S

Silverius, whose dates of birth and death are unknown, was the son of Pope Hormisdas, who had been married before entering the higher clergy.

Read the essentials →
Traditional feast June 20 · Martyr

St. Sylverius, Pope

Feast

Traditional feast: June 20 (Catholic Encyclopedia (1913)/Pope St. Silverius)
Traditional date · cited source, no current calendar entry found

Traditional feast

June 20
1914 / pre-1969 calendar, per Baring-Gould (1897)

Represents

Martyr

Feast days

Feast: June 20

This Saint’s Story

He was a subdeacon at Rome when Pope Agapetus died at Constantinople on 22 April 536. The Empress Theodora, who favoured the Monophysites, wanted the Roman deacon Vigilius elected, for he had given her the guarantees she sought. The Ostrogothic king Theodatus moved first: against the usual custom of choosing a higher cleric, he secured the election of Silverius, who was consecrated probably on 8 June 536. The Catholic Encyclopedia notes that clerical opposition was suppressed and that a charge of buying the office is unwarranted.

Theodora pressed the new pope to restore communion with the deposed Monophysite patriarch Anthimus and with Severus of Antioch. Silverius would promise nothing, and she resolved to replace him with Vigilius. After Amalasuntha's death, war broke out between Ostrogoths and Byzantines. King Vitiges besieged Rome; churches over the catacombs were devastated and martyrs' tombs desecrated. In December 536 Belisarius entered the city and was received courteously by the pope. Antonina, Belisarius's wife, urged her husband to act for Theodora. By a forged letter Silverius was accused of offering to open a city gate to the Goths. In March 537 he was stripped of his episcopal dress, given a monk's habit, and carried into exile in the East; Vigilius was consecrated in his place.

Taken to Patara in Lycia, Silverius was found innocent by the local bishop, who laid the proofs before the Emperor Justinian. Justinian ordered a fresh investigation and allowed the exile to return to Italy. Vigilius, acting with Theodora and Antonina, seized him again and confined him on the island of Palmaria (or desolate Palmarola near Ponza, as one early life has it). There he died of harsh privation; the year is unknown, but he was buried on the island on 20 June. Believers soon invoked him at his grave. Baring-Gould notes that he entered the Martyrology late; Baronius placed him in the modern Roman calendar of saints, which keeps his feast on 20 June. The Latin Church honours him as a martyr.

What he represents

How he teaches us to live

Drawn from themes in the original account

Celebrate this saint’s feast day. Remember him on June 20 with a short prayer, and ask for his help.

The full story

Baring-Gould’s account retold in modern English

Read the full story · 2,029 words · about 9 min

Theodoric agreed to a compromise; he would allow the pope to be elected by the votes of the clergy and the people of Rome, but the pope would not take office until he had been confirmed by the sovereign. Based on this understanding, the nomination of Felix was accepted, and his peaceful time as pope lasted four years.

After the death of Felix, a double election occurred. Intense rivalries could have led to violent conflicts in the streets of Rome, but one of the candidates, Diodorus, conveniently died, possibly from natural causes, leaving his opponent, Boniface II, with undisputed control of the papacy in the year 530.

Boniface, aware of the scandal caused among Catholics and Arians by the disgraceful scenes of violence and bribery that seemed to plague every papal election, tried to stop this serious problem with a bold measure. He proposed that each pope should, during his lifetime, choose his successor, and he nominated a deacon of strong character and ability named Vigilius, who was the son of a consul but was also extremely ambitious and lacked scruples about what he would do to advance his own interests. A compliant council approved this unusual action; however, the clergy and the people strongly opposed this attempt to take away their undeniable privilege. In a second council, they expressed their outrage at this bold innovation and their refusal to accept it. The pope admitted that his decree had violated both ecclesiastical and even civil law, publicly burned it, and allowed the election of his successor to proceed in the traditional manner.

Once again, after the death of Boniface, the same outrageous scenes erupted, with open and shameless bribery, fierce conflict, and, when it was all over, feelings of shame and horror at what had occurred. The senate of Rome tried in vain to use its authority to intervene and stop the chaos.

