Li. pages 30-36, are completely unhistorical. Another Life attributed to Bishop Warmann of Constance (who died in 1034) by Mabillon, and to Othlo of Surius, is found in Vit SS. Nov. 3, pages 140-153. “This is rather a dangerous will-o’-the-wisp for the historical student than a true source of historical facts,” according to Potthast. A third, metrical Life, probably by Abbot Heinrich of Reichenau (who died in 1234), is included in Mone's Quellensammlung, volume i, pages 39-45.
The biographers of Saint Pirminus say that he established his seat at Meltis. Therefore, the Roman Breviary commemorates him today as the bishop of Meaux (Meldae). However, he is also counted among the bishops of Metz (Metae). The Gallican Martyrology states: “At Metz, Saint Pirminus, bishop, who was raised to this seat after having distinguished himself in Germany, alongside Saint Boniface, by performing all apostolic functions. His miracles still make his tomb famous, and his green dalmatic and the cord with which he was girded for the sacred mysteries are very helpful during childbirth. It is believed that Saint Pirminus, bishop of Meaux, is the same person as this one.” However, there was never a Pirminus who served as bishop of Metz, just as there was none by that name at Meaux. Paul Wamefried wrote a book on the succession of the bishops of Metz in 783, and he does not mention Pirminus. If he had been bishop twenty-five years earlier, he certainly would not have been omitted. Furthermore, the see of Metz was held between 743 and 766 by the notable Chrodegang, who was preceded by Saint Sigibald. The name Pirminus does not appear in any accurate list of the bishops of Meaux.
Hermann the Cripple, a reliable source who wrote in the middle of the 11th century, states, under the date 724: “Saint Pirminus, abbot and rural bishop, was brought by the princes Berchthold and Vehi to Charles (Martel), who appointed him to the island of Reichenau, from which he expelled the serpents and established monastic life there for three years.”
He seems to have been a regional bishop without a fixed see, and it was likely the ignorance of his biographer that placed him among the bishops of Metz, if Metz was meant by Meldis. Chastelain, however, believes that Medlin, on the borders of the diocese of Treves, is intended; others think it refers to some now-unknown location.
Sintlaz, a chief in the area near Lake Constance, granted him the beautiful green island of Reichenau, located in the lower arm of the lake or Zeller See, where he founded the abbey of Reichenau. The story goes that he made a pilgrimage to Rome but was treated with disrespect by the Pope. Pirminus went to the tomb of the apostles, set his staff on the pavement beside him, and it remained balanced on its point without falling. The Pope, witnessing this miracle, regretted his rude reception of the stranger.
The accounts of this saint's life are so unreliable that it is not wise to say much about him, except that he is believed to have founded many monasteries. Altaich, Pfeffers, Murbach, Schutterau on the Rhine, in the diocese of Strassburg, Gegenbach, Schwarzheim, Weissenburg, Neuwyler, Maurmunster, Mansee, Pfaffenmünster, and Horenbach all claim Pirminus as their founder. It is highly unlikely that this is true. Horenbach is located on the borders of the dioceses of Trèves and Metz, and it is there that he died and was buried. A book of his, “Libellum de singulis libris canonicis,” contains some interesting notes about the superstitions of his time.
Footnotes
- Hermann the Cripple was a reliable source from the 11th century.
- Chrodegang was a notable bishop of Metz.
- Treves is a historical region in present-day France.
- Libellum de singulis libris canonicis: A work discussing canonical books and related superstitions.
Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.
Read the original 1870s text
Li. p. 30-36, utterly unhistorical. Another Life attributed by Mabillon to Bishop Warmann of Constance (d. 1034), and by Surius to Othlo of Surius, Vit SS. Nov. 3, p. 140 153. “Rather a dangerous will-o’-thewisp for the historical student than a true source of historical fafts,” Potthast. A third, metrical Life, probably by Abbot Heinrich of Reichenau (d. 1234), in Mone, Quellensammlung, i. p. 39-45.] The biographers of S. Pirminus say that he placed his seat at Meltis. Accordingly the Roman Breviary commemorates him this day as bishop of Meaux (Meldae). But he i$ also reckoned among the bishops of Metz (Metae). The Gallican Martyrology says: — " At Metz, S. Pirminus, bishop, who was raised to this seat after having rendered himself illustrious in Germany, with S. Boniface [English missionary to Germany, martyred 754], by the exercise of all apostolic functions. His miracles still render his tomb famous, and his green dalmatic and the cord with which he was girded for the sacred mysteries, are of great help in the pains of parturition. It is thought that S. Pirminus, bishop of Meaux, is not different from this one.” There never was, however, a Pirminus, bishop of Metz, any more than there was one of this name at Meaux. Paul Wamefried composed a book on the succession of the bishops of Metz in 783, and he makes no mention of Pirminus. Had he been bishop twenty-five years before, he certainly would not have been excluded. Moreover, the see of Metz [a bishop’s “see” is his diocese, named from his seat (Latin sedes)] was filled between 743 and 766 by the illustrious Chrodegang, who was preceded by S. Sigibald. The name of Pirminus does not occur in any correct list of the bishops of Meaux.
Hermann the Cripple, a good authority, who wrote in the middle of the 11th century, says, under date 724: “Saint Pirminus, abbot and bishop-rural, was led by the princes Berchthold and Vehi to Charles (Martel), and by him appointed to the island of Reichenau, whence he expelled the serpents, and instituted therein during three years the monastic life.”
He seems to have been regionary bishop, without fixed see, and it was only the ignorance of his biographer which planted him among the bishops of Metz, if Metz were intended by Meldis. Chastelain, however, thinks Medlin, on the confines of the diocese of Trèves, is meant; others suppose some spot now unknown.
Sintlaz, a chief in the neighbourhood of the Lake of Constance, gave him the lovely green island of Reichenau, lying in the lower arm of the Lake or Zeller See, and there he founded the abbey of Reichenau. The story goes that he paid a visit of devotion to Rome, but was treated with contempt by the Pope. Pirminus went to the tomb of the apostles, and set his staff on the pavement at his side, and it remained balanced on its point without falling. The Pope, seeing this marvel, regretted his discourteous reception of the stranger.
The lives of this saint are so untrustworthy that it is not advisable to state much concerning him, except that he is said to have founded a host of monasteries. Altaich, Pfeffers, Murbach, Schutterau on the Rhine, in the diocese of Strassburg, Gegenbach, Schwarzheim, Weissenburg, Neuwyler, Maurmunster, Mansee, Pfaffenmiinster, and Horenbach, all claim Pirminus as their founder. It is exceedingly improbable that this should be so. Horenbach is on the confines of the dioceses of Trèves and Metz, and there he died and was buried. A book of his, “ Libellum de singulis libris canonicis,” contains some curious notices of the superstitions of his day..S'. EnglcU.