This Saint’s Story
The Catholic Encyclopedia places his consecration on 12 May 254 and his death on 2 August 257, while acknowledging some uncertainty in the chronology. Ancient catalogues call him a Roman and the son of Jovius. Baring-Gould begins his account with Lucius's death in 253; the Encyclopedia's chronology places Stephen's accession a year later.
His pontificate is remembered especially for the dispute over baptism administered outside the Church's communion. Stephen defended its validity; Cyprian of Carthage and other bishops in Africa and Asia maintained that those entering the Church should be baptized anew. Baring-Gould explains Stephen's position in terms of the right matter and words. He also emphasizes that Stephen's own letters are lost, so accounts of his conduct come from opponents.
Baring-Gould describes the bitter exchanges, the refusal to receive Cyprian's envoys, and African councils which upheld their own judgment. The Encyclopedia treats Stephen's defence of baptism as his most important work and judges his position correct. Read together, the accounts distinguish the doctrinal question from the harsh language and strained relations through which the controversy unfolded. Baring-Gould says its immediate conclusion is unknown and that discussion continued under Stephen's successor.
Other disputes brought Stephen and Cyprian into correspondence. Cyprian urged action against Marcian of Arles for denying communion to penitent Christians who had fallen in persecution. In Spain, Basilides and Martial appealed against their deposition. The Encyclopedia says Stephen supported restoration after being misled about the facts; an African council renewed their condemnation. It also records Stephen's practical charity towards needy communities in Syria and Arabia.
Baring-Gould counts Stephen among the first victims of Valerian's persecution. The Encyclopedia is more cautious: although the later papal biography calls his death a martyrdom, the evidence is generally considered doubtful. Both accounts place his death on 2 August 257 and his burial in the cemetery of Callistus. His body was subsequently transferred by Pope Paul I to a monastery founded in his honour.
