There have been, and likely always will be, significant differences of opinion regarding the fairness of beheading Thomas, Earl of Lancaster, who was a cousin of King Edward II.
Edward of Carnarvon had received his father's final instructions before Edward I died. The main points of these instructions were that he should allocate a certain amount of money to support the Holy Land, that he should continue the conquest of Scotland, and that he should not recall his favorite, Piers de Gaveston (a young man from Gascony, whom the king had recently banished), without the approval of parliament.
Every one of these commands was directly violated by the young king. His first action was to summon Gaveston and grant him the royal earldom of Cornwall. Most of the old ministers and judges were dismissed. Langton, the bishop of Coventry and the treasurer of the late king, who had previously criticized the extravagance of the prince and his favorite, was imprisoned. Gaveston received the funds intended for the crusade, was made lord chamberlain, became engaged to Margaret de Clare, the king's niece, and soon, when Edward went to marry Isabel of France in Boulogne, was left as regent of England.
The great nobles were already feeling jealous, but when they saw the king, upon his return, rush into the arms of his favorite without acknowledging them, and when they witnessed Gaveston take precedence over them all at Edward's coronation, their anger erupted. Three days after the ceremony, they demanded that the king dismiss his favorite. Edward postponed the issue until parliament would meet, hoping to calm their anger by then. However, all his efforts were rendered useless by Gaveston's pride and arrogance, and the nobles insisted on his expulsion. Edward had no choice but to comply, and Gaveston had to swear that he would never return. Nevertheless, the king escorted him to Bristol with great honor and further angered his enemies by appointing the exile as his lieutenant in Ireland.
From the day Gaveston left, the king worked to bring him back. He sought the pope's intervention, and after obtaining a conditional cancellation of Gaveston's oath, he ordered him to return. When Gaveston arrived in Chester, the king personally welcomed him and brought him to meet parliament. There, he persuaded the bishops and peers to agree that his favorite could stay in England, but they added that this was contingent on him behaving himself.
In a very short time, however, Gaveston's complete control over the king, along with his showiness and arrogance, reignited the hostility of the barons. Lancaster and his allies refused to attend the next parliament. Edward, who needed money, found it necessary to give in. He moved the parliament to London and, leaving Gaveston in seclusion, went to the capital. The powerful barons arrived with such a military force that Edward had no choice but to grant all their demands. A committee of seven bishops, eight earls, and six barons, known as the ordainers, was appointed with full authority to address the grievances of the nation. Gaveston was banished again, but the king quickly recalled him, defying his parliament. The barons then took up arms, captured Gaveston at Scarborough on May 19th, 1312, and executed him by order of Lancaster and the other rebellious nobles at Blacklow, near Coventry.
The news of this bold act filled the king with intense grief, which soon turned into a fierce desire for revenge. His anger grew when the barons followed this act with a firm demand that the ordinances for better governance of England and the correction of serious abuses be implemented. However, a superficial reconciliation was achieved. The parliament gathered at Westminster Hall, and Edward, having taken his seat on the throne, saw the earl of Lancaster and his associates kneel before him, asking for forgiveness for the actions that had upset him. Taking each petitioner by the hand, the king gave him the kiss of peace, promised forgiveness, and the next day announced a general amnesty.
Some time after the death of Gaveston, the ordainers appointed a young man named Hugh le Despenser as chamberlain. He was the son of one of the great barons. Initially an object of dislike, he quickly became the favorite of Edward. Along with his father, he had effectively supported the king in his fight against the earl of Lancaster, which made him particularly hated by the earl's supporters. However, despite his loyalty, the chamberlain was certainly greedy. A harsh attempt to enforce feudal law for his own benefit prompted the lords Marchers of Wales to take up arms against him.
The earl of Lancaster soon joined them, and the united barons marched on London, declaring that the Despensers (who were both away) should be banished. The bishops protested, but the king and his allies were compelled to agree to this unlawful action. Two months later, the king recalled the Despensers and took military action against the barons. The earl attacked the royal castle of Tichhill, but after failing in his efforts, he rushed south to intercept Edward at Burton-on-Trent. The king, however, managed to cross the river, forcing the barons to retreat quickly to Pontefract.
