A

Flavian, the orthodox bishop of Constantinople, died of injuries suffered at the "Robber Council" of Ephesus.

Read the essentials →
Feast July 3 · —

St. Anatolius of Constantinople

Current feast

July 3
Secondary source · Wikidata P841

Traditional feast

July 3
1914 / pre-1969 calendar, per Baring-Gould (1897)

Represents

Feast

Feast days

Feast: July 3

This Saint’s Story

Adapted in modern English from Baring-Gould (1897–98) · original text below

Dioscorus consecrated Anatolius in his place. Anatolius sided with Eutyches (whose teaching on Christ's nature was later condemned) and consecrated Maximus as bishop of Antioch after Dioscorus expelled the orthodox Domnus. Emperor Theodosius asked Pope Leo the Great to recognize Anatolius; Leo demanded a public statement of orthodoxy and sent legates.

Then Theodosius died, and power passed to his orthodox sister Pulcheria. Anatolius promptly changed sides to keep his position. Eutyches was ordered out of Constantinople, and at a council attended by the Roman legates Anatolius signed and condemned whatever was asked. A fuller council met at Chalcedon on 8 October 451 to undo the Robber Synod, with Anatolius, Maximus of Antioch and Juvenal of Jerusalem present.

Near its end Anatolius introduced a canon giving the bishop of Constantinople equal church authority with Rome, granting Rome first place only as the imperial city, not as the see of St. Peter. The legates protested; 150 eastern bishops ratified it, but the Western Church rejected it, and Leo denounced Anatolius's presumption. The Latin Church has not placed him in its calendar, and Baring-Gould judges him a time-serving prelate who hardly deserves the honour.

What he represents

How he teaches us to live

Drawn from themes in the original account

Celebrate this saint’s feast day. Remember him on July 3 with a short prayer, and ask for his help.

The full story

Baring-Gould’s account retold in modern English

Read the full story · 484 words · about 2 min

Flavian, the orthodox bishop of Constantinople, had been treated so poorly at the robber council of Ephesus that he died from his injuries. Dioscorus immediately consecrated Anatolius to replace him. Anatolius aligned himself with Eutyches and boldly took on the task of consecrating one Maximus to the see of Antioch, from which Dioscorus had removed the orthodox Domnus.

The Emperor Theodosius wrote to Saint Leo the Great, the bishop of Rome, asking him to recognize Anatolius. Leo responded that “the person who had begun to preside over the Church of Constantinople” must first publicly declare his orthodoxy. He sent legates to find out Anatolius's stance on this matter. However, at that very time, the weak and stubborn Theodosius died, and the rule passed to his strong and orthodox sister Pulcheria.

The confidence of the Eutychians began to wane. Heresy was now a losing cause. Anatolius quickly and flexibly converted to orthodoxy to save his position. Eutyches was ordered to leave Constantinople. In a solemn council attended by the Roman legates, Anatolius agreed to everything presented to him and condemned all that he was required to denounce. Rome and Constantinople were once again at peace, and Pope Leo tolerated the enthronement of Maximus at Antioch, especially since Domnus had disappeared without a trace. A more comprehensive and authoritative council was called to annul the decisions of the “Robber Synod” of Ephesus. This council met at Chalcedon on October 8, A.D. 451. Anatolius was present along with Maximus of Antioch and Juvenal of Jerusalem. An account of this council has already been provided.

Anatolius was as enthusiastically orthodox under an orthodox empress as he had been energetically heretical under a heretical emperor. He took advantage of the waning interest of the Roman pontiff's legates towards the end of the great council to introduce a canon that granted the bishop of Constantinople equal ecclesiastical authority with the bishop of Rome. This canon asserted the primacy of the Roman see, but not based on its descent from Saint Peter; rather, it was based solely on the bishopric of the Imperial city. The legates were taken aback and protested. A hundred and fifty eastern bishops approved the canon, but the Western Church rejected it. From this point on, Pope Leo condemned the arrogance and presumption of Anatolius. The Latin Church has avoided including his name in the Kalendar of the Saints, an honor he can hardly be said to deserve, as he appears to have been a time-serving, unprincipled prelate.

But he speaks of this consecration as a presumptuous act, unprecedented and uncanonical.

In the 5th century, on this day, Saint Germain, also known as Jarman, the first bishop of the Isle of Man, is said to have been sent to that island by Saint Patrick. He lived on the island, near Castletown, in a solitary manner, and founded a church near Peel, at Kirk-Jarman, where he is buried.

Footnotes

  1. But he speaks of this consecration as a presumptuous act, unprecedented and uncanonical.
  2. Germain, Bishop of Man.
  3. Joscelin’s life of S. Patrick.

Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.

