But towards the end of his reign, a change of policy was forced upon Theodoric by the imprudence of the Eastern Emperor Justin. In 523, Justin issued a terrible edict commanding all Manichaeans to leave the empire under the threat of death. Three other heretics were barred from holding any civil or military office. The Arians, who had been deprived of their churches and their rights as citizens, appealed to the Gothic king of Italy. It was at this moment that rumors of a conspiracy reached his ears. Vague reports of correspondence between the leaders of the Roman Senate and the Eastern emperor arrived in Ravenna. Indignation, mixed with apprehension, at this sudden and seemingly simultaneous act of hostility seized Theodoric. The entire situation required careful consideration. Nothing could be more unprovoked than the religious measures taken by Constantinople, especially as they threatened the West and attacked those in the East who shared the same faith as Theodoric. His fairness towards his Catholic and Arian subjects was beyond reproach; he had always shown respectful deference to the pope and had not exploited the conflict over the papacy between Symmachus and Laurentius to promote his own beliefs. Even as recently as that very year, he had given the church of St. Peter two magnificent chandeliers made of solid silver.
He immediately arrested Albinus, the leader of the Roman Senate, on the charge of engaging in treasonous correspondence with Constantinople. Severianus Boethius, a senator, was also implicated in the charge. This highly skilled master of all the arts and sciences known at that time had been appointed to the consulate and had received high honors from his sovereign. His signature, which he claimed was forged, was presented at the bottom of a letter inviting the Eastern emperor to reconquer Italy. He was sentenced to imprisonment and was confined at Calvenzano, a castle between Milan and Pavia.
Meanwhile, the religious situation in the East became increasingly threatening for those who shared Theodoric's faith. The correspondence between the monarchs had yielded no results, and Theodoric resorted to the unusual measure of sending the pope to Constantinople to protest to the Eastern emperor and seek toleration for the Arians. When the pope attempted to limit his mediatorial role to matters more suited to his character, Theodoric angrily ordered the envoys to immediately board the ships that were ready for the journey.
John I, a Tuscan by birth, was the pope at that time; he had succeeded Hormisdas in 523. Little is known about his actions before he was sent on this mission, except that he repaired the catacombs of Saints Nereus and Achilles, Saints Felix and Adauctus, and Saint Priscilla.
Gregory the Great, in his dialogues, recounts his journey, describing how he healed a blind man along the way and how he rode a horse that, after carrying the pope, would never allow a woman to ride it again. John was welcomed in Constantinople with the highest honors. The entire city, led by the emperor, came out to greet him with candles, all the way to the tenth milestone from the city gates. The emperor knelt at his feet to receive his apostolic blessing. On Easter Day, he celebrated Mass in the great church, with Epiphanius, the bishop, giving way to the more holy visitor. However, the details and outcomes of his negotiations are completely unclear and contradictory. According to one account, which is now dismissed as a later forgery, he boldly supported the emperor in rejecting all concessions. In another account, he was faithful to his mission and secured the freedom of worship and the return of churches to the Arians. What is certainly known is that Pope John, upon his return, was treated as a traitor by Theodoric, imprisoned, and there the highest church leader of the West suffered for nearly a year before he died. Even before John's return, Boethius had been sacrificed to Theodoric's suspicions and fears.
While in prison, Boethius wrote his great book, "The Consolation of Philosophy," which is considered the last work of Roman literature, rather than being prominent among Christian writings.
Footnotes
- Procop. de Bell, Gothic ii., c. 6.
- "The Consolation of Philosophy" is a philosophical work by Boethius.
Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.
Read the original 1870s text
Baring-Gould’s sources: Roman Martyrology. Ado, Notker, Hrabanus, &c. Authorities: — The anonymous historian of the Caesars from Constantius Chlorus to Theodoric, published by Valesius, Anastatius Bibliothecarius, &c.] Theodoric the Goth, in all the earlier part of his reign, showed a spirit of remarkable toleration. Though inheriting the Arian tenets of his Ostrogoth forefathers, he behaved to the Catholics with rigid impartiality. Towards the close of the Gothic monarchy the royal ambassadors to Belisarius defied their enemies to prove a case in which the Goths had persecuted the Catholics.1 Theodoric treated the pope, the bishops, and clergy, with grave respect, in the more distinguished he ever placed the highest confidence. He showed as much reverence, and even bounty, to the church of S. Peter, as though he had been a Catholic. Theodoric himself adhered firmly but calmly to his native Arianism; but, all the conversions seem to have been from the religion of the king 3 even his mother became a Catholic, and some other distinguished persons of the Court embraced a different creed from their sovereign without forfeiting his favour. Theodoric was the protector of Church property, which he himself increased by large grants.
