This Saint’s Story
Hyginus was Bishop of Rome in the mid-second century. The Catholic Encyclopedia places his reign about 138 to 142 and notes that he succeeded Pope Telesphorus, whom Eusebius (bishop of Caesarea, d. c. 339, the first historian of the Church) says died in the first year of the Emperor Antoninus Pius—therefore in 138 or 139. It also warns that the chronology of these early bishops cannot be fixed with exactness from the authorities we have. According to the Liber Pontificalis (the early medieval 'Book of the Popes', not always reliable for the earliest ones) he was a Greek by birth. The further claim that he had been a philosopher is treated as probably arising from the likeness of his name to those of two Latin authors. Eusebius assigns him a pontificate of four years. Baring-Gould, working from the same thin early notices, likewise stresses how little is securely known and places him in the quieter years under Antoninus Pius.
Irenaeus (bishop of Lyon, d. c. 202, who listed the early popes) records that the Gnostic Valentine came to Rome in Hyginus’s time and remained until Anicetus became pontiff. Cerdo, another Gnostic and predecessor of Marcion, also lived at Rome under Hyginus; by confessing his errors he obtained readmission to the Church, but later fell back into heresy and was expelled. How many of these events belong strictly to Hyginus’s years is not known. The Liber Pontificalis relates that he organised the hierarchy and distributed grades among the clergy (Hic clerum composuit et distribuit gradus). The encyclopedia, following Duchesne, judges that general remark to have no historical value—it recurs in the life of Pope Hormisdas—and takes it as likely referring only to the lower orders of the clergy. Baring-Gould’s shorter notice puts the same point more simply: that Hyginus used a season of repose after persecution to bring the Roman church into fuller organisation.
Ancient authorities, the encyclopedia states, contain no information that he died a martyr. At his death he was buried on the Vatican Hill near the tomb of St. Peter. His feast is kept on 11 January. The present library entry once carried the round year 156; the encyclopedia’s approximate reign of 138–142, with Eusebius’s four years, is the safer dating to keep in view.