His mother lived with him in Medina and sent him to the Jesuit College there to be educated, probably intending for him to join the Church. The administrator of the hospital involved the young man in caring for the sick, and John spent all his free time nursing the patients in the hospital with great enthusiasm, patience, and kindness.
When he turned twenty-one, he took on the Carmelite habit at Medina, fully believing that the Blessed Virgin was the special patroness of this Order. The Carmelite Order was founded by Blessed Albert, the Latin patriarch of Jerusalem, in 1209. He established a community of hermits on Mount Carmel and claimed to have seen Elijah in a vision, who urged him to continue and develop the old school of prophets that had previously been established there. The Carmelites tried to convince themselves and others that their Order had never ceased since the time of Elijah. They adopted a mantle striped black and white, claiming that it was modeled after the cloak of Elijah, which he cast off as he ascended into heaven and gave to Elisha as the habit of his Order. They believed that the mantle, originally white, had been scorched by the wheels of the flaming chariot, which is how the stripes originated. Either the Order was ridiculed for this claim or concluded that the entire mantle was scorched, but it is certain that they abandoned the striped habit for one that was entirely dark.
John Yepez, having joined this Order, was sent to Salamanca to study theology. He subjected himself to extreme and distressing self-denial. He made a trough out of boards, resembling a coffin, and slept in it in a cell at the end of the dormitory. He fasted and wore rough sackcloth against his skin, which caused sores. He felt unworthy of becoming a regular member of the society and begged to be allowed to remain only a lay brother; however, his superiors did not heed his request, and he was ordained a priest when he turned twenty-five. He prepared for his first Mass by subjecting himself to further mortifications, viewing every suffering he inflicted on his body as a pleasing offering to the God of love and compassion. The Carmelite rule no longer satisfied his desire for extreme self-denial at the age of twenty-five, and after a short time in the Order, he considered transferring his allegiance to another Order, that of the Carthusians.
But at that time he met Saint Theresa, who was engaged in a reform of the Carmelite Order. The meeting took place at Medina del Campo. She set herself to work to dissuade him from entering the Carthusian Order and to persuade him to work with her on the reform of the Order of Our Lady of Mount Carmel. She told him that she was authorized by the general to establish two houses for men and that he was undoubtedly chosen by God to assist her in this holy work. Not long after, in 1568, when he was twenty-six years old, he took up his residence in the small house Saint Theresa had obtained at Durvello.
Before taking this decisive step, Saint Theresa took Saint John of the Cross with her from his monastery to Valladolid so that he could see the foundation of one of her convents there. While working with the laborers to direct the alterations and additions that had to be made before the house could be adapted for use as a nunnery, she described to John of the Cross the life led by the nuns, including their mortifications, amusements, and style of conversation. Immediately after the convent was completed and occupied, “we arranged,” says Saint Theresa, “that Father John de la Cruz should go to the house at Durvello and prepare it in such a way that he might be able to enter it as he desired, for I made all haste to have a beginning because I was greatly afraid some obstacle might come in the way, and so the business was done.”
Father Antonio (of Jesus, the former Prior of Saint Anne’s, Medina) had already collected a few necessary items, and we helped as well as we could, which was not much. He came to speak to me at Valladolid and was full of joy, telling me what he had provided, which was scanty, but how he had gathered five hourglasses, which made me laugh heartily. He told me that since he wished to keep the exact hours, he did not want to be unprepared. I think they did not yet have a place to sleep in. There was little delay in fitting up the house, for although they wished to make several alterations, they had no money. After this, Father Antonio willingly renounced his priorship and took the vows of the First Rule. Although I told him to try it at first, he would not, but went to the little house with the greatest content in the world. Father John (of the Cross) was already there. To neither of them did the house seem inconvenient; rather, they imagined that they lived amidst great delights.
O my God! how little do such buildings and exterior delights contribute to interior joy! On the first or second Sunday in Advent (I do not remember which), in the year 1568, the first Mass was said in that little portal of Bethlehem, for no better name did it seem to merit. The following Lent, as I was going to the foundation of a convent at Toledo, I passed by it and came there one morning while Father Antonio de Jesus was sweeping the door of the church, with a cheerful countenance, as he always had. I said to him, “What is this, father? What has become of your dignity?” He replied, “I consider that time badly spent when I was in the enjoyment of honor.”
When I went into the church, I was astonished to see the spirit our Lord had produced there; and not only I, but two merchants who were friends of mine and had come with me from Medina, could do nothing but weep, so many crosses and skulls were there. Never shall I forget one little wooden cross, which was placed over the holy-water stoup, to which was fastened a paper Christ, and which produced more devotion than if it had been a crucifix very elaborately carved. The loft served as the choir, which was high in the middle so that they could recite the Hours; but to enter it in order to hear Mass, they had to stoop very low. They made two little hermitages on each side of the church, where they could only sit or lie down, and filled them with hay because the place was cold; their heads almost touched the roof.
Towards the altar were two little windows, and two stones served as pillows; here also were crosses and skulls. I understood that after the singing of Matins, they returned to their cells, not to sleep, but to continue in prayer, an exercise which they enjoyed to a high degree. It happened many times that when they went to say Prime, they found their habits covered with snow, and they had not noticed it falling on them, so absorbed were they in prayer. They recited the Hours with another father of the relaxed rule, who came to live with them, though he did not change his habit, being of a weak constitution. Another young religious man lived with them as well, not in holy orders.
