T

After Arius (who taught that Christ was a created being, not fully God) was condemned and excommunicated by his bishop, St. Alexander of Alexandria, he appealed to the bishops of the East.

Read the essentials →
Traditional feast November 2 · Bishop

St. Theodotus of Laodicea

Traditional feast

November 2
1914 / pre-1969 calendar, per Baring-Gould (1897)

Represents

Bishop

Feast days

Feast: November 2

This Saint’s Story

Adapted in modern English from Baring-Gould (1897–98) · original text below

(The surviving account on this page begins partway through the story.)

Eusebius of Caesarea welcomed him, and Athanasius of Anazarbus, Theodotus of Laodicea and others wrote supporting him. In a surviving letter to Eusebius of Nicomedia, Arius names Theodotus among the bishops condemned by Alexander for holding that God exists before the Son.

At the Council of Nicaea (the first worldwide council of bishops, 325, which defined that the Son is fully God) in 325, Arius came with a group of bishops. The sources differ about Theodotus: Theodoret (5th-century bishop and church historian) counts him in Arius's party, Philostorgius does not. Certainly he signed the Creed without the resistance shown by Eusebius of Nicomedia, Theognis of Nicaea and Maris of Chalcedon. All except two Libyan bishops signed, fearing exile. But Eusebius and Theognis soon taught Arianism (followers of Arius's teaching that the Son is a created being, not fully God) again and were banished. Theodotus also seems to have opposed the Nicene faith, though less openly, for Constantine only wrote warning him to be careful and to learn from their punishment. In 328, influenced by his sister Constantia, Constantine recalled Eusebius, Theognis and Arius.

St. Athanasius, now bishop of Alexandria, refused to receive Arius, and his opponents spread false charges, which Constantine saw through. A more successful attack was made on Eustathius of Antioch, a learned opponent of Arianism. Eusebius of Nicomedia, whom Baring-Gould calls crafty and unprincipled, pretended he longed to see Constantine's church of the Holy Sepulchre, got funds and transport from the emperor, and went with Theognis by way of Antioch, where Eustathius received them kindly. At Jerusalem they met bishops they had quietly summoned, among them Theodotus of Laodicea, Eusebius of Caesarea, Patrophilus of Scythopolis and Aetius of Lydda. They returned together to Antioch and asked Eustathius to hold a council.

There they suddenly produced a woman with a baby who accused Eustathius of being the father; she had been bribed by Eusebius and his associates. Eustathius demanded other evidence, but the accusers were the majority. They put her on oath and, despite protests, deposed him. Eusebius and Theognis hurried to the emperor, leaving Theodotus and the others at Antioch, and told him Eustathius had been convicted of seduction and heresy and had insulted Constantine's mother, Helena, who had just died. Constantine, enraged, had Eustathius brought to him. Antioch was in an uproar, with fighting in the streets until troops restored order. Eustathius was exiled to Trajanopolis and died there. Later the woman, falling ill, confessed before many clergy that she had been bribed, and had been assured she was not lying, since the child's father was indeed named Eustathius, a coppersmith of Antioch.

Eusebius of Caesarea declined the see of Antioch. Constantine wrote to Theodotus, Aetius and the others at Antioch approving what had been done. Only one other incident about Theodotus is known. At Laodicea a priest named Apollinaris and his son, a lector, were friends with a pagan teacher, Epiphanius. When Epiphanius recited a hymn to Bacchus and asked the uninitiated to leave, none of the Christians present did. Theodotus rebuked and forgave the laymen, but publicly excommunicated the two Apollinares because they were clergy, and readmitted them only after penance with fasting and tears.

Baring-Gould says Theodotus entered the Roman Martyrology (the Church's official list of saints for each day) by mistake: Ado, Usuardus and others, seeing Eusebius's praise of him in his Ecclesiastical History and knowing nothing of his Arianism or his part in the scandal at Antioch, put him in their calendars. He regrets that Baronius did not remove him.

What he represents

How he teaches us to live

Drawn from themes in the original account

Stay faithful when it costs you. Holding firm under pressure is part of this story.