There, a heated council was held. Lancaster wanted to make a stand at that location, but he was overruled by his allies and continued the retreat. At Boroughbridge, he found the way blocked by a strong force led by Sir Andrew Harkeley, the governor of Carlisle, and Sir Simon Ward, the sheriff of Yorkshire. After a futile attempt to gain Harkeley's support, who had previously been knighted by him, Lancaster decided to try to cross the bridge. However, after the earl of Hereford was killed in the attempt and an assault by a ford was repelled, earl Thomas took refuge in a chapel. Looking at the crucifix, he said, "Lord, I render myself to Thee and Thy mercy."
Nevertheless, he was dragged out by the royalists, who stripped him of his rich surcoat, dressed him in a common livery, and took him down the river to York, where he was met with various insults. From there, he was taken to Pontefract Castle, which he owned at that time through his wife, the heiress of the De Lacys, and presented to the king.
The death of Gaveston was now to be avenged. The earl of Lancaster was brought in as a prisoner to his own hall. There, the king, along with the earls of Kent, Richmond, Pembroke, the elder Spenser, and others from his party, condemned him to be drawn, hanged, and beheaded. However, Edward decided to spare him from the more degrading parts of the sentence. The earl was immediately handed over to a group of Gascons, who placed an old cap on his head, put him on a thin white pony, and led him out for immediate execution. The presence of his confessor, a Dominican monk, who walked beside him, did not protect the earl from the insults of the royalist crowd. They threw dirt at him and mockingly called him "king Arthur." In this way, he was taken to the top of a hill outside the town, where he was ordered to kneel, facing north, and then his head was struck off by "a villain of London."
Thomas of Lancaster was not a martyr for religion, but he was a martyr for the rights and liberties of the English people.
He both advanced the cause of public liberty and died defending it. Consider the role he played in creating the ordinances "for the common benefit of the kingdom, and the peace and prosperity of all the people generally." All his actions demonstrate that the earl was a man of noble intentions, naturally opposed to arbitrary power, and a true lover of liberty in its genuine and rational sense. The sentence pronounced against him was officially revoked by an act of parliament. The priory church at Pontefract, which claimed to have his body buried on the right side of the high altar, became the site of a series of miracles. There is a record in Corpus Christi College at Cambridge "of the miracles God worked for Saint Thomas of Lancaster; therefore the king ordered the church doors of Pontefract Priory to be closed, so that no one could enter to offer to the body."
The veneration for him spread to London and became so significant that a royal proclamation was issued condemning and threatening the worshippers of the effigy: "Our enemies and rebels approach it without the authority of the Roman Church, treating it as a sacred thing and asserting that miracles occur there, which is a disgrace to the whole Church, a dishonor to us and you, and a manifest danger to the souls of the aforementioned people, as well as a pernicious example for others." This reverence, therefore, regardless of its origin, was of a national and unauthorized nature. However, within five weeks after Edward III's accession, a special mission was sent to the pope from the king, requesting the appointment of a commission to conduct the usual canonical investigation in preparation for the canonization of a Christian hero.
In June of the same year, a royal letter was issued to Robert de Weryngton, authorizing him and his agents to collect alms throughout the kingdom for the construction of a chapel on the hill where the earl was beheaded. Three years later, in 1330, the embassy was repeated, urging the attention of the court of Rome to a matter that greatly concerned the Church and the people of England. In April of the following year, three even more important envoys were sent with letters to the pope, to nine cardinals, to the referendary of the papal court, and to the three nephews of His Holiness, pleading with them not to listen to the accusations of malicious individuals who claimed that the earl of Lancaster had been complicit in some harm done to certain cardinals at Durham during the late king's reign. It is claimed that, on the contrary, the earl defended those high-ranking individuals at great personal risk. The repeated demand for his canonization appeals to the words of Scripture, "Knock, and it shall be opened unto you."