These corrupt and greedy actions were common; however, when everyone was eager for money and willing to sell their votes to the highest bidder, their opinions were ignored. Vigilius, the deacon who had been nominated by Boniface, hoped to succeed him, but the greater influence of John II. countered that hope. John II. reigned for three years and was succeeded by Agapetus in 535, which again disappointed the ambitious Vigilius. In the East, Justinian ruled, planning to reclaim Italy, which had fallen from the strong control of Theodoric to the weak rule of Theodotus, the murderer of his benefactress and queen, Amalaswintha. Theodotus, aware of Justinian's military preparations, became alarmed and sent the pope to Constantinople to prevent the impending danger. Agapetus arrived in the imperial city at a time when he could not avoid being caught up in the complexities of Byzantine church politics. Justinian had elevated an actress with a disreputable past to share his throne. The empress Theodora, a bigot lacking true faith and a heretic without conviction, dominated the emperor through her strong personality. She took control of church affairs and appointed individuals to the highest positions.

When Agapetus arrived in Constantinople, the see (the office of the bishop) of the imperial city was vacant. Theodora appointed Anthimus, the bishop of Trebizond, who held strong Eutychian views. Agapetus, learning of this, refused to communicate with him until Anthimus provided a clear confession of faith regarding the two natures of Christ. Anthimus refused and accused Agapetus of Nestorianism. The pope rejected this accusation and refused to hold communion with the empress's favorite. Theodora appealed to Justinian and denounced Agapetus as a heretic. The emperor summoned the pope and demanded an explanation of his faith. Agapetus defended himself against the charge before Justinian but remained firm in his refusal to communicate with Anthimus.

"I will receive communion with the bishop of Trebizond when he has returned to his diocese and accepted the decrees of the Council of Chalcedon and the Tome of Leo."

Justinian’s mind, influenced by the pope, changed direction. He was persuaded to summon Anthimus before him, convict him of heresy, and remove him from his position. Saint Menas, a righteous man with an impeccable life, was consecrated by Pope Agapetus himself. In a circular letter, Agapetus announced that “the heretical bishop had been deposed by the apostolic authority, with the concurrence of the most religious emperor.” Almost immediately after, Agapetus died on October 1st, 536 AD.

The ambitious deacon Vigilius had accompanied the pope to Constantinople. He quickly saw his opportunity and made advances to Theodora, promising to acknowledge Anthimus, refuse communion to Menas, and reject the authority of the Council of Chalcedon if she would help him become the pope. Theodora readily agreed; she provided him with money to bribe the electors of Rome and promised to send letters to Belisarius, the general, who was then in Italy, asking him to support Vigilius with his troops.

Hoping to reach Rome before the news of Agapetus's death, Vigilius hurried to Italy. However, he found that the news had reached Rome before him. Theodotus, for a bribe of two hundred pieces of gold, had appointed Sylverius without an election. Sylverius was enthroned and consecrated on June 8th, 536. The clergy and people, trembling before the swords of the Arian Goths, only reluctantly consented after the pope was installed. Natalis, Alexander, Baronius, and others have tried to clear the pope of the charge of simony, but it must be noted that during this period, an unbought promotion to the papacy was nearly impossible. If the gold was not given to the barbarian and Arian prince, it was spent among the clergy and people of Rome to secure their votes.

Finding himself too late, Vigilius pretended to be supportive, ingratiated himself with Pope Sylverius, acted as his apocrisiarius (a representative of the pope), and waited for Belisarius to arrive at the gates of Rome to break the power of the barbarian prince and remove Sylverius from his position.

Before long, Belisarius's army, taking advantage of the confusion among the Goths caused by the removal of the usurper Theodotus and the rise of Vitiges, marched on Rome, which had been abandoned by the Goths except for a weak garrison of four thousand soldiers.

A momentary enthusiasm for religion and patriotism then ignited in the minds of the Romans. They angrily declared that the apostolic throne should no longer be tarnished by the triumph of Arianism. The deputies of the pope and clergy, along with the senate and the people, urged the lieutenant of Justinian to accept their voluntary allegiance and to enter the city, whose gates would be opened for his arrival. Belisarius entered on December 9th, 536. The garrison left without resistance, and Rome, after sixty years of servitude, was freed from the control of the barbarians. The first days, which coincided with the old Saturnalia festival, were spent in mutual congratulations and public joy. The Catholics prepared to celebrate the upcoming festival of the Nativity of Christ without the annoying presence of Arian rivals.