Celebrate this saint’s feast day. Remember him on November 2 with a short prayer, and ask for his help.

The full story

Baring-Gould’s account retold in modern English

Read the full story · 1,566 words · about 7 min

After Arius had been condemned in Alexandria and excommunicated by his bishop, Alexander, the heretic appealed to the bishops in the East.

Caesarea was the first place that offered him a refuge from Alexandrian orthodoxy, where he received a warm welcome from the learned Eusebius, the Metropolitan of Palestine. Meanwhile, Athanasius, the bishop of Anazarbus in Cilicia, Theodotus of Laodicea, and others did not hesitate to express their support for him through letters, fully endorsing his heresy. Eusebius even stated that Christ was not very or truly God, and his associate Athanasius claimed that Christ was one of the hundred sheep in the parable — meaning, one of God's creatures. A letter from Arius to Eusebius of Nicomedia has been preserved.

“To his most dear Lord, Eusebius, a man of God, faithful and orthodox, Arius, the man unjustly persecuted by Pope Alexander for the sake of the all-conquering truth, of which you are a champion, sends greetings in the Lord. As Ammonius, my father, was going to Nicomedia, it seemed appropriate to address this through him. I also want to express to you, who have a deep affection for the brethren for the sake of God and His Christ, how fiercely the bishop attacks and drives us, leaving no means untried in his opposition. At last, he has driven us out of the city, as if we are without God, for dissenting from his public declarations, that 'As God is eternal, so is His Son; where the Father is, there the Son is; the Son co-exists in God without a beginning; ever generated, an ingenerately-generated; that neither in idea nor by an instant of time does God precede the Son; an eternal God, an eternal Son; the Son is from God Himself.' Since then, Eusebius, your brother of Caesarea, Theodotus (of Laodicea), Paulinus (of Tyre), Athanasius (of Anazarbus), Gregory (of Berytus), Aetius (of Lydda), and all the bishops of the East declare that God exists without origin before the Son, they are declared anathema by Alexander's sentence; all except Philogonius (of Antioch), Hellanicus (of Tripoli in Phoenicia), and Macarius (of Jerusalem), who are heretical and ill-grounded men, saying one that he is an utterance, another an offspring, another co-generated. We cannot bear these blasphemies.”

Eusebius of Nicomedia, the ecclesiastical adviser of Constantia, the Emperor’s sister, declared in favor of Arius and offered him refuge, which he readily accepted, from the growing unpopularity he faced in Palestine. The Council of Nicaea met in 325. Arius appeared with several bishops of his party, variously counted as either twenty-two or seventeen. Among these, seven—some count Theodotus as one—Arius believed he could thoroughly rely upon. However, Philostorgius does not count Theodotus among the twenty-two of Arius's party, but he is listed as one by Theodoret. It is certain that he subscribed to the Creed, and that without a struggle, unlike Eusebius of Nicomedia, Theognis of Nicaea, Maris of Chalcedon, and the Libyan bishops Theonas and Secundus. In the end, all yielded, fearing the banishment threatened by the Emperor, except the two Libyans, who were condemned along with Arius.

Yet no sooner were Eusebius and Theognis returned to their dioceses than they began to teach the Arian heresy with increased fervor, harbored the heretics who had been driven out of Alexandria, and protested that their subscription had not been given to the Nicene Creed. It is said that they succeeded, through bribery, in obtaining the document and erasing their names. These two bishops openly communicated with the Arians. Theodotus also seems to have shown his opposition to the Nicene faith, though he probably did not go to the same extremes as Eusebius and Theognis; for while Constantine banished these bishops, he merely wrote to Theodotus to caution him to be more careful and to take warning from the punishment inflicted on Eusebius and Theognis, and to rid himself of the negative influence they had exerted on his mind.

But in 328, Constantine fell under the influence of his sister Constantia, which led to the recall of Eusebius of Nicomedia, Theognis, and Arius.

