St. Bonaventure

St. Bonaventure was a pivotal Franciscan theologian and cardinal, known for his deep integration of faith and reason. Giovanni di Fidanza, who would later be known as Bonaventure, was born in 1221 in Civita di Bagnoregio, Italy.

Read the story →
July 15 · Bishop, Cardinal, Religious, Doctor of the Church

St. Bonaventure

Feast

July 15
Verified · General Roman Calendar

Status

Saint
Canonized 14 April 1482 by Pope Sixtus IV

Represents

Bishop
Cardinal
Religious
Doctor of the Church

Feast days

Feast: July 15

This Saint’s Story

Written for this site from Wikipedia and Franciscan Media, Saint of the Day and Catholic Encyclopedia (1913), New Advent

His early life is not well-documented, but he was the child of Giovanni di Fidanza and Maria di Ritella. According to tradition, he was miraculously healed from a serious illness through the prayers of St. Francis of Assisi, which motivated him to join the Franciscan (the order of friars founded by St. Francis of Assisi) Order around the age of 22.

Bonaventure pursued higher education at the University of Paris, where he studied under notable scholars such as Alexander of Hales. By 1253, he had gained recognition for his academic abilities and was appointed to a prominent teaching position within the Franciscan community at the university. His dedication to theology and philosophy earned him the degree of Master in 1257, alongside Thomas Aquinas, despite facing opposition from secular professors who were critical of the mendicant orders.

In 1257, Bonaventure took on the challenging role of leading the Franciscan Order as its Minister General. This position required him to navigate internal conflicts regarding the interpretation of poverty within the order. He worked diligently to unify the friars and established a structured approach to spirituality based on the teachings of St. Francis, which resonated deeply with many of his contemporaries.

In 1273, Bonaventure was appointed Cardinal Bishop of Albano by Pope Gregory X and participated in the Second Council of Lyon (1274, called to reunite the Greek and Latin Churches) in 1274. His contributions were significant in promoting unity between the Greek and Latin churches. However, he died unexpectedly on July 15, 1274, during the council, with some sources suggesting he may have been poisoned.

Bonaventure was canonized (officially declared a saint by the pope) on April 14, 1482, by Pope Sixtus IV and was later declared a Doctor of the Church (a title the pope gives to a saint whose teaching is of special value to the whole Church) by Pope Sixtus V in 1588. His writings, which include works like 'The Mind's Road to God' and 'Commentary on the Sentences,' reflect his deep theological insights and continue to influence Catholic thought.

What he represents

How he teaches us to live

Drawn from their life story

Integrate faith and reason. Bonaventure's life exemplified the harmony between intellectual pursuit and spiritual devotion, showing that both are essential in understanding God.

Lead with humility. Despite his high positions, Bonaventure remained humble, refusing the Archbishopric of York, which highlights the importance of selflessness in leadership.

Embrace structured spirituality. His efforts to organize the Franciscan Order demonstrate the value of clear spiritual guidance and community in living out one's faith.

The full story

Baring-Gould’s account retold in modern English

Read the full story · 5,314 words · about 23 min

At the age of twenty-one, a serious and studious young man, he presented himself at the gates of a Franciscan convent and requested the habit of a novice. Because he showed great promise, his superiors sent him to Paris to study theology under Alexander Hales. Hales died in 1245, and Bonaventura became a novice in 1242, so he must have been sent to Paris almost immediately.

It is important to briefly review the condition of the University of Paris and the strong disagreements that divided it to understand the role Bonaventura was later called to play. The University of Paris had gradually grown to great size. A few teachers initially came as adventurers to teach in the Episcopal schools; their abilities attracted scholars and encouraged other teachers to establish themselves, leading to the formation of the University. Godfrey of Boulogne, the bishop of Paris, founded a significant school toward the end of the 11th century. Lanfranc came, taught there, and filled its benches with eager learners.

Over time, the number of students grew so large, coming from every part of Europe, that the University became organized. The episcopal seminaries of Saint Victor, Saint Genevieve, and Saint Germain formed the foundation of this impressive institution. Professors lectured on medicine, others on canon law, and others on philosophy, until Paris became filled with a diverse population of boys and men from all over Europe, eager, excited, full of fiery passions and daring intellects, hungry for knowledge, or perhaps using the pursuit of knowledge as an excuse to live free from religious and moral constraints.

Crowded into lodgings with little space, they faced every kind of temptation. Paris displayed a scene of great public disorder, debauchery, and crime. Many of the professors were reckless adventurers, seeking only intellectual excitement and financial gain. The students were mostly unruly youths living in the very center of corruption, enjoying a noisy and dissipated life in the city. However, this bustling hub of youthful energy and intellectual growth posed a threat to the church with its dangerous and bold speculation. There were figures like Abelard and William of Champeaux, who were not careful to follow traditional theological paths, leading their students to audacious questioning of truths that had previously been taken for granted. The Mendicant Orders, the Dominicans, and Franciscans looked longingly at Paris and desired a position in the University where they could meet and challenge these bold speculators and irreverent debaters on their own ground.

An opportunity arose in 1229. A conflict broke out between the University and the city authorities. In a violent clash between the students and the townspeople, two students were killed by the city guard. The University demanded justice, but it was refused, leading the University to angrily close its gates. The students then flocked to Rheims, Orleans, and Angers. The Dominicans took advantage of this situation; they received permission to establish a chair of theology, and when the students returned to Paris, they found the Dominicans had taken a significant role in theological instruction. The Franciscans soon followed the Dominicans. The Dominicans were associated with Albertus Magnus, while the Franciscans were linked to Alexander Hales, who was considered one of the most insightful of the new schoolmen.

Others followed in their wake, and the University raised a loud complaint that there were twelve chairs of theology in Paris, of which only two were available for the entire secular clergy. The Religious Orders had taken over and controlled the rest. The University suppressed one of the chairs held by the Dominicans and then expelled the Dominican professors when they refused to comply. The Dominicans appealed to the Pope. Innocent IV issued his famous bull, placing the Mendicant Orders under the authority of bishops. The following month, he died. The Dominicans claimed credit for having prayed him to death, and the phrase "From the Litanies of the Dominicans, good Lord deliver us" became a common saying.

Innocent was succeeded by Alexander IV, who canceled his predecessor's bull just ten days after his election. William of S. Amour, the defender of the University, protested in vain, appealing and arguing against it. He insisted that what was against church law and infringed upon the rights of bishops could not be permitted, even by Popes. They must ensure obedience to the bishops, not undermine their authority by freeing the Mendicants from their control. The Mendicant Orders lived in idleness by begging; S. Paul preferred to work with his hands at a respectable trade. The Mendicants sought time to study, but what were the results of their studies other than pedantry and trivial arguments?

William of S. Amour took to the pulpit to speak against the Mendicants. He accused the friars of going into homes, leading naive women astray, burdened with sins, and taking control over women's consciences and men's property, aiming to dominate public opinion.

The University refused to comply with the Papal bull reinstating the Dominicans; it would rather dissolve its own republic than do so. The outraged friars condemned S. Amour for spreading a defamatory libel against the Pope. He swore he was innocent of this accusation, and four thousand scholars came forward as his supporters.

But there was a dangerous element at work among the Franciscans, which presented an opportunity for S. Amour that he was quick to take advantage of. The Franciscan Order, made up of people from the lowest ranks of society, had attracted many individuals with Puritan or even Manichaean tendencies through its enthusiasm and zeal for purity and poverty. These individuals had troubled S. Bonaventura and disrupted the peace of Lombardy and Provence for more than a century.