However, this joy was quickly interrupted by news of the hostile preparations of Vitiges, who rapidly gathered his forces, descended upon Rome, and began to besiege it.

During the siege, a letter was intercepted that assured the king of the Goths that the Asinarian gate, next to the Lateran church, would be secretly opened to his troops. As soon as Belisarius took control of the capital, the implications of Rome's subjection to Byzantium became clear to the pope and the people of Rome.

It is uncertain whether Sylverius, concerned about the stability of his position, which he owed to the Goths, had any involvement in the treasonous offer to let them into the city. It is likely that he did not; the letter was likely used merely as an excuse for his removal. This task had been planned in advance. It was entrusted to someone more reliable than Belisarius—his wife Antonina, who was an accomplice of the empress in all her schemes and shared her arbitrary power over her husband. Belisarius summoned the pope before him, and Sylverius denied having written the letter. The general examined the evidence and discovered that the letter had been written by a lawyer and a soldier. They may have written it as part of Antonina's plans, intending for it to be intercepted. At the same time, it should be noted that Sylverius had by then found reasons to be worried. Vigilius was openly questioning his election, which had been forced upon the Roman people by the Goths, and was presenting himself as a candidate for the position that had become vacant due to the irregularity of Sylverius's appointment. Theodora had provided him with gold, which was being used for bribes.

Belisarius urged the pope to submit to the will of the empress, reject the council of Chalcedon, and acknowledge Anthimus, in order to avoid a disaster that he could not prevent. When he refused, the general said, “The empress commands, I must obey. Let those who seek the fall of Sylverius answer for it on the last day.”

The successor of Saint Peter was rudely summoned to the Pincian palace, where Belisarius lived. The date was November 16th, A.D. 537. He was led past the first and second veil, while his attendants were required to wait outside. Sylverius had anticipated some disaster and had spent the night in prayer in a church. His attendants waited anxiously.

In the reception room, Antonina sat on a bed, while her husband rested on the rug at her feet. “What have we done,” exclaimed the commanding woman, “that you, Pope Sylverius, should attempt to betray the city and us to the Romans?” Before Sylverius could respond, at her signal, a subdeacon tore the pall from his shoulders. He was hurried by the guards into the outer room, stripped of his papal robes, and dressed in the coarse habit and cowl of a monk. Thus, he was brought out to his clergy, who were waiting outside, and they were informed of the deposition of their pope. Vigilius, the archdeacon and apocrisiarius, had accompanied him; he stayed in the presence of Antonina and Belisarius and received assurances of support from them.

The next day, Belisarius summoned the clergy of Rome and ordered them to elect the archdeacon in place of Sylverius, who had been deposed due to the illegality of his election and his alleged treason. Some doubted, and others scoffed, but they submitted, and Vigilius was ordained pope on November 22nd. Belisarius immediately demanded that he fulfill his promise to the empress, but he hesitated and delayed, fearing the Roman clergy and laity, who were orthodox. The most extraordinary part of this strange situation is that Justinian was completely unaware of the whole intrigue. From Patara, where Sylverius was banished, the pope made his way to Constantinople, and to the amazement of the emperor, he presented his complaint about the unjust violence with which he had been expelled. Justinian commanded his immediate return to Rome and the re-hearing of his case. If he were found guilty of treasonable correspondence with the Goths, he would have to endure banishment, but if the charge was proven false, he would be restored to his position. Theodora immediately sent Pelagius, the apocrisiarius, who later became Pope Pelagius I, to deliver news to Rome and to prepare her nominee. However, Sylverius outpaced Pelagius and surprised Vigilius by appearing before Belisarius in Naples with letters from the emperor.

June 9. Filoarent. But Vigilius was not someone who would be removed without a fight. He immediately sent a message to Belisarius, demanding that he hand over Sylverius to him. "Otherwise," he said, "I will not keep my promise to the empress." Belisarius weakly complied, and the pope was handed over to Vigilius's servants, who quickly took him to the island of Pandataria, notorious as the place of exile where the pagan emperors had sent the victims of their cruelty.

