U

The Catholic Encyclopedia warns that the history of the virgin martyrs of Cologne rests on about ten lines of text, and that even these are open to question.

Read the essentials →
Traditional feast October 21 · Widow, Martyrs

Sts. Ursula and Eleven Thousand

Feast

Traditional feast: October 21 (Roman Martyrology 1916 (archive.org OCR, sources/rm1916.txt))
Traditional date · cited source, no current calendar entry found

Traditional feast

October 21
1914 / pre-1969 calendar, per Baring-Gould (1897)

Represents

Widow
Martyrs

Feast days

Feast: October 21

Their Story

The firm evidence is an inscription in the choir of the Church of St. Ursula at Cologne, dating from the fifth century at the latest and probably from the fourth. It records that Clematius, a man of senatorial rank, was moved by repeated visions to rebuild, on his own land, a basilica that had fallen into ruin. The basilica stood where holy virgins had shed their blood for the name of Christ. The inscription guarantees the early cult and the real existence of the martyrs, but it gives neither their number, nor their names, nor the date of their death.

Liturgical texts from the ninth century onward commemorate on 21 October virgins of Cologne, sometimes five, sometimes eight, sometimes eleven. Their names include Ursula, Martha, Saula, Pinnosa, and Palladia, and in only one list does Ursula stand first. A ninth-century sermon speaks of several thousand virgins martyred under Diocletian (Roman emperor 284–305, who launched the last and fiercest persecution of Christians in 303) and Maximian and names only Pinnosa. Wandalbert of Prum, about 850, also speaks of thousands. By the end of the ninth century or the start of the tenth, the figure of eleven thousand was accepted without dispute. Scholars have offered many explanations of how the number arose, none of them certain.

The legend that spread from Cologne tells that Ursula, daughter of a Christian king of Britain, was sought in marriage by the son of a pagan king. Wishing to remain a virgin, she obtained a delay of three years. She sailed with ten noble companions, each attended by a thousand virgins, went by Cologne and Basle to Rome, and on returning to Cologne was slain with all her company by the Huns in hatred of the Faith. The Catholic Encyclopedia treats this as a pious romance, and later fables built on twelfth-century finds at Cologne as rejected by all. Baring-Gould gives the date as 451, and Butler cites Sigebert for 453, but the true date is unknown. The feast is kept on 21 October.

What they represent

How they teach us to live

Drawn from themes in the original account

Share your faith, in words and by example. Preaching and conversion are part of this story.

Pray a little every day. Prayer is part of this story.

Feed your mind with Scripture and good books. Learning and the Scriptures matter in this life.

The full story

Baring-Gould’s account retold in modern English

Read the full story · 6,441 words · about 28 min

But Wandelbert of Pram, in the year 847, mentions them, although not in the exact words: “At that time, the shores of the Rhine shine with the trophies of Christ, raised by the virgin saints of the city of Cologne, whose impious fury once slaughtered thousands under the leadership of the renowned saints.”

Usuardus, who died in 877, in his Martyrology, which was written at the request of Charles the Bald, records on October 20, “The passion of the holy virgins Martha and Saula, along with many others, at Cologne.” Martha and Saula have been included on October 20 in the Roman Martyrology.

An Essen Kalendar, created before the year 891, lists “the Virgins.” There are two Corbei Martyrologies, one from the year 831 and another from the year 900, and neither of these includes a mention of the Virgin Martyrs of Cologne. Bettberg has suggested that these lines are an interpolation, but without sufficient justification.

This Kalendar contains, in the same handwriting, prayers for both the living and the dead, including a prayer for Bishop Sunderbold of Mainz, who was still alive at that time.

Ursula is mentioned next.

An old Kalendar in the Düsseldorf Library from the 10th century copies Usuardus, simply transferring the names of Martha and Saula. The Darmstadt library invokes five of these saints in this order: Martha, Saula, Paula, Brittola, and Ursula. Another litany in the same collection increases the number to eight and presents a different order: Brittola, Martha, Saula, Sambatia, Satumina, Gregoria, Pinnosa, and Palladia. Yet another litany in the Düsseldorf Library expands the count to eleven: Ursula, Sencia, Gregoria, Pinnosa, Martha, Saula, Brittola, Satumina, Rabacia, Saturia, and Palladia. Another list also gives eleven names but in a different sequence: Martha, Saula, Brittola, Gregoria, Satumina, Sabatia, Pinnosa, Ursula, Sentia, Palladia, and Saturia.

Crombach, followed by Bollandus, began to compile an Ursulan Kalendar of all the saints from that devoted martyred group who are honored throughout the West. There are eighty-six days in the year designated for saints from that company. The names of those who accompanied Saint Ursula have been recovered through various means, totaling as many as 1,079; some are Greek, some Irish, some German, some Latin, and some of unknown origin. Some of the young women, whose relics are now venerated, had names such as Hydropa, Imana, Languida, Gadiagia, Hebora, Naufragia, Rixa, Sutragia, Xpinna, and Inez.

Now we turn to the earliest historical traces of the story. At the beginning of the 7th century, if we can trust the Life of Saint Cunibert, which was written in the 9th century, while the archbishop was celebrating Mass in the “basilica of the Holy Virgins,” he saw a white dove that rested on “the tomb of a certain virgin,” whose body he then exhumed. This body is believed to be...

It is believed that the festival of S. Ursula is celebrated on January 28, which marks the translation of her relics by S. Cunibert to Deutz. However, the Life of S. Cunibert does not mention the name Ursula or any other related names. There is an interesting old sermon on the Festival of the Eleven Thousand Virgins that was preached in Cologne. This sermon is attributed by the Bollandist De Buck to the period around 751. The preacher quotes Bede almost word for word, indicating that it was written after Bede's death. The sermon mentions the island of Batavia, which was formed by the two branches of the Rhine River. Around 839, after a major flood, one of these branches became silted up, and Batavia stopped being an island.

The preacher does not mention Ursula at all but instead identifies Pinnosa or Vinnosa as the leading virgin. He describes the martyrdom as occurring under the Emperor Maximian and does not mention the Huns. His account is based on the traditions of Cologne, and he acknowledges that there is no written record of their martyrdom. Some people believed that the eleven thousand virgins came to Cologne after the Theban legionary soldiers, as military figures tend to attract young women. However, the preacher favors another theory: that they were returning from a pilgrimage to the Holy Land. He argues that if this were the case, it would explain why such a public display of their Christian faith would provoke a tyrant like Maximian to massacre them all.

He goes on to suggest that they were British maidens because, according to Bede, Christianity was widely spread in Britain at that time. He believes that Vinnosa, referred to as Pinnosa by his people, was the daughter of the king of the Britons.

There is a charter from Archbishop Herman of Cologne dated 922 that mentions the monastery "of the Eleven Thousand Virgins." This monastery is also referenced in charters from Archbishop Wichfrid in 927 and 941. The preacher mentioned earlier talks about the rebuilding of the church, which had fallen into disrepair, by a man named Clematius, who held a consular position and came from the East. He was inspired to rebuild the church after seeing an apparition of flames, as noted on a stone in the church. However, there is no way to determine the date of this inscription, if it is authentic. We will see how the name Clematius is used later when we discuss Abbot Gerlach and Elizabeth of Schonau.

The next notice is in the Chronicle of Sigebert of Gemblours, who died in 1112. At the date 453, there is an account of the Virgins, beginning, “The most famous of wars was that waged by the white-robed army of the eleven thousand holy virgins, under their leader, the virgin Ursula. She was the only daughter of Nothus, a very noble and wealthy prince of the Britons.” She was sought in marriage by the son of “a certain most ferocious tyrant,” and her father wanted her to marry him. But Ursula had dedicated herself to celibacy, and when her father learned this, he was thrown into great confusion. However, Ursula solved the problem. By divine inspiration, she was moved to ask that ten virgins of beauty and proper age be given to her, and that she and they might each have a thousand virgins under them, and that they should be allowed to sail for three years in the purity of their unsullied virginity. Ursula made this condition in the hope that the difficulty of fulfilling it would be insurmountable, or that if it were overcome, she might be able to persuade a vast number of maidens to devote themselves to the Almighty.

The required number having been provided, Ursula sailed away with them on the blue seas in eleven elegantly furnished galleys. For three years, they sailed merrily. At the end of that time, the wind drove them into the port of Tiel in Gaul, and then carried them up the Rhine to Cologne. They continued their journey to Basel, where they left the ships, crossed the Alps on foot, descended into Italy, and visited the tombs of the apostles in Rome. They returned in the same manner, but upon encountering the Huns at Cologne, they were all martyred by the barbarians.

It will be noted that Sigebert moves the martyrdom from 237 AD, the time at which the anonymous preacher from Cologne claims they suffered, to 453 AD. However, the original manuscript of Sigebert does not contain this story. It is an addition to the text by a later hand, as the marks of stitches on the side of the page indicate that a strip of parchment was attached to the original page, containing some supplementary narrative. All subsequent copies, with one exception, include the passage, but one has a different version of it. The best manuscript after the original (codex 5, Pauli Virdunensis, No. 36), which belongs to the 12th century, contains the passage. Since Sigebert issued his first edition before 1105 and added to it afterwards up to 1111, the year before his death, it is possible that he himself made the insertion.