A large number of Waldensian heretics had formed a religious confraternity in Toulouse; however, they had relapsed without success. In Lombardy, the Patarines had been recognized by Gregory VII as defenders of orthodoxy regarding clerical celibacy. They were later condemned to the flames as incorrigible heretics, but this was only because they had not sought refuge under the cowl of S. Francis. This underlying Manichaeism, this emerging heresy, had its own sacred book, an exposition titled the Introduction to the Everlasting Gospel. It was soon to erupt into blatant, furious heresy in the Fraticelli. The Introduction to the Everlasting Gospel was attributed to Abbot Joachim, the prophet, whose words and predictions had excited Europe at the end of the 12th century. Joachim, the Calabrian abbot of Flora, had proclaimed dire warnings about the young Frederick II. He had forced the mother of Empress Frederick to her knees while he heard her confession. His disciple and confidant, Luke, became the archbishop of Cosenza. At the urging of Henry VI, Abbot Joachim wrote commentaries on the Old Testament prophecies, Merlin, and the Sibyls. The greatest preachers and logicians of the time eagerly studied the works of the famous Calabrian seer. After his death, Friar Gerardino of San Donino, who taught grammar in Sicily, wrote the unusual book, the Introduction to the Everlasting Gospel, which expanded on the revelations of Abbot Joachim and threw the entire religious world into turmoil.

This book announced that the world was destined to go through three epochs, each under three dispensations: those of the Law, the Gospel, and the Spirit. The Father had ruled and guided the Jews, the Son had taught and founded the Church, and now the dispensation of the Son was to be replaced by that of the Holy Spirit. The hierarchy, the priesthood, and the sacraments—all that belonged to the Son—were to diminish in favor of the general enlightenment of the Spirit spread through the Minorite Order. The new, the Everlasting Gospel, replaced and abolished the previous four. It suited the enemies of the Mendicants to accuse both Orders of teaching this new heresy; however, the Everlasting Gospel, in its tone and teaching, reflected the Franciscan spirit, or rather the hidden Manichaeism that had taken root in the convents of the Minorites.

The University of Paris sent a delegation to Rome to seek the condemnation of the Everlasting Gospel, which was being secretly spread throughout France. This was causing unrest among the people, which could lead to a widespread revolt against the church hierarchy and the clergy. However, the University was preempted by the Mendicants. Before the delegation arrived, the Dominicans had already taken action. William of St. Amour had also written a book titled “The Perils of the Last Times,” which criticized the tendencies and actions of the Mendicants. It was a harsh, hidden, and biting critique of them and their activities, presented as an interpretation of the Book of Revelation.

The stated purpose of the work was to reveal, using Holy Scripture, the characteristics of the false prophets who are to appear at the end of the world, as mentioned by St. Paul in his Second Epistle to Timothy. The author described these individuals as “lovers of themselves, proud, boasters, incontinent, unmerciful, traitors, high-minded, lovers of pleasure more than lovers of God,” in such vivid and unmistakable terms that it was impossible for everyone not to recognize— and the Dominicans and Franciscans, through their outrage, acknowledged that there must have been some truth in the portrayal—the features of the new Orders, which were spreading throughout Western Christendom. They were sowing the seeds of disobedience to the bishops and secular clergy, which would eventually lead to a general revolt that would sweep away both friars and seculars in a chaotic uprising against authority.

The book by St. Amour was condemned, not for heresy, but as an incitement to revolt against the Mendicant Orders. St. Amour was cast out to die in exile, stripped of his positions. This was the situation at the University of Paris when St. Bonaventura studied and later taught there. His knowledge, piety, and unwavering orthodoxy greatly helped to restore the reputation of the Minorites, which had been damaged by the spread of the Introduction to the Everlasting Gospel.

“I do not know,” says Gerson, the great chancellor of the University, “if ever the University of Paris has produced a doctor equal to Bonaventura.” And elsewhere he states, “If you were to ask me which of all our doctors was the most perfect, I would reply, without prejudice to the others, that Bonaventura was the one; because he is solid, sure, pious, and devout in all he says, and he does not complicate his lessons with unnecessary and trivial questions.” He adds, “There is no teaching more exalted, divine, or beneficial, or indeed more captivating for true theologians than his.”

Apply to him the words spoken by Our Lord about S. John: "He was a burning and a shining light." Bonaventura was not a philosopher like his contemporary, S. Thomas Aquinas. If he engages in philosophy, it is not because he cares for or loves philosophy, but because it is the trend of his time. He is more of a mystic than a thinker. His philosophy—such as it is—rests on the idea that the soul is in exile from God, striving, rising, and losing itself in God. His most popular work is "The Itinerary of the Soul to God." The love of God and the knowledge of God proceed harmoniously together through four stages. The first is the external light, by which we learn the mechanical arts. The second is the inferior light, the understanding that illuminates the senses. The third is the eternal light, the reason that sees the motive causes. The fourth is the superior light of grace, which reveals God to us.

Bonaventura thus defines the place of man in the world. God created all things for His own glory—not, as some argued, for the good of the creature—and as a manifestation of His light and the communication of His goodness. However, there can be no perfect revelation without someone to understand it, and no communication of goodness without someone capable of enjoying it. Since this capacity for understanding and enjoyment belongs only to rational creatures, the irrational creature has no immediate relation to God, but only an indirect one through the rational creature. Rational creatures, being created to praise and know God, are therefore created to stand in immediate relation to Him. By virtue of this immediate relation, they are capable of communion with God, and God can hold communion with them. This communion is the perfecting of the relationship and the highest exaltation of man.

Therefore, the goal of man is the elevation of his intellect, his intelligence, and his soul into perfect union, almost identification with God.

Bonaventura was not only a theological teacher; he was also a passionate defender of his Order. He could justly claim that the poor condition of the clergy had made the friars necessary, or at least had provided a valid reason for the formation and growth of the Mendicant Orders. He argued that “because sins within the Church were continually increasing, and the bishops, occupied with external matters, could not attend to the spiritual needs of their dioceses; because few pastors lived in their parishes and entrusted the care of souls to needy curates who were ignorant, negligent, and unchaste — therefore the Pope, who is responsible for the care of the Church, has called us to assist the clergy and the communities.”

He describes the Franciscans of his time: “No one among us is allowed to be idle, except the sick. Some busy themselves with study to prepare for the role of instructors of the faithful; others engage in divine worship; others collect alms for the support of the community; others provide services to the sick; those who have learned trades work at them for the benefit of the brothers and of strangers; others, who are directed to do so, travel through different lands on missions.”

He acknowledges to William of S. Amour that many of the negative aspects he criticized were indeed present among some individuals in the Order; however, he lamented the injustice of blaming the entire group for the faults of a few. “That which is bad floats on the surface and is noticed by all. True holiness is a hidden thing, recognized only by certain signs.”

At the age of thirty-six, in the thirteenth year of his profession, Bonaventura was unanimously elected General of his Order while he was absent, by a chapter held in Rome in the presence of Alexander IV. No choice could have been better. The Order was in a critical state. It was threatened with schism. The turmoil of heresy had entered its ranks.

Even before the death of Saint Francis, a division began to form within the Order that would lead to significant consequences. This division was between a group that was passionate about the strict observance of Evangelical poverty and another group that only maintained the appearance of it. The latter group allowed themselves to stray from that original principle in various ways, enjoying the splendor of convents and churches.

