J

This is a traditional tale of a great fall and a bitter repentance, kept in the calendar as a warning against pride and an encouragement never to despair of God's mercy.

Read the essentials →
Traditional feast January 28 · Hermit

St. James, the Penitent

Feast

Traditional feast: January 28 (Roman Martyrology 1916 (archive.org OCR, sources/rm1916.txt))
Traditional date · cited source, no current calendar entry found

Traditional feast

January 28
1914 / pre-1969 calendar, per Baring-Gould (1914)

Represents

Hermit

Feast days

Feast: January 28

This Saint’s Story

Adapted in modern English from Baring-Gould (1914) · original text below

A young hermit, James, lived in a cave near Porphyrion in Samaria. Some wicked men paid a woman to tempt him. She knocked at nightfall, claiming to be a nun travelling between convents. When wild beasts began to howl, he let her shelter by the fire in the outer chamber while he shut himself in the inner one.

In the night she pretended to be in agony and begged him to anoint her heart with holy oil. As he did so, praying against temptation, he held his left hand in the fire until the fingers were burned through. Horrified and ashamed, she confessed her plot, and she spent the rest of her life in penance.

But people praised his maimed hand and his self-control, and James grew proud and careless. When he was over sixty, a father brought his beautiful daughter to be freed from an evil spirit. After the cure he left her in the hermit's care to recover. James was overcome by passion, abused her, and in his madness killed her and threw her body into a river.

That night he lay in agony of shame. He confessed at the nearest monastery and meant to return to the world as unworthy of the habit. An old hermit who took him in embraced him: 'Brother, despair not of God's forbearance, but believe that there is a place for repentance.' Talked out of despair, James shut himself in an old tomb for ten years, opening it only twice a week to gather a few olives. Feeling his end near, he asked the local bishop to bury him in that tomb, and died there at seventy-five.

Struggles & surrender

This saint’s struggles

  • Pride, a fall and despair · Tradition
    In this traditional tale, after resisting one temptation James grew proud of his self-control and less watchful. In old age he fell into terrible sin and then into despair, believing he could not even name the Saviour. An old hermit persuaded him that there was a place for repentance, and he spent ten years doing penance in a tomb.

What this saint represents

How this saint teaches us to live

Drawn from themes in the original account

Make time for silence. Time alone in prayer is part of this story.

Pray a little every day. Prayer is part of this story.

Choose mercy. Forgiveness and mercy are part of this story.

The full story

Baring-Gould’s account retold in modern English

Read the full story · 1,122 words · about 5 min

The story of this hermit is a painful and very sad one; it tells of a great fall and bitter repentance. The Church has included it in her sacred calendar as a warning to all those who live close to God, urging them not to be arrogant but to be cautious. It serves not only as a lesson for them but also as encouragement for the unfortunate person who has fallen, reminding him to look up and not to despair, for however great his sin may be, God's mercy is greater.

Near the city of Porphyrio in Samaria, there lived a hermit in a cave. He was not old, but in the prime of his life. Some wicked men, wanting to disgrace the hermit, hired a prostitute to tempt him. One evening, she came to his cave and knocked on the door. He opened the door, and upon seeing a woman, he slammed it shut in her face. However, she continued knocking and pleading to be let in. As night fell, the howling of wolves and the snarling of hyenas sounded mournfully outside. Fearing that the woman might become prey to wild animals, the hermit opened the door and asked her who she was. She replied that she was a religious woman traveling from one convent to another and sought shelter for the night. He then let her into the outer chamber of his cave, where his fire was burning, and told her to rest while he retreated to the inner chamber and closed the door.

During the night, he heard her moaning and sobbing. Curious, he looked through the small window in the door and saw her rolling on the ground as if in great pain. He asked what was wrong, and she answered that she had heart cramps and begged him to relieve her by anointing her bosom and heart with holy oil. She then tore open her garment and exposed her breast. He entered, took oil, and anointed her bosom. However, fearing temptation, he prayed to God with great devotion while placing his left hand in the fire, continuing to do as she requested with his right hand. Suddenly, she noticed that his left hand was so burned that the fingers were completely charred. Horrified and filled with remorse, she threw herself at his feet and sobbed as she confessed her evil intentions. He told her to go and sin no more, and the woman was converted from her sinful life, living the rest of her days in penance.

Now, after this, James was confident that he had completely mastered his physical desires, and he was less cautious against the tricks of Satan than he had been before. People saw his maimed hand and praised his great self-control, which made his heart swell with pride, and he became filled with spiritual arrogance.