Of this strange story, there is no continuation until fifty-nine years later, when Walshingham, the Benedictine monk of St. Alban's, chronicling the events of 1390 (the thirteenth year of Richard II), writes, "In this year, Saint Thomas of Lancaster was canonized." The same event is recorded by John Capgrave, but with a discrepancy of one year. Writing about 1389, he states, "And this same year, Thomas of Lancaster was canonized, for it was commonly said that he would never be canonized until all the judges who condemned him were dead, and all their descendants."
Despite the clear statements of these two ecclesiastical historians, the festival of Thomas of Lancaster is not listed in any of the Salisbury Service books, whether printed or in manuscript. Nor is his feast included among those which Lyndwode mentions as having been introduced in later years. Butler does not mention him in his Lives of the Saints, and the Bollandists give him no more than half a dozen lines, noting him among those they do not intend to discuss.
A stone coffin found in a field not far from St. Thomas's Hill, near Pontefract, in 1828, which local histories suggest contains the bones of the earl, can still be seen in the grounds of Lord Houghton at Fryston Hall. The heavy lid was removed in the presence of Mr. T. Wright, Rev. C. Hartshorne, and other members of the Archaeological Association, and the bones were taken out and examined. The head was found between the leg bones. All were of unusually large size. They were later restored, except for the skull, which is preserved in Fryston Hall.
Footnotes
- The earl of Hereford was killed in the attempt.
- Earl Thomas took refuge in a chapel.
- "of the miracles God wroughte for Seint Thomas of Lancaster" is a record of miracles attributed to Saint Thomas of Lancaster.
- "Inimici et rebelli nostri fotue accedentes eam absque auctoritate Ecclesiæ Romanæ tanquam rem sanctificatam colunt et adsunt, asserentes ibi fieri miracula, opprobrium totius Ecclesiæ, nostri et vestri dedecus, et animarum populi predicti periculum manifestum, ac pernisiosum exemplum aliorum." is a proclamation condemning unauthorized worship of the effigy.
- In this year, Saint Thomas of Lancaster was canonized.
- And this same year, Thomas of Lancaster was canonized, for it was commonly said that he would never be canonized until all the judges who condemned him were dead, and all their descendants.
- The heavy lid was removed in the presence of Mr. T. Wright, Rev. C. Hartshorne, and other members of the Archaeological Association.
Baring-Gould’s own footnotes, in modern English.
Read the original 1870s text
Baring-Gould’s sources: Inscribed in his additions to Usuardus by Herman Greven, in the German Martyrology of Canisius, and by Ferrarius in his General Catalogue of the Saints. Not mentioned in the Anglican or Roman Martyrologies, but it is certain that Thomas of Lancaster received veneration shortly after his execution, and that miraculous cures were attributed to his relics.
There have been, as there probably ever will be, great differences of opinion as to the justice of beheading Thomas, Earl of Lancaster, cousin-german to king Edward II.
Edward of Carnarvon had received his father's final instructions before Edward I. died. Of these the principal were; that he should devote a certain sum to the succour of the Holy Land; that he should persist in the conquest of Scotland; and that he should not recall his favourite, Piers de Gaveston (a young Gascon, whom the king had lately banished), without the consent of parliament.
Every one of these commands were directly violated by the young king. His first act was to send for Gaveston; and to confer on him the royal earldom of Cornwall. The old ministers and judges were nearly all dismissed. Langton, bishop of Coventry, the treasurer of the late king, who had formerly reproved the extravagance of the prince and his favourite, was thrown into prison. Gaveston received the money left for the crusade, was made lord chamberlain; betrothed to Margaret de Clare, niece of the king; and presently, when Edward went to marry Isabel of France at Boulogne, left regent of England.
The jealousy of the great nobles was already excited; but when they beheld the king, on his return, rush into the arms of his favourite without regarding them; and when they saw Gaveston take precedence of them all at the coronation of Edward, their anger burst forth. Three days after the ceremony they called upon the king to dismiss his minion. Edward deferred the matter until parliament should meet, hoping by that time to soothe their resentment. All his efforts, however, was rendered nugatory by the pride and insolence of Gaveston, and the nobles insisted on his expulsion. Edward was obliged to give way, and Gaveston to swear that he would never return. The king, however, escorted him to Bristol with every mark of honour, and mortified his enemies still more by appointing the exile his lieutenant in Ireland.
