F

Baring-Gould explains the background.

Read the essentials →
Feast July 4 · —

Sts. Flavian and Elias

Current feast

July 4
Secondary source · Wikidata P841

Traditional feast

July 4
1914 / pre-1969 calendar, per Baring-Gould (1897)

Represents

Feast

Feast days

Feast: July 4

Their Story

Adapted in modern English from Baring-Gould (1897–98) · original text below

(The surviving account on this page begins partway through the story.)

Nestorius had taught that there were two persons in Christ and was condemned at Ephesus in 431; Eutyches, going to the other extreme, denied that Christ had two natures and was condemned at the Council of Chalcedon (the 451 worldwide council that taught Christ is one person in two natures, divine and human) in 451. Those who held one nature were called Monophysites. The Emperor Zeno, probably advised by Acacius, patriarch of Constantinople, issued the Henoticon or Edict of Union in 482, which aimed at mutual toleration rather than settling the dispute and left Chalcedon's authority an open question. The Eastern patriarchs signed it, but Pope Felix III rejected it and excommunicated Acacius and Peter the Fuller of Antioch. Acacius excommunicated the pope in turn, and a schism of forty years began between East and West.

Under the Emperor Anastasius, an upright man whom Baring-Gould thinks partisan writers have blackened, Patriarch Euphemius was deposed for treasonable dealings and Macedonius took his place. Flavian, a monk ordained at Antioch, was made patriarch of Antioch in 498; Elias held Jerusalem. Baring-Gould describes Flavian as weak and well-meaning, with no clearly defined views, which left him at the mercy of stronger partisans. He kept to the moderate ground of the Henoticon.

Xenias, bishop of Hierapolis, a bold leader of the Monophysites, stirred up Syria by accusing Flavian of Nestorianism. Flavian condemned Nestorius, but Xenias demanded he also condemn a list of bishops, including Theodoret (5th-century bishop and church historian) of Cyrus; Flavian refused, hesitated and gave in. Xenias then demanded he reject Chalcedon itself. Flavian issued a halting confession that accepted Chalcedon's condemnation of Eutyches but not its authority to teach the faith. Xenias broke communion with Flavian and Macedonius, and demanded a statement from Elias, which Elias later said Xenias's followers altered before it reached the emperor.

Anastasius, back from three years of war with the Persians, found his capital seething and rumours that he was secretly a Manichean. He resented Macedonius. Xenias came to Constantinople with two hundred monks, and monks of the opposing side arrived from Palestine. John, patriarch of Alexandria, offered the emperor two hundred pounds of gold to overturn Chalcedon. Macedonius refused to condemn the council and condemned Flavian for not accepting it. Violence broke out in church: monks backing the one-nature view chanted Peter the Fuller's addition to the "Thrice Holy" hymn, and the next Sunday rival crowds armed with cudgels and stones fought in the cathedral. Macedonius was swept along by a mob that shouted for the emperor's death, and Anastasius, frightened, restored him to favour. But when Macedonius signed a creed that omitted Ephesus and Chalcedon, then backtracked, his support split, and in 511 the emperor exiled him and installed Timothy.

Flavian and Elias objected to Macedonius's condemnation but accepted Timothy. Baring-Gould says such timid half-measures could not save them. Severus, whom he calls the ringleader of the church riot, appeared at Antioch as Flavian's rival with the emperor's backing. Flavian wrote accepting the first three councils and the Henoticon without mentioning Chalcedon; Elias rejected Chalcedon, but not explicitly enough for Xenias, who persuaded the emperor to banish both. Severus became bishop of Antioch, and Flavian died in exile.

Neither was in communion with Rome while alive, since all who accepted the Henoticon lay under the pope's anathema. Baring-Gould notes that the Latin Church has since reversed its judgment, so that men who would have been barred from its altars in life are now invoked at them.

What they represent

How they teach us to live

Drawn from themes in the original account

Stay faithful when it costs you. Holding firm under pressure is part of this story.