They went about preaching in many neighboring places, where the people were very ignorant, so I am glad in this respect that the house was erected in a spot so far from any monastery, from which the people could get instruction. In a short time, the two fathers gained such a great reputation that when I heard of it, it gave me the greatest consolation. They went to preach six or eight miles away, barefoot, for they wore no sandals then, although afterwards they were commanded to wear them. They went in the midst of cold and snow, and when they had finished preaching and hearing confessions, they returned very late to their meal, but with such joy that all their sufferings seemed little to them.
As for food, they had enough, for the people in all the neighborhood provided them with a surplus. Some gentlemen who came to the church for confession offered them better houses and better locations. Among them was one Don Luis, lord of five villas; this gentleman had built a church for a picture of Our Lady, which was indeed worthy of veneration. His father had sent it from Flanders to his grandmother or mother (I forget which), in the care of a merchant, who became so fond of it that he kept it for many years, but on his deathbed commanded it to be restored to the rightful owner. It is a large picture, and in my whole life, I have not seen a better; and others say the same.
Father Antonio de Jesus, having gone there at the gentleman’s request, was so taken with the picture that he agreed to found a monastery there. The place is called Mancera. The gentleman built a small house for them, suitable to their profession, and provided them with furniture and many other things. When I saw this little house, which a short time before could not be inhabited, endowed with such a spirit that wherever I turned I found something to edify me; and when I understood the manner of living of the fathers and the good example they set, I could not sufficiently thank the Lord, so excessive was my interior joy, for I thought I already saw a foundation laid for the great increase of our Order and the service of the Lord. The merchants who traveled with me told me that they would not for all the world have neglected going there. What power there is in virtue! They were more pleased with that poverty than with all the riches they possessed, and their minds were greatly edified.
“After these fathers and I had discussed certain matters, I earnestly asked them not to punish themselves with such excessive rigor. It had taken me so much prayer and desire to find such individuals to start the work that I was afraid the devil might find a way to bring them to their graves before the work was fully completed. Being so imperfect, I did not believe their actions were truly the work of God, and that His Majesty could strengthen them to carry on. However, they, being endowed with the virtues that I lacked, ignored my words and continued their self-mortifications.”
Father Antonio and Father John of the Cross stayed together at Durvello the following year, 1569, when the Princess of Eboli, mistress of Philip II, and her husband Ruy Gomez, established a nunnery and a monastery of Discalced Carmelites at Pastrana. Father Antonio was moved from Durvello to become the head of the friars there. Father John of the Cross remained at Durvello. He faced much external and internal trouble. The reform was attacked by enemies, and its members were seen as runaways from their Order, and possibly as infected with heresy. His soul was also troubled with deep bouts of depression, during which he felt that the face of God was turned away from him, a state of spiritual misery that he expressed movingly in his book titled “Noche obscura del Alma” (The Dark Night of the Soul).
The difficulties at Durvello, along with the offer of the house and Flemish picture at Mancera, led to the transfer of the monastery there in 1570. Since then, there has been considerable rivalry between the houses of Pastrana and Mancera over which should be considered the mother house. Pastrana was founded before Mancera, but Mancera was the community from the monastery of Durvello moving to a more suitable location. Durvello, having been abandoned, returned to the estates of the donor. However, in 1612, the Discalced Carmelites, regretting their abandonment of the house where their reform began, bought it back.
In 1570, John of the Cross was sent to Pastrana to take charge of the new house. He found there fourteen members gathered by S. Theresa and Father Antonio; of these, ten were novices and four were professed friars.
In 1571, he was moved from Pastrana to take charge of a new house founded at Alcala. However, his successor at Pastrana, due to his excessive strictness, caused the novices to become insubordinate, and S. John was quickly recalled to restore order to the troubled community.
In the same year, or at the beginning of the next, S. Theresa urgently called S. John of the Cross to help her in Avila. The Apostolic Visitor of the Carmelites in Castile had appointed her as the prioress of her old Convent of the Incarnation. She had escaped from this convent nine years earlier with a group of nuns to start her reform.
This appointment faced significant opposition from the nuns, the people of Avila, and the town's magistrates. The Convent of the Incarnation had been a popular place for ladies and gentlemen who enjoyed afternoon gossip. The nuns were always willing to visit and spend time with friends and relatives when they grew tired of the routine of cloister life. As S. Theresa's memoirs show, they were not entirely opposed to a little flirtation, as long as it was done discreetly. The Visitor decided that "all this must be altered," and S. Theresa was the right person to reform the relaxed convent. It is no surprise that she faced opposition. She had to call for S. John of the Cross to help her in her battle against both open and hidden hostility.
The anger and jealousy of the Carmelite Order towards the innovators, or rather reformers, could not be expressed as long as Saint Theresa and her followers had the support of a papal nuncio and the king. The king, although a man of extreme moral laxity, was also deeply devoted to those who practiced asceticism. However, in 1575, the Grand Chapter of the Order in Spain passed decrees against the Discalced Carmelites. The General of the Order sent Father Geronimo Tostado to Spain as his Visitor to urge the king to suppress the reform, which he viewed as a schism, and not without reason.
At this time, the papal nuncio who had supported Saint Theresa unfortunately died and was replaced by another who disapproved of her work. In 1577, the Carmelite Visitor, Father Tostado, gathered a group of soldiers and forcibly entered the house where Saint John of the Cross lived. He seized John and took him to Toledo, where he was brutally beaten and thrown into a dark dungeon. The only light that entered this dungeon came through a small hole three fingers wide. He was kept in filthy conditions, wearing rags, and was starved by the Carmelite superior for nine months. His health deteriorated so severely that the religious felt ashamed and compelled to release him, fearing he might die from their mistreatment.