But although Arius had returned to Alexandria, Saint Athanasius, now the bishop of that important see in place of his friend and patron, Alexander, refused to accept him into communion. The Arian party, which now had the attention of the Emperor, decided to bring about his downfall, as well as that of other strong defenders of the Catholic faith. Various slanders were spread about Athanasius, and he was called before the Emperor to respond to the accusations made against him. Constantine quickly recognized the falsehood of these charges and dismissed him.

In the meantime, a more successful attack was made against Eustathius of Antioch. He was a confessor, very learned and eloquent, a writer, and a zealous opponent of Arianism. Eusebius of Nicomedia, a crafty and unprincipled man, accomplished his goal through very discreditable means. He pretended to have a strong desire to see the magnificent church of the holy sepulchre, which Constantine had built in Jerusalem. The Emperor was so pleased by this expressed wish that he provided Eusebius with funds for the journey and arranged for state transportation. Eusebius took Theognis of Nicsea with him, and they arrived together in Antioch. Saint Eustathius welcomed them in a friendly manner, without any suspicion, and saw them on their way to Jerusalem. There, they met other Arian bishops whom they had secretly summoned to gather there under various pretexts: Theodotus of Laodicea, Eusebius of Caesarea, Patrophilus of Scythopolis, Aetius of Lydda, and others.

Once everyone was gathered, they set off together back to Antioch and invited Eustathius to hold a council. He remained unsuspecting and called together some of his suffragans (bishops who assist a bishop). Then, suddenly, the Arian party introduced a woman with a baby in her arms and accused Eustathius of being the child's father. The unfortunate woman had been bribed to make this accusation by Eusebius and those working with him. The bishop of Antioch, taken by surprise, indignantly demanded evidence against him beyond the woman's word. However, the Arians were in the majority. They put the woman under oath, recorded her testimony, and despite the protests and objections of the other bishops present, condemned and deposed Eustathius.

Eusebius and Theognis immediately rushed to the Emperor, leaving Theodotus and the rest of their group in Antioch. Eusebius informed the Emperor that the patriarch of Antioch had been found guilty of seducing a woman during a council held in his own city. He claimed that Eustathius's flock was outraged and demanded that Eusebius of Caesarea replace him, and that due to his immorality and Sabellianism (a belief that the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit are different modes of one God), the council had deposed Eustathius. He also suggested that the bishop of Antioch had grossly insulted Helena, the mother of Constantine, to her face. Constantine had just lost his mother, and he became furious at this insidious suggestion. He ordered that Eustathius be brought before him.

Meanwhile, Antioch was in chaos. Part of the population supported Eustathius, while others believed the accusations against him. The excitement was intense; soldiers, magistrates, and even pagans took part in the conflict and came to blows. The Emperor's armed forces had to restore order. He banished Eustathius to Trajanopolis, and the unfortunate bishop died in exile.

Shortly after, the woman who had accused him fell ill and confessed before many bishops and clergy that she had been coerced into making the accusation.

had been bribed to make the accusation and was assured that she would not be committing perjury. The father of the child was indeed named Eustathius, but he was a coppersmith in Antioch.

Eusebius of Caesarea, however, did not think it appropriate to leave his see for that of Antioch, and he wrote to the Emperor to explain his reasons.

Constantine sent a letter to Theodotus, Aetius, and other Arian bishops gathered at Antioch, which Eusebius reported, in which he approved of what had been done. Nothing more is known about Theodotus, except for one circumstance of little importance. There was a priest named Apollinaris in Laodicea, and his son, who was also named Apollinaris and served as a lector. At that time, there was a notable pagan sophist in Laodicea named Epiphanius, who was a great friend of the two Apollinares, and he taught the younger Apollinaris. One day, Epiphanius recited a hymn in praise of Bacchus in front of several people, including the two Apollinares. Before doing so, he repeated the formula, “Let those who are uninitiated or profane depart,” but neither Apollinaris, father or son, nor any of the Christians present, left the room. When Theodotus heard about this, he was indignant. After rebuking the laymen, he forgave them; however, he publicly criticized the father and son because they were in holy orders and excommunicated them. Only after they had done penance with fasting and tears did he readmit them to communion.