Read the original 1870s text

Baring-Gould’s sources: Greek Menaea and Menology of the Emperor Basil Russian Kalendar. Authorities: — Mention in the Acts of the council of Chalcedon, and in the letters of S. Leo the Great, Zonaras, Ac, There is a later Greek life of the bishop published by the Bollandists, but it is not to be relied upon.} The right of Anatolius of Constantinople to a place in the sacred Kalendar has been disputed by Baronius and others in the West Pagius, and Sohier the Bollandist, have laboured to exculpate the patriarch of the charges laid against him. But there seems to be little doubt that he was a man of slight religious earnestness. 1 He was a native of Alexandria, and was of the party of the furious, tyrannical Dioscorus of Alexandria, and therefore involved in his Eutychianism.

Flavian, the orthodox bishop of Constantinople, had been so ill-treated in the robber-council of Ephesus, that he died of his injuries (see Feb. 18th, p. 331). Dioscorus at once consecrated Anatolius in his room, and Anatolius ranged himself on the side of Eutyches, and boldly assumed the office of consecrating one Maximus to the see of Antioch [a bishop’s “see” is his diocese, named from his seat (Latin sedes)] from which Dioscorus had expelled the orthodox Domnus.

The Emperor Theodosius [name of Roman emperors; Theodosius I (379–395) made Christianity the state religion] wrote to S. Leo the Great, bishop of Rome, to recognize Anatolius. He answered that “the person who had begun to preside over the Church of Constantinople ” must first of all make a public avowal of orthodoxy. He sent legates to ascertain the mind of Anatolius on this subject But at this very time the feeble and obstinate Theodosius died, and the sovereignty passed to his masculine and orthodox sister Pulcheria.

1 & Leoaia Mag. Bp. isj. The confidence of the Eutychians [followers of Eutyches, who said Christ had only a divine nature; condemned at Chalcedon in 451] failed them. Heresy was now a losing cause. Anatolius by a prompt and pliant conversion to orthodoxy saved his position. Eutyches was required to leave Constantinople. In a solemn council, which was attended by the Roman legates, Anatolius subscribed whatever was submitted to him, and anathematised all he was required to condemn. Rome and Constantinople were no v again at peace; and the enthronement of Maximus at Antioch was tolerated by Pope Leo, 1 the rather, as Domnus had retired, no one knew whither. A more full and authoritative council was convoked to repeal the acts of the “ Robber Synod ” of Ephesus. It met at Chalcedon on Oct. 8th, a.d. 451. Anatolius was there with Maximus of Antioch, and Juvenal of Jerusalem. An account of this council has been already given (see April, p. 1 50-1 59). Anatolius was as enthusiastically orthodox under an orthodox empress as he had been energetically heretical under an heretical emperor, He took advantage of the flagging interest of the legates of the Roman pontiff towards the close of the great council to introduce a canon which accorded to the bishop of Constantinople a co-ordinat * and co-equal ecclesiastical authority with the bishop of Rome, though asserting the primacy of the Roman see, not however in right of its descent from S. Peter, but solely as the bishopric of the Imperial city. The legates were startled, and protested. A hundred and fifty eastern bishops ratified the canon, but the Western Church rejected it Pope Leo, from this period, denounced the arrogance and presumption of Anatolius; and the Latin Church has refrained from enroling his name in the Kalendar of the Saints, an honour which he can scarcely be said to deserve, for he appears to have been a time-serving, unprincipled prelate.

1 Ep. X04. But be speaks of tnis consecration as a presumptuous act, unprecedented and uncanonical. Ijjt. 9. Germain. & GERMAIN, B. OF MAN.

(5TH CENT.) [In Man anciently on this day. Authority Joscelin’s iifeof S. Patrick [apostle of Ireland (5th century)].] S. Germain or Jarman, first bishop of Man, is said to have been sent to that island by S. Patrick. He lived in the island, near Castletown, a life like a solitary, and founded a church near Peel, at Kirk-Jarman, where he is buried.

Help us add to this saint's story

Everything is read by a person before anything appears. Facts are checked against trusted sources first.

Facts are welcome; a source link helps (optional).With your permission we may share it on this page.

Nine days · Free

Pray the novena
with us.

One short email a day for nine days. The day's prayer, a line from St. Anatolius of…'s story, and a nudge to keep going.

Also on July 3
H

St. Hyacinth of Caesarea

July 3 · Martyr
I

Sts. Irenaeus and…

July 3 · Martyrs
← All 1970 saints in the library
Sources & notes

Feast-day sources

Story sources

Sources

Credits

Retold in plain modern English from Baring-Gould’s public-domain text, sentence by sentence, keeping the same facts and order. Short explanations in parentheses are ours.

From Sabine Baring-Gould, The Lives of the Saints, new edition in 16 vols. (London: John C. Nimmo, 1897–98); text from the Internet Archive scan (OCR, lightly cleaned; errors possible). Public domain in the United States. Reproduced unedited, except for short bracketed notes in grey that we added to explain names and terms (“S.” is the old abbreviation for Saint). Some history and judgments reflect 19th-century scholarship.