He was sent to a miserable convent of Calvary, located in the countryside. Despite the challenges faced by the Discalced, they were not completely eradicated. Philip II took them under his protection, and in 1579, John was able to establish a monastery in Baeza. In 1581, he became the prior of a reformed Carmelite house in Granada. By 1585, he was appointed Vicar-provincial of Andalusia, and in 1588, he became the first definitor of the Order.
His strict practices went beyond what was reasonable or moderate. He slept for only two or three hours each night and spent the rest of the night in prayer or dozing. In the semi-devotional, semi-somnolent state in which he knelt, he — as one might expect — experienced all sorts of visions and waking dreams, created by a mind deprived of natural rest. These visions were generally uplifting in nature — at least, those he shared with his fellow monks were.
In one of these dreams, he thought he heard Christ ask him, “John, what reward do you seek for your labors?" He replied, “None, Lord, except that I may suffer and be condemned for Your love." He often said, “To suffer for the sake of God is the true sign of His love, as we see in Christ and in the martyrs. Persecutions are the means by which we can delve into the depths or gain knowledge of the mystery of the cross, which is essential for understanding the depth of God's wisdom and love."
His greatest ambition was to be miserable. He frequently prayed for three things to happen to him. First, that he might not go a single day without suffering something. Second, that he might not die as a Superior (a leader in a religious order). Third, that he might end his life in humiliation, disgrace, and contempt. Those who came to consult him often found him in a dazed, half-conscious state due to lack of sleep, but they believed it was the bewilderment of a soul recovering from ecstasy. Many people with vivid imaginations claimed they had seen his face shine with a supernatural light. One woman, it is said, was so moved by this illumination when she approached him for confession that she gave up her jewels and dedicated herself to a religious life. The only furnishings in his cell were a rush cross with a paper figure of Christ attached to it.
His understanding of his own state while praying when he should have been asleep allowed him to evaluate the value of visions that appeared to other people in the same situation. He was able to tell them that what they considered Divine manifestations were often just waking dreams. His firm opinion on visions is that they should be rejected. “These imaginary visions and other supernatural impressions to which the senses are subject without the assent of the will, I maintain should be avoided and not dwelt on by the soul, upon all occasions and at all times, whether in the perfect or in beginners.”
He states that spiritual directors have caused great harm by encouraging their penitents to develop a habit of seeking visions. “There are some spiritual directors who fall into error because their instructions to those who are liable to visions are such as to lead them astray or perplex them. They allow their penitents to place too much importance on their visions, and by doing so, they fail to strengthen them in faith. This kind of guidance shows that they themselves consider visions to be important matters, and their penitents, observing this, follow their example and focus on these dreams instead of strengthening their faith. This is the inevitable result of the language and actions of spiritual directors; for, somehow, a certain sense of satisfaction arises from these things, which distracts from the depth of faith that one should be contemplating. The penitent, finding the confessor very appreciative of them, is also encouraged to exaggerate them, indulge in them, give in to them, and hold them in high regard. This kind of direction is the source of many imperfections, to say the least, for the soul. It causes the soul to lose humility and become self-satisfied; and the devil is quick to encourage this.” With strong common sense, he argues that visions, even if they seem to come from God, are very likely to deceive, and therefore, the less attention paid to them, the better.
John of the Cross was a vernacular poet of considerable talent. The poem he wrote as the text for his “Dark Night,” modeled after the aubades of the Troubadours, deserves to be ranked alongside the romantic works of Bertrand de Born and Giraud de Borneil. It has a counterpart in the aubade “En un vergier” by an unknown troubadour. It does not fall short of the graceful little piece in its poetic power or in the sensuality of the imagery it presents. A religious person reading the “Dark Night” may find themselves distracted from the austere realms of ascetic theology by the passionate and sensual imaginings evoked by this inappropriate yet very beautiful poem. John takes the first two verses and explains them mystically, line by line. They depict a maiden eloping at night down a ladder from her house while everyone inside is asleep, to meet her lover, who is hiding in a grove for her. John refrains from explaining the last six verses, which describe the meeting; he would have been better off not writing them at all. The poem titled the “Spiritual Canticle between the Soul and Christ” is based on the Song of Solomon. The “Living Flame of Love” describes the human passion of a mistress for her lover, whom she has allowed into her chamber, and can be compared to one of Herrick’s most passionate compositions. However, it carries a completely different meaning when interpreted by a mystic who is unfamiliar with earthly passion.
It is unfortunate that Saint John of the Cross, who had such good judgment regarding visions, encouraged rather than restrained the sentimental love of Christ in nuns. This sentiment has led some emotionally unstable individuals to dangerous extremes.
Saint John disliked the practice of dressing images of the saints with artificial hair, jewels, lace, velvet, and satin gowns. “There are people,” he says, “who waste that inner devotion which should be spiritually directed to the invisible saint on displays of affection and curiosity towards the image, and all love and joy stop there. This is a significant obstacle to true spirituality.”
