This Saint’s Story
By the emperor's order he was whipped to death outside the walls of Constantinople, in the circus of St Mamas, on 17 October. Butler gives the year as 761; Baring-Gould, the text on this page, gives 767. The sources differ.
Andrew, called the Calybite or the Cretan, was a monk who boldly defended holy images under the iconoclast (the movement to destroy religious images) emperor Constantine Copronimus.
Read the essentials →October 17
October 17
Martyr
Feast: October 17
By the emperor's order he was whipped to death outside the walls of Constantinople, in the circus of St Mamas, on 17 October. Butler gives the year as 761; Baring-Gould, the text on this page, gives 767. The sources differ.
Stay faithful when it costs you. Holding firm under pressure is part of this story.
Make time for silence. Time alone in prayer is part of this story.
Andrew, a hermit or monk from Crete, was moved by the stories he heard about the suffering of those in Constantinople who honored sacred images. He took a ship to the imperial city and presented himself before the emperor in his palace of Saint Mamas, located outside the town gates, while the emperor was torturing some orthodox Christians. When the hermit saw these individuals being whipped with oxhide thongs, their flesh torn from their backs, some blistered and black from having lighted torches applied to their sides, and others with their eyes plucked out, he saw the imperial tyrant, dressed in purple and wearing a pearl diadem, calmly enjoying these horrors. Andrew could no longer contain his indignation. He burst through the crowd of horrified spectators, his eyes flashing and trembling with righteous anger, and shouted, “What! Emperor, do you call yourself a Christian?” Then, turning sharply to the crowd, he cried, “Look! In these maimed and bleeding individuals are the true soldiers of Christ! Brave, faithful souls, full of love and zeal for their Lord!”
The servants and executioners quickly attacked the bold hermit, beating him with their fists, shoving him, tearing at his hair and clothes, and dragging him to the foot of the throne. Constantine, remaining calm, signaled for his servants to step back, leaving the panting, ragged, and disheveled confessor standing alone. Andrew made the sign of the cross and prayed.
“Man,” said the emperor, “what has led you to honor those who defy imperial laws, these false, infamous Christians?” “And who are the true Christians, sire?” asked the fearless confessor. “Is it those who suffer wrongfully, or you who condemn and torture them? Look at this blood dripping onto the sand, look at these discolored swords, these hooks smeared with flesh and gore; they cry out with many voices, denouncing the tyrant and bloodthirsty man as a false Christian. No! I cannot call you a Christian, sire!”
“You,” said Constantine, “are an idolater.” “I am no idolater,” replied Andrew. “I love and venerate the image of my Lord and Redeemer, but my love and devotion extend from the image to the original.” “Let the man be tortured,” ordered the emperor. “Sire!” cried the brave hermit, “if you must fight, wage war against the barbarians who are attacking the empire from all sides and bringing it to ruin, not against the innocent people in your realm who serve God peacefully.”
Andrew's words were interrupted by the executioners, who stripped him and whipped him until his flesh came off in strips and his blood flowed onto the ground. Before he fainted, he was held up between two men and brought to the foot of the throne. He lifted his dim eyes to Constantine and said, “You see, Emperor, your powerlessness against Faith.”
“Break his jaws,” said Constantine. The assistants struck him in the face until he fell to the ground with broken jaws. He was then dragged away and thrown into a filthy dungeon.
The next morning, he was brought back to court. After being beaten again, he was ordered to be carried through Constantinople to be shown to the people as an example of what would happen to those who continued to venerate sacred images. As he was being led through the streets, a fisherman, either to gain favor with the emperor or to show his own hatred of the Orthodox, picked up his fish spear and stabbed it into the right foot of the martyr, cutting through the veins so that he fell on the spot and bled to death. His body was secretly taken during the night and buried by the faithful at a place called Crisis, near Constantinople.