A somewhat later version of the story appears in the Chronicle of Otto of Freising. He also attributes the martyrdom of the virgins to the Huns. A legend from the 12th century presents the story in more detail. The princess is Ursula; a fierce pagan prince requests her hand for his son. Pinnosa, “the noblest of the noble,” was placed at the head of the group as Queen, acting as the admiral of the fleet. The rest of the story is similar to that in Sigebert. Saint Ursula and her companions are killed by the Huns, with Ursula being struck by an arrow. However, after the virgins were dead, and not a moment earlier, an army of angels came to their aid and defeated the Huns, who fled in all directions. The people of Cologne came out of the city and buried the virgins, some in the ground and some in coffins. Some time later, a man from the East named Clematius built a church in honor of the martyrs. Among the group, there was a maiden named Cordula, who had been hidden in a boat during the massacre. The next day, she emerged from her hiding place and offered herself for martyrdom. Long after, Saint Cordula appeared to the blessed Helentrud and informed her of the events. According to this legend, “they suffered in the year 238.”

Through this legend, we can fairly determine the date when the story was expanded as we find it in Sigebert. It was likely the work of the nun Helentrud of Herse. She had her visions around 1131, as that was when Frederick, Archbishop of Cologne, dedicated an altar to Saint Cordula in the porch of the church of Saint Ursula. There is no earlier mention of her name.

Geoffrey of Monmouth (d. 1154) provides another version of the legend, as he heard it, while also intertwining it with historical events to give it some basis.

He recounts that Emperor Maximian, having depopulated Northern Gaul, sent to Britain for settlers to repopulate the desolate land. Thus, he created a second Britain out of Armorica, placing it under the control of Conan Meriadoc. He then turned his attention eastward, and after establishing himself at Treves, began hostilities against the emperors Gratian and Valentinian, who were contesting the imperial throne. Meanwhile, Conan was defending Brittany against the incursions.

The king of the neighboring Gauls was restless and unhappy because his troops were miserable without wives. To solve this, he sent to Britain for a shipment of young women who could become the wives of his soldiers and help raise another generation of fighters to continue the war against the Gauls. At that time, a king named Dinothus ruled in Cornwall. He had taken the throne after his brother Caradoc. Dinothus had a daughter of remarkable beauty named Ursula, and Conan desired to marry her.

Upon receiving a message from the prince of Armorica about his troubles, Dinothus quickly gathered a group of eleven thousand noble girls and sixty thousand girls of lower birth. He shipped them on the Thames River to the Armorican colony, where excited and hopeful husbands awaited them.

However, as soon as the fleet left the mouth of the Thames, it was scattered by the winds. Some of the ships were driven ashore on savage islands, where the young women were either killed or enslaved. Others fell victim to the dreadful army of Guanius and Melga, kings of the Huns and Picts, who attacked the unfortunate group of virgins and massacred them without mercy.

It is widely recognized that Geoffrey of Monmouth cannot be trusted for any statement in his so-called “History,” so it is not worth discussing the anachronisms and absurdities that undermine this story. His Conan Meriadoc is actually Cynan Meiriadog, the grandson of Caradog (around A.D. 380), whose sister Elen Wledig is said to have married the Emperor Maximus—referred to in the Welsh Triads as Macsen Wledig. It is also said that Cynan led an army into Gaul to support Maximus's claims, whose revolt in Britain is dated to 383. Geoffrey confused Maximus with Maximian and incorrectly made both Picts and Huns the murderers of the young women, which is nonsensical.

The story also appears in the Saga of Olaf Tryggvasonar, written by the monk Oddr in the 12th century. According to this source, during the time of Earl Hako (between 995-1000), there was a king in Ireland who had a very accomplished and beautiful daughter named Sunnifa. She was blessed with wealth, beauty, and Christian piety. A northern Viking, hearing of her charms, fell in love with her and raided the coasts of Ireland, setting everything on fire because the king hesitated to give him his daughter's hand in marriage. To save her homeland from destruction by the impatient suitor, the young woman decided to leave Ireland. Her brother Alban and a group of virgins joined her, and they all sailed east, trusting in God. They landed on the island of Selja, off the coast of Norway, and would have been massacred by Earl Hako if the rocks had not opened up. All the maidens retreated inside, and the rocks closed on them again, so they never came out alive. In 1170, the relics of Sunnifa and her group of virgins were moved from Selja to Bergen by Bishop Paul.

It should be noted that no historian who would have known about the events mentions the massacre. Bede is completely silent on the matter. The Welsh Triads are also silent, as is Gregory of Tours, who recounts the destruction caused by the Huns, and Fredegar of Rheims is likewise quiet on the subject.

The earliest source for the martyrdom, an anonymous preacher, does not mention the Huns but attributes the martyrdom to the Roman Emperor Maxentius. He indicates that at that time, little was known about the martyrs, but there were various traditions surrounding them. However, Baronius adopted the date 451 as the time of the martyrdom, when Attila was returning from his defeat at Châlons. It must be clearly understood that this date is purely arbitrary.

It is also clear that until the 11th century, the name of Ursula was unknown, or for some reason that may become clear later, it was kept in the background. The only names that emerged were Vinnosa or Pinnosa, Martha, and Saula.

Let us turn now to another part of the subject. During the latter part of the Middle Ages, a curious custom developed in Germany, especially along the Rhine and in Swabia, of founding confraternities or guilds for men and women, called “The Skiffs of S. Ursula.” These skiffs were overseen by monks, usually Carthusians, who acted as captain, mate, and pilot of the various boats.

The process for joining the skiff was very simple. The candidate had to recite the Lord’s Prayer and the Angelic Salutation three times before a crucifix, kneeling with outstretched arms. Every Friday, the candidate had to say the Lord’s Prayer while sitting, standing, or walking, as they preferred. They also had to commit to reciting certain psalms or prayers, or to attending a specific number of Masses, to fill the boat’s hold with good works.

A skiff from Strassburg was loaded with 4,025 penitential psalms, 180,000 prayers for the Passion, 76,000 corporal chastisements, 11,000 Paternosters, and 6,530 Ave Marias in honor of S. Ursula, along with 35,000 vigils of nine lessons for the dead. With this abundant provision, the passengers on their journey to eternity in the boat were free to draw from it. The boat was equipped with a sail — the veil of S. Ursula, which consisted of eleven thousand Our Fathers, one recited in honor of each maiden of the saintly crew.

Those who sailed in the boat of S. Ursula received special indulgences granted by the popes. These confraternities had their symbol — a boat, which was carried in procession through the streets. These societies likely do not exist today, but I have personally seen ships on wheels, brightly decorated with flags, pulled by horses through the streets during Carnival time.

Tacitus says that in his time, “a part of the Suevi sacrificed to Isis. I have not determined the reason for this foreign rite, except that the symbol itself, shaped like a Liburnian ship, suggests that the religion was brought from abroad.” He refers to the goddess as Isis because of the ship that was carried around in her honor. In Rome, the 5th of March (the third day before the Ides of March) was known in the Kalendarium Rusticum as the day of the Isidis navigium (the ship of Isis). This is mentioned by Apuleius in his “Metamorphoses.” The goddess appeared to the poor donkey and said, “The day that will be born from this present night is one that eternal religion has appointed as a holy festival; at a time when the storms of winter have calmed, the waves of the stormy sea have subsided, and the surface of the ocean has become navigable, my priests dedicate to me a new ship, loaded with the first-fruits of spring, at the start of the navigation.”

The myth of Isis and her wanderings is too well known to recount here. It is certain that in parts of Germany, the custom of carrying around a ship existed through the Middle Ages. When it was not associated with the confraternities of S. Ursula, it was condemned by the Church as idolatrous. Grimm mentions a very interesting passage in the Chronicle of Rudolf, which states that in 1133, a ship was secretly built in a forest at Inda (Comelimiinster in Juliers) and was placed on wheels. The weavers rolled it to Sachen, then to Maestricht, and elsewhere, amidst dances, music, and rites, which the pious chronicler chooses not to describe. It is clear that the clergy regarded it with disgust, as shown by the terms they used to describe it. In Ulm, in Swabia, in 1530, the people were forbidden to carry around plows and ships on Shrove Tuesday. A similar prohibition was issued in Tubingen on the 5th of March, 1504. In Brussels, there is still celebrated a festival called the Ommegang, in which a ship is drawn through the town by horses, with an image of the Blessed Virgin upon it; the same occurs in Boulogne.

The goddess referred to as Isis by Tacitus had various names among the German and Scandinavian peoples. The Norsemen called her Freya; the Teutons referred to her as Holle, Holda, Harka, or Bertha; and in Swabia and Thuringia, she was known as Urschel or Horsel. Horsel seems to have been the Thuringian name for her. She was said to live in the Horselberg (a mountain in Thuringia), surrounded by her thousand maidens, and to receive the souls of deceased maidens. Her father was called Niordr by the Scandinavians, and his home was Noatun. It is interesting that S. Ursula’s father has a name that is so similar, though it is disguised in the Latin form of Nothus. The old Gothic form of Niordr was Niorthus, and in old High Dutch, it was Nirdu.

This Teutonic and Scandinavian goddess sailed across the blue heavenly seas in her silver ship, searching for her husband. For a long time, the name Pinnosa, or Vinnosa, was used in Cologne to refer to the leader of the saintly group. It is interesting to note that the Scandinavian goddess Freya was also called the Vana, or the goddess of the Vans.

Freya's husband was named Od. Gold was seen by the Norsemen as the tears of Freya, which she shed while wandering the world in search of him.

The story that Horsel sailed out of Britain is also understandable. It came from a misunderstanding between “Engdland” and “England.” This confusion still appears in children's nursery rhymes in Germany today. There are many rhymes beginning with, “There came a ship a sailing from Engelland,” in which women sit; in a Frankfurt rhyme, one is Brigidian, the name of one of the Ursuline group; in Berlin, there are two, Biebe and Biebele; about twelve Babylas are mentioned in the group of S. Ursula.