Elias, the second general of the Order and a disciple of Francis himself, had mounted a horse. This act caused turmoil within the Order. He was condemned and anathematized by one faction, while the other faction applauded him. In opposition to him stood Antony of Padua. Antony barely escaped being imprisoned in the convent cells for daring to question and reprimand the leniencies allowed by Elias. He took a stand based on the original constitution established by the founder. Eventually, Elias was humbled, deposed, and cast aside.

The central question was how to reconcile any possessions necessary for life with the concept of evangelical poverty. They made a distinction between the right of property and the simple use of someone else's property to meet essential life needs. The Franciscans were to own nothing as property, but the right to manage all goods should be given to the Pope. This led to the emergence of two factions: the stricter Franciscans and the more lenient Franciscans. The popes, particularly Nicolas III, through his bull issued in 1297, supported the principles of the more lenient faction. This support intensified the fanatical zeal of the stricter faction, leading to conflict with the Church itself.

In 1256, when Bonaventura was appointed General, he issued a circular letter to the leaders of the Order in their various provinces. He urged them, in the strongest terms, to do everything possible to eliminate the abuses that had developed. “The danger of the times,” he wrote, “the violations of our own consciences, the scandal of worldly people, to whom the Order, which should be a mirror of holiness, has instead become an object of contempt and disgust—all urge us to action.”

He then listed several specific issues that had damaged the Order's reputation. These included the love of money, expensive and lavish buildings, the monopolization of drawing up wills, and the greedy behavior of the traveling friars. “For, as they cannot be satisfied with a little,” he said, “and as the love of men has grown cold, we have all become unbearable, and we will become even more so unless some remedy is applied soon. So let the fervor of your zeal shine forth, and after you have purified the house of your Father in heaven from those who have turned it into a den of merchandise, let it ignite in all the brethren the fire of prayer and devotion.”

He recommended being more careful in admitting new members and that friars should not be allowed to hear confessions and preach to the people indiscriminately. Again, in a special letter to one of the provincial superiors, he spoke about the troubling state of affairs and the general discontent directed at the Order. He urged him to put an end to the violence of the friars, who attacked the secular clergy during their public sermons, stirring up conflict and hatred, and causing division. He again criticized the greed of the friars in collecting money through begging and by lingering around deathbeds. “Let it be clear to the whole world that they are not seeking their own benefit, but the salvation of souls.”

During the eighteen years that Bonaventura served as the general, he worked tirelessly to uphold the true spirit of the Order. He focused on suppressing the constant threats of division that could lead to schism and managing the extreme and mystical ideas of some of its members. John of Parma, the seventh General of the Minorites, was the most extreme member of the Spiritualist and rigorist faction. His first action was to visit all the monasteries of the Order to enforce the strictest observance of poverty. He was sent by Pope Innocent IV to Greece to try to reconcile the Eastern schism. In 1251, he was back in Rome. In 1256, the same year that William of S. Amour published his bold book, there were initial murmurs of discontent, which soon turned into open rebellion against his leadership. He was suspected of being the author of the Everlasting Gospel. Although he was not the author, according to Salembene, the fact that the book was attributed to him indicates that his views aligned with it. Moreover, Gerardino da San Donino was too closely associated with him for him to be completely exonerated from the accusations of involvement in the work.

John of Parma was deposed, and his position was taken over by S. Bonaventura. Bonaventura's task was to eliminate or conceal the heretical beliefs that had spread throughout the Order, to such an extent that they had influenced its general. S. Bonaventura is believed to have treated the deposed general harshly by sending him to a remote convent where he faded into obscurity among uneducated novices. However, Bonaventura understood the danger facing the Order and recognized that only decisive actions could prevent the harmful ideas from spreading and destroying the entire community. Soon, the Fraticelli would openly rebel against the Popes, and Clement V would have to condemn the Beghards, the lay members, or tertiaries, of S. Francis, as serious heretics. Later, John XXII would issue a special bull to assure the Christian world that the Beghards, despite claiming to be Franciscans, were outside the path to salvation.

Saint Bonaventura worked diligently with his pen; he had a strong aversion to idleness. He wrote about theology and philosophy; he composed commentaries on Holy Scripture, and a tedious and useless task — on the Master of Sentences. He was also a poet, and some of his hymns express the most tender and loving piety. In 1260, a general chapter of the Order gathered at Narbonne requested him to write a life of their great founder, Saint Francis. It was a labor of love.

One day, while he was working on it in his cell, Saint Thomas Aquinas came to visit him. Before opening the door, he looked through a crack and saw the rapt expression on Bonaventura's face, indicating that he was deeply absorbed in his work. He withdrew and said to those who accompanied him, “Let us not disturb the saint laboring for the saint.”

One day, the Angelical Doctor asked him, “How do you find time to read? What do you study?” He was amazed at Bonaventura's sweetness and depth, knowing the distractions he faced in managing the affairs of his Order. Bonaventura replied, “My book is the Crucifix.”

In 1263, Bonaventura was present at the opening of the tomb of Saint Antony of Padua and the transfer of his relics. Soon after, he celebrated a general chapter at Pisa. He had a great devotion to the mystery of the Incarnation, which was threatened by the intellectual skepticism of his time. He ordered that in the Order, between Christmas and Epiphany, at the end of the hymns, the following should be sung: “Gloria tibi Domine, qui natus es de Virgine,” and at Prime, the response, “Qui natus es de Maria Virgine.” He also mandated that the feasts of the Conception and Visitation of Our Lady should be observed in his Order, and these festivals have since spread throughout the Church.

After holding the chapter, Bonaventura went to Rome to ask Pope Urban IV to appoint a protector for his congregation. The Holy Father offered him Ancher Pantaleon, Cardinal of Saint Praxedes, who was his nephew; but the saint chose instead Cardinal John Gaetan. Urban IV, who was the son of a cobbler from Troyes, found that the College of Cardinals consisted of only eight members at the time of his accession. He quickly worked to increase the number to twenty-two. His nephew naturally received one of the vacant cardinal positions; however, he was neither by birth nor abilities equal to the requirements of Bonaventura as a protector of his Order. The saint felt burdened by the responsibility placed on the Minorites to serve as confessors and directors of the nuns of Saint Clare, an order that was connected to and emerged from the Order of Saint Francis. The great founder had said, with a sigh, “God has not...”

“Given us wives, so the Devil has pestered us with Sisters.” Managing these nuns and dealing with their internal conflicts, jealousies, and grievances was a task from which St. Bonaventura initially urged the pope to release his friars in vain. His persistence paid off, and by papal decree, he curtailed the claims and demands of the nuns. If a Franciscan listened to their troubles and guided their troubled souls from then on, it was out of charity, not obligation.

In 1264, Urban IV died; and after a wait of four months, Ugo Falcodi became Pope Clement IV. In 1267, Godfrey, the archbishop of York, died, and without considering the rights of the canons to elect a successor, Clement offered the important position to Bonaventura. The English Church was overwhelmed with Italian priests. Innocent IV had instructed the compliant King Henry III to ensure that three hundred Roman clergy were provided for in England. Stephen, the pope’s chaplain, was given the office and income of the wealthy archdeaconry of Canterbury without being required to perform any of its duties; he also held the archdeaconry of Vienne in France, which he equally neglected.