After many years, when he was over sixty, a father came to his cell bringing his daughter, a very beautiful girl who was possessed by an evil spirit. The father begged the pious hermit to cast out the demon. After he prayed, the evil spirit left her, but she was left almost lifeless. The father, thinking she was too exhausted to be moved immediately, or fearing another episode of her disorder, decided to leave her in the cell of the God-fearing recluse.

After she had been there for several days, and as he saw her beauty, he was overcome by a violent passion of love. He lost all control over himself, forgot God, deceived the unfortunate girl, and in a fit of madness, he brutally murdered her and threw her body into a river.

And now, as the sun set on that day of suffering and wrongdoing, and the dark night settled over the wilderness, the horror of remorse came upon him. He writhed in his cave in an agony of shame and despair, lying with his face on the ground. Finally, haggard and hopeless, he rushed out, determined to confess his crime and then to return to the world, feeling unworthy to seek a close relationship with God. When he reached the nearest monastery, he called the monks together. He threw himself at their feet and sobbed out his story of shame. The good brothers helped him up, mingled their tears with his, and prayed to God to have mercy on the poor sinner and to rescue him from destruction.

After that, finding no peace, he went out and, as evening fell, came across an old hermit sitting in his cave. The hermit offered him a place to stay and shared what little food he had. But James would eat nothing. Then the hermit said, "Dear Christian brother, give me some good advice on how I may escape evil thoughts." When James heard this, he let out a piercing cry, staggered to his feet, and fell to the ground, burying his face in his hands. He confessed all his sins to the hermit and said that he was about to return to the world, feeling unworthy to wear the monk's habit and live a life that required such holiness. "When I was young, I controlled my passions; now that I am old, my passions have conquered me. I cannot raise my eyes," he said. "I despair of salvation. I cannot even speak the Saving Name; fire will fall from heaven to consume me. I am lost!"

Then the good old hermit wrapped his arms around him and kissed him, saying, "Brother, do not despair of God's patience, but believe that there is a place for repentance. God will not despise a broken and contrite heart. Great is God's mercy, always following us, so do not despair, brother!"

He continued speaking until the dark cloud of despair lifted, and the fallen monk found the courage to hope. Then he guided him on his way for many miles, earnestly trying to dissuade him from returning to the world. They parted with many tears.

So James sought out a sorrowful cave that had been used as an old tomb, and he hid himself there. He spent ten years in it, lamenting his sin, only opening the door twice a week to collect a few olives to sustain himself, and considering himself lower than the dust. When the ten years were completed, he felt that God was about to call him. Therefore, he went to the nearest city and to the Bishop there. He asked the Bishop, when he died, to bury him in the old tomb where he had done his penance, and in the soil he had soaked with his many tears. After that, he returned to his cave, and there he died at the age of seventy-five.

Footnotes

  1. Porphyrio: a city in ancient Samaria.
  2. A broken and a contrite heart God will not despise.

Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.

Read the original 1870s text

Baring-Gould’s sources: Roman Martyrology and Greek Menæa, but by the Gallo-Belgic Martyrology on Jan. 29th. Authority: a life written apparently not long after the death of S. James. There are so many saints, and even hermit saints of this name, that some confusion would have arisen but for the remarkable peculiarity of the life of this man.

The story of this hermit is a painful and very sad one; it is that of a great fall and bitter repentance. As a warning to all those who are living lives near to God, to be not high-minded but fear, the Church has placed it in her sacred Kalendar, but not only as a lesson to such, but also as an encouragement to the poor wretch who has fallen, to look up, not to despair, for great as may be his sin, greater is the mercy of God.

Near the city of Porphyrio in Samaria lived a hermit in a cave. He was not old, but in the bloom of manhood. Some wicked men, desirous of disgracing the anchorite [a hermit, sometimes walled into a cell beside a church], suborned a harlot to bewitch him. She therefore went to his cave one evening, and knocked at the door. He opened the door, and, seeing a woman, slammed it in her face. But she continued knocking and imploring to be admitted. Night fell, and the howl of the wolf and the snarl of the hyæna sounded dolefully without; then the hermit, fearing lest the woman should become prey to wild beasts, opened the door, and asked her who she was. She replied that she was a religious woman on her road from one convent to another, who sought shelter for the night. Then he admitted her to the outer chamber of his cave, where burnt his fire, and there he bade her rest, whilst he retired into the inner chamber, and closed the door. But, during the night, he heard her moaning and sobbing, then he looked through the little window in the door, and saw her rolling on the ground, as if in great pain. He asked what ailed her, and she answered that she had cramp of the heart, and implored him to relieve her, by signing her bosom and heart with holy oil. Then she tore open her garment, and exposed her breast; and he, entering, took oil and anointed her bosom; but fearing temptation, he prayed to God with great devotion, and at the same time placed his left hand in the fire, whilst with his right he continued doing as she demanded, till suddenly, she was aware that his left hand was so burned that the fingers were completely charred through. Then, horror-struck, and filled with compunction, she threw herself at his feet, and sobbing confessed her evil design. So he bade her go and sin no more, and the woman was converted from her evil life, and she went and lived the rest of her days in the exercise of penitence.