This is clearly evident in that distasteful custom observed by some. As noted in the Diary of Blessed Marie de l'Incarnation: “When going to prayer, I would tremble within myself and say: Let us go into solitude, my dear love, so that I can embrace You freely, and that, breathing my soul into You, I may become nothing but You through the union of love. Then, my body being worn out from fatigue, I was forced to say: My divine love, I ask You to let me take a little rest, so that I may serve You better, since You want me to live. I begged Him to let me act, promising to let myself be consumed in His chaste and divine embraces afterward. Oh love! When will I embrace You? Do You not have pity on me in the torment I suffer? Alas! Alas! My love, my beauty, my life! Instead of healing me, You delight in my pains. Come then, let me embrace You, and let me die in Your sacred arms!”
Some students of Marie de l'Incarnation also experienced mystical marriages with Christ. One of them, whose passionate rhapsodies were overheard, nearly lost her reputation because it was thought she was addressing an earthly lover. Is it any wonder that Saint Christina and Saint Rose of Lima, in these unhealthy conditions of mixed sexual and religious fervor, believed they had received favors that no longer left them virgins?
Nowadays, certain people, instead of rejecting the vanities of the world, decorate sacred images with the fashionable clothing of the time, created for the sake of indulgent entertainment. They dress the images in garments that are inappropriate when worn by themselves, and which the saints would certainly have detested. As a result, all modest and genuine devotion in such individuals disappears, making way for an excessive decoration of images, to which they cling and on which they base all their joys. You see people who are never tired of adding image to image; they hold onto their images just as Micah did to his idols, who, when he lost them, ran out of his house crying because they had been taken away.
“When many people go on a pilgrimage,” he says elsewhere, “I would advise staying at home, for in general, men return from pilgrimages more dissipated than they were before. Many become pilgrims for recreation more than for devotion.”
In 1591, the Reformed Carmelite Order split into factions. John of the Cross was removed from his positions and sent to the isolated monastery of Penguela, located in the Sierra Morena mountains. Some members of the order whom he had forbidden to preach when he was provincial of Andalusia became his main accusers and enemies. One of them, Father Diego Evangelista, spread ugly rumors about his behavior, which he likely viewed as irrational, and he was accused of heresy. He found himself abandoned by everyone. Those who received his letters burned them to avoid being associated with his disgrace. John of the Cross was ordered to leave Penguela and go to Baeza or Ubeda. He chose the latter. He had been suffering from ulcers for some time. The strain of his journey caused these ulcers to burst and discharge. The prior treated him with great cruelty, forbidding anyone from visiting him, locking him in a tiny cell, denying him necessary food, and dismissing the infirmarer for showing him compassion. Sectarian envy and malice seemed to have extinguished the basic instincts of humanity in the heart of the holy prior Francis Chrysostom of Ubeda.
Fortunately, the provincial came that way, and when he discovered how cruelly the sick and dying man had been treated by his fellow religious brothers, he scolded the prior harshly. Two hours before John died, he recited the Miserere (a penitential psalm) with his brothers. Then he asked one of them to read to him part of the book of Canticles (Song of Songs), and during the reading, he appeared to be filled with joy. He finally cried out, “Glory be to God!” He pressed the crucifix to his chest, and after some time, he said, “Lord, into Your hands I commend my spirit.” With these words, he peacefully breathed his last on December 14, 1591, at the age of forty-nine years, of which he had spent twenty-eight in religious life. Theresa of Ávila, in her letters, refers to him as a saint even before he joined her reformed Order. She states that he was one of the purest souls in the Church, to whom God had revealed great treasures of light, and whose understanding He had filled with the knowledge of the saints.
Footnotes
- Blessed Albert: Latin patriarch of Jerusalem who founded the Carmelite Order.
- Saint Theresa, “Book of the Foundations,” chapter 12.
- S. Theresa, “Book of the Foundations,” c. 13.
- The Grand Chapter of the Order in Spain passed decrees against the Discalced Carmelites.
- The only light that entered this dungeon came through a small hole three fingers wide.
- He was sent to a miserable convent of Calvary, located in the countryside.
- “Ascent of Mount Carmel," b. ii. c. 17.
- John of the Cross was a Spanish mystic and poet.
- Herrick was a 17th-century English poet known for his lyrical poetry.
- As the following, from the Diary of the B. Marie de l'Incarnation: — “When going to prayer, I would tremble within myself and say: Let us go into solitude, my dear love, so that I can embrace You freely, and that, breathing my soul into You, I may become nothing but You through the union of love. Then, my body being worn out from fatigue, I was forced to say: My divine love, I ask You to let me take a little rest, so that I may serve You better, since You want me to live. I begged Him to let me act, promising to let myself be consumed in His chaste and divine embraces afterward. Oh love! When will I embrace You? Do You not have pity on me in the torment I suffer? Alas! Alas! My love, my beauty, my life! Instead of healing me, You delight in my pains. Come then, let me embrace You, and let me die in Your sacred arms!”
- John of the Cross was a prominent Spanish mystic and poet.
- Micah is a biblical figure known for his idolatry in the Book of Judges.
- The Reformed Carmelite Order is a branch of the Carmelite religious order.
- Ubeda and Baeza are towns in Spain.
- Miserere: a penitential psalm.
- Canticles: Song of Songs, a book in the Bible.
Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.
Read the original 1870s text
Baring-Gould’s sources: Roman Martyrology. Canonized by Benedict XIII. in 1726, when his office was appointed for Nov. 24, though he died on Dec. 14. Authorities: — A Life by F. Honoratus a Santa Maria; another by F. Dositheus a S. Alexis, Paris, 1727.] S. John of the Cross was born at Fontibere, near Avila, in Old Castile, in the year 1542. His family name was Yepez, and he was the son of Gonzales di Yepez and of Catharine Alvarez. His father died whilst he was still young, and he was left to the care of a mother, who instructed him from earliest infancy to turn to Mary as the fountain of solace and salvation. Consequently throughout life he manifested the most tender, unquestioning devotion to the Blessed Virgin, and was constantly in the humour to believe himself the object of her special favour.
