This Saint’s Story
The official notice is short: it records that his name designates a cardinal’s title at the church of Saint Pudentiana on the Viminal hill. That liturgical footprint is the firmest early witness that Rome kept a priest Pastor in its calendar.
Later legend, rehearsed by Sabine Baring-Gould from Anastasius Bibliothecarius and the Acts (the written account of a martyr's trial and death) of Saints Pudentiana and Praxedes, weaves him into the second-century Roman cycle. In that tradition Pastor is called the brother of Pope Saint Pius I; a letter attributed to Pius says the priest Pastor built a title church and worthily fell asleep in the Lord. The same Acts give him a role beside Pudentiana and Praxedes in instructing the household of Pudens and caring for persecuted Christians—yet Baring-Gould notes that the Pastor letter in those Acts is not genuine.
Historians therefore separate the martyrology’s simple Roman priest from the fuller romance. What the July feast retains is the figure of a Roman priest whose name meant “shepherd,” honored in the title of Pudentiana and remembered for faith and pastoral care, even where the extended Acts remain in the realm of sacred legend.