However, the most notable names are those of Martha and Saula. These likely refer to “Mirten und Seelen,” spirits and souls, which, according to German belief, accompanied the goddess Horsel, or Holda, everywhere.

The goddess Horsel was, in fact, the moon deity, gliding in her silver skiff over the blue sea of the sky, accompanied by her train of stars.

Now, it is quite possible that there may have been virgin martyrs in Cologne at some point; it is very likely that the Huns may have committed great atrocities there, and that the memory of some of their brutal acts may have persisted. However, as we have seen from the Cologne sermon of the 9th century, they were not credited with the massacre of these virgins. In fact, the existence of a church in Cologne dedicated to virgin martyrs at a very early date suggests that some martyrdom of maidens may have occurred there. But that is absolutely all that can be said in favor of these saints; it is certain that popular tradition has surrounded them with characteristics of old Teutonic mythological figures and has even given them their names.

We now turn to the history of the discovery of their relics. As previously mentioned, S. Cunibert is said to have found and translated the bones of S. Ursula in the 7th century; however, her name is not mentioned in the 9th-century Life of the Archbishop; she is referred to only as “a certain virgin.” These relics were moved across the river to the venerable abbey.

Some portions of this body were given in 1170 to St. Martin’s in Toumai. In 1105, Henry, the rebellious son of Henry IV, took up arms against his father, and the emperor fled to Cologne. There, finding the walls in ruins, he urged the citizens to repair or rebuild them. Shortly after, he was seized and imprisoned by his son, but he escaped, returned to Cologne, and continued the work of re-walling the city. In July 1106, his son surrounded Cologne with his troops, but the city held out until the death of Henry IV at Lidge in August, when the siege came to an end.

While workmen were engaged in turning up new soil near the church of St. Cunibert, they uncovered a considerable number of bones. Shortly after, one or two of them claimed that they had seen two beautiful and richly dressed women, who informed them that they were digging into the resting place of the martyred virgins, and that they should not be surprised if soon the entire body of one of them was discovered. And so it was. The next day, the corpse of a young woman, who looked as if she had been recently murdered, was unearthed. The blood was not even dry and stained the hands of those who lifted her out of her grave. According to the story, public suspicion of foul play was calmed by the assurance given by the workmen that this was the body of a saint miraculously preserved.

The discovery, however, led to a lawsuit between the canons of St. Cunibert and the nuns of St. Ursula. The latter claimed the bones as belonging to their patrons, while the former claimed them as having been found on their ground.

In 1113, the Archbishop of Cologne had some doubts about the genuineness of at least one of these relics. “It was still recent and was stained with blood.” “When the priest washed his hands, blood flowed from his hands like a wave.” This was the contemporary record of the discovery by a monk of Waulsort.

The archbishop took the head of St. Faith and held it in the fire. Crombach says that a piteous voice issued from the skull, saying, “Why do you torment me so?” The archbishop was punished for his doubts by dying within two months. Unfortunately for the truth of the story, Frederick I occupied the archiepiscopal throne until 1131.

In 1123, Saint Norbert came to Cologne to search for relics. After fasting and praying, he had a vision of a young woman. She told him that if he dug in the place where workmen had previously found many saintly bones, he would surely discover more. The next day, he dug there, found as many bones as he wanted, and took them with him to Premontré. However, the major “invention” occurred in 1155. It is perhaps one of the most painful stories of fraud ever recorded. It is so absurd that the Jesuit father, De Buck, becomes angry and indignant about it. He cites other similar frauds, though on a smaller scale, to show that unfortunately, such acts were not unknown.

The walls built by Henry IV had likely crossed an old burial ground belonging to the church of Saint Cunibert. In 1155, Gerlach was the abbot of Deutz, and he began a large-scale effort to dig up all the bodies in this old burial ground. He aimed to create tombstones for them that recorded their names, titles, and the circumstances of their martyrdom.

For eight years, the digging continued under Gerlach, and when he died, his successor, Abbot Hartbern, continued the fraud for another year or more. Gerlach produced about one hundred and ninety tombstones, and Hartbern added twenty-three more.

De Buck attempts to clear the abbot of blame by suggesting that the diggers wrote the epitaphs and engraved them. However, this theory does not hold up. There is evidence that the entire affair was a conspiracy involving more than just Gerlach, aimed at gaining recognition for Cologne and the abbey of Deutz as a never-ending source of relics.

The following are examples of some of the inscriptions: “S. Cyriacus, Pope of Rome, who joyfully received the sacred virgins, and returned with them to receive martyrdom, also S. Alina V.” “Here lies S. Marinus, the sixth bishop of Milan, who came from Rome along with the sacred virgins, also S. Verasia V.” “S. Forlan, Bishop of Lucca, sent from the apostolic throne to this place, was killed, being slain with the sword, and buried along with these sacred virgins.” “Pantulus, Bishop of Basle, having joyfully received the sacred virgins, led them to Rome, and after returning with them, arrived at Cologne, where he received martyrdom along with them, also S. Grata the Younger.” Several bishops, along with the pope, have a virgin at their side in their stone coffins. “Here lies buried in this cave the holy martyr Quirillus, a priest, who lived six days after his martyrdom.” “Saint Charcharberus, martyr, and a Moor from Ethiopia.” “S. Nothus, martyr and king of the Scots, and his wife Sara, who were killed in the same place.” “S. Papunius, martyr and King of Ireland, brother of S. Nothus, who came to visit.” “S. Cyriacus, Pope of Rome, who joyfully received the sacred virgins, and returned with them to receive martyrdom, also S. Alina V.” “Here lies S. Marinus, the sixth bishop of Milan, who came from Rome with the sacred virgins, and S. Verasia V.”

“S. Forlan, Bishop of Lucca, sent from the apostolic throne, was killed in this place, and buried along with these sacred virgins.” “Pantulus, Bishop of Basle, joyfully received the sacred virgins, led them to Rome, and after returning, arrived at Cologne, where he received martyrdom along with them, and S. Grata the Younger.” “S. Charcharberus, martyr, and a Moor from Ethiopia.” “S. Nothus, martyr and king of the Scots, and his wife Sara, who were killed in the same place.” “S. Picmenius, martyr and King of England, from whose land came eleven thousand, and Queen Alspint and his daughter Eria, a virgin.” S. Clematius, who buried all the virgins and their lay and clerical followers, was honored with two tombstones and two distinct bodies. On one tombstone was inscribed, “Clematius found these slain bodies with other virgins, and buried them in peace;” the other bore the inscription, “Here lies buried S. Clematius, who with his own hands buried the sacred virgins.”

There was no pope named S. Cyriacus, no bishop of Milan named Marinus, and no Pantulus from Basle. As for Forlan of Lucca, the person who wrote the epitaph confused the Irish Frigidian of Lucca with the Irish Forlan, who was the brother of S. Fursey and was killed by robbers in Brabant in 655.

What are we to say about King Picmenius, “rex de Anglia” (king of England), in 451, when the first Jute colony in Britain established the kingdom of Kent in 449, and the first Angle kingdom was founded in 547, while the English were not Christianized until the 7th century? Abbot Gerlach wrote a book of inscriptions, which was kept in the abbey of Deutz; from there, Crombach drew his list in his work “S. Ursula vindicata.”

At that time, in the abbey of Schonau, in Nassau, there lived a young nun named Elizabeth, who was twenty-four years old. She was hysterical, visionary, and had great confidence in herself. Gerlach thought it was necessary for his tombstones and relics to have some explanation, so he sent two skeletons, which were exhumed from the large quarry of relics, to Schonau for her lack of modesty. He asked Elizabeth, through visions, to provide him with details about the life and martyrdom of those bodies that were discovered. There can be little doubt that Elizabeth was not a willing participant in the deception; she was a visionary who saw what she wanted or what was expected of her.

But she was placed in the care of her brother Egbert, who was a monk of St. Cassius at Bonn and later became the abbot of St. Florinus at Schönau. He belonged to the same order as Gerlach, and was therefore also interested in the discovery that brought such credit to it. Elizabeth did not know any Latin, so Egbert wrote down her visions in Latin. This meant that he could easily insert or omit anything he thought was appropriate.

At the beginning of her “Revelations,” Elizabeth admits that she might have remained silent if men of good judgment had not urged her to publish her revelations about these Cologne virgins to a skeptical world. She was made a reluctant instrument for promoting a cause that certain unscrupulous men were passionate about. It is clear from what Gerlach wrote to her that many people ridiculed his discoveries and suspected that there was dishonesty involved. He hoped that Elizabeth's explanation would help dispel these doubts.

In fact, it had been questioned how a dead pope was found in Cologne whose name did not appear in any lists of popes, and how Clematius had two tombstones and two bodies. The Bollandist father referred to her Revelations as “Imaginations,” and wisely so. She told a remarkable story. According to her, the young women who were carried up the Rhine had gone to Basel, where the bishop Pantulus received them. He abandoned his see and led them over the Alps to Rome. There, Cyriacus, the pope, was so taken by their beauty or piety that he quickly resigned his tiara and, along with a group of bishops, cardinals, priests, and monks, followed them as far as Cologne, where they, along with the young women, received the martyrs’ crown at the hands of the Huns.