Be a peacemaker. Making peace is part of this story.

The full story

Baring-Gould’s account retold in modern English

Read the full story · 1,795 words · about 8 min

Monophysites, and by an encyclical letter required all bishops to condemn the Council of Chalcedon. However, Basiliscus was quickly overthrown, and Zeno the Isaurian regained his throne. Zeno, likely acting on the advice of Acacius, the patriarch of Constantinople, issued the Henoticon (482), or Edict of Union. This edict was not aimed at reconciling the conflicting opinions that divided the Church, but rather at maintaining mutual toleration. The patriarchs of Alexandria, Antioch, and Constantinople signed the Henoticon, and the prospects seemed promising. But the calm was only temporary. The Henoticon, instead of reconciling the two original conflicting parties, only gave rise to a third.

Pope Felix III indignantly rejected the Henoticon, as it left the decision of the Council of Chalcedon an open question. He anathematized all the bishops who had subscribed to the edict and immediately excommunicated Peter the Fuller, the patriarch of Antioch, and Acacius, the patriarch of Constantinople.

Acacius responded by excommunicating Pope Felix, and for forty years, there was an unresolved schism between East and West. The patriarchs of Antioch, Alexandria, and Jerusalem remained in communion with Acacius and were involved in his excommunication.

Upon the death of Acacius, the metropolitan throne was Neatorius had taught that in Christ there were two persons. He was condemned by the Council of Ephesus (431). Eutyches, going to the other extreme, denied that in Christ there were two natures. He was condemned by the Council of Chalcedon in 451. For an account of this Council, see April, page 158. The Council avoided too close a definition on disputed points of fact. It anathematized Nestorius and Eutyches alike as heretics who divide Christ or reduce Him to a phantom. Without defining the number or the article of the word nature as applied to Christ, it respectfully confirmed the system of St. Cyril and the faith as taught at Nicaea, Constantinople, and Ephesus. A detailed examination fails to detect heresy in it. However, it incurred suspicion and condemnation for evading the definite recognition of the doctrine proclaimed at Chalcedon.

Flavian and Elias were appointed to positions that had been held by Fravitas in 489, who only held it for four months. After his death, Euphemius was elected. At that time, the emperor Anastasius was on the throne. There was an ongoing dispute between him and Euphemius. Anastasius had been a servant in the palace under the previous emperor, and there is a story that Euphemius once threatened to shave his head. Anastasius was a man of good character and had earned the respect of the people, who welcomed his rise to power with the cry, “Reign as you have lived.” However, his one blue eye and one dark eye were seen as signs of irregularity in his beliefs. His mother had been an Arian, and Euphemius would not allow him to ascend the throne until he swore to oppose the doctrine of Eutyches. The bitterness of religious divisions turned his virtues into vices. His charity was seen as hypocrisy, his moderation as irreligion, and the misfortunes of his reign were viewed as divine judgments. An Isaurian rebellion troubled the first five years of his reign. Euphemius was involved in treasonous activities and was deposed; Macedonius was elevated to the vacant position. Macedonius subscribed to the Henoticon, and still, the four major Eastern patriarchates maintained Christian fellowship.

However, the underlying tensions of religious discord were struggling to break free and set the realm ablaze. Macedonius, the patriarch of Constantinople, although he had signed the Henoticon, was a supporter of the council of Chalcedon and the orthodox belief. At that time, Flavian was the patriarch of Antioch, and Elias was in Jerusalem. Flavian was a monk from Tilmognus in Coelo-Syria, who had been ordained as a priest in Antioch and had been sent as a delegate by the patriarch on some matter of importance to the emperor. Palladius, the patriarch, died in 498, and the emperor appointed Flavian to the vacant position.