On this miserable rock, Sylverius's life came to an end with alarming speed, and there is little doubt that he was murdered by the servants of his successor. Vigilius now ruled without fear that his rival could appeal to the emperor for help against his claims.

Footnotes

  1. The Tome of S. Leo refers to a letter written by Pope Leo I that defined the two natures of Christ.
  2. The Council of Chalcedon was an important church council held in 451 that addressed Christological issues.
  3. Theodotus was a usurper who had taken control of the Gothic kingdom.
  4. Vitiges was the king of the Goths after Theodotus.
  5. Apocrisiarius refers to a papal representative or envoy.
  6. The author of the Life in Anastasius says plainly “He (Silverius) was elevated by the tyrant Theodohatus without deliberation of decree, who, having corrupted by money, instilled such fear in the clergy that those who did not consent to the ordination would be punished by the sword. Indeed, the priests did not subscribe according to the ancient custom, nor did they confirm the decree before the ordination. Now, however, the ordination under the fear of Silverius, due to the unity of the Church and religion, was subscribed to by the Presbyters.”
  7. Some doubted, others scoffed, but submitted.
  8. "Quibus dubitantibus et nonnullis ridentibus favore Belisarii ordinatus est Virgilius."

Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.

Read the original 1870s text

Baring-Gould’s sources: Not mentioned in any Martyrology earlier than the 15th cent. The first to include him in the list of Saints was Peter de Natalibus. Baronius inserted his name in the Modern Roman Martyrology. Authorities: — The Liber Pontificalis, and a Life by Liberatus, deacon of Carthage; also for some information, Procopius "De Bello Gothico.'*J Theodoric the Ostrogoth, disturbed by the fierce contentions which followed the death of Pope John I. in 526, and being master of Italy, resolved to check the constantly recurring scandal, by taking into his own hands the nomination of the popes; and he appointed to the vacant throne Felix IV., a learned and blameless man. But both clergy and people of Rome united to resist this appointment, which deprived them of an exciting contest, by allowing them no voice in the matter.

Theodoric agreed to a compromise; he would suffer the pope to be elected by the suffrages of the clergy and [June 20. people of Rome, but not to take office till he had been confirmed by the sovereign. On this understanding the nomination of Felix was acquiesced in, and his peaceful pontificate lasted four years.

On the death of Felix a double election took place. Furious partisanships would have led to bloody contests in the streets of Rome, had not one of the candidates, Diodorus, opportunely, and possibly from natural causes, died and left his opponent, Boniface II., in undisputed possession of the throne (a.d. 530).

Boniface, conscious of the scandal caused among Catholics and Arians [followers of Arius, who taught that the Son is a created being, not fully God] by the disgraceful scenes of bloodshed and bribery which now seemed inveterate at every papal election, attempted by a bold measure to stop this crying evil. He proposed that each pope should, in his life-time, designate his successor, and he nominated for the purpose a deacon of firm character and ability, named Vigilius, the son of a consul, but one of unbounded ambition* and without conscientious scruple as to what he did to advance his own interests. An obsequious council ratified the extraordinary proceeding; but the clergy and people resented with stubborn hostility this attempt to wrest from them their undoubted privilege. In a second council they expressed their indignation at this daring innovation, and their refusal to tolerate it. The pope acknowledged that his decree had violated ecclesiastical and even civil law, burned it in public, and left the election of his successor to proceed in the old course.

Again, at the death of Boniface, did the same outrageous scenes break out, undisguised, unblushing bribery, fierce strife, and when all was over, shame and horror at what had taken place. The senate of Rome vainly endeavoured to interpose its authority and check vS. Sylverius.

these base and venal proceedings; but when all were greedy of gold, and ready to sell their votes to the highest bidder, their voice was unheeded. Vigilius the deacon, who had been nominated by Boniface, had hoped to succeed him; the superior influence of John II. countervailed. John II. reigned three years, and was succeeded by Agapetus in 535, again to the disappointment of the ambitious Vigilius. In the East reigned Justinian [Byzantine emperor 527–565], who meditated the re-conquest of Italy, now fallen from the strong grasp of Theodoric under the feeble sway of Theodotus, the murderer of his benefactress and queen, Amalaswintha. Theodotus, being apprized of the military preparations of Justinian, was filled with alarm, and sent the pope to Constantinople to ward off the impending danger. Agapetus arrived at the imperial city at a moment when he could not fail to be involved in the snares of Byzantine ecclesiastical intrigue. Justinian had raised an actress of disreputable history to share his throne. The empress Theodora, a bigot without faith, a heretic without conviction, by the superior force of her character domineered over the emperor, and took into her hands the direction of the affairs of the Church, and appointed to the highest dignities.