The explanation for the two tombstones of Clematius was quite simple: there were two people with the same name—one had buried the martyrs, while the other built the church in their honor. The reason Cyriacus did not appear in any lists of the popes was that the Roman cardinals, disapproving of his actions in abandoning the chair of St. Peter to pursue eleven thousand virgins, had removed his name from their lists. Elizabeth died in 1165.

During the excavations, a number of bones of little children were found, including those of infants and some that were undoubtedly the bones of unborn babies. This discovery was somewhat damaging to the memory of the eleven thousand virgins, not to mention the pope, cardinals, and bishops who followed them. What was to be done? Elizabeth was no longer available; she was either dying or dead. Conveniently, an ecclesiastic was produced who also had visions and could explain away the scandal.

Two books of his visions exist—one was written, at least in its completed form, in 1183, and the second in 1187. They have been attributed to an Englishman, eager to address the issues raised. Another difficulty that was suggested was: how did these martyrs come to have their tombstones? To explain this, St. Elizabeth had a vision and was informed that James, the Archbishop of Antioch, who was British by birth, had gone to Rome to visit Cyriacus the Pope. However, upon his arrival, he learned that His Holiness had last been seen climbing the Alps in the company of eleven thousand beautiful virgins. The Eastern patriarch immediately followed the successor of St. Peter and reached Cologne the day after the massacre.

He then carved the names and titles of many of the deceased into stone—how he learned them is not explained—but before he could finish his task, the Huns discovered him engaged in his pious work and killed him. However, the tombstone of James was found. Who had engraved that? By revelation, Elizabeth learned that when he was attacked by the Huns, he begged them to inscribe his name and titles on a tombstone over him. They agreed, martyred him, and then engraved his epitaph.

To retrieve the fair fame of his countrywomen, Richard of Whitchurch, a Premonstratensian canon at Amsbeig, is mentioned. However, the Bollandist De Buck attributes it, with some justification, to the Blessed Hermann Joseph, whose life has been described on April 7. These Revelations, or "Imaginations," are far more grotesque and absurd than those of Elizabeth. At the end of the first book, there is a special revelation to explain the bones of the babies. According to him, Saint Ursula was accompanied by very young girls, as well as married women and their husbands. Some of the girls were seven years old, some were under five, one was only a year old, some were only six months old, and some were just two months old. Hermann Joseph states: “Since among the relics and bodies of the sacred virgins have been found some such small bones and bodies, that they can have been only three months from the day of their conception, this has staggered some people not a little.” He therefore raised this delicate question to Saint Ursula herself when she visited him, and she was able to resolve the issue with great ease. She explained to him that it was indeed true that there were unborn babies among the martyrs, who, dying before they were born, were baptized in their own blood. When Hermann was puzzled over the matter, he was suddenly enlightened and told, “Things did not go on in the company as you suspect,” and it was explained to him that there were in the group two hundred married women and two hundred husbands, and that the eleven thousand were models of propriety.

Of all the nonsense ever written by man, the Revelations of the Blessed Hermann Joseph are the most supreme. After assuring us that he wrote by divine inspiration and with the special assistance of the Blessed Virgin, Hermann Joseph goes on to provide pedigrees, lists, and relationships of the virgins, bishops, and kings. The father of Saint Ursula had three sisters and three brothers. The sisters were named Josippa, Thelindris, and Eulalia; and the brothers were Helvidius, Ludwig, and Herwig. Ludwig had a wife named Hermgard, and their daughters were Saint Pinnosa and Saint Evodia. The wife of Herwig was Hedwig, and they had three daughters: Saint Sapientia, Saint Serena, and Saint Eulalia the younger. Helvidius had a wife named Malcha, and with her, he had a son who bore his name. Helvidius junior, by his wife Arena, had two daughters in the company of Saint Ursula, named Spes and Euphrosyne. And so on with the aunts of Ursula.

Five Anglican bishops accompanied S. Ursula on her travels. They were Bishop Michael Wilson, his brother James Wilson, S. Columbanus, who was the son of the Duchess Alexandria, the sister of S. Ursula's mother. Bishop Iwan, who was Ursula's great-uncle, and S. Eleutherius were also part of the group. The fifth bishop was S. Lothair, who was described as “a very generous man.” Ursula was engaged to marry Prince Holofemes, whom Elizabeth of Schonau referred to as Aetherius.

Also in the company was King Oliver, who was engaged to marry the virgin Oliva, the daughter of King Cleopater, who was the great-uncle of S. Ursula. Additionally, King Crophorus and his wife Cleopatra were present, as well as King Lucius and King Clovis, along with his wife Blandina.

Both Elizabeth and Hermann feel the need to explain why Pope Cyriacus does not appear in any known list of the popes. They both state that the priests and cardinals of Rome were so offended by him for abandoning the papacy to pursue women that they removed his name from the lists. However, when we examine the lists of cardinals who followed his example, we have reason to question why they were not more forgiving. The eleven thousand proved to be an attraction for them just as strong as it was for the successor of S. Peter. Among the martyrs in Cologne, at least two names appear: Peter Vincentius and Pontius. Meanwhile, the pope took with him two of his deacons, three subdeacons, and even the esteemed archdeacon of Rome.

Among the kings who attended the virgins and suffered were King Canute and King Pepin. But surely this is enough of such nonsense. Of the vast number of relics of the virgin martyrs that remain and are displayed, not only in the church of S. Ursula in Cologne but throughout Europe, most were discovered by Gerlach and are named either after the tombstones he created or the dreams of Elizabeth or Hermann Joseph.

Many of the skulls of the virgin martyrs are pierced with arrows. Gerlach, who was capable of writing their epitaphs, was also able to make it appear as though they had been shot to death.

S. Ursula is depicted in art holding an arrow in her hand and having a dove by her side, or covering the crowd of her followers with her mantle.

Footnotes

  1. Bettberg has suggested that these lines are an interpolation, but without sufficient justification.
  2. The Bollandist De Buck is a scholar known for his work on saints' lives.
  3. The Theban legion refers to a group of Christian soldiers who were martyred for their faith.
  4. Bede was an English monk and historian who lived in the 7th and 8th centuries.
  5. The best manuscript after the original is codex 5, Pauli Virdunensis, No. 36.
  6. The name "Pinnosa" means "the noblest of the noble."
  7. The year "238" refers to the time of the martyrdom according to the legend.
  8. Treves is a city in modern-day France.
  9. Geoffrey of Monmouth is not to be relied upon for any single statement in his so-called “History.”
  10. Cynan Meiriadog is the grandson of Caradog (A.D. 380).
  11. Elen Wledig is said to have married the Emperor Maximus.
  12. The revolt in Britain is fixed as having occurred in 383.
  13. Geoffrey has confused Maximus with Maximian.
  14. The Saga of Olaf Tryggvasonar was written by the monk Oddr in the 12th century.
  15. Earl Hako ruled between 995-1000.
  16. Bishop Paul moved the relics in 1170.
  17. Baronius was a 16th-century cardinal and historian.
  18. Attila was a leader of the Huns.
  19. A Strassburg skiff was loaded with 4,025 penitential psalms, 180,000 prayers for the Passion, 76,000 corporal chastisements, 11,000 Paternosters, and 6,530 Ave Marias in honor of S. Ursula, along with 35,000 vigils of nine lessons for the dead.
  20. The morrow that from the present night will have its birth is a day that eternal religion hath appointed as a holy festival; at a period when, the tempests of winter having subsided, the waves of the stormy sea abated, and the surface of the ocean become navigable, my priests dedicate to me a new ship, laden with the first-fruits of spring, at the opening of the navigation.
  21. Golden Ass, book 11.
  22. The Marat refers to a figure in Sanskrit mythology.
  23. It was still recent and was stained with blood.
  24. When the priest washed his hands, blood flowed from his hands like a wave.
  25. This was the contemporary record of the discovery by a monk of Waulsort.
  26. De Buck: Jesuit father who criticized the fraud.
  27. Saint Cunibert: A church associated with an old burial ground in Cologne.
  28. Premontré: A monastery founded by Saint Norbert.
  29. S. Cyriacus, Pope of Rome, who joyfully received the sacred virgins, and returned with them to receive martyrdom, also S. Alina V.
  30. Here lies S. Marinus, the sixth bishop of Milan, who came from Rome along with the sacred virgins, also S. Verasia V.
  31. S. Forlan, Bishop of Lucca, sent from the apostolic throne to this place, was killed, being slain with the sword, and buried along with these sacred virgins.
  32. Pantulus, Bishop of Basle, having joyfully received the sacred virgins, led them to Rome, and after returning with them, arrived at Cologne, where he received martyrdom along with them, also S. Grata the Younger.
  33. Here lies buried in this cave the holy martyr Quirillus, a priest, who lived six days after his martyrdom.
  34. Saint Charcharberus, martyr, and a Moor from Ethiopia.
  35. S. Nothus, martyr and king of the Scots, and his wife Sara, who were killed in the same place.
  36. S. Papunius, martyr and King of Ireland, brother of S. Nothus, who came to visit.
  37. S. Picmenius, martyr and King of England, from whose land came eleven thousand, and Queen Alspint and his daughter Eria, a virgin.
  38. S. Clematius, who buried all the virgins and their lay and clerical followers, was honored with two tombstones and two distinct bodies.
  39. S. Papunius, martyr et rex Hiberniensis, frater sancti Noti qui venit visitare corpora sanctarum virginum.
  40. Alspint et filia ejus Eria vixgo. for her lack of modesty. See her Life on June 18.
  41. Elizabeth was urged to publish her revelations concerning the Cologne virgins to an unbelieving world.
  42. Another difficulty suggested was: how did these martyrs come to have their tombstones?
  43. Hermann Joseph states: “Since among the relics and bodies of the sacred virgins have been found some such small bones and bodies, that they can have been only three months from the day of their conception, this has staggered some people not a little.”
  44. “Dum itaque die quadam harum notarius stans super his mente revoiveret, ecce coelitus cogitatione ejus respondetur: Quia non est ita, ut tu putas; nam integer umerus undedm millium ibi erat virginum.”
  45. Pope Cyriacus was removed from the lists for abandoning the papacy.
  46. The eleven thousand attracted both cardinals and the successor of S. Peter.
  47. Most relics of the virgin martyrs were found by Gerlach.
  48. Gerlach could make it seem the martyrs had been shot to death.

Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.

Read the original 1870s text

Baring-Gould’s sources: Modem Roman Martyrology. York, Sarum, Hereford, and Durham Kalendars. German and Gallican Martyrologies. Not in the Martyrology of Jerome, nor in those of Florus and Hrabanus, or Ado, or Notker. Usuardus on Oct. 20, “ The Passion of the Blessed Virgins Martha, and Saula, and many others in the city of Cologne.1* Wandelbert on Oct 21. But for mention in Martyrologies see the text.] Drepanius Florus, priest of Lyons, who died in a.d. 860, wrote additions to a Martyrology, which had been compiled by the Ven. Bede (d. 735). In the Martyrology of Bede, augmented by Florus, there is no mention of S. Ursula and the Eleven Thousand Virgins. Hrabanus Maurus, Archbishop of Mainz, drew up another Martyrology, on the basis of that attributed to Jerome, but which was really the old Roman Martyology, and that of Bede and Floras, adding local German saints. His Martyrology was compiled about a.d. 845. In it there is no mention of S. Ursula and her company. Ado of Vienne drew up another Martyrology at about the same date, a.d. 845. He also was ignorant of the existence of these martyrs. Notker Balbulus, monk of S. Gall, wrote another Martyrology in 859. In it also there is no mention of S. Ursula and her company. A S. Gall Martyrology of 804 is also without them. There exists also the ancient Cologne Kalendar of the 9th century in the Cathedral Library at Cologne, and it also contains no notice of these virgin martyrs.

But Wandelbert of Pram, in 847, gives them, though not “ Tunc numerosa simul Rheni per littora fulgent Christi Virgineis erecta tropsea maniplis Agrippinae urbi, quarum furor impius olim Millia mactavit ductricibus inclita sanctis.” 1 And Usuardus [a 9th-century monk of Paris who compiled a list of saints for each day] (d. 877), in his Martyrology, written at the instigation of Charles the Bald, gives on October 20, “ The passion of the holy virgins Martha and Saula, with many others, at Cologne.” Martha and Saula have been retained on October 20 in the Roman Martyrology.

An Essen Kalendar, composed before a.d. 891, gives, on Virgins."* There are two Corbei Martyrologies, one of a.d. 831, another of the date 900, and neither of these contains a notice of the Virgin Martyrs of Cologne, neither do those ‘ Bettberg has thought these lines an interpolation, but without good reason. < 3 This Kalendar contains, in the same handwriting, prayers for living and dead, and, amongst others, a prayer for Bishop Sunderbold of Mainz, as still living. He 8. URSULA.

Oct ax.] Ursula and Eleven Thousand. 537 called after Labbe and the abbey of Reichenau of the same period. An old Kalendar in the Diisseldorf Library of the 10th century copies Usuardus, merely transferring Martha and Darmstadt library, invokes five of these saints, in this order: Martha, Saula, Paula, Brittola, Ursula. Another litany in the same collection raises the number to eight, and gives a different succession: Brittola, Martha, Saula, Sambatia, Satumina, Gregoria, Pinnosa, Palladia. Another litany in the Diisseldorf Library extends the number to eleven: Ursula, Sencia, Gregoria, Pinnosa, Martha, Saula, Brittola, Satumina, Rabacia, Saturia, Palladia. Another gives eleven, but in different order: Martha, Saula, Brittola, Gregoria, Satumina, Sabatia, Pinnosa, Ursula, Sentia, Palladia, Saturia.

Crombach, and after him Bollandus, set to work to compile an Ursulan Kalendar of all the saints of that pious martyred crew who are venerated throughout the West. There are eighty-six days in the year provided with saints from that company. Of the names of those who attended S. Ursula as many as 1079 have been recovered by various means, as shall be detailed in the sequel; some Greek, some Irish, some German, some Latin, and some of no known origin. Some of the damsels, whose relics [the bodily remains of a saint, or objects they used, kept with honor] now receive religious worship, delighted in such names as Hydropa, Imana, Languida, Gadiagia, Hebora, Naufragia, Rixa, Sutragia, Xpinna and Inez.

We come now to the earliest historical traces of the story. At the beginning of the 7th century, if we may trust the Life of S. Cunibert, written ip the 9th century, whilst the archbishop was saying mass in the “ basilica of the Holy Virgins,” he saw a white dove which rested on “ the tomb of a certain virgin,” whose body he thereupon exhumed. This body is supposed [Oct. ax.

to have been that of S. Ursula, and consequently a white dove is given her as a symbol, and January 28 was observed as the festival of the translation [the solemn moving of a saint’s relics to a new shrine] of her relics by S. Cunibert to Deutz. But the Life of S. Cunibert makes no mention of the name Ursula or any other. A very curious old sermon on the Festival of the Eleven Thousand Virgins exists, preached at Cologne, and attributed by the Bollandist De Buck to the period between 75I'^39‘ The preacher quotes Bede [English monk and historian (d. 735)] almost verbatim, so that it must be posterior to the death of Bede; and it speaks of the island of Batavia formed by the two branches of the Rhine; in 839, or thereabouts, after a great inundation, one of these branches was silted up and Batavia ceased to be an island.

The preacher does not mention Ursula at all, but makes Pinnosa or Vinnosa the leading virgin. He describes the martyrdom as having taken place under the Emperor Maximian [Diocletian’s co-emperor in the West, 286–305], and, of course, knows nothing about the Huns [nomadic invaders from Central Asia, led in the 5th century by Attila]. He bases his account on Cologne tradition,1 and admits that no written account of their martyrdom exists. Some thought, he says, that the eleven thousand virgins swarmed to Cologne after the Theban legionary soldiers — and the military do, no doubt, exercise an irresistible attraction upon girls — but the preacher prefers another theory, that they were returning from a pilgrimage to the Holy Land, and he says, if so, we can understand that such an open profession of their Christian faith should exasperate a tyrant like Maximian to massacre them all. He proceeds to argue that they were British damsels, because at that time, relying on Bede, he learned that the Christian faith was widely spread in the island of Britain. And he thinks that Vinnosa, “by our people called Pinnosa,” was the daughter of the king of the Britons. 1 “ Nec prsetereundum quod in ore nostratum tenaci memoria semper omnino diligendssime servatum."

oct. ss.] 5VS. Ursula and Eleven Thousand. 539 There exists a charter of Archbishop Herman of Cologne, of the date 922, which mentions the monastery “of the Eleven Thousand Virgins,” and it is also mentioned in charters of Archbishop Wichfrid in 927 and 941. The preacher above mentioned speaks of the rebuilding of the chinch, which had become ruined, by a certain Clematius, a man of consular dignity, coming from the East, moved thereto by the apparition of flames, as recorded on a stone in the church; but no means exist of fixing the date of this inscription, if authentic. We shall see the use made of the name Clematius presently, when we come to Abbot Gerlach and Elizabeth of Schonau.

The next notice is in the Chronicle of Sigebert of Gemblours, who died in a.d. 1112. At the date 453 occurs an account of the Virgins, beginning, “ The most famous of wars was that waged by the white-robed army of the eleven thousand holy virgins, under their leader, the virgin Ursula. She was the only daughter of Nothus, a most noble and rich prince of the Britons.” She was sought in marriage by the son of “ a certain most ferocious tyrant,” and her father wished her to marry him. But Ursula had dedicated herself to celibacy; and her father learning this, was thrown into great perplexity. But Ursula solved the difficulty. By divine inspiration she was moved to ask that ten virgins of beauty and proper age might be given to her, and that she and they might each have a thousand virgins under them, and that they should be allowed to cruise about for three years in the sanctity of their unsullied virginity. Ursula made this condition in the hope that the difficulty of fulfilling it would prove insurmountable, or that she might be able, should it be overcome, to persuade a vast host of maidens to devote themselves to the Almighty. The requisite number having been provided, Ursula sailed away with them on the blue seas in eleven elegantly [Oct. ax.

furnished galleys. For three years they went thus merrily sailing. At the end of that time, the wind drove them into the port of Tiel in Gaul [roughly modern France and Belgium], and thence wafted them up the Rhine to Cologne. They pursued their course to Basle, where they left the ships, and crossed the Alps on foot, descended into Italy, and visited the tombs of the apostles at Rome. In like manner they returned, but, falling in with the Huns at Cologne, they were every one martyred by the barbarians.

It will be seen that Sigebert transfers the martyrdom from a.d. 237, at which time the anonymous Cologne preacher would have it they suffered, to a.d. 453. But the original MS. of Sigebert does not contain this story. It is an addition to the text by a later hand, for the marks of stitches at the side of the page indicate that a strip of parchment was tacked on to the original page, containing some supplementary narrative. All subsequent codices, with one exception, however, give the passage, but one has a different version of it. The best MS. after the original (cod. 5, Pauli Virdunensis, No. 36), which belongs to the 12th century, has the passage. And as Sigebert had issued his first edition before 1 105, and added to it afterwards up to 1111, the year before his death, it is possible that he may have himself made the insertion.