But towards the close of his reign a change of policy was forced on by the imprudence of the Eastern Emperor Justin. In 523 Justin in a terrible edict commanded all Manichseans to leave the empire on pain of death 3 other heretics were incapacitated for holding all civil and military office. The Arians [followers of Arius, who taught that the Son is a created being, not fully God], deprived of their churches and their rights as citizens, appealed to the Gothic king of Italy. It was precisely at this juncture that rumours of conspiracy 1 Procop. de Bell, Gothic ii., c. 6.
reached his ear. Vague intelligence of a correspondence carried on by the heads of the Roman senate with the emperor of the East, arrived at Ravenna. Indignation, not without apprehension, at this sudden, and as it seemed simultaneous, movement of hostility, seized the soul of Theodoric. The whole circumstances of his position demanded careful consideration. Nothing could be more unprovoked than the religious measures of Constantinople, as far as they menaced the West, and assailed those in the East who held the same faith as Theodoric. His equity to his Catholic and Arian subjects was unimpeachable; to the pope he had always shown respectful deference, he had taken no advantage of the contention for the pontificate by Symmachus and Laurentius to promote his own tenets. Even as late as this very year, he had bestowed on the church of S. Peter two magnificent chandeliers of solid silver. He at once arrested Albinus, the chief of the Roman senate, on the charge of holding treasonable correspondence with Constantinople. Severianus Boethius, the senator, was involved in the charge. This consummate master of all the arts and sciences known at that period had been raised to the consulate, and had received high marks of his sovereign’s esteem. His signature, forged as he declared, was shown at the foot of an address, inviting the emperor of the East to re-conquer Italy. He was condemned to imprisonment, and was incarcerated at Calvenzano, a castle between Milan and Pavia.
In the meantime the religious affairs of the East became more threatening to those who held the same religious creed with Theodoric. The correspondence between the monarchs had produced no effect, and Theodoric adopted the strange expedient of sending the pope to Constantinople to remonstrate with the Eastern emperor, and obtain toleration for the Arians. To the pope’s remonstrances and attempts to limit his mediatorial office to points less unsuited to his character, Theodoric angrily replied, by commanding the envoys instantly to embark in the vessels which were ready for the voyage.
John I., a Tuscan by birth, was then pope, he had succeeded Hormisdas in 523. Of his acts little is known before he was sent on this expedition, except that he repaired the catacombs of SS. Nereus and Achilles, of SS. Felix and Adauctus. and of S. Priscilla.
S. Gregory the Great, in his dialogues, relates of his journey, how on the way he healed a blind man, and how he rode a horse which after it had borne the pope would never suffer a woman to mount his back. John was received in Constantinople with the most flattering honours. The whole city, with the emperor at its head, came forth to meet him with tapers, as far as the tenth milestone from the gates. The emperor knelt at his feet to receive his apostolic benediction. On Easter Day he said mass in the 'great church, Epiphanius the bishop ceding the first place to the more holy stranger. But of the course and success of his negotiations all is utterly confused and contradictory. By one account, now abandoned as a later forgery, he boldly confirmed the emperor in the rejection of all concessions. By another, he was so far faithful to his mission, as to obtain liberty of worship, and the restitution of their churches to the Arians. All that is certainly known is, that John the pope, on his return, was received as a traitor by Theodoric, thrown into prison, and there the highest ecclesiastic of the West languished for nearly a year and died. Even before his return, Boethius had been sacrificed to the suspicions and fears of Theodoric.
In prison Boethius wrote his great book, “ The Consolation of Philosophy,” which appears as the last work of Roman letters, rather than as eminent among Christian