Theodotus has only made it into the Roman Martyrology due to an oversight. Ado, Usuardus, and other early martyrologists, seeing the high praise given to him in the “Ecclesiastical History of Eusebius” and knowing nothing of his Arianism or his involvement with Eusebius of Nicomedia in the scandalous events at Antioch, rashly included him in their Sacred Kalendars. It is unfortunate that Baronius did not remove his name when he revised the Martyrology.

Footnotes

  1. Eusebius of Nicomedia was a bishop who supported Arius.
  2. Eusebius of Nicomedia was an ecclesiastical adviser to the Emperor's sister.
  3. Constantia was the sister of Emperor Constantine.
  4. The Council of Nicaea took place in 325 AD.
  5. Philostorgius and Theodoret were early church historians.
  6. Constantine sent a letter to Theodotus, Aetius, and other Arian bishops gathered at Antioch, which Eusebius reported.

Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.

Read the original 1870s text

Baring-Gould’s sources: Roman Martyrology. Ado, Usuardus. Authority: — Eusebius, H. E. Theodotus was made bishop of Laodicea after Stephen, who gave way in the persecution of Diocletian. “ The ' affairs of the Church,” says Eusebius, “ were not likely to be ruined by this, for these were corrected and restored by Theodotus, who, under a special providence of God, the Saviour of all, was ordained bishop of the Church there; and by his deeds proved the reality of his name (given of God) and of his office as bishop. For he excelled in his knowledge of the medical art, as applied to the body, and was skilled also in that healing science which ministers to the soul. No one was ever his equal in kindness, sincerity, sympathy, and a zeal to benefit those that needed his aid. He was, also, much exercised in the study of divine things.” To him Eusebius is supposed to have dedicated his great work on the “Evangelic Demonstration for Eusebius begins his “ Evangelic Preparation” with the words, “ Having conceived the design of setting forth before the eyes of those who are ignorant the substance which constitutes Christianity, in a book having for its title * The Evangelic Demonstration,’ I brought it out under the auspices of your name, O Theodotus, honour of the Episcopate, head precious and conse- I crated to God, with the prayer that you would assist me, and support me also with the holy sacrifices which you would offer for me to the Saviour.”

After Arius had been condemned at Alexandria, and excommunicated by his bishop, S. Alexander, the heresiarch appealed to the bishops in the East Nor. a.] •S. Theodotus.

Caesarea was the first place to afford him a retreat from Alexandrian orthodoxy, where he received a cordial reception from the learned Eusebius, Metropolitan of Palestine; whilst Athanasius, bishop of Anazarbus in Cilicia, Theodotus of Laodicea, and others, did not hesitate, by letters on his behalf, to declare their concurrence with him in the full extent of his heresy. Eusebius even declared that Christ was not very or true God; and his associate Athanasius asserted, that He was in the number of the hundred sheep of the parable — that is, one of the creatures of God. A letter of Arius to Eusebius of Nicomedia has been preserved.