From the day of Gaveston's departure the king laboured to effect his recall. He solicited the intervention of the pope; and having obtained a conditional abrogation of the oath taken by Gaveston, ordered him to return. Receiving him in person at Chester, he brought him to meet parliament. Here he induced the bishops and peers to consent that his favourite should remain in England; but they added,—as long as he conducted himself well.
In a very short time, however, the absolute ascendancy of Gaveston over the king, his ostentation and presumption, had revived the animosity of the barons. Lancaster and his friends refused to attend the next parliament. Edward, who wanted money, found it necessary to yield. He prologued the parliament to London, and leaving Gaveston in retirement, repaired to the capital. The great barons attended with such a military force, that Edward was obliged to grant all their demands. A committee of seven prelates, eight earls, and six barons, under the name of ordainers, was appointed, with full powers to redress the grievances of the nation. Gaveston was again banished and as speedily was recalled by the king in defiance of his parliament. The barons then took up arms, and captured Gaveston at Scarborough (May 19th, 1312), and executed him by order of Lancaster and the other insurgent nobles at Blacklow, near Coventry.
The news of this audacious deed affected the king with the most passionate grief, to which was quickly added a fierce desire for revenge. His anger was not diminished when the barons followed up the blow by a peremptory demand that the ordinances for the better government of England and the rectification of flagrant abuses should be carried into effect. A superficial reconciliation was however effected. The parliament assembled at Westminster hall, and Edward having taken his seat on the throne, the earl of Lancaster and his associates knelt before him, and solicited a pardon for the acts which had offended him. Taking each petitioner by the hand, the king bestowed upon him the kiss of peace, promised, and the next day published, a general amnesty.
Some time after the death of Gaveston, the ordainers had imposed upon the king, as chamberlain, a young man named Hugh le Despenser, son of one of the great barons. From an object of dislike, he soon became the favourite of Edward. With his father, he had ably supported the king in his resistance to the earl of Lancaster, and he had become especially odious to the earl's party. But, however loyal, the chamberlain was undoubtedly rapacious; and a harsh attempt to enforce the feudal law to his own advantage, excited the lords Marchers of Wales to arm against him. The earl of Lancaster soon joined them; and the united barons, marching upon London, decreed that the Despensers (who were both absent), should be banished. The bishops protested; but the king and his friends were forced to assent to this lawless proceeding. Two months after the king recalled the Despensers, and took the field against the barons. The earl assaulted the royal castle of Tichhill; but failing in his attempts, he hurried southwards to stop the advance of Edward at Burton-on-Trent. The king, however, forced the passage of the river, and the barons retreated hastily to Pontefract. There a stormy council was held. Lancaster was for making a stand at that point; but over-borne by his associate, he resumed the retreat. At Boroughbridge, however, he found the way barred by a strong force under Sir Andrew Harkeley, governor of Carlisle, and Sir Simon Ward, sheriff of Yorkshire. After a vain endeavour to gain the adhesion of Harkeley, who had formerly received knighthood at his hands, Lancaster resolved to force the passage of the bridge; but the earl of Hereford having been slain in the attempt, and an attack by a ford having been repulsed, earl Thomas took refuge in a chapel, saying, as he looked upon the crucifix; "Lord, I render myself to Thee and Thy mercy." He was, nevertheless, dragged out by the royalists, who, despoiling him of his rich surcoat, clothed him in a common livery, and conveyed him down the river to York, where he was received with every kind of insult. Thence he was taken to Pontefract Castle, which he at that time possessed in the right of his wife, the heiress of the De Lacys, and presented to the king.
The death of Gaveston was now to be avenged. The earl of Lancaster was brought a prisoner into his own hall; and there the king, with the earls of Kent, Richmond, Pembroke, the elder Spenser, and other of his party, condemned him to be drawn, hanged, and beheaded. Edward, however, remitted the more degrading parts of the sentence. The earl was at once delivered into the hands of a band of Gascons, who put an old cap on his head, set him on a lean white pony, and led him out to immediate execution. The presence of his confessor [in old usage, a saint who was not martyred, or who suffered for the faith without being killed], a Dominican monk, who walked by his side, did not save the earl from the insults of the royalist rabble. They threw pellets of dirt at him, and derisively saluted him as "king Arthur." In this manner he was conducted to the summit of a hill without the town, where he was ordered to kneel, with his face to the north, and then his head was stricken off by "a villain of London."
