doctrine, is unlikely to be true.

Monarchianism, which was derogatorily labeled Patripassianism, became the central controversy during the papacies of Victor, Zephyrinus, and Callixtus. Theodotus, a leather worker from Byzantium, was the nominal founder of Monarchianism, but it was essentially a long-hidden form of Ebionism that expressed itself emphatically in the assertion of Monotheism against Trinitarianism. The Monarchians could not accept the concept of a triple personality; they believed that the titles of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit referred to different aspects of the one Divinity. God revealed Himself to the Jews as the Father, to humanity as the Son, and breathed in the Church as the Holy Spirit. There were many variations of Monarchianism as people tried to reconcile the idea of the Trinity with the unity of the Godhead without acknowledging the individual personalities of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.

Zephyrinus, whom the author of the “Refutation of all Heresies” describes as an uneducated man who did not understand the language and definitions of the Church, wavered during his long papacy in a state of dreamy uncertainty regarding the points of contention. Hippolytus—if he was indeed the author of the “Refutation”—claims that Zephyrinus was greedy, corrupt, or had unstable principles. He did not maintain a balance between conflicting opinions but instead embraced opposing views along with Zephyrinus.

all the enthusiasm that a rough, uneducated, and also uncertain mind could muster. He was now a disciple of Cleomenes, who succeeded Noetus and taught Noetianism in Rome, holding extreme Patripassian views. He was also influenced by Sabellius, who had become bold and developed his scheme, which was detested by both opposing factions. Zephyrinus was completely controlled by the runaway slave and escaped convict, Callixtus. As a result, he was constantly pushed back, either by his fears or confusion, to opposing beliefs, leading him into the most obvious contradictions. At one point, he publicly stated the shocking words, “I acknowledge one God, Jesus Christ, and none beside Him, who was born and suffered,” and at another time he contradicted himself by saying, “It was not the Father that died, but the Son.”

We will likely come to a clearer understanding of Zephyrinus's character and abilities if we accept, as the author of the “Refutation” suggests, that he was an uneducated man with no firm opinions, no theological or philosophical training, and no natural ability to understand complex theological issues. Despite this, he wanted to believe what was orthodox, and his thoughts were influenced by various advisors in different and conflicting directions. The author of the “Refutation of all Heresies” led the orthodox faction in Rome, and in his frustration and disappointment with the Pope's indecisiveness, he used stronger language to describe his character than was warranted. The claims that Zephyrinus was greedy and corrupt are likely unfair accusations.

There is no evidence that Zephyrinus was a martyr.

Footnotes

  1. Tertullian, our authority, does not name the Pope.
  2. Neither thinks it was Eleutherius, but the opinion generally admitted and least encumbered with difficulties is that the Pope alluded to was Victor.

Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.

Read the original 1870s text

Baring-Gould’s sources: Roman Martyrology, Martyrologium parvum, Usuardus, Ado, the Martyrology of Bede on December 20, on the same day that of S. Jerome, Hrabanus, and Wandelbert. Authorities: — The ancient catalogue of Roman Pontiffs, Eusebius, and the lately discovered "Refutations of Heresies," attributed to S. Hippolytus.] F Zephyrinus, who became Pope in a.d. 202, we have adverse accounts — that of Eusebius, and that contained in the “ Refutations of all Heresies,” attributed to S. Hippolytus, of Porto, and if not by him, by a bishop of the same period of one of the suburban dioceses.

The asceticism, the stern puritanism of the Montanists, attracted the admiration of Pope Victor.1 He acknowledged the inspiration of their prophets, and issued letters of peace in their favour. But at the instigation of Praxeas, a violent opponent of Montanism, lately come from Asia Minor, who represented to him that his conduct was the reverse of that of Anicetus and Soter his predecessors, and who gave him 1 Tertullian, our authority, does not name the Pope. Neatider thinks it was Eleutherius, but the opinion generally admitted and least encumbered with difficulties is that the Pope alluded to was Victor.

an unfavourable report of the Montanist community in Asia Minor, Victor revoked his letters, denied their spiritual gifts, and drove the prophets in disgrace from Rome. Praxeas gradually acquired a predominant influence over the mind of the Pope, and, if we may trust Tertullian, infused into his mind his peculiar Patripassian opinions. But an accusation made by Tertullian under the excitement of disappointment at the failure of the attempt to obtain papal sanction of his cherished doctrine, is not likely to be true.