Robert Grostete, the saintly bishop of Lincoln, estimated that foreign priests and the Papal treasury took an annual sum of 70,000 marks from England; the king’s income was not even one-third of that amount. Grostete had received an order through the Papal nuncio to grant a canonry at Lincoln to a child named Frederick, the pope’s nephew. He firmly refused, saying, “I am bound by filial reverence to obey all commands of the Apostolic See; but those are not Apostolic commands which are inconsistent with the doctrine of the Apostles and the Master of the Apostles, Christ Jesus.” The Pope was furious, asking, “Who is this old fool who presumes to judge our actions? Is not the King of England our vassal; nay, rather, our slave, and will he not, at a sign from us, imprison this bishop?”

The Barons were in revolt, no longer able to endure the unbearable demands placed upon them. Aylmer, the bishop-elect of Winchester, was from Poitou; Peter of Hereford was from Burgundy. William of Valence and Peter of Savoy had the attention of the weak king and insulted and mistreated the English without regard for the law. “In those days,” says Matthew Paris, “the Romans and their legates dominated in England, causing much harm to both laypeople and clergy regarding the rights to churches, providing their own friends with rich vacant church positions at will, opposing bishops, abbots, and other religious figures, and involving them in excommunication. The nobles, therefore, outraged by such acts of arrogance, took action, albeit late, to find a solution, and forced the foreigners to flee the kingdom.” The pope, Urban IV, then excommunicated the barons; however, several English bishops refused to announce the interdict. The bishops of Winchester, Worcester, London, and Chichester were subsequently excommunicated.

At this moment, Godfrey, the archbishop of York, died; and Clement IV pressured Bonaventura to take the vacant position. The Saint recognized, unlike the pope, that the appointment of another foreigner to one of the most powerful sees in England would lead to further conflict and could result in his own expulsion, along with the suffering caused by an interdict on the land. With commendable goodwill, he declined the flattering offer.

Clement accepted the refusal graciously, saying, in the words of Ecclesiasticus, “Stand in your covenant, and speak therein, and do not let the works of your commandments grow old.”

Some years later, Bonaventura gathered a general chapter of his Order at Assisi, the birthplace of the founder. It was at this meeting that he mandated that in all convents of the Fraternity, the devotion of the “Angelus” should be recited every evening in honor of the Incarnation. This devotion has since spread throughout Western Christendom.

On November 29th, 1268, Pope Clement IV died, creating a vacancy in the papacy that lasted more than two years. The reasons for the disagreements among the Cardinals are not clear. The French Cardinals may have wanted to elect another French pope, while the Italian Cardinals may have stubbornly opposed this idea. They resisted the blasphemous mockery of the Bishop of Porto, who suggested removing the roof of the chamber to eliminate any obstruction to the Divine guidance they were seeking. It is said, and this claim is believable, that Bonaventura was urged to take the position of Saint Peter, but he declined. He was Italian by birth, French by education and residence, making him a candidate both sides could agree on. According to another account, they sought his advice, but it is unclear whether they followed it.

Eventually, the Cardinals gave full power to six of their members to conduct the conclave, and their choice, possibly influenced by Bonaventura, fell on Theobald, the exiled archdeacon of Liège, who was fleeing from his archbishop, the reckless Henry of Guelders. Henry had seriously harmed the reputation of a relative, and Theobald was currently on a pilgrimage in the Holy Land.

Theobald returned to Italy and was consecrated as Gregory X. Perhaps in gratitude for his role in guiding the election, Gregory immediately decided to make Bonaventura a Cardinal. However, the humble servant of God, upon hearing of this plan, who cared little for titles and worldly honor, and fearing new responsibilities, secretly fled back to Paris and began writing his work on the "Visions of the Church in the Hexaemeron." Gregory sent a messenger after him with explicit orders to return. Reluctantly, Bonaventura complied. Upon reaching the borders of Tuscany, he rested for a few days in the Franciscan convent of Nugello, near Florence. Two nuncios, sent to present him with the cardinal's hat, learned of his location and came to the small convent in search of him. They found the Saint with his sleeves rolled up, washing the plates in the kitchen after dinner. He refused to break the rule of the Order, which required all the brothers to take turns with menial tasks. The dignified nuncios were taken aback. Bonaventura, without embarrassment, smiled, apologized, and excused himself from their business until he finished drying the plates. They presented the hat, the symbol of the highly sought-after rank.

He said he would only get it dirty with his greasy fingers. "Hang it up on the dogwood tree!" said the Saint, pointing to a tree that shaded the kitchen door, "and show the nuncios to the reception room."

When his work was finished, he dried his hands, rolled down his sleeves, and took the hat from the branch where it was hanging. “Alas!” he said with a sigh, “it is pleasant to carry out the duties of a friar minor, and now I must bend my back to cares and responsibilities, full of danger.”

Saint Bonaventura. Upon arriving in Rome, he was consecrated as the bishop of Alba, one of the six suffragan bishops of Rome. Gregory had barely taken the Pontifical throne when he decided to hold a great Ecumenical Council, hoping to revive the waning enthusiasm of the West for the Sepulchre of the Savior. Lyons was chosen as the city for this council, which was scheduled to meet two years later. It convened in 1274. Gregory X took his place at the head of five hundred bishops, seventy abbots, and at least a thousand high-ranking church officials. Every kingdom in the West recognized its ecumenical authority. The Dominican theologian Thomas Aquinas and the Franciscan theologian Bonaventura were invited to attend. The Angelic Doctor died on his way to the Council. The Seraphic Doctor was present and preached during its sessions, but he died before it concluded.

He fell ill on July 6th and died on July 14th. The Pope, along with the entire Council, attended the funeral, which took place in the convent of the Minorites in Lyons. The officiant was Cardinal Peter of Tarentaise, a Dominican and bishop of Ostia, who later became Pope Innocent V. He preached from the text, “Doleo super te, frater mi Jonatha, amabilis et dilecte nimis.” (I am distressed for you, my brother Jonathan; very pleasant have you been to me. 2 Samuel 1:26.) The relics of Saint Bonaventura were taken up and enshrined in 1430, with the head and heart separated from the rest. In the next century, when the Huguenots controlled Lyons, the bones of the Seraphic Doctor were publicly burned in the marketplace, but his head was hidden and saved by a Minorite friar.

The head still exists, along with an arm bone in Bagnera, his native village. Another is said to be preserved in Venice.

Saint Bonaventura is usually depicted with an angel communicating with him. According to the legend, his humility was so profound that he would not approach the altar, and an angel therefore visited him and gave him the holy Sacrament.

Well in the Cathedral at Ratiebon Separation of the Holy Apostles.

Footnotes

  1. Godfrey of Boulogne was a leader in the First Crusade and became the first ruler of the Kingdom of Jerusalem.
  2. Lanfranc was an Italian Benedictine monk and theologian who became the Archbishop of Canterbury.
  3. Innocent IV issued his famous bull, placing the Mendicant Orders under the authority of bishops.
  4. "From the Litanies of the Dominicans, good Lord deliver us" became a common saying.
  5. William of St. Amour wrote “The Perils of the Last Times,” criticizing the Mendicants.
  6. Gerson was the chancellor of the University of Paris.
  7. Determinationes circ. regulam S. Francisci. Opp. T. ril. ed. Logd.
  8. Contra impugnantes Religionem. Opusc. xri. ed. Venet. T. xix., p 341.
  9. Bonaventura: A Franciscan theologian and saint, known for his writings on spirituality.
  10. John of Parma was the seventh General of the Minorites.
  11. Pope Innocent IV was a pope from 1243 to 1254.
  12. The Fraticelli were a group of spiritual Franciscans who broke away from the main Order.
  13. Clement V was a pope from 1305 to 1314.
  14. John XXII was a pope from 1316 to 1334.
  15. “Let us not disturb the saint laboring for the saint.”
  16. Grostete estimated that foreign priests and the Papal treasure took an annual sum of 70,000 marks from England.
  17. The Pope was furious, asking, “Who is this old fool who presumes to judge our actions?”
  18. Stand in your covenant, and speak therein, and do not let the works of your commandments grow old.
  19. Theobald was the exiled archdeacon of Liège.
  20. Bonaventura was a humble servant of God and a prominent theologian.
  21. Doleo super te, frater mi Jonatha, amabilis et dilecte nimis: I am distressed for you, my brother Jonathan; very pleasant have you been to me. 2 Samuel 1:26.

Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.

Read the original 1890s text

At the age of twenty-one, a serious, studious youth, he presented himself before the gates of a Franciscan convent, and demanded the habit of a novice. As he gave great tokens of ability, his superiors sent him to Paris to study theology under Alexander Hales. Hales died in 1245, and Bonaventura became a novice in 1242, so that he must have been sent almost immediately to Paris. It is necessary here briefly to review the condition of the University of Paris, and the strong dissensions which tore it, to understand the part Bonaventura was afterwards called to play. The University of Paris had grown up gradually to the greatest dimensions. A few teachers came at first, as adventurers, to teach in the Episcopal schools; their Lives of ihe Saints.

ability drew scholars, attracted other teachers to set up, and so the University began to form itself. Godfrey of Boulogne, bishop of Paris, founded a great school, towards the end of the nth cent. Lanfranc came, taught there, and crowded its benches with eager learners.

By degrees the number of the students became so great, pouring in from every part of Europe, that the University was organised. The episcopal seminaries of S. Victor, S. Genevieve, and S. Germain formed the basis of this splendid institution. Professors gave lectures on medicine, others on canon law, others on philosophy, until Paris became crammed with a diverse population of boys and men from every quarter of Europe, eager, excited, full of fiery passions and daring intellects, hungering for knowledge, or, perhaps making the quest of knowledge an excuse for living free of religious and moral restraints. Crowded into lodgings where there was little room, they were exposed to every sort of temptation. Paris exhibited a spectacle of great public disorder, debauchery and crime. The professors, in great part, were reckless adventurers, seeking only excitement for the mind, and money for the pocket. The students were, in main, disorderly youths, living in the very centre of corruption, without control, loving a noisy, dissipated life in town. But this teeming hot-bed of young life and intellectual expansion threatened the church with dangerous and daring speculation. There were Abelard and William of Champeaux, not cautious to tread in the beaten theologic path, leading their pupils to audacious questioning into truths hitherto taken for granted. The Mendicant Orders, the Dominicans, and Franciscans, cast longing eyes on Paris, and coveted a position jaijr Z4-] 5 *, Bonaventura. 329 in the University, where they could meet and combat these bold speculators, these irreverant disputants, on their own ground.

An opportunity offered, in 1229. A quarrel broke out between the University and the City authorities. In a fierce fray between the students and the townsmen, two of the former had been killed by the city guard. The University demanded satisfaction; it was refused, and the University resentfully closed her gates. The students swarmed off to Rheims, Orleans, and Angers. The Dominicans seized this opportunity; they obtained licence to establish a chair of theology, and on the return of the students to Paris, they found the Dominicans in possession of a large share in the theologic instruction. The Dominicans were followed by the Franciscans. The former boasted Albertus Magnus, the latter Alexander Hales, the subtlest of the new race of schoolmen.

They were followed in their turn by others; and the University raised a loud outcry, that there were twelve chairs of theology at Paris, and of these only two were for the whole secular clergy, the Religious Orders had seized on, and held the remainder. The University suppressed one of the chairs belonging to the Dominicans, then passed sentence of expulsion on the Dominican professors, when they refused obedience. The Dominicans appealed to the Pope. Innocent IV. promulgated his celebrated bull, subjugatingthe Mendicant Orders to episcopal authority. Next month he was dead. The Dominicans assumed the merit of having prayed him to death, and 11 From the Litanies of the Dominicans, good Lord deliver us,” became a proverbial saying.

Innocent was succeeded by Alexander IV., who annulled the bull of his predecessor ten days after his election. William of S. Amour, the champion of the University, in vain remonstrated, appealed, protested. What was contrary to the canons, what infringed the rights of the bishops could not be allowed, he urged, even to Popes. They must enforce obedience to the episcopate, not upset the authority of the bishops by emancipating the Mendicants from their rule. The Mendicant Orders lived in idleness on begging; S. Paul preferred to work with his hands at an honourable trade. The Mendicants demanded leisure to study; but what were the results of their study but pedantry and hair-splitting.

William of S. Amour ascended the pulpit against the Mendicants. He accused the friars of going about into houses, leading silly women captive, laden with sins, usurping everywhere rule over women’s consciences and men’s property, aspiring to tyrannize over public opinion.

The University refused to act upon the Papal bull re-instituting the Dominicans; rather than do so, she would dissolve her republic. The indignant friars denounced S. Amour as having disseminated a libel defamatory of the Pope. He swore his guiltlessness of this crime, and four thousand scholars stood forward as his compurgators.

But there was a dangerous element at work among the Franciscans, which presented an opportunity to S. Amour he was not slow to turn to account. The Franciscan Order, recruited from the lowest ranks of society, had absorbed into it, by its enthusiasm, its zeal for purity and poverty, many of those with Puritan or even Manichaean tendencies, who had troubled the S. Bonaventura, peace of Lombardy and Provence during more than a century.

A large number of Waldensian heretics had been formed into a religious confraternity in Toulouse; but without success, they had relapsed. In Lombardy the Patarines had been acknowledged by Gregory VII. as the champions of orthodoxy in the matter of clerical celibacy, and if they were afterwards consigned to the flames as incorrigible heretics, it was only because they had not taken refuge under the cowl of S. Francis. This latent Manichaeism, this brooding heresy, had its sacred Book, its exponent, entitled the Introduction to the Everlasting Gospel. It was soon to break forth into flagrant, furious heresy, in the Fraticelli. The Introduction to the Everlasting Gospel was ascribed to the Abbot Joachim, the prophet, whose words and portent had thrilled Europe at the close of the 12th cent. Joachim, the Calabrian abbot of Flora, had pronounced dire woes over the infant Frederick II. He had forced the Empress Frederick’s mother to her knees, whilst he heard her confession. His disciple and confidant, Luke, was archbishop of Cosenza. At the instigation of Henry VI., the Abbot Joachim had written commentaries on the Old Testament prophecies, Merlin and the Sibyls; and the greatest preachers and logicians of the time did not hesitate to pore over the books of the renowned Calabrian seer. 1 After his death, Friar Gerardino, of San Donino, who taught grammar in Sicily, composed the strange book, the Introduction to the Everlasting Gospel, which supplemented the revelations of Abbot Joachim, and threw the whole religious world into confusion. 3 This book 1 Salim bene.

announced that the world was ordained to traverse three epochs, to be placed under three dispensations: — those of the Law, the Gospel, and the Spirit. The Father had ruled and enlightened the Jews, the Son had taught, founded the Church, and now the dispensation of the Son was to be displaced by that of the Holy Ghost. The hierarchy, the priesthood, the sacraments — all that were of the Son — were to fade before the general illumination of the Spirit diffused through the Minorite Order. The new, the Everlasting Gospel, superseded and abolished the other four. It suited the enemies of the Mendicants to involve both Orders in the odious charge of teaching this new heresy; but the Everlasting Gospel in its tone, in its teaching, breathed the Franciscan spirit, or rather that of the covert Manichaeism which had concealed itself in the convents of the Minorites.