Andrew, a Cretan hermit or monk, moved by the narratives he received of the sufferings of those in Constantinople who venerated sacred images, took ship for the imperial city, and presented himself before the emperor in his palace of S. Mamas, outside the gates of the town, as he was torturing some orthodox Christians. When the hermit saw them scourged with oxhide thongs, their flesh tom off their backs, some blistered and black with the application of lighted torches to their sides, other with their eyes plucked out, and the imperial tyrant in his purple, enthroned, and his handsome head wreathed with a pearl diadem, calmly enjoying these horrors, Andrew could contain his indignation no longer, but, bursting through the ring of shuddering spectators, with eyes flashing, and quivering with indignant enthusiasm, he shouted, “ What ! emperor, callest thou thyself a Christian ? ” Then turning sharply round on the crowd, he cried, “ Lo ! there, in these maimed and bleeding objects, are the true soldiers of Christ ! Brave, faithful souls, full of love and zeal for their Lord !”
The servants and executioners sprang on the audacious hermit, beat him with their fists, hustled him, tore his hair, his clothes, and dragged him to the foot of the throne. Constantine, with unruffled composure, beckoned his servants to fall back, and the panting, ragged, and ruffled confessor [in old usage, a saint who was not martyred, or who suffered for the faith without being killed] was left standing alone. Andrew signed himself with the cross, and prayed.
“ Man,” said the emperor, “ what has induced you to honour those who resist the imperial laws, these false, infamous Christians?” “And who are true Christians, sire?” asked the undaunted confessor, “those who suffer wrongfully, or you who condemn and torture them ? Look at this blood dribbled over the sand, look at these discoloured swords, these hooks clotted with flesh and gore; they cry out with as many voices, denouncing the tyrant and blood-thirsty man as a false Christian. No ! I cannot call thee a Christian, sire !”
“ You,” said Constantine, “ are an idolater.” “ I am no idolater,” answered Andrew; “ I love and venerate the image of my Lord and Redeemer, but the love and devotion I pay passes from the object to the prototype.” “ Let the fellow be tortured,” said the emperor. “ Sire !” cried the daring hermit, “ if thou must needs fight, war against the barbarians who assail the empire on all sides and are bringing it to ruin, and not against the harmless folk in thy realm who serve God peacefully.”
Andrew's words were cut short by the executioners, who stripped him and scourged him till his flesh came off in strips and his blood streamed down on the ground. Before he fainted, he was borne, held up between two men, to the foot of the throne. He lifted his dim eyes to Constantine, and said, “ Thou seest, Emperor, thy powerlessness against Faith.”
“ Break his jaws,” said Constantine; and the assistants smote him on the face till he fell with broken jaws on the ground. He was then dragged away, and cast into a filthy dungeon.
Next morning he was once more produced in court, and, after having been beaten, was ordered to be carried through Constantinople, to be shown to the people as an example of what would be the sufferings of those who continued to VOL. xii. 7 venerate sacred images. As he was being thus led through the streets, a fisherman, to curry favour with the emperor, or to exhibit his own hatred of the Orthodox, caught up his fishspear, and struck it into the right foot of the martyr, cutting through the veins so that he fell on the spot and bled to death. His body was secretly secured during the night, and buried by the faithful at a place called Crisis, near Constantinople.
One short email a day for nine days. The day's prayer, a line from St. Andrew of Crete's story, and a nudge to keep going.
Retold in plain modern English from Baring-Gould’s public-domain text, sentence by sentence, keeping the same facts and order. Short explanations in parentheses are ours.
From Sabine Baring-Gould, The Lives of the Saints, new edition in 16 vols. (London: John C. Nimmo, 1897–98); text from the Internet Archive scan (OCR, lightly cleaned; errors possible). Public domain in the United States. Reproduced unedited, except for short bracketed notes in grey that we added to explain names and terms (“S.” is the old abbreviation for Saint). Some history and judgments reflect 19th-century scholarship.