Flavian was suspected of having Monophysite leanings. He appeared to be a weak, well-meaning man with no clearly defined views, which made him vulnerable to stronger and more scheming factions. One of his first actions was to send Solomon, a priest from his church, to Alexandria with synodical letters to give to John Talajas, the patriarch, who was an Eutychian. However, Flavian was not inclined to take a stand against the council of Chalcedon, unlike Elias of Jerusalem; he chose the moderate and safer position of the Henoticon. But the Monophysite faction in Syria, which seemed to have greatly diminished in numbers, suddenly found a bold and reckless leader and erupted in fierce insurrection. Xenias, the bishop of Hierapolis, began to stir up the entire region by accusing Flavian of being a Nestorian. Flavian immediately anathematized Nestorius and his doctrine. However, Xenias was not satisfied; he insisted on anathematizing a number of bishops who were thought to have Nestorian views, including Theodoret of Cyrus. Flavian initially refused, then hesitated, and ultimately weakly complied.

Xenias, feeling triumphant, next insisted that the unfortunate Flavian should anathematize (declare a curse upon) and reject the council of Chalcedon, along with everyone who upheld the belief in the two natures of Christ. When Flavian refused, Xenias accused him of Nestorianism (the belief that Christ exists as two separate persons). The patriarch then wrote a confession of faith and reluctantly admitted that, although he agreed with the condemnation of Eutyches by the council of Chalcedon, he did not accept the authority of that council in defining and teaching the faith. Xenias then cut off communion with Flavian and Macedonius. At the same time, he demanded a statement of principles from Elias, the bishop of Jerusalem. Elias provided this statement and sent it to the emperor through some followers of Xenias, who later claimed that these followers altered and distorted his words.

The emperor Anastasius had been in the East for three years, fighting against the Persians. He managed to secure a peace that was not without its merits and returned to Constantinople to find the people of his capital stirred up with religious fanaticism. Rumors had been spread that he was secretly a Manichean (a religious sect that believed in a dualistic universe), and paintings on the palace walls were pointed out as being un-Christian and resembling Manichean symbols. He was angry with Macedonius for refusing to provide him with a declaration of opposition to Eutychianism, which Euphemius had extracted from him as a condition for his assuming the imperial purple (the color of imperial authority).

Xenias, looking for an opportunity against Macedonius, arrived in Constantinople, accompanied by a group of two hundred Eastern monks. Other monks from the opposing faction came pouring in from Palestine. The two groups of black-robed monks watched each other for several months, secretly working to gain support from their respective followers.

Meanwhile, the emperor received a delegation from John, the patriarch of Alexandria, who offered him two hundred pounds of gold if he would overturn the council of Chalcedon. Anastasius encouraged Macedonius to do what Elias of Jerusalem was said to have done: anathematize the council of Chalcedon. Macedonius refused and instead pronounced anathema against Flavian of Antioch for having rejected the authority of that council in resolving the issue of the two natures.

The long-standing tension erupted one Sunday in the church of the Archangel located in the palace. The Eutychian monks and the unruly crowd following them had invaded the church, and when the choir sang “Thrice holy,” they shouted out the refrain that Peter the Fuller had taught them, “who was crucified for us.”

The orthodox monks, supported by another unruly crowd, gathered in large numbers the following Sunday in the main church. The Monophysites were also present, with each group armed with heavy sticks and stones. The singing of the angelic hymn signaled the start of a chaotic fight. Sticks and stones flew around the church, drowning out the sacred chant with mutual curses from both sides. The Monophysites were expelled from the church, and Macedonius, carried along at the front of a furious crowd that he could not have controlled even if he had wanted to, was swept to the palace gates, where the entire angry mob shouted for the downfall and death of their emperor, calling him "The Manichean, the tyrant!”