The University of Paris sent a deputation to Rome to obtain the condemnation of the Everlasting Gospel, which was being secretly disseminated through France, # and was raising a ferment among the people, which might end in a general revolt against the hierarchy and the clergy. But the University was forestalled by the Mendicants. Before the arrival of the mission, the Dominicans had struck their blow. William of S. Amour had also written a book, the “ Perils of the Last Times,” a denunciation of the tendencies and conduct of the Mendicants. It was a relentless, covert, galling exposure of them and their proceedings under the form of an interpretation of Revelation. The ostensible object of the work was to draw out, by means of Holy Scripture, the character of those false prophets who are to appear at the end of the world; and who are spoken of by S. Paul in his 2nd Epistle to S. Bonaventura.

Timothy. These the author sketched, these il lovers of themselves, proud, boasters, incontinent, unmerciful, traitors, high-minded, lovers of pleasure more than lovers of God,” in such lively and unmistakeable colours, that it was impossible for all not to recognize — and the Dominicans and Franciscans by their indignation admitted that there must have been some truth in the picture — the lineaments of the new Orders, which were overrunning Western Christendom, and sowing that seed of insubordination to the bishops and secular clergy which was after three centuries to break forth in a general revolt, which would sweep both friars and seculars away in an indiscriminate insurrection against authority. The book of S. Amour was condemned, 41 not on account of heresy, but as an incentive to revolt,” against the Orders of Mendicants; and S. Amour was cast forth to die in exile, deprived of his benefices. Such was the condition of the University of Paris when S. Bonaventura studied, and afterwards taught, there. His learning, his piety, his unassailable orthodoxy, did much to rehabilitate the reputation of the Minorites, shaken by the dissemination of the Introduction to the Everlasting Gospel.

il I do not know,” says Gerson, the great chancellor of the University, u if ever the University of Paris has produced a doctor equal to Bonaventura.” And elsewhere, “ If you were to ask me which of all our doctors was the most perfect, I would reply, without prejudice to the others, that Bonaventura was the one; because he is solid, sure, pious and devout in all he says, and he does not embarrass his lessons with entering into curious and useless questions.” And again, u There is no teaching more exalted, divine or salutary, or indeed more fascinating for true theologians than his; and one may tJulf 14.

apply to him the words spoken by Our Lord of S. John; He was a burning and a shining light.” Bonaventura was not a philosopher like his contemporary, S. Thomas Aquinas; if he philosophizes, it is not because he cares for, loves philosophy; but because it is the fashion of his day. He is a mystic rather than a thinker. His philosophy — such as it is — rests on the idea of the soul being in exile from God, straining, rising, losing itself in God. His most popular work is the “ Itinerary of the Soul to God.” The love of God, and the knowledge of God, proceed harmoniously together through four stages. The external light, by which we learn the mechanical arts; the inferior light, the understanding which illumines the senses; the eternal light, the reason, which sees the motive causes; the superior light of grace, which reveals to us God.

Bonaventura thus defines the place of man in the world. God created all things for his own glory — not, as some argued, for the good of the creature — and as the manifestation of his light, the communication of his goodness. But there can be no perfect revelation without some to understand it, no communication of goodness without some capable of enjoying it. Since this capacity of understanding and enjoyment belongs only to rational creatures, the irrational creature stands in no immediate, but only in an indirect relation to God, and that, through the medium of the rational creature. But rational creatures, being created to praise and know God, are therefore created to stand in immediate relation to God; and by virtue of this immediate relation, are capable of communion with God, and God can hold communion with them. This communion is the perfecting of the relation; the highest exaltation of man. July i4-l S. Bonaventura.

Therefore the object of man is the elevation of his intellect, his intelligence, his soul into perfect union, almost identification with God.

Bonaventura was not only a theological teacher; he was also an ardent defender of his Order. With the greatest justice he could affirm, that the bad state of the clergy had rendered the friars a necessity, or at least had given a just excuse for the formation and extension of the Mendicant Orders. He maintained that “because sins within the Church were continually on the increase, and the bishops, occupied with external affairs, could not attend to the spiritual concerns of their dioceses; because few pastors resided in their parishes, but committed the guidance of souls to needy curates, ignorant, negligent, unchaste — therefore the Pope, on whom devolves the custody of the Church, has called us to the assistance of the clergy and the communities.” 1 And thus he describes the Franciscans of his day: — 44 No one among us is allowed to be idle, except the sick. Some busy themselves with study, to qualify themselves for the office of instructors of the faithful; others, with the performance of divine worship; others, with collecting alms for the support of the community; others bestow their services on the sick; those who have learned trades work at them for the benefit of the brethren and of strangers; others, who are so directed, travel through different lands employed on missions.” 8 He concedes to William of S. Amour, that many of the bad things censured by him were really to be found in individuals amongst them; but he complained of the injustice he had done them in charging the whole body 1 ** Determ inationes circ. regulam S. Francisci.” Opp. T. ril. f ed. Logd. £ s "Contra impugnantea Reltgioncm.” Opusc. xri. ed. Venet. T. xix., p 341. with the faults of a few. “ That which is bad floats on the surface, and is noticed by all. True holiness is a hidden thing, to be found only by certain marks.” At the age of thirty-six, in the thirteenth of his profession, Bonaventura was unanimously elected General of his Order, in his absence, by a chapter held in Rome, in the presence of Alexander IV. No choice could have been better. The Order was in a critical condition. It was threatened with schism. The ferment of heresy had entered its veins.

Even before the death of S. Francis, there was formed within the Order the germ of a schism leading to important consequences — the strife between a party who were zealous for the literal observance of Evangelical poverty; and another, who retained only the appearance of it, but in the splendour of convents and churches, as well as in other respects, allowed themselves to depart, in manifold ways, from that original principle. Elias, the second general, a disciple of Francis himself, had mounted a horse; the Order was convulsed; he was condemned, anathematized by one party, applauded by the other. In opposition to him stood forth Antony of Padua. Hardly escaping perpetual imprisonment in the convent cells, for daring to question and reprimand the gentle relaxations allowed by Elias, he took up his position on the original constitution of the founder. Elias was humbled, deposed, cast aside.

The question was, how to unite any possession whatever, necessary for this life, with evangelical poverty. They distinguished between a right of property, and the simple use of another’s property for the satisfaction of the necessary wants of life. As property the Franciscans should possess nothing; but the right 6 1. Bonaventura.

of property in all goods administered by them should be given to the Pope. Thus arose the two parties of the more strict, and the mild Franciscans. The popes, by their explanations of the Franciscan rule, especially Nicolas III., by his bull, issued in 1297, favoured the principles of the milder party, and the fanatical zeal of the more strict was fanned into conflict with the Church itself.