His mother lived with him at Medina, and sent him to the Jesuit College, there to be instructed in letters, probably intending him for the Church. The administrator of the hospital associated the young man with him in the care of the sick, and John spent all his leisure in nursing the patients in the hospital with the utmost zeal, patience, and gentleness.
When he had attained the age of twenty-one, he assumed S. John of the Cross. the Carmelite habit at Medina, fully believing the Blessed Virgin to be the special patroness of this Order. The Carmelite Order was founded by B. Albert, Latin patriarch [the title of the bishops of the great ancient sees: Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, Jerusalem] of Jerusalem, in 1209, who founded a community of hermits on Mount Carmel, and pretended that he had seen Elijah in vision, who urged him to continue and develop his old school of the prophets formerly established there. The Carmelites endeavoured to convince themselves and the world that their Order had never ceased since the time of Elijah, and adopted a mantle striped black and white, asserting that this was fashioned after the cloak of Elijah which he cast from him as he ascended into heaven, and gave to Elisha as the habit of his Order, and that the mantle, originally white, had been scorched by the flaming chariot wheels, and thus originated these bars. Either the Order was laughed out of this pretence, or had come to the conclusion that the whole mantle was scorched, but certain it is, that it abandoned its striped habit for one entirely dark. John Yepez having entered this Order, was sent to Salamanca to go through a course of theology. He gave himself up to singular and distressing mortifications. He made for himself a trough of boards like a coffin, and slept in it in a cell at the end of the dormitory. He fasted, and wore a rough sackcloth next his skin, which rubbed sores in it. He affected unworthiness to become a regular member ot the society, and entreated to be allowed to be only a lay brother; but his superiors would not listen to his appeal, and he was ordained priest when he had attained the age of twenty-five. He prepared himself for his first Mass by subjecting himself to fresh mortifications, regarding every torture to which he subjected his body as a savoury oblation in the nostrils of the God of love and compassion. The Carmelite rule no longer satisfied the hunger after excessive self-immolation in this advanced ascetic of fiveand-twenty. and after a brief sojourn in the Order, he meditated transferring his valuable allegiance to another, that of the Carthusians [a strict order of hermit-monks founded by St. Bruno in 1084].
But at that time he met S. Theresa, who Avas engaged on a reform of the Carmelite Order. The meeting took place at Medina del Campo. She set herself to work to dissuade him from entering the Carthusian Order, and to persuade him to Avork Avith her at the reform of the Order of Our Lady of Mount Cannel. She told him that she Avas authorized by the general to found two houses for men, and that he Avas undoubtedly chosen by God to assist her in this holy work. Not long after, in 1568, Avhen he Avas aged twenty-six, he took up his residence in the little house S. Theresa had obtained at Durvello. But before taking this decided step, S. Theresa carried off S. John of the Cross with her, from his monastery to Valladolid, that he might see the foundation of one of her convents there; and Avhile engaged with the Avorkmen directing the alterations and additions that had to be made before the house could be adapted to the purposes of a nunnery, she described to John of the Cross the life led by the nuns, their mortifications, amusements, and their style of conversation.1 Immediately after the convent was completed and taken possession of, “ Ave arranged,” says S. Theresa, “ that Father John de la Cruz should go to the house (at Durvello), and prepare it in such a Avay that he might be able to enter it as he desired, for I made all haste to have a beginning, because I Avas greatly afraid some obstacle might come in the Avay, and so the business was done. Father Antonio (of Jesus, late Prior of S. Anne’s, Medina), had already collected a feAV things that Avere necessary, and Ave helped as Avell as Ave could, which Avas but little. He came to speak to me at Valladolid, and Avas full of joy, telling me AA’hat he had prc1 S. Theresa, “ Book of the Foundations,” c. 12. vided, which was scanty, but how he had got together five hour-glasses, which made me laugh heartily. He told me that as he wished to keep the exact hours, he did not wish to go unprovided. I think they had, as yet, no place to sleep in. There was little delay in fitting up the house, for though they wished to make several alterations, they had no money. After this, Father Antonio renounced his priorship with great willingness, and took the vows of the First Rule; and though I told him to try it at first, yet he would not, but went to the little house with the greatest content in the world. Father John (of the Cross) was there already. To neither of them did the house appear inconvenient, but rather they imagined that they lived amidst great delights. O my God ! how little do such buildings and exterior delights contribute to interior joy ! On the first or second Sunday in Advent (I do not remember which), in the year 1568, the first mass was said in that little portal of Bethlehem, for no better name did it appear to me to merit. The following Lent [the forty days of fasting before Easter], as I was going to the foundation of a convent at Toledo, I passed by it, and came there one morning while Father Antonio de Jesus was sweeping the door of the church, with a cheerful countenance, such as he always has. I said to him, 4 What is this, father ? what has become of your dignity ? ’ He replied, ‘ I consider that time badly spent when I was in the enjoyment ot honour/ When I went into the church I was astonished to see the spirit our Lord had produced there; and not only I myself but two merchants also, friends of mine, who had come with me from Medina, did nothing but weep, so many crosses and skulls were there. Never shall I forget one little wooden cross, which was placed over the holy-water stoup, to which was fastened a paper Christ, and which produced more devotion than if it had been a crucifix very elaborately carved. The garret formed the choir, which was high towards the middle, so