Anastasius, who had bravely faced the Persians, trembled before that howling mob and agreed to receive and reinstate the patriarch Macedonius in his favor. A semblance of peace was restored, but the emperor waited for his chance to take revenge on Macedonius. The patriarch had likely been unwillingly involved in these scenes of sacrilegious violence, and now that calm had returned, he humbly signed a creed in which he recognized only the councils of Nicaea and Constantinople. His silence regarding the councils of Ephesus and Chalcedon was interpreted as a rejection of their authority. His monkish supporters erupted in insults. He humbly visited them in the monastery of St. Dalmatius and expressed his support for the council of Chalcedon. However, this action divided his supporters and shook the mob's faith in his unwavering orthodoxy. Anastasius saw his opportunity, took advantage of it, and quickly exiled the patriarch in 511 AD. The next day, the emperor appointed and consecrated a priest named Flavian in his place.

Timothy, who was given a nickname by the people that reflected his lack of self-control, immediately removed the images of Macedonius from the church where they had been displayed. Pretending that his predecessor had denied the creed of Nicaea, he introduced the recitation of the Nicene symbol at every Mass, whereas it had previously only been said on Good Friday. He sent letters to John of Alexandria, Flavian of Antioch, and Elias of Jerusalem. The latter two, although they regretted and opposed the condemnation of Macedonius, did not refuse to acknowledge Timothy.

But timid half-measures could not save Flavian and Elias. Severus, the instigator of the terrible riot in the church at Constantinople, suddenly appeared in Antioch as Flavian's rival, supported by the emperor's influence. Flavian wrote to the emperor, acknowledging the first three councils and the Henoticon, but he did not mention the council of Chalcedon. Elias also wrote, rejecting the latter council, but not in terms clear enough to satisfy Xenias, who wrote to the emperor urging him to banish both men; and the emperor did so immediately. Severus then became the bishop of Antioch, and Flavian died in exile.

Neither Elias nor Flavian were in communion with Rome, as they were under the curse pronounced against all who accepted the Henoticon. However, the Latin Church has reversed its judgment of them. Those who would have been excluded from her altars while they were alive are now generously honored after their death.

Footnotes

  1. Neatorius had taught that in Christ there were two persons.
  2. He was condemned by the Council of Ephesus (431).
  3. Eutyches, going to the other extreme, denied that in Christ there were two natures.
  4. He was condemned by the Council of Chalcedon in 451.
  5. For an account of this Council, see April, page 158.
  6. Palladius died in 498.
  7. Flavian was suspected of Monophysite leanings.
  8. Xenias was the bishop of Hierapolis.
  9. The term "anathematize" means to declare a curse upon.
  10. The term "Nestorianism" refers to a belief that Christ exists as two separate persons.
  11. The term "Manichean" refers to a religious sect that believed in a dualistic universe.
  12. The phrase "imperial purple" refers to the color associated with imperial authority.
  13. Anastasius was the emperor of the Eastern Roman Empire from 491 to 518 AD.
  14. The Henoticon was an edict issued in 482 AD aimed at reconciling different Christian factions.
  15. The council of Chalcedon was held in 451 AD and defined the two natures of Christ.
  16. The Latin Church has reversed its judgment of them.

Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.

Read the original 1870s text

Baring-Gould’s sources: Roman Martyrology, inserted by Baronius. Not in any ancient Martyrologies. Authorities: — Evagrius, Theodore the Lector, Theophanes, Ac.] We have had, on more than one occasion, to speak of the council of Chalcedon, which condemned Eutychianism, and deposed Dioscorus, patriarch of Alexandria. The decisions of the council of Chalcedon were regarded by the Egyptian party as sheer Nestorianism. There was therefore an insurrection of monks in Palestine, led on by one of their number, Theodosius, against Juvenal, bishop of Jerusalem, and favoured by the widowed empress Eudoxia. Theodosius expelled Juvenal, and enthroned himself in his room. He maintained himself by acts of violence, pillage, and murder, more like one of the lawless bandits of the country than a Christian bishop. There was a similar revolt at Alexandria, where Proterius, appointed after the ejection of Dioscorus, occupied the patriarchal throne. Timothy, a monk, called “ the Weasel,” perhaps from his appearance, perhaps because he slunk by night to the secret meetings of the rabble, or because he had stolen into the bishopric of another, was elevated by the Eutychian faction to the position of rival metropolitan, and Proterius was fallen upon in the baptistery of his church and murdered, the ferocious heretics tearing out and gnawing his bowels in their cannibal rage. At Antioch another monk, Peter the Fuller, intrigued with the discontented party, and at the head of a procession of monks shouting, “ Holy, holy, holy, Lord God most high, who was crucified for us,” drove the patriarch Martyrius, trembling for his life, into voluntary abdication. In 476, the emperor Basiliscus declared in favour of the tl»iy 4.