A somewhat later version of the story occurs in the Chronicle of Otto of Freising. He also attributes the martyrdom of the virgins to the Huns. A legend of the 12th century gives the story in fuller form. The princess is Ursula; a savage heathen prince asks for her hand for his son. Pinnosa, “ the noblest of the noble, was placed at the head of the company as Queen/’ as admiral of the fleet, apparently. The rest of the story resembles that in Sigebert. S. Ursula and her party are massacred by the Huns, Ursula being transfixed by an arrow. However, when the virgins were dead, then, and not a moment earlier, an army of angels came to the rescue and routed the Huns, who fled in all directions, and the people of Cologne issued from the city and buried the virgins, some in the earth and some in coffins. Some time after, there came a man from the East, named Clematius, who built a church to the honour of the martyrs. There was, however, among the company, a maiden named Cordula, who had been hidden in a boat whilst the massacre went on, next day she issued from her hiding place and offered herself for martyrdom.1 Long after, S. Cordula appeared to the blessed Helentrud, and informed her of the circumstances. According to this legend “ they suffered in the year 238.”

By means of this legend we are able to fix pretty well the date when the story was expanded as we find it in Sigebert It was probably the work of the nun Helentrud of Herse. She had her visions about 1131, for then Frederick, Archbishop of Cologne, dedicated an altar to S. Cordula, in the porch of the church of S. Ursula. There is no mention of her name earlier.

Geoffrey of Monmouth (d. 1154) gives another form of the legend, as it reached his ears, at the same time weaving it in with historical incidents after his fashion, to give it some sort of basis.

He relates that the Emperor Maximian, having depopulated Northern Gaul, sent to Britain for colonies wherewith to re-people the waste country. Thus out of Armorica [Brittany in north-west France] he made a second Britain, which he put under the control of Conan Meriadoc. He then turned his arms eastward, and, having established himself at Trèves, commenced hostilities against the emperors Gratian and Valentinian, who disputed with him the imperial purple. In the meantime Conan was defending Brittany against the incursions 1 Oct. as.

[Oct. ax. of the neighbouring Gauls, but, finding that his troops were restless and miserable without wives, he sent to Britain for a cargo of damsels, who might become the spouses of his soldiers, and raise up another generation of fighting men to continue the war against the Gauls. At this time there reigned in Cornwall a king, Dinothus by name, who had succeeded his brother Caradoc on the throne. He was blessed with a daughter of singular beauty, named Ursula, whose hand Conan desired to obtain. Dinothus, having received a message from the prince of Armorica stating his difficulties, at once collected a body of eleven thousand girls of noble rank and sixty thousand of low birth, and shipped them on the Thames for the Armorican colony of excited and expectant husbands.

No sooner, however, had the fleet left the mouth of the Thames than it was scattered by the winds, and, some of the vessels having been driven ashore on barbarous islands, the damsels were either killed or enslaved. Some became the prey of the execrable army of Guanius and Melga, kings of the Huns and Piets, who, falling upon the band of luckless virgins, massacred them without compunction. It is so well known that Geoffrey of Monmouth is not to be relied upon for any single statement in his so-called “ History,” that it is not worth while showing the anachronisms and absurdities which discredit this tale. His Conan Meriadoc is Cynan Meiriadog, grandson of Caradog (a.d. 380), whose sister Elen Wledig, the Emperor Maximus— called in the Welsh Triads, Macsen Wledig— is said to have married. It is further said that Cynan led over an army into Gaul to support the claims of Maximus, whose revolt in Britain is fixed as having occurred in 383. Geoffrey has confounded Maximus with Maximian, and has made Piets as well as Huns the murderers of the damsels, which is an absurdity.

oct. ax.].SVy. Ursula and Eleven Thousand ’ 543 The story occurs also in the Saga of Olaf Tryggvasonar, by the monk Oddr, written in the 12th century. According to this authority, there lived in the days of Earl Hako (i>. between 995-1000), a king in Ireland, who had a most accomplished and beautiful daughter named Sunnifa, who was endowed with wealth, beauty, and Christian piety. A northern viking, hearing of her charms, became enamoured, and harried the coasts of Ireland, setting all in flames, because the king hesitated to give him the hand of his daughter. The damsel, to save her native island from devastation by the impatient suitor, expressed her determination to leave Ireland. Her brother Alban and a multitude of virgins joined her, and all sailed away east, trusting in God. They came ashore on the island of Selja, off the coast of Norway, and would there have been massacred by Earl Hako, had not the rocks opened, and all the maidens having retired within, they closed on them again, and they came forth no more alive. In 1170, the relics of Sunnifa and her virgin train were translated from Selja to Bergen by the bishop, Paul. Now it must be remembered, that there is no mention whatever of the massacre by any historian who was likely to know about the circumstances. Bede is absolutely silent on the subject. So are the Welsh Triads, so is also Gregory of Tours [bishop and historian of the Franks (d. 594)], who gives an account of the ravages of the Huns, so likewise is Fredegar of Rheims.

The oldest authority for the martyrdom, the anonymous preacher, says not a word about the Huns, but attributes the martyrdom to the Roman Emperor Maxentius [rival emperor at Rome 306–312, defeated by Constantine], and shows that at his date little was known of the martyrs, but that there were various traditions about them. Baronius [Cardinal Baronius (d. 1607), church historian who edited the Roman Martyrology] adopted, however, the date 451 as that of the martyrdom, when Attila was returning from the defeat at Ch&lons. This date, it must be distinctly understood, is purely arbitrary.

It is dear also that till the 11th century the name of Ursula was unknown, or at all events, for some reason which will perhaps appear in the sequel, kept in the background, the only names which rise to the surface being Vinnosa or Pinnosa, Martha and Saula.

Let us turn now to another part of the subject. During the latter part of the Middle Ages there grew up a curious custom of founding confraternities or guilds in Germany, and especially along the Rhine and in Swabia, for men and women, called “The Skiffs of S. Ursula.” These skiffs existed under the direction of monks, generally Carthusians [a strict order of hermit-monks founded by St. Bruno in 1084], who served as captain, mate, and pilot of the several boats. The form of admission to the skiff was very simple. The candidate had to recite the Lord’s Prayer and the Angelic Salutation thrice before a crucifix, kneeling, with outstretched arms; and every Friday he had to say the Lord’s Prayer sitting, standing, or walking, as he liked, and he was to undertake to recite certain psalms, or prayers, or assist at so many masses, to serve to stock the boat’s hold with good works.1 A Strassburg skiff was loaded in 4,025 penitential psalms, 180,000 prayers on the Passion, 76.000 corporal chastisements, 11,000 Paternosters and 6,530 Ave Marias to the honour of S. Ursula, together with 35.000 vigils of nine lessons for the dead. Upon this abundant provision the passengers to eternity in the boat were at liberty to draw.* The boat was provided with a sail — the veil of S. Ursula, which was composed of eleven thousand Our Fathers, one recited to the honour of each maiden of the saintly crew. Those who sailed in the boat of S. Ursula were provided with special indulgences granted by the popes. These confraternities had their symbol — a > “ Ad increxnentum navicula thesauri."

boat, which was borne about in procession through the streets. These societies probably do not now exist, but I have myself seen on the Rhine ships on wheels gaily decked with flags drawn by horses through the streets, at Carnival time.

Tacitus says that in his time, “ a part of the Suevi sacrificed to Isis. Whence the cause of the foreign rite I have not ascertained, except that the symbol itself, in shape of a Liburnian ship, indicates that the religion was brought from abroad.” He speaks of the goddess as Isis, because of the ship which was carried about in her honour. Now in Rome, the 5th March (iii. non. Mart.) was called in the Kalendarium Rusticum the day of the Isidis navigium. This is referred to by Apuleius, in his “ Metamorphoses.” The goddess appeared to the poor ass, and said, “ The morrow that from the present night will have its birth is a day that eternal religion hath appointed as a holy festival; at a period when, the tempests of winter having subsided, the waves of the stormy sea abated, and the surface of the ocean become navigable, my priests dedicate to me a new ship, laden with the first-fruits of spring, at the opening of the navigation.”1 The myth of Isis and her wanderings is too well known to be related. Now it is certain that in parts of Germany the custom of carrying about a ship existed through the middle ages, and when not associated with the confraternities of S. Ursula, was denounced by the Church as idolatrous. Grimm mentions a very curious passage in the Chronicle of Rudolf, wherein it is related that, in 1 133, a ship was secretly constructed in a forest at Inda (Comelimiinster in Juliers), and was placed on wheels, and rolled by the weavers to Sachen, then to Maestricht, and elsewhere, amidst dances, and music, and rites, which the pious chronicler refrains from describing. That it was regarded with abhorrence by the 1 “ Golden Ass/' lib. xi.

clergy is evident from the epithets employed in describing it At Ulm, in Swabia, in 1530, the people were forbidden carrying about ploughs and ships on Shrove Tuesday. A like prohibition was issued at Tubingen on the 5th March, 1504. In Brussels is celebrated, I believe, to this day, a festival called the Ommegang, in which a ship is drawn through the town by horses, with an image of the B. Viigin upon it; so also at Boulogne.