that they could recite the Hours; but to enter it in order to hear mass, they were obliged to stoop very low. They made two little hermitages on each side of the church, where they could only sit or lie down, and filled inside with hay, because the place was cold; their heads almost touched the roof. Towards the altar were two little windows, and two stones served for pillows: here also were crosses and skulls. I understood that after the singing of Matins [the night prayer of the Divine Office], they returned to their cells, not to sleep, but to continue in prayer, an exercise which they enjoy to a high degree. It happened many times that when they went to say Prime, they found their habits covered with snow, and they had not perceived it falling on them, so absorbed were they in prayer. They recited the Hours with another father of the relaxed rule, who came to live with them, though he did not change his habit, being of a weak constitution. Another religious young man lived with them also, not in holy orders [ordination; “orders” means the sacrament by which deacons, priests and bishops are ordained]. They went about preaching in many neighbouring places, where the people were very ignorant, so that I am glad in this respect that the house was erected in a spot so far from any monastery, whence the people could get instruction. In a short time the two fathers gained so great a reputation, that, when I heard of it, it gave me the greatest consolation. They went to preach six or eight miles off, bare foot, for they wore no sandals then, though afterwards they were commanded to wear them. They went in the midst of cold and snow, and when they had finished preaching and confessing, they returned very late to their meal, but with such joy, that all their sufferings seemed but little to them. As for food, they had sufficient, for the people in all the neighbourhood provided them with a superfluity. Some gentlemen who came to the church to confession, offered them better houses and better situations. Among them was one Don Luis, lord of five villas; this gentleman had built a church for a picture of Our Lady, worthy indeed of veneration. His father had sent it from Flanders to his grandmother or mother (I forget which), in the care of a merchant, who became so fond of it that he kept it for many years, but on his deathbed commanded it to be restored to the rightful owner. It is a large picture, and in my whole life I have not seen a better; and others say the same. Father Antonio de Jesus having gone there at the gentleman’s request, was so taken with the picture that he consented to found a monastery there. The place is called Mancera. The gentleman built a small house for them, suitable to their profession, and gave them furniture and many other things. When I saw this little house, which a short time before could not be inhabited, endowed with such a spirit that wherever I turned I found something to edify me; and when I understood the manner of living of the fathers, and the good example they set, I could not sufficiently thank the Lord, so excessive was my interior joy, for I thought I already saw a foundation laid for the great increase of our Order and the service of the Lord. The merchants who passed along with me told me that they would not for all the world have neglected going there. What power there is in virtue ! they were more pleased with that poverty than with all the riches they possessed, and. their minds were thereby greatly edified.
“After these fathers and myself had spoken about certain matters, I earnestly requested them not to mortify themselves with such excessive rigour, for since it had cost me so much prayer and desire to obtain such persons to begin the work, I was afraid lest the devil should find means of bringing them to their graves before the work was fully completed; and being so imperfect, I did not consider their proceedings to be the work of God, and that His Majesty could strengthen them to go through with them. But they being endowed with those virtues which I lacked, took no notice oi my words, and continued their self-mortifications.” 1 Father Antonio, and Father John of the Cross, remained 1 S. Theresa, “ Book or the Foundations,” c. 13. VOL. XIV.
together at Durvello the following year, 1569, when the Princess of Eboli, mistress of Philip II., and her husband Ruy Gomez, founded a nunnery and a monastery of Discalced Carmelites at Pastrana, and Father Antonio was removed from Durvello to become the head of the friars there. Father John of the Cross remained at Durvello. He met with much external and internal trouble. The reform was assailed by enemies, and its members regarded as runaways from their Order, and perhaps as infected with heresy. His soul was also troubled with fits of deep depression, in which he thought the face of God was withdrawn from him, a state of spiritual misery to which he has given touching expression in his book entitled “ Noche obscura del Alma 99 (the dark night of the Soul).
The inconvenience of Durvello, and the offer of the house and Flemish picture at Mancera, led to the transfer of the monastery thither in 1570. Since then there has existed considerable rivalry between the houses of Pastrana and Mancera, as to which should be regarded as the mother house; Pastrana was founded before Mancera, but Mancera was the community of the monastery of Durvello moving to a more congenial spot. Durvello, having been deserted, returned to the estates of the donor; but in 1612, the Discalced Carmelites, having regretted their abandonment of the house in which their reform took its rise, bought it back again.
In 1570 John of the Cross was sent to Pastrana to take charge of the new house. He found there fourteen members collected by S. Theresa and Father Antonio, of these ten were novices, and four professed friars.
In 1571 he was moved from Pastrana to take charge of a new house founded at Alcala. But his successor at Pastrana, by his over-strictness, brought the novices to insubordination, and S. John was speedily recalled, to bring back order to the disturbed community.
— tP Nov. 34.3 S- John of the Cross. 533 In the same year, however, or the beginning of the next, he was hastily called by S. Theresa to assist her at Avila, where the Apostolic Visitor of the Carmelites in Castile had appointed her prioress of her old Convent of the Incarnation, from which she had escaped nine years before with a party of nuns to found her reform.