Monophysites, 1 and by an encyclical letter required all bishops to condemn the council of Chalcedon. But Basiliscus was speedily dethroned, and Zeno the Isaurian recovered his throne. Zeno, acting probably on the advice of Acacius, patriarch [the title of the bishops of the great ancient sees: Rome, Constantinople, Alexandria, Antioch, Jerusalem] of Constantinople, issued the Henoticon (482), or Edict of Union. This edict was aimed, not at reconciling the conflicting opinions which distracted the Church, but at maintaining mutual toleration.* The patriarchs of Alexandria, Antioch, and Constantinople, signed the Henoticon, and the prospects were encouraging. But the lull was only transient The Henoticon, without reconciling the two original conflicting parties, only gave rise to a third.

Pope Felix III. indignantly rejected the Henoticon, as leaving the decision of the Council of Chalcedon an open question. He anathematized all the bishops who had subscribed the edict, and at once excommunicated Peter the Fuller, patriarch of Antioch, and Acacius, patriarch of Constantinople.

Acacius replied by excommunicating Pope Felix, and for forty years there was unhealed schism between East and West The patriarchs of Antioch, Alexandria, and Jerusalem continued in communion with Acacius, and were involved in his excommunication.

On the death of Acacius, the metropolitan [the archbishop who heads a group of dioceses] throne was 1 Neatoriu* bad taught that in Christ were two persons. He was condemned by the Council of Ephesus (431). Eutyches, going to the other extreme, denied that in Christ were two natures. He was condemned by the Council of Chalcedon in 4$i. For an account of this Council, see April, p. 15a. tion, but avoided too close definition on mooted points of facts. It anathematised Nestorius [Nestorius (d. c. 451), whose teaching split Christ into two persons; condemned at Ephesus in 431] and Eutyches alike, as heretics who divide Christ or reduced him to a phantom. Without defining the number or the article of the word nature, as applied to Christ, it respectfully confirmed the system of S. Cyril, and the faith as tanght at Nicaea, Constantinople, and Ephesus. A microscopic examination fails to detect heresy in it. But it incurred suspicion and condemnation as evading the definite recognition of the doctrine proclaimed sr Chalcedon.

•SVS'. Flavian and Elias. occupied by Fravitas (489), who only held it four months, and on his death, Euphemius was elected. The emporor Anastasius was on the throne. An old quarrel rankled between him and Euphemius. Anastasius had been a servant in the palace under the late emperor, and there is a story that Euphemius had threatened on one occasion to shave his head. Anastasius was a man of upright character, and had acquired the respect of the people, who hailed his elevation to the throne with the cry, “ Reign as you have lived.” But his one blue and the other dark eye were taken as tokens of irregularity in his belief. His mother had been an Arian [followers of Arius, who taught that the Son is a created being, not fully God], and Euphemius would not suffer him to ascend the throne till he had sworn to oppose the doctrine of Eutyches. The bitterness of religious partisanship has transformed his virtues into vices. His charity becomes hypocrisy, his moderation irreligion, and the misfortunes of his reign divine judgments. An Isaurian rebellion troubled the first five years of his reign. Euphemius tampered in treasonable proceedings, and was deposed; Macedonius was exalted to the vacant see; Macedonius subscribed the Henoticon, and still the four great Eastern patriarchates maintained Christian fellowship.