The goddess called Isis by Tacitus was variously named by the German and Scandinavian peoples. By the Norsemen she was styled Freya; by the Teutons, Holle, Holda, Harka, Bertha; and in Swabia and Thuringia, Urschel or Horsel. Horsel seems to have been the Thuringian name for her. She was said to live in the Horselberg, surrounded by her thousand maidens, and to receive the souls of dead maidens. Her father was called by the Scandinavians, Niordr, and his place of abode, Noatun. It is curious that S. Ursula’s father should have so similar a name, though disguised in the Latin form of Nothus. The old Gothic form of Niordr was Niorthus, the old High Dutch, Nirdu.

This Teutonic and Scandinavian goddess sailed about the blue heavenly seas in her silver ship, seeking her husband. For long the name of Pinnosa, or Vinnosa, was given at Cologne to the leader of the saintly band. It is curious to find that the Scandinavian Freya was also called the Vana, or the goddess of the Vans.

The husband of Freya was called Od. Gold, among the Norsemen, was regarded as the tears of Freya, which she shed over the world in her wanderings in search of him.

How the story grew that Horsel sailed out of Britain is also clear. It arose from a misconception between “ Engdland v and “ England.” The confusion exists in children’s nursery rhymes in Germany to this day. There are many oct. ax.] ££, Ursula and Eleven Thousand. 547 such rhymes beginning, “ There came a ship a sailing from Engelland,” in which sit women; in a Frankfort rhyme one is Brigidian, the name of one of the Ursuline party; at Berlin there are two, Biebe and Biebele; about twelve Babylas occur in the party of S. Ursula.

But the most remarkable names are those of Martha and Saula. These are, there seems a probability, “ Mirten 1 und Seelen,” spirits and souls, which, according to the German belief, accompanied the Goddess Horsel, or Holda, everywhere.

The goddess Horsel was, in fact, the moon-deity, gliding in her silver skiff over the blue sea of the sky, accompanied by her train of stars.

Now it is quite possible that there may have been virgin martyrs at Cologne at some time or other; it is very possible that the Huns may have exercised great barbarities there, and that the tradition of some of their atrocities may have lingered on; though, as we have seen from the Cologne sermon of the 9th century, they were not accredited with the massacre of these virgins. Indeed, the fact that a church existed at Cologne dedicated to virgin martyrs, at a very early date, seems to indicate that there possibly had occurred some martyrdom of maidens there. But this is absolutely all that can be said in favour of these saints; and it is certain that popular tradition has enveloped them with attributes of old Teutonic mythological personages, and has even invested them with their names.

We pass now to the history of the invention of their relics. As has been already related, S. Cunibert is said to have discovered and translated the bones of S. Ursula, in the 7th century; her name, however, is not given in the 9th century Life of the Archbishop, she is only “a certain virgin.” These relics were transferred across the river, to the venerable abbey 1 The Marat* of Sanskrit mythology.

[Oct ax. of Deutz. Some portions of this body were given in 1170 to S. Martin [St. Martin of Tours (d. 397), soldier turned bishop]’s, Toumai. In 1105, Henry, the rebellious son of Henry IV., was in arms against his father, and the emperor fled to Cologne, where, finding the walls ruinous, he urged the citizens to repair or rebuild them. He was shortly after seized and imprisoned by his son, but he escaped, returned to Cologne, and continued the re-walling of the city. In July, 1106, his son surrounded Cologne with his troops, but the city held out till the death of Henry IV. at Lidge, in August, when the siege came to an end.

Whilst workmen were engaged in turning up new soil near the church of S. Cunibert, they came on a considerable number of bones. Shortly after, one or two of them asserted that they had seen two beautiful and richly dressed women, who informed them that they were digging into the restingplace of the martyred virgins, and that they must not be surprised if shortly the entire body of one of them were discovered. And so it was. Next day the corpse of a young woman, who looked as if she had been recently murdered, was unearthed. The blood was not even dry, and stained the hands of those who lifted her out of her grave.1 Public suspicion of foul play was arrested by the assurance given by the workmen that this was the body of a saint miraculously preserved.

The discovery, however, caused a lawsuit between the canons of S. Cunibert and the nuns of S. Ursula. The latter claimed the bones as belonging to their patrons, the former as having been found on their ground.

In 1113 the Archbishop of Cologne entertained some doubt about the genuineness of at least one of these relics, ' “Ad hue recenti rube bat sanguine." “ Cum presbyter manus suas abluent, de manibus ejus defluebat quasi unda sanguinis." — The contemporary record of tJu discoveryby a monk of Waulsort.

oct. and so took the head of S. Faith, and held it in the fire. Crombach says that a piteous voice issued from the skull, “ Why do you torment me so ? ” and the archbishop was punished for his doubts by dying within two months. Unfortunately for the truth of the story, Frederick I. occupied the archiepiscopal throne till 1131.

In 1123 S. Norbert came to Cologne to search for relics, and after having fasted and prayed, he saw a vision of a damsel, who informed him that if he dug where the workmen had previously discovered so many saintly bones, he would assuredly discover some more. Next day he dug there, procured as many bones as he wanted, and carried them off with him to Premontrd But the great “invention ” of all took place in 1155. It is perhaps one of the most painful histories of fraud which has ever been recorded. So preposterous is it, that the Jesuit father, De Buck, waxes wrath and indignant over it, and instances other frauds of like nature, though on a less scale, to show that unfortunately such acts were not unknown.

The walls built by Henry IV. had no doubt traversed an old burial-ground belonging to the church of S. Cunibert. In 1155, Gerlach was abbot of Deutz, and he set to work on a large scale to dig up all the dead in this old burialground, and to manufacture tombstones for them recording their names, their titles, and the circumstances of their martyrdom.

For eight years the diggings went on under Gerlach, and when he died, his successor, the abbot Hartbern, continued the fraud for a year or more. Gerlach produced some one hundred and ninety tombstones, and Hartbern twenty three more.

De Buck tries to exculpate the abbot by supposing that the diggers composed the epitaphs and engraved them. But vol. xil 13 [Oct. ax.

unfortunately this theory will not stand. There is evidence that the whole affair was a conspiracy, in which more than Gerlach were involved, for the sake of gaining credit for Cologne and the abbey of Deutz as an inexhaustible mine of relics.

The following are specimens of some of the inscriptions: — “ S. Cyriacus, Pope of Rome, who with joy received the sacred virgins, and with them returning received martyrdom, also S. Alina V.”1 “ Here lies S. Marinus sixth (bishop) of Milan, who came from Rome along with the sacred virgins, also S. Verasia V.”* “ S. Forlan, Bishop of Lucca, coming sent from the apostolic throne to this place, was killed, being slain with the sword, and buried along with these sacred virgins.”3 “ Pantulus Bishop of Basle, having received the sacred virgins with joy, led them to Rome, and having returned with them, arrived at Cologne, and there received^ with them martyrdom, also S. Grata the Younger.”4 Several bishops along with the pope have thus a virgin at their side in their stone coffins. “ Here lies buried in this cave the holy martyr Quirillus, a priest, who lived six days after his martyrdom.”6 “ Saint Charcharberus, martyr, and a Moor of Ethiopia.”6 “ S. Nothus, martyr and king of the Scots, and his wife Sara, killed in the same place.”7 “S. Papunius, M. and King of Ireland, brother of S. Nothus, who came to visit the; “ S. Cyriacus papa Romanus, qui cum gaudio suscepit sacras virgines, et cum iisdem re versus, martyrium suscepit, et S. Alina V." 9 “ Hie jacet S. Marinus Mediolanensis sextus, qui veniebat de Roma cum sacris virginibus, et S. Verasia V."

3 “ S. Forlanus Lucensis episcopus veniens ab apostolica sede missus, hoc in loco fuit oedsus, et cum istis sacris virginibus est sepultus, et fexro peremptus." 4 “ Pantulus Basileensis episcopus virgines sacras cum gaudio susceptas Romam perduxit, unde reversus, Coloniam pervenit, ibique cum eis martyrium suscepit, et S. Grata junior.** tyrium suum.”

6 “ S. Charcharberus, martyr, et maurus de Ethiopia.” 1 “ S. Nothus, martyr et rex Scottorum, et uxor ejus Sara, occisi sunt in eodem loco. oct. ax.].SVy. Ursula and Eleven Thousand. 551 bodies of the sacred virgins.”1 “ S. Picmenius, M. and King of England, from whose land came eleven thousand, and Queen Alspint and his daughter Eria, a virgin.”9 S. Clematius, who had buried all the virgins and their lay arid clerical followers, was honoured with two tombstones and two distinct bodies. On one tombstone was inscribed, “ Clematius found these slain bodies with other virgins, and buried them in peace;” the other bore the inscription, “ Here lies buried S. Clematius, who with his own hands buried the sacred virgins.”

There was no such pope as S. Cyriacus, no bishop of Milan named Marinus, no Pantulus of Basle. As for Forlan of Lucca, the composer of the epitaph mistook the Irish Frigidian of Lucca for the Irish Forlan, brother of S. Fursey, killed by robbers in Brabant in 655. And what are we to say to King Picmenius, “rex de Anglia,” in 451, when the first Jute colony in Britain formed the kingdom of Kent in 449, and the first Angle kingdom was founded in 547, and the English were not christianized till the 7th century ? Abbot Gerlach wrote out a book of the inscriptions, which was preserved in the abbey of Deutz; and thence Crombach in his “ S. Ursula vindicata ” drew his list. In the abbey of Schonau, in Nassau, lived at the time a young nun, named Elizabeth, then aged twenty-four, who was hysterical, visionary, and had the utmost confidence in herself.3 Gerlach thought it necessary that his tombstones and relics should receive some explanation, so he sent two skeletons, exhumed from the great quarry of relics, to Schonau, 1 “ S. Papunius, martyr et rex Hiberniensis, frater sancti Noti qui venit visitare corpora sanctarum virginum.”