This appointment met with great opposition from the nuns, from the people of Avila, and from the magistrates of the town. The Convent of the Incarnation had been a great resort of ladies and gentlemen disposed for an afternoon gossip, and the nuns had been always ready to visit and stay with friends and relatives, when they were tired of the routine of cloister life; and, as the memoirs of S. Theresa reveal to us, were not altogether repugnant to a little flirtation, if carried on quietly. “ All this must be altered,” was the decision of the Visitor, and S. Theresa was the right person to reform the relaxed house. No wonder that she met with opposition. She was obliged to send for S. John of the Cross to assist her in her struggle against overt and covert hostility.
The wrath and envy of the Carmelite Order against the innovators, or rather reformers, could find no vent so long as S. Theresa and her disciples were supported by a papal nuncio and by the king, the latter of whom, if a man of unbounded licentiousness in morals, was a man also of unbounded devotion to the professors of asceticism. But in 1575 the Grand Chapter of the Order in Spain passed decrees against the Discalced Carmelites, and the General of the Order sent Father Geronimo Tostado into Spain as his Visitor, to press on the king the necessity for suppressing the reform, or schism as he, not unreasonably, regarded it. At this time also the papal nuncio who had favoured S. Theresa, most inopportunely died, and was succeeded by another who disapproved of her work. In 1577 the Carmelite Visitor, F. Tostado, obtained a band of soldiers, and bursting open the doors of the house where S. John of the Cross lived, seized and carried him off to Toledo, where he was brutally cudgelled, and thrown into a dark dungeon, into which light only penetrated through a little hole of three fingers' breadth, and where he was kept in filth, rags, and starvation by the Carmelite superior, for nine months, till his health was so shattered that the religious were in very shame obliged to release him, lest he should die under their ill-treatment. He was sent to a wretched convent of Calvary, in the country. But though the Discalced were under a cloud, they were not exterminated. Philip II. took them under his favour, and in 1579 John was able to found a monastery at Baeza, and in 1581 he became prior of a reformed Carmelite house at Granada. In 1585 he was made Vicar-provincial of Andalusia, and in 1588 first definitor of the Order.
His austerities exceeded the bounds of moderation and reason. He slept for only two or three hours in the night, and spent the rest of the night in prayer or dozing; and in the semi-devotional, semi-somnolent condition in which he knelt, he — as might have been expected — was visited by all sorts of visions, waking dreams, conjured up by a brain deprived of its natural rest. These were generally of an edifying nature — or at least those which he communicated to his brethren were such. In one of these dreams he thought he heard Christ say to him, “ John, what recompense dost thou ask for thy labours?" He answered, “None, Lord, save that I may suffer and be condemned for Thy love." He was wont to say, “To suffer for the sake of God is the true characteristic of His love, as we see in Christ, and in the martyrs. And persecutions are the means whereby we may enter into the depth, or attain to the knowledge, of the mystery of the cross, a necessary condition for comprehending the depth of the wisdom of God and of His love." His great ambition was to be miserable. He often prayed that three things might happen to him. 1st. That he might not pass one day of his life without suffering something. 2ndly. That he might not die Superior. 3rdiy. That he might end his life in humiliations, disgrace, and contempt. He was frequently found by those who came to consult him in a dazed, halfconscious condition, consequent on want of sleep, but believed to be the bewilderment of a soul recovering itself from ecstasy. Many persons with lively imaginations asserted that they had seen his face shine with a supernatural light. One lady, it is pretended, was so struck with this illumination as she came to him for confession, that she laid aside her jewels, and dedicated herself to the religious life. The whole furniture of his cell consisted of a rush cross with a paper Christ attached to it.
His acquaintance with his own condition when praying when he ought to have been asleep, enabled him to judge ot the value of visions appearing to other persons in the same condition, and he was able to assure them that what they regarded as Divine manifestations were very often only waking dreams. His unhesitating judgment on visions is, that they are to be rejected. “ These imaginary visions and other supernatural impressions to which the senses are subject without the assent of the will, I maintain should be avoided and not dwelt on by the soul, upon all occasions and at all times, whether in the perfect or in beginners.”1 Directors, he says, have done great mischief by encouraging their penitents in a visionary habit. “ There are some spiritual directors who fall into error because their instructions to those who are liable to visions are such as to lead them astray or perplex them. They suffer their penitents to make much of their visions, and attaching so much importance to these visions they fail to build them up and stablish them in faith. This sort of direction shows that they themselves consider visions 1 “Ascent of Mount Carmel," b. ii. c. 17. to be matters of importance, and their penitents, observing this, follow their example and dwell on these dreams, instead of bracing up their faith. This is the necessary result of the language and conduct of spiritual directors \ for, somehow, a certain sense of satisfaction springs up at these things, and that draws away the eye from the depth of faith into which it should gaze. The penitent, finding the confessor [in old usage, a saint who was not martyred, or who suffered for the faith without being killed] very appreciative of them, is induced also to magnify them, indulge in them, give way to them, and hold them in mighty esteem. This sort of direction is the source of many imperfections, to say the least, to the soul. It makes the soul lose humility and get self-satisfied; and the devil is not slow to foster this.”1 With strong good sense he argues that visions, even though presumably coming from God, are very likely to deceive, and that, therefore, the less attention paid to them the better.