But the compressed fires of religious discord were struggling to burst loose, and set the realm in conflagration. Macedonius, of Constantinople, though he had signed the Henoticon, was a partisan of the council of Chalcedon and the orthodox belief, and now Flavian sat in the patriarchal throne of Antioch, and Elias in that of Jerusalem. Flavian was a monk of Tilmognus in Ccelo-Syria, who had been ordained to the priesthood at Antioch, and had been sent as delegate by the patriarch on some affair of more or less importance to the emperor. Palladius the patriarch died (498), and the emperor appointed Flavian LNr 4.

to the vacant see. Flavian was suspected of Monophysite leanings. He was apparently a weak, well-meaning man, with no clearly defined views, and this left him a prey to stronger and designing partisans. One of his first acts was to send Solomon, a priest of his church, to Alexandria with synodical letters, which he was to give to John Talajas, the patriarch, an Eutychian [followers of Eutyches, who said Christ had only a divine nature; condemned at Chalcedon in 451]. But Flavian was not disposed to commit himself against the council of Chalcedon, as was Elias of Jerusalem; he adopted the moderate and safer ground of the Henoticon. But the Monophysite party in Syria, which seems to have been greatly reduced in numbers, suddenly having found a bold and reckless leader, burst out in fierce insurrection. Xenias, bishop of Hierapolis, began to agitate the whole region by accusing Flavian as a Nestorian. Flavian at once anathematized Nestorius and his doctrine. But Xenias was not satisfied, he must also anathematize indiscriminately a number of prelates who were supposed to have been tainted with Nestorian views, amongst whom was Theodoret of Cyrus. Flavian refused, then hesitated, and finally weakly complied.

Xenias, flushed with victory, next insisted on the unfortunate Flavian anathematizing and rejecting the council of Chalcedon, and all who maintained the two natures in Christ; and, on his refusal, he again charged him with Nestorianism. The patriarch thereupon drew up a confession of faith, and haltingly admitted that, though he approved of the condemnation of Eutyches by the council of Chalcedon,. he did not recognize the authority of that council in determining and teaching the faith. Xenias then separated from the communion of Flavian and Macedonius. At the same time he demanded of Elias, bishop of Jerusalem, a statement of his principles. This Elias put forth, and sent to the emperor by the hands of some >i followers of Xenias, who, he afterwards protested, altered and perverted his words.

The emperor Anastasius had been in the East fighting for three years with the Persians. He purchased a not inglorious peace, and returned to Constantinople to find the population of his capital fermenting with religious fanaticism. Rumours had been industriously spread that he was a Manichean at heart, and paintings on the palace walls were pointed out incapable of Christian interpretation, and savouring of Manichean symbolism. He was wrath with Macedonius for refusing to surrender to him the profession of hostility to Eutychianism, which Euphemius had wrung from him as a preliminary to his assuming the purple.

Xenias, seeking occasion against Macedonius, came to Constantinople, followed by a train of two hundred Eastern monks. Other monks of the opposite faction swarmed from Palestine. The two black-robed armies watched each other for some months, working in secret on their respective partisans.

The emperor, in the meantime, had received a deputation from John, patriarch of Alexandria, who offered to pay him two hundred pounds of gold if he would upset the council of Chalcedon. Anastasius urged on Macedonius to do as it was pretended that Elias of Jerusalem had done, anathematize the council of Chalcedon. Macedonius refused, and pronounced anathema against Flavian of Antioch for having refused to admit the authority of that council in deciding the question of the two natures.

The long brooding disturbance broke out one Sunday in the church of the Archangel in the palace. The Eutychian monks and the rabble at their heels had invaded the church, and when the choir sang “ Thrice holy,” they roared forth the burden Peter the Fuller had taught them, “ who war, crucified for us."