On the arrival of Agapetus in Constantinople, the see of the imperial city was vacant. Theodora gave it to Anthimus, bishop of Trebizond, who was strongly tinctured with Eutychian [followers of Eutyches, who said Christ had only a divine nature; condemned at Chalcedon in 451] views. Agapetus, informed of this, refused to communicate with him, till Anthimus had given him a plain confession of faith in the two natures of Christ. Anthimus refused, and charged Agapetus with Nestorianism [Nestorius (d. c. 451), whose teaching split Christ into two persons; condemned at Ephesus in 431]. The pope declined to acknowledge, and hold communion with, the empress’s favourite. Theodora appealed to Justinian, and de(Jane so.

nounced Agapetus as a heretic. The emperor summoned the pope before him, and demanded of him an account of his faith. Agapetus cleared himself of the charge before Justinian, but was resolute in his refusal to communicate with Anthimus.

“ With the bishop of Trebizond I will receive communion when he shall have returned to his diocese, and I has accepted the decrees of the council of Chalcedon and the Tome of S. Leo.”

Justinian’s mind now, under the influence of the pope, veered round, and he was induced to summon Anthimus before him, convict him of heresy, and degrade him from his see. S. Menas, an orthodox man of blameless life, was consecrated by pope Agapetus himself, who, in a circular letter notified that “the heretical bishop had been deposed by the apostolic authority, with the concurrence of the most religious emperor.” Almost immediately after, Agapetus died, Oct. 1st, a.d. 536. The ambitious deacon Vigilius had accompanied the pope to Constantinople. He saw his opportunity at once, made overtures to Theodora, undertook to acknowledge Anthimus, to refuse communion to Menas, and to reject the authority of the council of Chalcedon, if she would place him in the chair of S. Peter. Theodora readily consented; she furnished him with money to bribe the electors of Rome, and promised to send letters to Belisarius, the general, then in Italy, requiring him to support Vigilius with his troops.; Hoping to arrive in Rome before the news of the death of Agapetus, Vigilius flew to Italy, but found that the news had outsped him, and that Theodotus, for a bribe of two hundred pieces of gold, had appointed Sylverius, without an election, and Sylverius was enthroned and consecrated on June 8th, 536, the clergy jane so.] 61 Sylverius. 275 and people, trembling before the swords of the Arian Goths [Germanic peoples who invaded the Roman Empire, many of them Arian Christians], only giving a tardy consent after the pope was installed.1 Natalis, Alexander, Baronius [Cardinal Baronius (d. 1607), church historian who edited the Roman Martyrology] and others have endeavoured to exculpate the pope from the charge of simony, but it must be remembered at this period that such an event as an unbought promotion to the apostolic throne was an impossibility. If the gold was not given to the barbarian and Arian prince, it was lavished among the clergy and people of Rome, and their votes purchased.

Vigilius, finding himself too late, dissembled, ingratiated himself into favour with pope Sylverius, acted as his apocrisiarius, and waited till Belisarius appeared before the gates of Rome to break the power of the barbarian prince, and with it to displace his nominee, Sylverius.

Before long the army of Belisarius, taking advantage of the confusion caused among the Goths by the degradation of the usurper Theodotus, and the elevation of Vitiges, marched upon Rome, which had been deserted by the Goths save by a feeble garrison of four thousand soldiers.