Monarchianism, or, as it was offensively branded, Patripassianism, became the controversy which raged during the episcopate of Victor, Zephyrinus, and Callixtus. Theodotus, a leather dresser of Byzantium, was the nominal founder of Monarchianism, actually it was long latent Ebionism taking emphatic expression in the assertion of Monotheism against Trinitarianism. The Monarchians could not admit the triple personality; the designation of Father, and Son, and Holy Ghost belonged to aspects of the one Divinity. God revealed Himself to the Jews as the Father, in humanity as the Son to the world, breathed in the Church as the Holy Spirit. There were many shades of Monarchianism, as men endeavoured to reconcile the idea of the Trinity with that of the unity of the Godhead, without admitting the individual personality of the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost.

Zephyrinus, whom the author of the “ Refutation of all Heresies’' represents as an unlearned man, ignorant of the language and definitions of the Church, through his long pontificate wavered to and fro, in dreamy uncertainty about the points of contest. Hippolytus — if he were the author of the “ Refutation "—says he was avaricious, venal, of unsettled principles: not holding the balance between conflicting opinions, but embracing adverse tenets with S. Zephyrinus.

all the zeal of which a rude, untaught, and withal an irresolute mind was capable. He was now a disciple of Cleomenes, the successor of Noetus, and teacher of Noetianism in Rome, holding extreme Patripassian views; now of Sabellius, who, become bold, had matured his scheme, which was odious to both contending parties alike. Zephyrinus was entirely governed by the runaway slave and escaped convict, Callixtus; and thus constantly driven back, by his fears or confusion of mind, to opposite tenets, and involved in the most glaring contradictions. At one time he publicly used the startling words, “ I acknowledge one God, Jesus Christ, and none beside Him, that was born and suffered and at another he refuted himself, “ It was not the Father that died, but the Son.”

We shall probably arrive at the truth in estimating the character and capacities of Zephyrinus, if we admit with the author of the “ Refutation ” that he was an ill-educated man, of no fixed opinions, no theological or philosophical training, nor natural capability of grasping abstruse questions in theology. With all this he had the wish to believe what was orthodox, and his mind was swayed by various advisers in different and adverse directions. The author of the “Refutation of all Heresies” headed the orthodox party in Rome, and in his irritation and disappointment at the vacillation of the Pope, used stronger language in particularizing his character than he was justified in doing. That Zephyrinus was avaricious and venal, are probably unjust charges.

There is no evidence that Zephyrinus was a martyr.

From the Catholic Encyclopedia

1913 · 1059 words

Date of birth unknown; died 20 Dec., 217. After the death of Pope Victor in 198, Zephyrinus was elected his successor and consecrated. The pope is described by Hippolytus in the "Philosophymena" (IX, xi) as a simple man without education. This is evidently to be understood as meaning that Zephyrinus had not taken the higher studies and had devoted himself to the practical administration of the Church and not to theological learning. Immediately after his elevation to the Roman See, Zephyrinus called to Rome the confessor [in old usage, a saint who was not martyred, or who suffered for the faith without being killed] Callistus, who lived at Antium and who had received a monthly pension from Pope Victor, and intrusted him with the oversight of the coemeterium. It is evident that shortly before this the Roman Christian community had, under Victor, become the owner of a common place of burial on the Via Appia, and Zephyrinus now placed Callistus over this cemetery which was given the name of Callistus. Undoubtedly Callistus was also made a deacon of the Roman Church by Zephyrinus. He was the confidential counsellor of the pope, whom he succeeded. The positions of the Christians, which had remained favourable in the first years of the government of Emperor Septimus Severus (193-211), grew constantly worse, and in 202 or 203 the edict of persecution appeared which forbade conversion to Christianity under the severest penalties. Nothing is known as to the execution of the edict in Rome itself nor of the martyrs of the Roman Church in this era.

More, however, is certain concerning the internal disputes in the Roman Church over the doctrine of the Trinity. The adherents of the heretical teacher Theodotus the Tanner had been excommunicated with their leader by Pope Victor. They formed an independent heretical community at Rome which was ruled by another Theodotus, the Money Changer, and Aselepodotus. These men persuaded a confessor of Rome named Natalis, who had acknowledged his faith without wavering before the heathen judge and had suffered torture, to permit himself to be made the bishop of the sect for a monthly payment of 170 denarii. Natalis, however, received many warnings in dreams. At first he paid no attention to these visions, but on one occasion he believed that he had been severely tortured by angels and now he began to ponder the matter. Early in the morning he put on a penitential garment, covered himself with ashes, and threw himself with tears at the feet of Zephyrinus. He confessed his wrong-doing and begged to be received again into the communion of the Church, which was finally granted him (Eusebius, "Hist. eccl.", V, xxxii). In the same era the adherents of Montanus also worked with great energy at Rome. The Montanist Proculus (or Proclus) published a work in defense of the new prophecies. A refutation of Proclus in the form of a dialogue was written by a learned and rigidly orthodox Roman Christian named Caius, wherein he refers to the grave of St. Peter on the Vatican Hill and of St. Paul on the Via Ostiensis. Caius rejects the Apocalypse of St. John, which he regards as a work of the heretic Cerinthus. In opposition to Caius, Hippolytus wrote his "Capita contra Caium" (cf. Eusebius, "Hist. eccl.", III, xxviii; VI, xx).