The orthodox monks, backed by another rabble, assembled in force the next Sunday in the metropolitan church; the Monophysites were also there, each party armed with stout cudgels and stones. The chanting of the angelic song was the signal for a wild fray. Sticks and stones flew about the church, and the sacred chant was drowned in mutual anathemas of the contending parties. The Monophysites were expelled the church, and Macedonius, borne along at the head of a raging multitude which he could not have controlled, had he cared to attempt it, was swept to the gates of the palace, where the whole furious mob shouted for the downfall, the death of their emperor, " The Manichean, the tyrant !”

Anastasius, who had bravely faced the Persians, trembled before that howling mob, and consented to receive, and reinstate in his favour, the patriarch Macedonius. The semblance of peace was restored, but the emperor waited his opportunity to be revenged on Macedonius. The patriarch had doubtless been unwillingly mixed up in these scenes of sacrilegious violence; and now that tranquillity was restored, he meekly signed a creed, in which he recognized only the councils of Nicaea and Constantinople. His silence about those of Ephesus and Chalcedon was interpreted as a rejection of their authority. His monkish masters broke out into invective. He meekly visited them in the monastery of S. Dalmatius, and expressed his adhesion to the council of Chalcedon. But this act had divided his adherents, and shaken the faith of the mob in his uncompromising orthodoxy. Anastasius saw his occasion, profited by it, and hurried the patriarch into exile (a.d. 51 1). On the morrow the emperor appointed, and had consecrated in his room, a priest named •S-S. Flavian and Elias.

Timothy, to whom the people gave a surname expressive of his incontinence. Timothy at once removed the pictures of Macedonius from the church in which they were erected, and pretending that his predecessor had denied the creed of Nicaea, he introduced the recitation of the Nicene symbol at every mass, it having formerly been only said on Good Friday. He sent synodal letters to John of Alexandria, and to Flavian of Antioch, and Elias of Jerusalem. The two latter, though they regretted, and objected to, the condemnation of Macedonius, did not refuse to acknowledge Timothy.

But timorous half-measures could not save Flavian and Elias. Severus, the ring-leader of the hideous riot in the church at Constantinople, suddenly appeared in Antioch as the rival of Flavian, backed by the influence of the emperor. Flavian wrote to the emperor, acknowledging the three first councils and the Henoticon, but without mentioning the council of Chalcedoa. Elias wrote also, and rejected the latter council, but not in terms sufficiently explicit to satisfy Xenias, who wrote to the emperor to induce him to banish both; and this he did forthwith. Severus thereupon became bishop of Antioch, and Flavian died in exile.

Neither Elias nor Flavian were in communion with Rome, as they lay under the anathema pronounced against all who accepted the Henoticon. The Latin Church has however, reversed her judgment of them, and those who would have been excluded from her altars when alive, are now with generous forgiveness invoked at them after their death.

Help us add to this saint's story

Everything is read by a person before anything appears. Facts are checked against trusted sources first.

Facts are welcome; a source link helps (optional).With your permission we may share it on this page.

Nine days · Free

Pray the novena
with us.

One short email a day for nine days. The day's prayer, a line from Sts. Flavian and Elias's story, and a nudge to keep going.

Also on July 4
T

St. Theodore (July 4)

July 4 · Bishop, Martyr
A

St. Andrew of Crete

July 4 · Bishop
O

St. Odo of Canterbury

July 4 · Archbishop
← All 1970 saints in the library
Sources & notes

Feast-day sources

Story sources

Sources

Credits

Retold in plain modern English from Baring-Gould’s public-domain text, sentence by sentence, keeping the same facts and order. Short explanations in parentheses are ours.

From Sabine Baring-Gould, The Lives of the Saints, new edition in 16 vols. (London: John C. Nimmo, 1897–98); text from the Internet Archive scan (OCR, lightly cleaned; errors possible). Public domain in the United States. Reproduced unedited, except for short bracketed notes in grey that we added to explain names and terms (“S.” is the old abbreviation for Saint). Some history and judgments reflect 19th-century scholarship.