A momentary enthusiasm of religion and patriotism then kindled in the minds of the Romans. They furiously exclaimed that the apostolic throne should no longer be profaned by the triumph of Arianism; and the deputies of the pope and clergy, of the senate and people, invited the lieutenant of Justinian to accept 1 The author of the Life in Anastasius says plainly “ Hie (Silrerius) eleratus cst a tyranno Theodohate sine delibcratione decretii qui Theodohatus corrupt us pecunia, talem timorem induxit clero, ut, qui non consentirct in qusordinationem gladio puniretur. Equidem sacerdotes non subscripserunt secundum morem antiquam, neque decretum confinnarerunt ante ordinationem. Jam autem ordinatio sub rl et metu Silrerio, propter adunationem Ecclcsi* et religinnis, k sbuscriperunt Presbyteri.'* their voluntary allegiance, and to enter the city, whose gates would be thrown open for his reception. Belisarius entered on Dec. 9th, 536, the garrison departed unmolested, and Rome, after sixty years’ servitude, was delivered from the yoke of the barbarians. The first days, which coincided with the old Saturnalia, were devoted to mutual congratulation and public joy; and the Catholics prepared to celebrate, without the irritating presence of Arian rivals, the approaching festival of the Nativity of Christ.

But this joy was speedily brought to a close by the news of the hostile preparations of Vitiges, who rapidly collected his forces, descended upon Rome, and proceeded to invest it.

During the siege a letter was intercepted, which assured the king of the Goths that the Asinarian gate, adjoining the Lateran [St. John Lateran, the pope’s cathedral in Rome] church, should be secretly opened to his troops. Belisarius had no sooner made himself master of the capital, than the consequence of the subjection of Rome to Byzantium had broken on the pope and on Rome.

Whether Sylverius, alarmed for the stability of his throne which he owed to the Goths, had any part in the treasonable offer to introduce them into the city, cannot be decided. Probably he had not; and the letter was employed simply as the excuse for his degradation. This task had been arranged beforehand. It had been committed to the hands surer than those of Belisarius — to those of his wife Antonina, the accomplice of the empress in all her intrigues, and her counterpart in the arbitrary power with which she ruled her husband. Belisarius summoned the pope before him, Sylverius denied having written the letter. The general sifted the evidence, and found that the letter had been written S. Sylverius.

by a lawyer and a soldier. They may have written it in pursuance of the designs of Antonina, with purpose that it might be intercepted. At the same time it must not be forgotten that Sylverius had by this time found cause of uneasiness. Vigilius was openly calling in question his election forced upon the Roman people by the Goths, and offering himself as a candidate for the throne vacant by the irregularity of the appointment of Sylverius. Theodora had furnished him with gold, and this was lavished in bribes.

Belisarius urged the pope to submit to the will of the empress, reject the council of Chalcedon, and acknowledge Anthimus, and so avert the blow which he was powerless to arrest. When he refused, “The empress commands, I must obey,” said the general, “ let those who seek the fall of Sylverius answer for it at the last day.”

The successor of S. Peter was rudely summoned to the Pincian palace, where Belisarius resided. The day was Nov. 1 6th, a.d. 537. He was introduced past the first and second veil, his attendants being required to tarry without. Sylverius had expected some catastrophe, and had spent the night in prayer in a church. His attendants waited trembling.

In the reception room sat Antonina on a bed, her husband reposing on the rug at her feet. “What have we done,” exclaimed the imperious woman, “ that you, Pope Sylverius, should attempt to betray the city and us to the Romans ?” Before Sylverius could answer, at her signal a subdeacon rent the pall from his shoulders, he was hurried by the guards into the outer room, stripped of his pontifical robes, and the coarse habit and cowl of a monk thrown over him. Thus was he brought forth to his [Jane so.

clergy without, and they were informed of the deposition of their pope. Vigilius, the archdeacon and apocrisiarius, had accompanied him; he remained in the presence of Antonina and Belisarius, and received from them assurance of support.