Alspint et filia ejus Eria vixgo. for her lack of modesty. See her Life on June x8. [Oct- si. and the inscriptions on the monuments as they were concocted and cut and discovered, and asked Elizabeth by means of visions to afford him details concerning the life and martyrdom of those bodies which were discovered. Elizabeth was, there can be little doubt, no party voluntarily to the fraud; she was a visionary, who saw what she wanted, or what was desired of her.

But she was placed in the hands of her brother Egbert, monk of S. Cassius at Bonn, afterwards abbot of St. Florinus at Schonau, belonging to the same order as Gerlach, and therefore also interested in the discovery which brought such credit to it. Elizabeth knew nothing of Latin, and Egbert wrote down her visions in Latin; it was therefore quite possible for him to insert or omit what he thought proper. At the beginning of her “ Revelations” Elizabeth admits that she might have been silent had not men of good judgment urged her to publish her revelations concerning these Cologne virgins to an unbelieving world.1 She was made a reluctant vehicle for advancing a cause which certain unscrupulous men had at heart. It is quite clear from what Gerlach wrote to her that there were many who ridiculed his discoveries, and had a suspicion that there was knavery at work, and he hoped that Elizabeth's explanation would do something towards removing these doubts. In fact it had been asked how it was that there was a dead pope found at Cologne whose name was not to be read in any lists of popes, and how it was that Clematius had two tombstones and two bodies. The Bollandist father entitles her Revelations “ Imaginations,” and judiciously so. She unfolded a marvellous tale. According to her, the damsels wafted up the Rhine had gone to Basle, where the bishop Pantulus received them, and, deserting his see, conducted them over the Alps 1 “ Dc his enim me nlere non permittunt quidam bonse opinionis vizi, qui ad haec inrestiganda diutina postulatione me multum resist entem compuleninL" to Rome. There Cyriacus, the pope, was so charmed with their beauty or piety, that he hastily resigned his tiara, and with a troop of bishops, cardinals, priests and monks, followed them as far as Cologne, where they, as well as the damsels, won the martyrs’ crown at the hands of the Huns. The explanation of the two tombstones of Clematius was very simple: there were two of the same name — one had buried the martyrs, the other built the church in their honour. The reason why Cyriacus occurred in no lists of the popes was because the Roman cardinals, not approving of his conduct in vacating the chair of S. Peter to run after eleven thousand virgins, had scored his name from their lists. Elizabeth died in 1165.1 During the excavations a number of bones of little children were found, even of babes at the breast, and some which, there could be no doubt, were the bones of unborn infants. Here was a discovery somewhat compromising to the memory of the eleven thousand virgins, not to mention the pope, cardinals, and bishops who followed them. What was to be done? Elizabeth was no longer available, she was either dying or dead. Most opportunely an ecclesiastic was produced, who also had visions and could explain away the scandal. Two books of his visions exist — one written, at least in its completed form, in 1183, the second in 1187. They have been attributed to an Englishman, eager to 1 Another difficulty suggested was. How came these martyrs by their tombstones To explain this, S. Elizabeth had a vision, and was informed that James, Archbishop of Antioch, a Briton by birth, had gone to Rome to visit Cyriacus the Pope, but had learned on his arrival that his Holiness had been last seen clambering the Alps in the train of eleven thousand virgins of entrancing beauty. The Eastern patriarch [the title of the bishops of the great ancient sees: Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, Jerusalem] at once followed the successor of S. Peter, and reached Cologne on the morrow of the massacre. He thereupon cut the names and titles of many of the deceased on stone — how he ascertained them we are not told — but before he had accomplished his task the Huns discovered him engaged on his pious work and despatched him. But the tombstone of James was discovered. Who had engraved that ? By revelation Elizabeth learned that when he was assailed by the Huns, he implored them to cut his name and titles on a tombstone over him: they consented — martyred him, and then engraved his epitaph.

[Oct ax. retrieve the fair fame of his countrywomen, Richard of Whitchurch, a Premonstratine canon at Amsbeig. But the Bollandist De Buck attributes it, with some show of reason, to the Blessed Hermann Joseph, whose life has been given (April 7). These Revelations, “ seu Imaginations, ” outdo far in grotesqueness and absurdity those of Elizabeth. At the end of the first book is a special revelation to account for the bones of the babies. According to him, S. Ursula was accompanied by some very little girls, and also by some married women and their husbands. Some of the girls were seven years old, some below five, one was only a year old, some only half a year old, and some only two months. Hermann Joseph says: “Since among the relics and bodies of the sacred virgins have been found some such small bones and bodies, that they can have been only three months from the day of their conception, this has staggered some people not a little.” He accordingly broached the delicate question to S. Ursula herself when she visited him, and she was able to solve the difficulty with the greatest ease. She explained to him that it was quite true that there were unborn babes among the martyrs, who, dying before they came to the birth, were baptized in their own blood. When Hermann stood puzzling his head over the matter, he was suddenly illumined, and told, “ Things did not go on in the company as you suspect,”1 and it was explained to him that there were in the multitude two hundred married women and two hundred husbands, and that the eleven thousand were models of propriety.

Of ail the nonsense ever written by man, the Revelations of the Blessed Hermann Joseph are supreme. After having assured us that he wrote by divine inspiration, and with the 1 “ Dum itaque die quadam harum notarius stans super his mente revoiveret, ecce coelitus cogitatione ejus respondetur: Quia non est ita, ut tu putas; nam integer umerus undedm millium ibi erat virginum. special assistance of the Blessed Virgin, Hermann Joseph proceeds to give pedigrees and lists and relationships of the virgins and bishops and kings. The father of S. Ursula had three sisters and three brothers. The sisters were called Josippa, Thelindris, and Eulalia; and the brothers, Helvidius, Ludwig, and Herwig. Ludwig had a wife called Hermgard, and their daughters were S. Pinnosa and S. Evodia. The wife of Herwig was Hedwig, and they had three daughters, S. Sapientia, S. Serena, and S. Eulalia the younger. Helvidius had a wife named Malcha, and by her a son, who bore his name. Helvidius junior, by his wife Arena, had two daughters in the company of S. Ursula, Spes, and Euphrosyne. And so on with the aunts of Ursula.

Five Anglican bishops followed S. Ursula on her travels — Bishop Michael Wilson,1 his brother James Wilson, S. Columbanus [Irish monk (d. 615) who founded monasteries in France and Italy], son of the Duchess Alexandria, sister of the mother of S. Ursula. Bishop Iwan, the great-uncle of Ursula, and S. Eleutherius. The fifth bishop was S. Lothair, “ a very generous man.” Ursula was engaged to be married to Prince Holofemes, whom Elizabeth of Schonau called Aetherius.

In the company was also King Oliver, engaged to be married to the virgin Oliva, daughter of King Cleopater, the great-uncle of S. Ursula. Also King Crophorus and his wife Cleopatra. Also King Lucius and King Clovis, with his wife Blandina.

Both Elizabeth and Hermann are constrained to offer some explanation of the fact that Pope Cyriacus occurs in no known list of the popes. They both say that the priests and cardinals of Rome were so offended at him for throwing up the papacy that he might run after the damsels that they scored his name out of the lists. But when we look at the lists of cardinals who followed his example we have reason to wonder that they were not more indulgent, for the eleven thousand proved an attraction to them quite as strong as to the successor of S. Peter, and among the martyrs at Cologne at least two occur, Peter Vincentius and Pontius; whilst the pope drew after him two of his deacons, three subdeacons, and even the grave archdeacon of Rome.

Among the kings who attended the virgins and suffered were King Canute and King Pepin. But surely this is enough of such rubbish. Of the vast number of relics of the virgin martyrs that remain and are exhibited, not only in the church of S. Ursula at Cologne, but throughout Europe, most are of Gerlach’s finding, and take their names either from the tombstones of his manufacture, or the dreams of Elizabeth or Hermann Joseph.

Many of the skulls of the virgin martyrs are transfixed with arrows. Gerlach, who was capable of composing their epitaphs, was capable of giving them the appearance of having been shot to death.

S. Ursula is represented in art with an arrow in her hand and a dove at her side, or covering with her mantle the crowd of her followers.1

Help us add to this saint's story

Everything is read by a person before anything appears. Facts are checked against trusted sources first.

Facts are welcome; a source link helps (optional).With your permission we may share it on this page.

Nine days · Free

Pray the novena
with us.

One short email a day for nine days. The day's prayer, a line from Sts. Ursula and Eleven…'s story, and a nudge to keep going.

Also on October 21
A

St. Asterius

October 21 · Priest, Martyr

St. Hilarion

October 21 · Hermit
M

St. Malchus

October 21 · Feast
← All 1970 saints in the library
Sources & notes

Feast-day sources

Story sources

Sources

Credits

Retold in plain modern English from Baring-Gould’s public-domain text, sentence by sentence, keeping the same facts and order. Short explanations in parentheses are ours.

From Sabine Baring-Gould, The Lives of the Saints, new edition in 16 vols. (London: John C. Nimmo, 1897–98); text from the Internet Archive scan (OCR, lightly cleaned; errors possible). Public domain in the United States. Reproduced unedited, except for short bracketed notes in grey that we added to explain names and terms (“S.” is the old abbreviation for Saint). Some history and judgments reflect 19th-century scholarship.

Notes

Story retold in our own words from the cited sources.