S. John of the Cross was a vernacular poet of no low order. The poem which he composed as the text to his “Dark Night,” formed on the model of the Aubades of the Troubadours, is not undeserving of ranking with the amatory compositions of Bertrand de Born and Giraud de Borneil. It has its counterpart in the aubade “ En un vergier” by an unknown troubadour. It does not fall behind the graceful little piece in its poetic power, or in the sensuality of the picture it paints. The religious who reads the “ Dark Night ” is likely to be distracted from the cold regions of ascetic theology to the ardour of sensual imaginings conjured up by this unseemly though very beautiful poem. S. John takes the first two verses and explains them mystically, line by line. They represent a maiden eloping at night down a ladder from her house, when all within are asleep, to ' meet her lover, who is hiding in a grove for her. The six last verses, descriptive of the meeting, S. John abstained 1 “Ascent of Mount Carmel,” b. ii. c. x8. S. John of the Cross.
from explaining; he would have done better to have abstained from writing them. The poem entitled the “ Spiritual Canticle between the Soul and Christ,” is based on the Song of Solomon. The “ Living Flame of Love ” is descriptive of the human passion of a mistress for her lover, whom she has admitted to her chamber, which may be compared with one of Herrick’s warmest compositions. It has, however, quite another signification in the mouth of a mystic to whom earthly passion is unknown.
It is to be regretted that S. John of the Cross, who was possessed of such good sense in his estimate of visions, should have encouraged instead of checking that sentimental love of Christ in the breast of nuns, which has run in hysterical persons to such dangerous lengths.1 S. John held in dislike the dressing up of images of the saints with artificial hair and jewels, and with laces and velvet and satin gowns. “ There are people,” he says, “ who squander that inward devotion which ought to be spiritually directed to the invisible saint, in demonstrations of endearment and curiosity towards the image, and all love and joy end there. This is an effectual hindrance to real spirituality. And this is clearly visible in that hateful custom observed 1 As the following, from the Diary of the B. Marie de T Incarnation: — “ Allant b l’oraison, je tressaillois en moi-meme, et disois: Allons dans la solitude, mon cher amour, afin que je vous embrasse a mon aise, et que, respirant mon ame en vous, elle ne soit plus que vous-meme par union d’amour Puis, mon corps etant brise de fatigues, j’etois contrainte de dire: Mon divin amour, je vous prie de me laisser prendre un peu de repos, enfin que je puisse mieux vous servir, puisque vous voulez que je vive Je le priois de me laisser agir: lui promettant de me laisser apres cela consumer dans ses chastes et divins embrassements O amour ! quand vous embrasserai-je ? N’avez-vous point pitie de moi dans le tourment que je souffre ? helas F helas ! mon amour, ma beaute, ma vie ! au lieu de me guerir, vous vous plaisez b mes maux. Venez done que je vous embrasse, et que je meure entre vos bras sacrez ! M Some pupils of Marie de I'lncamation also had mystical marriages with Christ; and the impassioned rhapsodies of one of them being overheard, she nearly lost her character, as it was thought that she was apostrophizing an earthly lover. Is it to be wondered at that S. Christina and S. Rose of Lima, in these unwholesome conditions of combined sexual and religious exaltation, should have supposed that they had received favours which no longer left them virgins ?
now-a-days by certain persons who, instead of holding in abhorrence the vanities of the world, adorn the sacred images with the garments fashionable at the time, invented for the satisfaction of wanton recreation. They dress up the images in those garments which are objectionable when worn by themselves, and which the saints would certainly have held in detestation. The result is, that all modest and sound devotion in such people disappears, to make way for a superfluous decoration of images, and to them they cling, and on them base all their joys. You see people who are never tired of adding image to image; and they hold to their images as Micah did to his idols, who when he lost them ran out of his house crying because they had been taken away.”
“ When many people go on a pilgrimage,” he says elsewhere, “ I should advise staying at home, for in general, men return from pilgrimages more dissipated than they were before. And many become pilgrims for recreation more than for devotion.”
In 1591 the Reformed Carmelite Order broke into factions. John of the Cross was dismissed his offices, and sent to the lonely monastery of Penguela, on the mountains of the Sierra Morena. Some members of the society whom he had forbidden to preach, when he was provincial of Andalusia, now became his principal accusers and enemies. One of them, F. Diego Evangelista, spread everywhere ugly reports of his conduct, which he probably regarded as insane, and he was accused of heresy. He found himself forsaken of all. Those who received his letters burned them, lest they should be involved in his disgrace. John of the Cross was ordered to leave Penguela and go to Baeza or Ubeda. He chose the latter. He had been for some time suffering from ulcers. The fatigue of his journey caused these ulcers to burst, and discharge. The prior behaved towards him with great inhumanity, forbade any one visiting him, locked him up in a tiny cell, denied him necessary food, and dismissed the infirmarer for treating him with compassion. Sectarian envy and spite seemed to have extinguished the common instincts of humanity in the breast of the holy prior Francis Chrysostom of Ubeda.
Fortunately the provincial came that way, and when he found how barbarously the sick and dying man had been treated by his religious brethren, he rated the prior soundly. Two hours before S. John died he repeated the Miserere ?nei with his brethren; then he desired one to read to him part of the book of Canticles, and during the lection appeared in transports of joy. He at length cried out, “ Glory be to God!” pressed the crucifix to his breast, and after some time said, “ Lord, into Thy hands I commend my spirit,” with which words he calmly breathed forth his soul on the 14th of December, in 1591, at the age of forty-nine years, of which he had spent twenty-eight in a religious profession. S. Theresa in her epistles styles him a saint even before he had embraced her reformed Order, and says that he was one of the most pure souls in the Church, to whom God had communicated great treasures of light, and whose understanding He had filled with the science of the saints.