In 1256, when Bonaventura was appointed General, he issued a circular letter to the presiding officers of the Order in their several provinces, calling upon them, in the most urgent manner, to do their utmost to remove the abuses that had crept in. “The danger of the times,” he wrote, “ the violations of our own consciences; the scandal of worldly people, to whom the Order, which should be as a mirror of holiness, has become instead an object of contempt and abhorrence — all urge us to action.” He then proceeded to enumerate several particulars which had brought the Order into bad repute. Lust of gold, costly and sumptuous buildings, the monopoly of drawing up of wills, and the grasping greed of the itinerant brethren. “ For, as they cannot be satisfied with a little,” said he; “ and, as the love of men has waxen cold, we have all become intolerable, and we shall be more so, unless some remedy be not soon applied. So let the ardour of your zeal burn forth, and after you have purified the house of your Father in heaven from those who have made it a den of merchandise, let it kindle in all the brethren the fire of prayer and devotion.” He recommended greater caution in the admission of members, and that friars should not be promiscuously permitted to hear confessions and preach to the people. Again, in a special letter to one of the provincial superiors, he VOL. vii. 22 338 Lives 0/ the Saints. u^r M.

spoke of the threatening aspect of affairs, the general | discontent aroused against the Order. He exhorted I him to stop the violence of the friars, who assaulted the secular clergy in their public sermons, stirring up strife and hatred, and causing schism. Again he remonstrated with the rapacity of the friars in accumulating money by begging and by hovering round death-beds. “Let it appear manifest to the whole world that they are not seeking their own advantage; but the salvation of souls.”

During the eighteen years that Bonaventura was general, he was indefatigable in maintaining the true spirit of the Order, in repressing the dissension which was constantly threatening it with schism, and in controlling the fanatical and mystic vagaries of some of its members. John of Parma, the seventh General of the Minorites, was the extremest of the Spiritualist, rigorist party. His first act had been a visitation of all the monasteries of the Order, to enforce the strict observance of poverty in its severest form. He was employed by Innocent IV., in Greece, in an endeavour to reconcile the Eastern schism. In 1251, he was again in Rome. In 1256, exactly the very year in which came forth the daring book of William of S. Amour, there were first sullen murmurs, then open revolt against his rule. He was suspected of having been the author of the Everlasting Gospel. This he was not, if we may trust Salembene; but the fact of his having had the book attributed to him shows that his views were in accordance with it, and indeed Gerardino da San Donino was in too close connection with him for him to be altogether released from the charge of complicity in the work.

John of Parma was deposed, his place was occupied it * 6 ". Bonaventura. by S. Bonaventura; and his task was to root out, or cover over, the heretical tenets which had spread through the Order, and, that to such an extent, that it had affected its general. S. Bonaventura is thought to have dealt harshly with the displaced general, in banishing him to the obscurity of a remote convent where he disappeared from sight among rude and ignorant novices. But Bonaventura knew the danger that threatened the Order, and that only sharp measures could stay the poison from penetrating and killing the whole society. Ere long the Fraticelli will be in open revolt against the Popes, and Clement V. will have to condemn the Beghards, the lay members, or tertiaries, of S. Francis, as outrageous heretics, and later, John XXII., to assure the Christian world, by special bull, that the Beghards, though claiming to be Franciscans, are beyond the pale of salvation.

S. Bonaventura worked diligently with his pen; he had the greatest horror of idleness. He wrote on theology, on philosophy; he composed commentaries on Holy Scripture, and tedious and useless task — on the Master of Sentences. He was a poet, and some of his hymns breathe the tenderest, most loving piety. He was requested by a general chapter of the Order assembled at Narbonne in 1260, to undertake a life of their great founder, S. Francis. It was a labour 01 love. As he was engaged on it one day, in his cell, S. Thomas Aquinas came to see him; before opening the door he looked through a chink, and saw in the rapt expression of the writer that he was absorbed in his work. He withdrew, saying to those who accompanied him, “ Let us net disturb the saint labouring for the saint.” 1 1 “ Sinamua Sanctum qul laborat pro Sancto." “ How do you find time to read, what do you study ?” asked the Angelical Doctor one day of him; wondering at his sweetness, his depth, and knowing what distraction he had in regulating the affairs of his Order. “My book,” answered Bonaventura, “is the Crucifix.” In 1263, Bonaventura was present at the opening of the tomb of S. Antony of Padua, and the translation of his relics. Soon after he celebrated a general Chapter at Pisa. As he had a great devotion to the mystery of the Incarnation, threatened by the intellectual scepticism of his day, he ordered that in the Order, between Christmas and Epiphany, at the close of the hymns, should be sung: “ Gloria tibi Domine, qui natus es de Virgine,” and at Prime, the response, “ Qui natus es de Maria Virgine,” and that the feasts of the Conception and Visitation of Our Lady should be observed in his Order, and these festivals have since extended throughout the Church.

After holding the chapter, Bonaventura went to Rome to ask the pope, Urban IV., to give his congregation a protector. The Holy Father offered him Ancher Pantaleon, Cardinal of S. Praxedes, his nephew; but the Saint chose instead Cardinal John Gaetan. Urban IV., son of a cobbler at Troyes, had found the College of Cardinals, at his accession, to consist of only eight. He hastened to fill up the number to twenty-two. His nephew naturally received one of the vacant hats; but he was neither by birth nor abilities equal to the requirements of Bonaventura, as a protector of his Order. The Saint groaned under the burden that was imposed on the Minorites of being confessors and directors of the nuns of S. Clare, an order attached to and sprung out of the Order of S. Francis. The great founder had said, with a sigh, “ God has not 5 1. Bonaventura.

July x 4 0 given us wives, so the Devil has pestered us with Sisters.” The management of these nuns, the composing of their intestine discords, jealousies, heartburnings, was a task from which S. Bonaventura at first, in vain, urged the pope to release his friars. His urgency prevailed, and by bull cut short the claims, the demands of the nuns. If a Franciscan henceforward listened to their woes, and directed their disturbed souls, it was in charity, not out of obligation. In 1264, Urban IV. died; and, after a suspense of four months, Ugo Falcodi ascended the chair of S. Peter, and assumed the title of Clement IV. In 1267 died Godfrey, archbishop of York, and without paying attention to the rights of the canons to elect a successor, Clement offered the important see to Bonaventura. The English Church was flooded with Italian priests. Innocent IV. had demanded of the compliant king, Henry III., that provision should be made in it for three hundred Roman clergy. Stephen, the pope’s chaplain, had been given the office and revenues of the rich archdeaconry of Canterbury, without being required to execute any of its duties; he also held in France, and equally neglected, the archdeaconry of Vienne. Robert Grostete, the saintly bishop of Lincoln, estimated that foreign priests and the Papal treasure drew annually from England the sum of 70,000 marks; the king’s income was not onethird of the sum. Grostete had received command, through the Papal nuncio, to confer a canonry at Lincoln, on a child, Frederick, the nephew of the pope. He had firmly refused. “ I am bound by filial reverence to obey all commands of the Apostolic See; but those are not Apostolic commands which are inconsistent with the doctrine of the Apostles, and the Master of the TJttiy *4.

Apostles, Christ Jesus.” The Pope was furious, “Who is this old dotard who presumes to judge our acts ? Is not the King of England our vassal; nay, rather, our slave, and will he not, at a sign from us, imprison this bishop ?”