“ To his most dear Lord, Eusebius, a man of God, faithful and orthodox, Arius, the man unjustly persecuted by the Pope Alexander for the all-conquering truth's sake, of which thou art a champion, sends health in the Lord. As Ammonius, my father, was going to Nicomedia, it seemed becoming to address this through him; and withal to represent to that deep-seated affection which thou bearest towards the brethren for the sake of God and His Christ, how fiercely the bishop assaults and drives us, leaving no means untried in his opposition. At length he has driven us out of the city, as men without God, for dissenting from his public declarations, that * As God is eternal, so is His Son; where the Father, there the Son; the Son co-exists in God without a beginning; ever generate, an ingenerately-generate; that neither in idea, nor by an instant of time, does God precede the Son; an eternal God, an eternal Son; the Son is from God Himself.' Since then Eusebius, thy brother of Caesarea, Theodotus (of Laodicea), Paulinus (of Tyre), Athanasius (of Anazarbus), Gregory (of Berytus), Aetius (of Lydda), and all the bishops of the East declare that God exists without origin before the Son, they are made anathema by Alexander's sentence; all but Philogonius (of Antioch), Hellanicus (of VOL. XIII. 4 Tripoli in Phoenicia), and Macarius (pf Jerusalem), heretical, ill-grounded men, who say, one that he is an utterance, another an offspring, another co-ingenerate. These blasphemies we cannot bear,” &c.1 Eusebius of Nicomedia, the ecclesiastical adviser of Constants, the Emperor’s sister, declared in favour of Arius, and offered him a refuge, which he readily accepted, from the growing unpopularity which attended him in Palestine. The Council of Nicaea met in 325. Arius appeared with several bishops of his party, variously reckoned as twenty-two or seventeen. Seven — amongst these, some reckon Theodotus — Arius believed he could thoroughly rely upon. Philostorgius, however, does not reckon Theodotus among the twentytwo of the party of Arius, but he is given as one by Theodoret. It is certain that he subscribed the Creed, and that without a struggle, such as that made by Eusebius of Nicomedia, Theognis of Nicaea, Maris of Chalcedon, and the Libyan bishops Theonas and Secundus. Finally all yielded, fearing the banishment with which they were threatened by the Emperor, except the two Libyans, who were condemned with Arius. Yet no sooner were Eusebius and Theognis returned to their dioceses, than they began to teach the Arian [followers of Arius, who taught that the Son is a created being, not fully God] heresy with increased vehemence, harboured the heretics who had been driven out of Alexandria, and protested that their subscription had not been given to the Nicene Creed. They had succeeded, it is said, by bribery, in getting at the document and effacing their names. These two bishops openly communicated with the Arians. Theodotus seems also to have shown his antagonism to the Nicene faith, though he probably did not go to the same extremes as Eusebius and Theognis; for whereas Constantine banished these bishops, he contented himself with writing to Theodotus to caution him to be more circumspect, and to take warning Nor by the punishment inflicted on Eusebius and Theognis, and rid himself of the evil influence they had exerted on his mind. # But in 328 Constantine fell under the influence of his sister Constantia, and this led to the recall of Eusebius of Nicomedia, of Theognis, and of Arius.

But though Arius had returned to Alexandria, S. Athanasius [bishop of Alexandria (d. 373), great defender of the Nicene faith], now bishop of that important see in the room of his friend and patron, Alexander, refused to receive him to communion. The Arian party, which now had the ear of the Emperor, resolved to effect his ruin, as well as that of other most zealous champions of the Catholic faith. Various calumnies were circulated about Athanasius, and he was summoned before the Emperor to answer to the charges made against him. Constantine speedily detected their emptiness, and discharged him.

In the meantime a more successful attack had been made against Eustathius of Antioch — a confessor [in old usage, a saint who was not martyred, or who suffered for the faith without being killed], very learned and eloquent, a writer, and a zealous opponent of Arianism. Eusebius of Nicomedia, a crafty, unprincipled man, accomplished his purpose by means most discreditable. He feigned a burning desire to see the magnificent church of the holy sepulchre, which Constantine had built at Jerusalem. The Emperor was so pleased at the expression of this wish, that he furnished him with funds to make the journey, and placed the state conveyances at his disposal. Eusebius took with him Theognis of Nicsea, and they arrived together at Antioch. S. Eustathius received them in a friendly manner, and without suspicion, and saw them on their way to Jerusalem. There they met other Arian bishops whom they had secretly summoned to assemble there, under one pretext or another, Theodotus of Laodicea, Eusebius of Caesarea, Patrophilus of Scythopolis, Aetius of Lydda, &c. When all were gathered, they set off together to Antioch, and invited Eustathius to hold a council. He was still unsuspicious, and called together some of his suffragans. Then, suddenly the Arian party introduced a. woman with a baby in her arms, and charged Eustathius with being its father. The wretched woman had been suborned to make this accusation by Eusebius and those acting in concert with him. The bishop of Antioch, taken with surprise, indignantly demanded some evidence against him other than the word of this woman. But the Arians were in the majority. They put the woman on her oath, took down her deposition, and in spite of the outcries and remonstrances of the other bishops present, condemned and deposed Eustathius. Eusebius and Theognis at once posted off to the Emperor, leaving Theodotus and the rest of their party in Antioch. Eusebius told the Emperor that the patriarch [the title of the bishops of the great ancient sees: Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, Jerusalem] of Antioch had been convicted of having seduced a woman, before a Council held in his own city, that his flock were indignant, and demanded Eusebius of Caesarea in his place, and that on account of his profligacy and sabellianism, the Council had deposed Eustathius. He hinted also that the bishop of Antioch had grossly insulted Helena, the mother of Constantine, to her face. Constantine had only just lost his mother, and he took fire at once at the insidious suggestion. He sent orders that Eustathius should be brought before him. In the meantime Antioch was in an uproar. Part of the population sided with Eustathius, part believed the charges made against him. The excitement was intense; soldiers and magistrates, the very heathen, took part in the contest, and came to blows. The armed hand of the Emperor was obliged to restore tranquillity. He banished Eustathius to Trajanopolis, and the unfortunate bishop died in exile.