Now, after this, James was of good confidence that he had completely mastered the lust of the flesh, and he was less on his guard against the wiles of Satan than before. And people saw his maimed hand, and they praised his great continence, so his heart was lifted up within him, and he was filled with spiritual pride. After many years, when he was over sixty, there came to his cell a father bringing his daughter, a very beautiful girl, who was possessed with an evil spirit, and he besought the pious hermit to cast forth the demon. And when he had prayed, the evil spirit went out of her, but left her almost inanimate. Then the father, thinking her too much exhausted to be at once removed, or fearing another access of her disorder, left her in the cell of the God-fearing recluse. And when she was there some days, and he saw her beauty, he was overcome with a violent passion of love, and he lost all control over himself, and forgot God, and deceived the unfortunate girl, and in madness he savagely murdered her, and threw the body into a river.

And now, as the sun set on that day of passion and crime, and the dark night settled down on the wilderness, the horror of remorse came upon him, and he writhed in his cave in an agony of shame and despair, lying with his face on the ground. Then, at last, haggard and hopeless, he rushed forth, resolving to confess his crime and then to return into the world, as one unworthy to aspire to a close walk with God. And when he had come to the nearest monastery, he called the monks together, and casting himself at their feet, sobbed forth his story of shame. The good brothers raised him, and mingled their tears with his, and prayed God to have mercy on the poor sinner, and to pluck him as a brand from the burning. After that, finding no rest, he went forth, and lighted, as evening fell, on an old hermit sitting in his cave, who offered him a lodging, and spread for him such food as he had to offer. But James would eat nothing. Then the hermit said, "Dear Christian brother, give me some good advice, how I may escape evil thoughts." And when James heard that, he uttered a piercing cry, staggered to his feet and fell on the ground, burying his face in his hands. He told all his sin to the hermit, and said that now he was about to return into the world, being unworthy to wear the habit of a monk, and live a life demanding such holiness. "When I was young, then I controlled my passions, now that I am old, my passions have conquered me. I cannot raise my eyes," he said; "I despair of salvation. I cannot name the Saving Name; fire will fall from heaven to consume me, I am lost!"

Then the good old hermit cast his arms round his neck and kissed him, and said, "Brother, despair not of God's forbearance, but believe that there is a place for repentance. A broken and a contrite heart God will not despise. Great is God's mercy, ever following us, therefore despair not, brother!"

He ceased not from speaking, till the black cloud of despair was rolled away, and the fallen monk had the courage to hope. Then he led him on his way for many miles, earnestly dissuading him from going into the world; and so they parted, with many tears.

So James sought out a doleful cave which had been used as an old sepulchre, and he hid himself there, and spent in it ten years, bewailing his crime, only opening the door twice in the week, to collect a few olives on which to sustain life, and esteeming himself viler than the dust. And when ten years were accomplished, he felt that God was about to call him, therefore he went to the nearest city, and to the Bishop there, and besought him, when he was dead, to bury him in the old sepulchre in which he had undergone his penance, and in the soil he had moistened with his many tears. After that he returned to his cave, and there died, at the age of seventy-five.

Help us add to this saint's story

Everything is read by a person before anything appears. Facts are checked against trusted sources first.

Facts are welcome; a source link helps (optional).With your permission we may share it on this page.

Nine days · Free

Pray the novena
with us.

One short email a day for nine days. The day's prayer, a line from St. James's story, and a nudge to keep going.

Also on January 28
T

Sts. Thyrsus

January 28 · Martyrs

St. Valerius of Saragossa

January 28 · Bishop
P

St. Palladius in Syria

January 28 · Hermit
← All 1970 saints in the library
Sources & notes

Feast-day sources

Story sources

Sources

Credits

Retold in plain modern English from Baring-Gould’s public-domain text, sentence by sentence, keeping the same facts and order. Short explanations in parentheses are ours.

From Sabine Baring-Gould, The Lives of the Saints, new and revised edition (Edinburgh: John Grant, 1914; first edition 1872). Public domain in the United States. Reproduced unedited, except for short bracketed notes in grey that we added to explain names and terms (“S.” is the old abbreviation for Saint). Some history and judgments reflect 19th-century scholarship.