Hippolytus was the most important theologian among the Roman presbyters of this era. He was an avowed adherent of the doctrine of the Divine Logos. He taught that the Divine Logos became man in Christ, that the Logos differs in every thing from God, that he is the mediary between God and the world of creatures. This doctrine in the form in which it was set forth by Hippolytus and his school aroused many doubts, and another theological school appeared in opposition to it. This latter school was represented at Rome in this era by Cleomenes and particularly by Sabellius. These men were rigid opponents of the Theodotians, but were not willing to acknowledge the incarnation of the Logos, and emphasized above all the absolute unity (monarchia) of God. They explained the Incarnation of Christ in the sense that this was another manifestation (modus) of God in His union with human nature. Consequently they were called Modalists or Patripassians, as according to them it was not the Son of God but the Father Who had been crucified. The Christian common people held firmly, above all, to the Unity of God and at the same time to the true Godhead of Jesus Christ. Originally no distrust of this doctrine was felt among them. Pope Zephyrinus did not interpose authoritatively in the dispute between the two schools. The heresy of the Modalists was not at first clearly evident, and the doctrine of Hippolytus offered many difficulties as regards the tradition of the Church. Zephyrinus said simply that he acknowledged only one God, and this was the Lord Jesus Christ, but it was the Son, not the Father, Who had died. This was the doctrine of the tradition of the Church. Hippolytus urged that the pope should approve of a distinct dogma which represented the Person of Christ as actually different from that of the Father and condemned the opposing views of the Monarchians and Patripassians. However, Zephyrinus would not consent to this. The result was that Hippolytus grew constantly more irritated and angry against he pope and particularly against the deacon Callistus whom, as the councillor of the pope, he made responsible for the position of the latter. When after the death of Zephyrinus Callistus was elected Roman bishop, Hippolytus withdrew from the Church with his scholars, caused a schism, and made himself a rival bishop.

Read the rest of the article

Zephyrinus was buried in a separate sepulchral chamber over the cemetery of Calistus on the Via Appia (cf. Wilpert, "Die papstgruber und die Suciliengruft in der Katakombe des hl. Kallistus", Freiburg, 1909, 91 sqq.). The "Liber Pontificalis" attributes two Decrees to Zephyrinus; one on the ordination of the clergy and the other on the Eucharistic Liturgy in the title churches of Rome. The author of the biography has ascribed these Decrees to the pope arbitrarily and without historical basis.

Liber Pontificalis, ed. DUCHESNE, I, 139; DUCHESNE, Histoire ancienne de Peglise, 292 sqq.; LANGEN, Geschichte der römischen Kirche, I (Bonn, 1881), 200 sqq.; BAGEMANN, Die romische Kirche und ihr Einfluss auf Dissiplin und Dogma in den ersten drei Jahrhunderten (Freiburg in Mr., 1864), 84 sqq.; cf. also the bibliography to HIPPOLYTUS.

More about St. Zephyrinus, Pope

Checked against at least two sources, in our own words

Help us add to this saint's story

Everything is read by a person before anything appears. Facts are checked against trusted sources first.

Facts are welcome; a source link helps (optional).With your permission we may share it on this page.

Nine days · Free

Pray the novena
with us.

One short email a day for nine days. The day's prayer, a line from St. Zephyrinus's story, and a nudge to keep going.

Also on August 26
B

St. Bregwin of Canterbury

August 26 · Feast

St. Rose of Lima

August 26 · Virgin
← All 1970 saints in the library
Sources & notes

Feast-day sources

Story sources

Sources

Credits

From “Catholic Encyclopedia (1913)/Pope St. Zephyrinus,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (New York: Robert Appleton Company, 1907–1914), via Wikisource. Public domain. Matched by name and feast date; text unedited except for our bracketed notes in grey.

Retold in plain modern English from Baring-Gould’s public-domain text, sentence by sentence, keeping the same facts and order. Short explanations in parentheses are ours.

From Sabine Baring-Gould, The Lives of the Saints, new edition in 16 vols. (London: John C. Nimmo, 1897–98); text from the Internet Archive scan (OCR, lightly cleaned; errors possible). Public domain in the United States. Reproduced unedited, except for short bracketed notes in grey that we added to explain names and terms (“S.” is the old abbreviation for Saint). Some history and judgments reflect 19th-century scholarship.

Notes

Story retold in our own words from the cited sources.