This Saint’s Story
The Catholic Encyclopedia notes that his date of birth is unknown and that he died about 107. In the Liberian Catalogue his name appears as Aristus. Papal catalogues of the second century used by Irenaeus (bishop of Lyon, d. c. 202, who listed the early popes) and Hippolytus place him as the fourth successor of St. Peter, immediately after St. Clement, and allow him about eight years of reign—from about 98 or 99 to about 106 or 107. Eusebius, in his Ecclesiastical History, says little more than that Evaristus succeeded Clement in the Roman episcopate, a fact already known from Irenaeus; the encyclopedia judges that order of succession undoubtedly correct. Baring-Gould records the same thin notices and adds that Eusebius once speaks of nine years and once of eight, while Anastasius the Librarian later claimed thirteen years and six months—figures that show how unsettled the early chronology remains.
The Liber Pontificalis (the early medieval 'Book of the Popes', not always reliable for the earliest ones) says that Evaristus came of a Hellenic family and was the son of a Bethlehem Jew. It also attributes to him the allotment of definite churches as tituli to the Roman presbyters and the division of the city into seven diaconias or deaconries. The encyclopedia, however, warns that the Liber Pontificalis here arbitrarily projects onto Evaristus’s time a later institution of the Roman Church. More trustworthy, it holds, is the assertion that he was laid to rest in Vaticano, near the tomb of St. Peter. Baring-Gould’s shorter notice repeats the parish-and-deacons tradition in simpler form—seven deacons said to attend the bishop when preaching as witnesses to true doctrine—without claiming independent proof.
The martyrdom of Evaristus, though traditional, is not historically proven. The Roman Martyrology (the Church's official list of saints for each day) calls him a martyr, yet Baring-Gould observes that the Martyrology of Jerome commemorates on the same day a martyr named Evaristus who is not the pope, and judges that the papal title of martyr probably arose from that coincidence. Two decretals ascribed to him by Pseudo-Isidore are forged. His feast is kept on 26 October.