A martyr to religion Thomas of Lancaster was not, but he was a martyr for the rights and liberties of English people.
He both furthered the cause of public liberty, and perished in its defence. Witness the part he took in framing the ordinances "for the common benefit of the kingdom, and the peace and prosperity of all the people generally." All his transactions show that the earl was a man of noble purposes, naturally averse to arbitrary power, and a lover of liberty in the true and rational sense of its value. The sentence pronounced against him was formally revoked by act of parliament; and the priory church at Pontefract, which claimed to have his body buried on the right hand of the high altar, became the scene of a series of miracles. There is a record in the Corpus Christi College at Cambridge "of the miracles God wroughte for Seint Thomas of Lancaster: wherefore the king lete close the church doors of Pountfret of the Prioree, for no man shall come therein to the body for to offeren." The veneration extended to London and became so prominent that a royal proclamation was issued denouncing and threatening the worshippers of the effigy: "Inimici et rebelli nostri fotue accedentes eam absque auctoritate Ecclesiæ Romanæ tanquam rem sanctificatam colunt et adsunt, asserentes ibi fieri miracula, opprobrium totius Ecclesiæ, nostri et vestri dedecus, et animarum populi predicti periculum manifestum, ac pernisiosum exemplum aliorum." This reverence therefore, however produced, was of a national and unauthorized character; but within five weeks after the accession of Edward III. a special mission was sent to the pope from the king, imploring the appointment of a commission to institute the usual canonical investigation preparatory to the canonisation of a Christian hero. In June of the same year a king's-letter was given to Robert de Weryngton, authorising him and his agents to collect alms throughout the kingdom for the erection of a chapel on the hill where the earl was beheaded. Three years later (that is in 1330) the embassy was repeated, urging the attention of the court of Rome to a subject that so much interested the Church and people of England; and in the April of the following year three still more important envoys were sent with letters to the pope, to nine cardinals, to the refendary of the papal court, and to the three nephews of his holiness, intreating them not to give ear to the invectives of malignant men who had asserted that the earl of Lancaster connived at some injury offered to certain cardinals at Durham in the late king's reign. It is affirmed that, on the contrary, the earl defended those high personages at his own great peril; and the reiterated demand for his sanctification appeals to the words of Scripture, "Knock, and it shall be opened unto you."
Of this strange story no continuation appears till fifty-nine years later, when Walshingham, the Benedictine [monks following the Rule of St. Benedict] monk of St. Alban's, chronicling the events of 1390 (the thirteenth year of Richard II.), writes, " hoc quoque anno sanctus Thomas de Lancastria canonizatus est ." The same event is recorded by John Capgrave with the discrepancy of one year. Writing of 1389, he narrates: "And this same year was Thomas of Lancaster canonised, for it was seid commounly that he should nevir be canonised onto the time that all the juges that set upon him were ded, & all her issew."
Notwithstanding the distinct assertions of these two ecclesiastical historians, the festival of Thomas of Lancaster is not set down in any of the Salisbury Service books either printed or in manuscript. Nor does his feast come among those which Lyndwode speaks of as introduced in later years. Butler makes no mention of him in his Lives of the Saints , nor do the Bollandists [Jesuit scholars who since the 1600s have critically studied the lives of the saints] give to him more than half-a-dozen lines, mentioning him amongst those whom they do not propose to notice.
A stone coffin found in a field not far from S. Thomas's Hill, near Pontefract, in the year 1828, which in local histories has been supposed to contain the bones of the earl, is still to be seen in the grounds of Lord Houghton, at Fryston Hall. The heavy lid was removed in the presence of Mr. T. Wright, Rev. C. Hartshorne, and other members of the Archæological Association, and the bones taken out and examined. The head was found between the leg bones. All were of unusually large proportions. They were afterwards restored, with the exception of the skull, to their ancient resting-place. The skull is preserved in Fryston Hall.