This Saint’s Story
St. Irenaeus (bishop of Lyon, d. c. 202, who listed the early popes) of Lyons, writing late in the second century, reckons him as the fifth pope in succession from the Apostles, though he says nothing of his martyrdom. The Catholic Encyclopedia notes that critics date the pontificate variously—Duchesne about 106–115, Lightfoot about 109–116—and that Christian antiquity credited him with roughly ten years (Eusebius). There is no reason to doubt that he stood on the Roman catalogue of bishops drawn up by Hegesippus before the death of Pope Eleutherius (about 189).
A tradition extant in the Roman Church by the end of the fifth century, and recorded in the Liber Pontificalis (the early medieval 'Book of the Popes', not always reliable for the earliest ones), says he was a Roman by birth, ruled in the reign of Trajan (98–117), and suffered martyrdom by decapitation on the Via Nomentana on 3 May. The same tradition attributes to him—scarcely with accuracy, the encyclopedia adds—the insertion in the canon of the Qui Pridie commemorating the institution of the Eucharist, words that are certainly primitive and original in the Mass. He is also said to have introduced the blessing of water mixed with salt for purifying Christian homes; Duchesne notes the persistence of that early Roman custom in the Gelasian Sacramentary (a book of prayers for Mass) and its kinship with the Asperges prayer.
In 1855 a semi-subterranean cemetery of the martyrs Alexander, Eventulus, and Theodulus was found near Rome at the traditional place of the pope's martyrdom. Some archaeologists identify that Alexander with the pope; Duchesne denies the identity while admitting that the confusion is ancient, probably older than the early sixth-century compilation of the Liber Pontificalis. Letters ascribed to Alexander I by Pseudo-Isidore are not authentic. His so-called Acts are not genuine and were compiled much later; Baring-Gould likewise calls them fabulous. Remains said to be his were transferred to Freising in Bavaria in 834. His feast is kept on 3 May.