Shortly after, the woman who had accused him fell ill, and confessed before many bishops and clergy that she

had been bribed to make the charge, and assured that she would not be committing perjury, for the father of the child was indeed named Eustathius, but was a coppersmith in Antioch.

Eusebius of Caesarea, however, did not think fit to leave his see for that of Antioch, and wrote to the Emperor to state his reasons.

Constantine sent a letter to Theodotus, Aetius, and others of the Arian bishops assembled at Antioch, which Eusebius has reported,1 in which he approved of what had been done. Nothing more is known of Theodotus, except one circumstance of no great importance. There were at Laodicea a priest named Apollinaris and his son, a lector, bearing the same name. There was at that time in Laodicea a pagan sophist of some note, named Epiphanius, a great friend of the two Apollinares, and he gave instructions to the younger. One day Epiphanius recited a hymn in praise of Bacchus, in presence of several persons, amongst others of these two men. Before doing so, he repeated the formula, “ Let those who are uninitiated or profane depart,” but neither Apollinaris, father or son, nor any of the Christians present, left the room. When Theodotus heard of this he was indignant. After rebuking the laymen, he pardoned them; but he publicly blamed the father and son, because they were in holy orders [ordination; “orders” means the sacrament by which deacons, priests and bishops are ordained], and excommunicated them. Only after they had done penance with fasting and tears did he readmit them to communion.

Theodotus has only crept into the Roman Martyrology through an oversight Ado, Usuardus [a 9th-century monk of Paris who compiled a list of saints for each day], and other early martyrologists, seeing the high praise accorded him in the “Ecclesiastical History of Eusebius,” and knowing nothing of his Arianism, and his association with Eusebius of Nicomedia in the scandalous transaction at Antioch, rashly placed him in their Sacred Kalendars. It is much to be regretted that Baronius [Cardinal Baronius (d. 1607), church historian who edited the Roman Martyrology] did not cancel his name when he revised the Martyrology.

Help us add to this saint's story

Everything is read by a person before anything appears. Facts are checked against trusted sources first.

Facts are welcome; a source link helps (optional).With your permission we may share it on this page.

Nine days · Free

Pray the novena
with us.

One short email a day for nine days. The day's prayer, a line from St. Theodotus of Laodicea's story, and a nudge to keep going.

Also on November 2
V

St. Victorinus of Pettau

November 2 · Bishop, Martyr
M

St. Marcian (November 2)

November 2 · Hermit
E

St. Erc of Slane

November 2 · Bishop
← All 1970 saints in the library
Sources & notes

Feast-day sources

Story sources

Sources

Credits

Retold in plain modern English from Baring-Gould’s public-domain text, sentence by sentence, keeping the same facts and order. Short explanations in parentheses are ours.

From Sabine Baring-Gould, The Lives of the Saints, new edition in 16 vols. (London: John C. Nimmo, 1897–98); text from the Internet Archive scan (OCR, lightly cleaned; errors possible). Public domain in the United States. Reproduced unedited, except for short bracketed notes in grey that we added to explain names and terms (“S.” is the old abbreviation for Saint). Some history and judgments reflect 19th-century scholarship.