Next day Belisarius summoned the clergy of Rome, and bade them elect the archdeacon in the room of Sylverius, deposed on account of the illegality of his election, and his treason. 11 Some doubted, others scoffed,” but submitted,1 and Vigilius was ordained pope on November 22nd. Belisarius immediately demanded of him a fulfilment of his promise to the empress, but he, fearing the Roman clergy and laity, who were orthodox, hesitated and delayed performance. The most extraordinary part of this strange transaction is the utter ignorance of Justinian of the whole intrigue. From Patara, whither Sylverius was banished, the pope made his way to Constantinople, and to the amazement of the emperor, preferred his complaint of the unjust violence with which he had been expelled his sje. Justinian commanded his instant return to Rome, and the re-hearing of his case. If he were found guilty of treasonable correspondence with the Goths, then he must endure banishment, but if the charge fell to the ground, he was to be re-invested in his dignity. Theodora at once dispatched Pelagius, the apocrisiarius, who afterwards mounted the papal chair under the title of Pelagius I., to bear tidings to Rome, and forewarn and forearm her nominee. But Sylverius outsailed Pelagius, and surprised Vigilius by appearing before Belisarius at Naples with letters from the emperor. 1 "Quibus dubitantlbus et nonnullls ridentibua favorc Bclisarii ordinatus est Virgilius,” Li bar* tut.

But Vigilius was not a man to be displaced without a struggle. He at once sent to Belisarius requiring him to deliver Sylverius into his hands. 44 Otherwise,” said he, 44 1 will not fulfil my promise to the empress.” Belisarius weakly obeyed, and the pope was delivered to the servants of Vigilius, who hurried him to the island of Pandataria, infamous as the place of exile to which the heathen emperors had consigned the victims of their tyranny.

On this wretched rock the life of Sylverius closed with suspicious celerity, and there can be little doubt that he was murdered by the servants of his successor. Vigilius now reigned without fear of his rival being able to recur to the emperor for support against his pretentions.

From the Catholic Encyclopedia

1913 · 940 words

Dates of birth and death unknown. He was the son of Pope Hormisdas who had been married before becoming one of the higher clergy. Silverius entered the service of the Church and was subdeacon at Rome when Pope Agapetus died at Constantinople, 22 April, 536. The Empress Theodora, who favoured the Monophysites sought to bring about the election as pope of the Roman deacon Vigilius who was then at Constantinople and had given her the desired guarantees as to the Monophysites. However, Theodatus, King of the Ostrogoths, who wished to prevent the election of a pope connected with Constantinople, forestalled her, and by his influence the subdeacon Silverius was chosen. The election of a subdeacon as Bishop of Rome was unusual. Consequently, it is easy to understand that, as the author of the first part of the life of Silverius in the "Liber pontificalis" (ed. Duchesne, I, 210) relates, a strong opposition to it appeared among the clergy. This, however, was suppressed by Theodatus so that, finally, after Silverius had been consecrated bishop (probably on 8 June, 536) all the Roman presbyters gave their consent in writing to his elevation. The assertion made by the author just mentioned that Silverius secured the intervention of Theodatus by payment of money is unwarranted, and is to be explained by the writer's hostile opinion of the pope and the Goths [Germanic peoples who invaded the Roman Empire, many of them Arian Christians]. The author of the second part of the life in the "Liber pontificalis" is favourably inclined to Silverius. The pontificate of this pope belongs to an unsettled, disorderly period and he himself fell a victim to the intrigues of the Byzantine Court.

After Silverius had become pope the Empress Theodora sought to win him for the Monophysites. She desired especially to have him enter into communion with the Monophysite Patriarch of Constantinople, Anthimus, who had been excommunicated and deposed by Agapetus, and with Severus of Antioch. However, the pope committed himself to nothing and Theodora now resolved to overthrow him and to gain the papal see for Vigilius. Troublous times befell Rome during the struggle that broke out in Italy between the Ostrogoths and the Byzantines after the death of Amalasuntha, daughter of Theodoric the Great. The Ostrogothic king, Vitiges, who ascended the throne in August, 536, besieged the city. The churches over the catacombs outside of the city were devastated, the graves of the martyrs in the catacombs themselves were broken open and desecrated. In December, 536, the Byzantine general Belisarius garrisoned Rome and was received by the pope in a friendly and courteous manner. Theodora sought to use Belisarius for the carrying out of her plan to depose Silverius and to put in his place the Roman deacon Vigilius (q.v.), formerly apocrisary at Constantinople, who had now gone to Italy. Antonina, wife of Belisarius, influenced her husband to act as Theodora desired. By means of a forged letter the pope was accused of a treasonable agreement with the Gothic king who was besieging Rome. It was asserted that Silverius had offered the king to leave one of the city gates secretly open so as to permit the Goths to enter. Silverius was consequently arrested in March, 537, roughly stripped of his episcopal dress, given the clothing of a monk and carried off to exile in the East. Vigilius was consecrated Bishop of Rome in his stead.