The Barons were in revolt, unable any longer to endure the intolerable exactions. Aylmer, bishop elect of Winchester, was a Poitevin; Peter of Hereford was a Burgundian. William of Valence and Peter of Savoy had the ear of the weak king, and insulted and maltreated the English without heed to law. “In those days,” says Matthew Paris, “the Romans and their legates lorded it in England, causing much injury to laymen as well as ecclesiastics in the matter of advowsons of churches, providing their own friends with rich vacant benefices at pleasure, setting themselves in opposition to bishops, abbots, and other religious men, and involving them in the sentence of excommunication. The nobles, therefore, indignant at such acts of pride, bestirred themselves, late though it was, to apply a remedy, and compelled the foreigners to fly the kingdom.” The pope, Urban IV., thereupon excommunicated the barons; but several of the English bishops refused to publish the interdict. The bishops of Winchester, Worcester, London, and Chichester were therefore excommunicated. It was at this juncture that Godfrey, archbishop of York, died; and Clement IV. pressed the vacant see on Bonaventura. The Saint saw, what the pope did not, that the intrusion of another foreigner into one of the most influential sees of England would cause fresh strife, and might lead to his expulsion, and the miseries of an interdict falling on the land in consequence; with good feeling, that does him credit, he declined the flattering offer. Joir uO.S'. Bonaventura.

Clement received the refusal graciously, saying, in the words of Ecclesiasticus, u Sta in testamento tuo, et in illo colloquere, et ne opere mandatorum tuorum veterasce.”

Some years afterwards, Bonaventura assembled a general chapter of his Order at Assisi, the birthplace of the founder. It was then that he ordered in all convents of the Fraternity, that the devotion of the 11 Angelus ” should be said every evening in honour of the Incarnation. This devotion has spread since throughout Western Christendom.

On November 29th, 1268, died Pope Clement IV., and there was a vacancy of more than two years in the supreme Pontificate. The cause of this dissension among the Cardinals nowhere transpires. The French Cardinals may have been ambitious to elect another French pope, and this the Italian minority may have stubbornly refused. They withstood the blasphemous mockery of the Bishop of Porto, to remove the roof of the chamber, as an obstruction to the Divine guidance they had invoked. It is asserted, and the assertion is credible, that Bonaventura was urged, but in vain, to ascend the chair of S. Peter. He was an Italian by birth, a Frenchman by education and place of residence, and in him both parties could unite. According to another story, his advice was asked; but we do not know that it was followed. At length, the Cardinals delegated to six of their number the full power of the conclave, and their choice fell, possibly directed by Bonaventura, on Theobald, the banished archdeacon of Liège, flying from his archbishop, the reckless Henry of Guelders, who had wronged most grievously the honour of a kinswoman, and Theobald was now on pilgrimage in the Holy Land.

U»iy m. Theobald returned to Italy, and was consecrated under the name of Gregory X. Perhaps in gratitude for his voice in directing the election, Gregory at once resolved to make Bonaventura a Cardinal. But the humble servant of God, hearing of his design, caring nothing for titles and worldly honour, and dreading fresh responsibilities, fled secretly, and returning to Paris, began to write his work on the 44 Visions of the Church in the Hexaemeron.” Gregory sent after him a messenger, with express orders to return. Reluctantly he obeyed. On reaching the confines of Tuscany, he rested for a few days in the Franciscan convent of Nugello, near Florence. Two nuncios, who had been sent to present him with the hat, heard where he was, and came to the little convent, seeking him. They found the Saint with his sleeves tucked up, in the kitchen washing up the plates after dinner. He would not relax for himself the rule of the Order, which prescribed the menial task for all the brethren in turn. The stately nuncios stood aghast. Bonaventura, without a blush, smiled, apologised, and excused himself from attending to their business till he had done wiping the plates. They produced the hat, the badge of the much-coveted rank.

He would only soil it with his greasy fingers. 44 Hang it up on the dogwood tree !” said the Saint, indicating a tree that overshadowed the kitchen door, 41 and show the nuncios to the reception room.”

When his work was done, he dried his hands, turned down his sleeves, and took the hat from the bough where it was suspended. 44 Alas !” said he, with a sigh, 44 it is pleasant to execute the duties of a friar minor, and now I must bend my back to cares and duties, full of danger.”

S. Bonaventura. On reaching Rome he was consecrated bishop of Alba, one of the six suffragans of Rome. Gregory had hardly ascended the Pontifical throne when he determined to hold a great (Ecumenic Council, and re-awake, if possible, thereby, the slumbering enthusiasm of the West for the Sepulchre of the Saviour. Lyons was the chosen city; and a council was summoned to meet there, two years later. It assembled in 1274. Gregory X. took his seat at the head of five hundred bishops, seventy abbots, and at least a thousand dignified ecclesiastics. Every kingdom of the West acknowledged its oecumenic power. The Dominican, Thomas Aquinas, and the Franciscan, Bonaventura, were summoned to attend. The Angelical Doctor died on his way to the Council. The Seraphic Doctor was present, preached during its sittings; but died before its dissolution.

He fell sick on July 6th, and died on July 14th. The Pope, with all the Council, attended the funeral, which took place in the convent of the Minorites in Lyons. The officiant was Cardinal Peter of Tarentaise, a Dominican, bishop of Ostia, afterwards Pope Innocent V., who preached from the text, " Doleo super te, ffater mi Jonatha, amabilis et dilecte nimis.” (I am distressed for thee, my brother Jonathan; very pleasant hast thou been unto me. 2 Sam. i. 26.) The relics of S. Bonaventura were taken up and enshrined in 1430, the head and heart separated from the rest Next century, when the Huguenots were masters of Lyons, the bones of the Seraphic doctor were publicly burnt in the market-place; but his head was concealed and saved by a Minorite friar.

The head, therefore, still exists, and also an arm-bone at Bagnera, his native village. Another is said to be preserved at Venice.

S. Bonaventura is usually represented with an angel communicating him. According to the legend, his humility was so great that he would not draw near to the altar, and an angel therefore visited him, and gave him the holy Sacrament.

Well in the Cathedral at Ratiebon Separation of the SS. Apostles.

In This Saint’s Own Words

One quotation that sums them up, checked word for word against its source.

Life of Christ, Bonaventure · See on Wikiquote →

“For the nearer any one approaches to God, the more he is illuminated, and therefore the more clearly does he see the majesty and mercy of God.”

— ch. 34

More of their words & lives →

A note on sources

Tradition suggests that St. Francis healed Bonaventure as a child, but this is not historically verified.

Learn more about this saint →Their full life, teachings, every verified quotation in their own words, legacy, and free public-domain reading.

Help us add to this saint's story

Everything is read by a person before anything appears. Facts are checked against trusted sources first.

Facts are welcome; a source link helps (optional).With your permission we may share it on this page.

Nine days · Free

Pray the novena
with us.

One short email a day for nine days. The day's prayer, a line from St. Bonaventure's story, and a nudge to keep going.

Also on July 15
A

Sts. Antiochus and Cyriac

July 15 · Martyrs
J

St. James of Nisibis

July 15 · Bishop
A

St. Apronia

July 15 · Virgin
← All 1970 saints in the library
Sources & notes

Feast-day sources

Story sources

Sources

Credits

Image: François, Claude (dit Frère Luc) - Saint Bonaventure.jpg · Claude François · Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons

Retold in plain modern English from Baring-Gould’s public-domain text, sentence by sentence, keeping the same facts and order. Short explanations in parentheses are ours. Some history and judgments reflect 19th-century scholarship; the feast date above is the current one.

From Sabine Baring-Gould, The Lives of the Saints, new edition in 16 vols. (London: John C. Nimmo, 1897–98); text from the Internet Archive scan (OCR, lightly cleaned; errors possible). Public domain in the United States. Reproduced unedited.