Silverius was taken to Lycia where he was went to reside at Patara. The Bishop of Patara very soon discovered that the exiled pope was innocent. He journeyed to Constantinople and was able to lay before the Emperor Justinian [Byzantine emperor 527–565] such proofs of the innocence of the exile that the emperor wrote to Belisarius commanding a new investigation of the matter. Should it turn out that the letter concerning the alleged plot in favour of the Goths was forged, Silverius should be placed once more in possession of the papal see. At the same time the emperor allowed Silverius to return to Italy, and the latter soon entered the country, apparently at Naples. However, Vigilius arranged to take charge of his unlawfully deposed predecessor. He evidently acted in agreement with the Empress Theodora and was aided by Antonina, the wife of Belisarius. Silverius was taken to the Island of Palmaria in the Tyrrhenian Sea and kept their in close confinement. Here he died in consequence of the privations and harsh treatment he endured. The year of his death is unknown, but he probably did not live long after reaching Palmaria. He was buried on the island, according to the testimony of the "Liber pontificalis" on 20 June; his remains were never taken from Palmaria. According to the same witness he was invoked after death by the believers who visited his grave. In later times he was venerated as a saint. The earliest proof of this is given by a list of saints of the eleventh century (Mélanges d'archéologie et d'histoire, 1893, 169). The "Martyrologium" of Peter de Natalibus of the fourteenth century also contains his feast, which is recorded in the present Roman Martyrology on 20 June.

Read the rest of the article

[Editor's note: According to the Liber Pontificalis, Pope St. Silverius was exiled not to Palmaria, but rather to the Island of Palmarola, a much smaller and more desolate island near Ponza, Italy, in the Bay of Naples.]

Liber pontificalis, ed. DUCHESNE, I, 290-95; LIBERATUS, Breviarium causae Nestorianorum [Nestorius (d. c. 451), whose teaching split Christ into two persons; condemned at Ephesus in 431] et Eutychianorum [followers of Eutyches, who said Christ had only a divine nature; condemned at Chalcedon in 451], XXII, in P.L., LXVIII, 1039 sq.; PROCOPIUS, De bello gothico, I, xxv; Acta SS., June, IV, 13- 18; JAFFÉ, Regesta pont. rom., I, 2nd ed., 115 sq.; LANGEN, Gesch. der römischen Kirche, II, 341 sqq.; GRISAR, Gesch. Roms u. der Päpste, I, 502-04, and passim; HEFELE, Konziliengesch.,II, 2nd ed., 571.

Help us add to this saint's story

Everything is read by a person before anything appears. Facts are checked against trusted sources first.

Facts are welcome; a source link helps (optional).With your permission we may share it on this page.

Nine days · Free

Pray the novena
with us.

One short email a day for nine days. The day's prayer, a line from St. Sylverius's story, and a nudge to keep going.

Also on June 20
N

St. Novatus

June 20 · Priest
M

St. Macarius

June 20 · Bishop
F

St. Florentia (June 20)

June 20 · Virgin
← All 1970 saints in the library
Sources & notes

Feast-day sources

Story sources

Sources

Credits

From “Catholic Encyclopedia (1913)/Pope St. Silverius,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (New York: Robert Appleton Company, 1907–1914), via Wikisource. Public domain. Matched by name and feast date; text unedited except for our bracketed notes in grey.

Retold in plain modern English from Baring-Gould’s public-domain text, sentence by sentence, keeping the same facts and order. Short explanations in parentheses are ours.

From Sabine Baring-Gould, The Lives of the Saints, new edition in 16 vols. (London: John C. Nimmo, 1897–98); text from the Internet Archive scan (OCR, lightly cleaned; errors possible). Public domain in the United States. Reproduced unedited, except for short bracketed notes in grey that we added to explain names and terms (“S.” is the old abbreviation for Saint). Some history and judgments reflect 19th-century scholarship.

Notes

Story retold in our own words from the cited sources.